Procedural rights and substantive defenses must both be pursued.
Procedural track: Each stage of inspection, examination and decision-making is subject to statutory procedures. Statement and defense, hearings, administrative reconsideration and administrative litigation are the remedial channels conferred by law, grounded in the Tax Collection and Administration Law and related procedural laws; the factual findings, application of law and procedural compliance in the penalty decision are all reviewable points. Substantive track: Organize evidence around the core of the dispute—characterization of income (whether it is property transfer income or business income), cost verification (evidentiary rules and presumptive rules), and credit for foreign taxes already paid—and seek no penalty or a reduced penalty.
The adversarial nature of a tax inspection is far lower than that of a criminal case, but its technical complexity is not low. The most common source of loss when responding on one's own is not "losing," but the cascading exposure caused by inconsistent positions: a single internally contradictory statement of circumstances may expand a problem in a single year into a multi-year problem. Bringing in a lawyer with cross-border tax experience as early as possible is a pragmatic choice for controlling risk exposure.
