Determination turns on function, not on the label. The OECD definition of a reporting entity (RCASP) is: any individual or entity that, as a business, acts as a counterparty or intermediary, or facilitates crypto asset exchange transactions for customers by providing a trading platform.
"Substance over form" means that the name used (exchange, broker, or "technology company"), the technical architecture employed, and whether user assets are custodied are not decisive factors. Under the OECD framework and the guidance of jurisdictions that have published guidance, the determination for common business models is as follows: centralized exchanges, brokers, over-the-counter (OTC) dealers, and crypto ATM operators typically fall within scope; payment service providers and custodial institutions are analyzed on a case-by-case basis depending on whether they facilitate exchange transactions; pure DeFi protocols generally do not fall directly within scope because there is no operating entity, but their front-end operators and interface service providers require case-by-case assessment.
The IR1127 flowchart published by the New Zealand Inland Revenue Department reduces the assessment to three consecutive questions: Does it facilitate exchange transactions? Is it for or on behalf of customers? Is it as a business? If the answer to all three is "yes," it constitutes an RCASP in principle. The guidance of Singapore and the United Kingdom follows the same logic.
