Digital collectibles are not inherently off-limits; the key is whether they are treated as certificates of rights or as financial products: the former leaves room under contract law, while the latter readily runs into regulatory red lines.

As for the legal value of digital collectibles, the first question is what rights they actually represent.

When clients ask about the legal value of digital collectibles, I usually begin by asking in return: what can the holder actually obtain in exchange for this collectible? If it corresponds to brand membership rights, offline tickets, redemption for physical goods, or eligibility for a particular community, its value lies in being a certificate of rights that can be confirmed by contract; the legal relationship is clear, and the commercial arrangement can likewise be calculated. Conversely, if all that remains is an expectation of price movements, and the issuer promises buybacks, principal protection, or resale on the holder's behalf, then what must be discussed is not the collectible but the question of whose hands the funds and returns pass through and who bears the redemption obligation. Only by assigning roles to the specific issuer, platform, technology provider, and marketing team can the allocation of liability be discussed clearly.

Which specific actions will future compliance challenges mainly turn on?

There is currently no unified dedicated legislation in this field, and regulatory approaches differ across jurisdictions; the specific applicable rules are matters to be verified and require separate assessment in light of the transaction structure. The relatively certain categories of high-risk actions are: dividing collectibles into shares or creating them in batches, linking them to financial assets such as securities, insurance, or credit, a platform acting as both seller and matchmaker, and promising returns or stable exits to the public. A structurally potentially viable direction is to weaken the financial narrative, ground the rights in genuine consumption scenarios and written contracts, and support value through offline redemption and brand rights. Whether resale functionality is opened up, and how, is a gray area requiring case-by-case assessment.

What specific materials should investors and enterprises focus on when identifying risks?

Do not identify risks by looking only at white papers and promotional posters. The first layer is money: whose account the funds enter, who actually controls it, and whether the platform has formed a pool of funds. The second layer is promises: whether there are written return or buyback arrangements, who signed them, and whether the contracting entity has the ability to redeem. The third layer is assets: whether the redemption object actually exists, who controls the exit channel, and whether the platform can unilaterally close it or temporarily change the rules. If a dispute does arise, arbitral institutions or courts will mainly look at the contractual terms, promotional materials, communication records, and payment records; liability follows whoever made the promise and whoever received the money. Enterprises conducting this business themselves are also advised to align this set of materials first before deciding whether to launch.

Verification Checklist

  • Verify the business registration entities, business scope, and relevant qualifications of the issuer and the platform, and whether they have the registration basis to undertake this business.
  • Verify whether there are written or oral promises of returns, buybacks, or principal protection, and who the specific entity making such promises is.
  • Verify who controls the fund accounts and whether the flow of funds is clear, and whether the rights redemption objects corresponding to the collectibles are genuine and controllable.
  • Verify the resale and exit rules, and whether the platform unilaterally controls them and may change them at any time.
  • Preserve promotional pages, communication records, agreement texts and payment vouchers as the foundational materials for any subsequent dispute.

Reference materials

  1. National Internet Finance Association of China, China Banking Association and Securities Association of China, Initiative on Preventing NFT-Related Financial Risks (April 2022) — the original wording and current effect require verification.
  2. People's Bank of China and nine other departments, Notice on Further Preventing and Handling the Risks of Virtual Currency Trading and Speculation (September 2021) — the scope of application and effect require verification.
  3. Provisions of the Contract Part of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China on contract validity, fraud and standard terms — the application of specific provisions requires verification in light of the individual case.
  4. National Enterprise Credit Information Publicity System — used to verify the entity registration information of the issuer and the platform.