Beneath the Cultural Hype, Hidden Criminal Pitfalls
In 2023, the founder of a well-known NFT platform was placed under investigation on suspicion of the crime of illegally absorbing public deposits, with the amount involved exceeding RMB 500 million;
In 2024, a "metaverse land" project was characterized as disguised fundraising due to its promises of high returns, and investors lost their entire principal...
Web3Behind the industry's vigorous development, the boundary between NFT projects' operating models and fund flows and criminal legal risk is increasingly blurred. As an entrepreneur, one may have an "innovative model" misjudged as a crime. How do we hold the legal bottom line in NFT projects, and how should we defend our own rights and interests?

High-frequency Criminal Charges in NFT Projects
(1) Crime of Illegally Absorbing Public Deposits
Why are NFT projects frequently entangled in the "crime of illegally absorbing public deposits"?
Under Article 176 of the Criminal Law, the core elements of the crime of illegally absorbing public deposits include:public promotion without permission、promises of returns、absorbing funds from unspecified personsand other elements.
In the course of operating many NFT projects, it is easy for them to become inadvertently involved:
publicly promoting “limited releases” and “scarcity-driven appreciation” through social media and community channels;
disguising promises of returns through models such as “staking mining” and “holding dividends”;
attracting public funds to enter through secondary-market speculation......
It is precisely these features of NFT projects that have led to their “inseparable connection” with the crime of illegally absorbing public deposits.
If an NFT project, under names such as “digital collectible investment” or “rights splitting,” publicly promotes to unspecified persons a promise of principal and interest repayment or high returns (such as “daily dividends” or “periodic repurchase”), and has not obtained a financial business license, then it meets the characteristics of this crime.
For example, in judicial case (2024) Yu 03 Criminal Appeal 77, the conduct of Huang XX in absorbing funds under the guise of “yew investment” was determined to constitute the crime of illegally absorbing public deposits; the judicial interpretation of the Supreme People's Court also makes clear that illegally absorbing funds by means of virtual currency transactions constitutes illegal fundraising.
Article 2 of the Interpretation of the Supreme People's Court on Several Issues Concerning the Specific Application of Law in the Trial of Criminal Cases of Illegal Fundraising (2022 Amendment)
Where any of the following acts is carried out and meets the conditions specified in Paragraph 1 of Article 1 of this Interpretation, it shall be convicted and punished as the crime of illegally absorbing public deposits in accordance with Article 176 of the Criminal Law:......(8) illegally absorbing funds by means such as online lending, investment in shares, or virtual currency transactions;......(12) other acts of illegally absorbing funds.
(II)Crime of fund-raising fraud
The core characteristic of the crime of fund-raising fraud is the need to prove that the actor has an “intent to illegally possess,” specifically manifested as fabricating projects, concealing the true use of funds (such as using raised funds for personal extravagance or transfer), and using new funds to repay old ones, among other things.
In judicial practice, the determination of illegal fundraising involving NFTs tends to favor the principle of "substantive penetration" and to focus on the flow of funds:
1. The principle of substantive penetration in supervision
Courts tend to characterize conduct based on the substance of the transaction rather than its technical form. For example, although a certain platform operated under the name of "digital collectibles," because it established a secondary market and promised principal protection and returns, it was ultimately determined to constitute the crime of fundraising fraud rather than an ordinary contract dispute.
2. Flow and use of funds
If the funds of an NFT project are not used for the development of the underlying assets as claimed, but are used to pay interest to early investors or to cover other operating losses, this can directly corroborate an "intent to illegally possess" and may escalate the offense from the crime of illegally absorbing public deposits to the crime of fundraising fraud; alternatively, if an NFT platform falsely claims cooperation with well-known institutions (such as museums or cultural associations) or fabricates the value of underlying assets (such as forging the scarcity of collectibles), and attracts investment by manipulating prices before absconding with the funds, this may also constitute that crime. The "Tonggu Platform" case heard by the Shanghai Minhang District Court falls within this category. In a typical case before the Intermediate People's Court of Shantou City, Guangdong Province, Huang Mouyan was determined to have committed the crime of fundraising fraud for fabricating investment projects and transferring funds.
Other related charges in NFT projects
(I)Crime of illegal business operations
If an NFT platform, without approval, engages without authorization in financial business such as payment settlement or foreign exchange conversion (for example, using USDT for fiat currency exchange), it may violate this offense. In the referenced case, the use of virtual currency to conduct illegal foreign exchange transactions was determined to constitute the crime of illegal business operations.
(2) Money laundering or the crime of concealing or disguising criminal proceeds
If NFTs are used as a means of transferring illegally raised funds (for example, laundering funds through multi-layered transaction chains), such offenses may be suspected.
Directions for criminal compliance and risk management for NFT entrepreneurs
(1) Criminal compliance as a front-end measure
NFT issuance must clearly define ownership relationships, be genuinely recorded on-chain, and avoid false advertising;
The model design for NFTs should avoid absorbing public funds in disguised forms such as "splitting rights and interests" or "transfer of revenue rights."
NFT issuance should be careful to strip away financial attributes and strengthen the cultural, marketing, and use-right value of digital collectibles (for example, by combining them with physical benefits);
Retain evidence such as community promotional content and user agreements to prove that there is no "principal guarantee."
(2) Crisis response strategy
When encountering complaints from platform users or when problems arise on the platform due to poor operations caused by business, market, partners, or other circumstances, the platform should respond actively, explain the situation, properly handle user conflicts, and report to local regulatory authorities when necessary, so as to prevent the problems from expanding and escalating into criminal risk.
If an investigation has indeed been opened, actively cooperate with the judicial authorities, explain the platform's development process, clarify the flow of funds, and reach a compensation plan and other methods to reduce one's own liability.
In a fraud case involving a digital collectibles platform that we recently represented, the operator of the digital collectibles platform was accused of suspected fraud. The cause was that users purchased collectibles with an investment mindset, then suffered losses due to market fluctuations, and the platform shut down under the impact of the industry downturn; some users reported the matter, and the public security organ opened an investigation on suspicion of fraud. After Mankun lawyers intervened and communicated orally and in writing with the prosecutor multiple times, they integrated the platform's core disputed points, including "the platform had no subjective intent to commit fraud and no objective fraudulent conduct," "no purpose of illegal possession," "the proceeds were lawful business income," and "the authenticity of the evidence is questionable," and conducted a multi-dimensional defense asserting innocence. After two supplementary investigations, Mankun lawyers still maintained that the facts of the case were unclear and the evidence was insufficient. Ultimately, the procuratorate made a decision ofnon-prosecutionagainst the platform, and the client's lawful rights and interests were safeguarded.
Why choose Mankun?
Mankun's criminal team focuses on the field of digital economy crime and pioneered a dual-track defense approach of "technology + law":
✅ Technical understanding: Team members have Web3 professional or knowledge backgrounds and can translate Web3 technical language into legal terminology that case-handling authorities can understand, and interpret the business logic of NFTs;
✅ Database of similar cases: Covering NFT-related criminal cases across the country over the past three years, distilling more than 20 effective defense points;
✅ Extensive practical experience: Mankun's Criminal Legal Affairs Department has provided dozens of digital collection platforms nationwide withNFTspecialized legal services for criminal risk prevention and risk management, helping platforms achieve a smooth landing.
Successful NFT-related cases
-
Providing criminal defense in criminal cases involving digital collection platforms in Shanghai, Henan, Anhui, Fujian, Heilongjiang, Shandong and other placesNFTProviding criminal defense in criminal cases involving digital collectible platforms
Mankun represented several persons in the digital collection industry in Shanghai, Henan, Anhui and other places in criminal cases involving suspected fraud, suspected illegal absorption of public deposits, suspected fund-raising fraud and other matters, and several cases are ongoing. Some cases include: representing the legal representative of a digital collection company in Shanghai in a suspected fraud case, in which the procuratorate made a decision not to approve arrest within 37 days, and the public security authority voluntarily withdrew the case; representing a shareholder of a digital collection company in Henan in a suspected fraud case, in which the procuratorate returned the case for supplementary investigation on the grounds that "the facts are unclear and the evidence is insufficient," and the public security authority voluntarily withdrew the case; and representing the actual controller of a digital collection company in Henan in a suspected fraud case, in which legal opinions were submitted regarding circumstances of induced confession during the investigation stage, prompting the procuratorate to confront the case squarely and to truthfully record in the interrogation transcript facts favorable to the client.
-
From 2022 to 2023, Mankun's Criminal Legal Affairs Department provided dozens of digital collection platforms nationwide withNFTspecialized legal services for criminal risk prevention and risk management, helping platforms achieve a smooth landing
Representing dozens of digital collection companies in Jiangsu, Henan, Hainan, Guangxi, Hebei, Sichuan, Anhui, Inner Mongolia and other places, compiling written industry reports and consolidating relevant laws, regulations and policies, and assisting relevant authorities in understanding the background of the digital collection industry and industry policies. Based on the specific information of different platforms and in light of the degree of criminal risk to which the platforms were exposed (or being questioned, subject to preliminary investigation, having office equipment controlled, and so on), Mankun identified the key content and, with respect to the evolution of changes in the operating entity, IP licensing, marketing and promotion and other aspects, assisted platform personnel in sorting out their business operations and provided legal services for the orderly exit of the platforms, all with good results.
Final remarks:
Technological innovation should not come at the cost of criminal risk. Whether you are a founder or an investor, consulting a lawyer three hours in advance may help you avoid three years of imprisonment or recover CNY 3 million in asset losses.
Mankun Law Firm Web3 Criminal Practice TeamFocused on Web3 criminal defense, criminal risk prevention and management, and recovery of losses involving virtual assets, we safeguard the vast possibilities of the Web3.0 industry with professional expertise and ensure that Web3.0 takes place lawfully in China.


