Circumstances That May Be Encountered
In cross-border business, an enterprise may engage in the exchange of fiat currency for foreign currency through over-the-counter (OTC) channels using virtual assets as an intermediary (i.e., "matched trades": receiving RMB domestically and paying foreign currency offshore, or vice versa), with enormous fund flows. When facing investigation or prosecution by judicial authorities for the crime of illegal business operations, management must assess the direction of the case and the scope for a defense, particularly why, in a case involving an amount as high as RMB 200 million or more, some defendants still received suspended sentences.
Why This Requires Attention
The core legal dispute in such cases lies in characterizing the nature of the transactions (whether they constitute illegal foreign exchange trading/illegal business operations) and in assessing sentencing circumstances. Operators must reconstruct the specific fund-flow paths: who controlled the fiat currency accounts and the virtual asset wallets? Who initiated the exchange instructions? Who handled matching or reconciliation? This is because the news only disclosed the results that "the amount involved exceeded RMB 200 million" and that "some defendants received suspended sentences," but did not publish key sentencing bases in the judgment, such as each defendant's specific position in the criminal chain (principal offender/accessory), acceptance of guilt and punishment, and details of disgorgement and compensation. Therefore, the term of imprisonment cannot be inferred simply from the size of the amount; it must be analyzed in light of the specific circumstances established by the court in the individual case.
What Can Be Done Now
- Organize and preserve all bank statements, third-party payment records, and on-chain transfer hashes of virtual assets involving cross-border fund transfers, and clarify the correspondence of each "matched trade" transaction.
- Verify evidence of the internal division of labor, including chat records, emails, and approval documents, to distinguish the roles of core organizers, technology providers, and persons merely carrying out operations.
- Organize and verify the basis for calculating all illegal gains, prepare a plan for disgorgement, and confirm whether there is written proof of statutory mitigating circumstances such as voluntary surrender, truthful confession, or meritorious service.
- Review the various service agreements and payment-on-behalf agreements signed with upstream clients or downstream channels, and assess the probative value of the contract terms regarding the degree of subjective knowledge.
- Collect the interrogation transcripts and witness testimony of other persons in the same case, and compare the consistency of the parties' descriptions of the transaction model, profit distribution, and decision-making process.
1. This Q&A is based solely on non-detailed facts disclosed in the news summary, such as "disclosed by the Shanghai Jing'an District People's Procuratorate," "amount involved exceeding RMB 200 million," "represented by Attorney Shao Shiwei's team," and "suspended sentences imposed." The full text of the judgment in this case has not been obtained, and it is impossible to confirm the specific criminal facts, details of the evidence chain, and sentencing reasons found by the court. 2. The "suspended sentence" outcome mentioned in the news must not be generalized as a common conclusion for similar cases; sentencing in each case depends on the specific evidence examined and cross-examined at trial. 3. No definitive legal opinion is provided on the specific sentencing ranges for the "crime of illegal business operations," nor is any absolute legal characterization made as to whether "RMB 200 million" necessarily constitutes "especially serious circumstances"; the final determination of the judicial authorities shall prevail. 4. The defense strategies mentioned in this article are only general compliance suggestions and do not constitute a legal commitment or guarantee of outcome for any specific case.
