China's regulatory authorities need to reach a consensus in the field of crypto assets and blockchain.
After the two documents on cryptocurrency came out a couple of days ago, my entire social media feed was flooded. I saw a large number of peer friends publishing interpretive articles, and I also saw that on short videos, institutions or teams discussing real-world assets (RWA) have become active as well.
In the first half, everyone was focused on the entire crypto world tightening again, being finished, collapsing; later, it was about China ushering in a happy new spring again, with some partners saying that China can finally issue coins, and all kinds of voices were lively and bustling.
Let me discuss my basic views:From a strict perspective, there is indeed a clear contractionMany crypto asset or Web3-related businesses that previously operated in the cracks in China are also facing great challenges to their room for survival, such as mining and so on. At the same time, I also mentioned that,China has finally left an opening in the area of real-world assets (RWA)Of course, this formulation is not necessarily very rigorous, because according to the CSRC's expression, it is actually not RWA, but is called tokenization of securities. But from an industry perspective, tokenization of securities is one type within the broad RWA framework that we discuss.
So I think there is no need to be particularly bound by the literal wording; it is enough that everyone can understand what the CSRC intends to express. Some journalists also came to interview me about my personal views on these two documents.
In the previous short video I mainly talked about some RWA, but I personally believe that such a regulatory document still has many aspects that can be interpreted.
So in this short video, I will spend a bit more time, based on the relevant content of the two documents, to talk with everyone more about my views from my perspective.
More importantly, for practitioners in our industry, and for some of the business practices I have seen in this industry, weCan it still be done in the mainland? If it cannot be done, what should we do?This is perhaps what I want to discuss with everyone in this short video.
This video may be a little long, so if you are indeed interested in this topic, I suggest you save it first so you do not scroll past it.
First, we can openthe topic concerning cryptocurrency risk prevention and handling by the central bank and other eight ministries and commissions, which is a report by National Business Daily. In it, we can go through point by point what it intends to convey.
First, one point is quite interesting: atthe very beginning, it actually directly defines the attributes of real-world asset tokenization, which is actually quite subtle. Because if you are familiar with China's regulation of crypto assets, you know that many things have already been said too many times, such as that virtual currency is equivalent to legal tender, that there is no legal protection, and so on.
However, this should be another instance of Chinese regulators, at the beginning of an article or a regulatory document, characterizing the matter of real-world asset tokenization. So this thing is actually quite strange, namely thatfrom the perspective of Web3, real-world assets (RWA) may merely be a commercial track, and even this commercial track's application across the entire global scope at present is not as good as imagined.
On many occasions, I have actually discussed with people that currentlyreal-world assets (RWA) globally actually fall into different typesof.
The first type may berepresented by the U.S. financial market, namely the tokenization of traditional financial assets.The most typical example is U.S. equities. We now see many exchanges proposing this, whether fully spot exchanges or fully derivatives exchanges, which would broadly allow players who were originally on a trading platform for crypto assets to buy, in addition to trading the traditional crypto assets we understand, a large volume of U.S. equities. This is in fact a track with relatively high certainty. After all, there are still a large number of people globally who wish to own assets in the U.S. capital market, but under a traditional securities account they may be unable to enjoy them, so this is a relatively common track or direction, and I am personally fairly optimistic about it.
The second point is thatunder the Hong Kong framework, that is, since the year before last, we have seen entities such as Ant Digital Technologies, LongShine, GCL, and Xunying, among others, ascommercial service providers, offering assets within the mainland to qualified investors or qualified investment institutions in Hong KongOf course, this still remains at the primary market and has not formed liquidity in the secondary market.
The third point is that, from the perspective of financial risk prevention, what China's regulatory authorities should focus on most is the large volume of mainland assets, mainland funds and mainland audiences active domestically,through various tokens issued in the name of NFTs, digital collectibles, or real-world assets (RWA)What regulators should focus on preventing actually falls within this third category.
So after the regulatory document was issued, I saw on WeChat Moments or short-video platforms a large number of people in the RWA field once again waving banners and shouting, saying they would rally their forces anew and that this day had finally come. I personally think this is actuallyprematurebecause the paths and methods by which these people or teams previously operated and conducted business fall squarely within the scope that the regulatory document expressly characterizes as illegal financial activities.
This regulatory document places real-world assets (RWA) at the very beginning, which shows that from the perspective of financial risk prevention, it is mainly aimed at the third category of people; their cheering is all the more peculiar.
Therefore, Lawyer Honglin strongly advises everyoneto be sure to conduct RWA-related activities in mainland China with caution, whether it is: providing one-stop business consulting, providing so-called technical solutions for token issuance, conducting marketing promotion, or directly selling products to end users. This carries very great risk in China. Placing it at the beginning of the document certainly has very important value and reasons.
There is also the matter of inter-departmental coordination. I have previously discussed with everyone why, at the end of 2025, there would be two documents characterizing stablecoins, as well as the characterization of RWA. The core point is that,China's regulatory authorities need to reach a consensus in the crypto assets and blockchain fieldFrom the perspective of judicial practice, the current legal treatment of the entire crypto world is fragmented: from a civil law perspective, it constitutes a citizen's individual private property and should be protected; but courts and government departments in different regions may hold inconsistent views and understandings. The same situation may be protected in Shanghai but may not be protected in some other mainland cities. Therefore, this requires coordination among multiple departments.
The core point of this document is that,whether it is the procuratorate, the court, the Cyberspace Administration, or financial institutions, all need to form a coordinated mechanism.This means that in cases or projects involving crypto assets and blockchain, all departments need to maintain consistent positions and pace.
Take another No. 1 document issued by the securities regulator as an example: in addition to understanding the relevant products as content within the securities regulatory framework, it is also necessary to satisfy other relevant requirements of the Cyberspace Administration, financial regulatory authorities and others, which can also be regarded as a cautious form of innovation.
Strengthening the risk prevention departments—here, China's foreign exchange administration authorities are in fact also brought in. Because we know that as the year-end approaches, especially after the regulatory characterization of stablecoins, a very important regulatory direction is in fact that concerning OTC dealers. I have always strongly advised some partners around me who previously did OTC business that they should indeed lie low for a while recently. Becausethe current core focus of domestic attention on cryptocurrencies has shifted, with a slight adjustment in wording, from the previous "issuing tokens and conducting ICOs to raise funds" to "guarding against raising funds through real-world assets (RWA)."This is in fact a key point concerning illegal fundraising and financial risk prevention.
In addition, one point that regulatory authorities care about most is in fact the issue of capital outflow. The original methods may be subject to certain restrictions, so a large number of partners hope to transfer funds across borders through methods such as USDT and other stablecoins. From the perspective of regulatory authorities, this is also a direction that requires key attention.
Moreover, we understand that since last year there have already been relevant projects or research directions that seek, from the perspective of on-chain tracking and in combination with the direction of off-chain interbank fund flows, to conduct big-data screening and monitoring, thereby identifying the paths of relevant capital outflows.
Thereforewe have always held the conservative view that mainland China will in fact not open up with respect to cryptocurrencies.A very important point is the issue of the capital management system, so this should be something that everyone in the industry needs to focus on at present.
From this perspective, whether it is acting as an OTC dealer in the narrow sense, or having related business needs around you and engaging in some matchmaking and pairing, or online using referral trading or rebates through certain exchanges to have netizens purchase crypto assets through your channel and then transfer them out in this way or use them for other purposes, the risk to you is too high, and we strongly advise against doing so.
At the same time, we also see in thiscertain restrictions on intermediaries or related service groupsI think this is also quite business-oriented, because the reason such a regulatory document is so detailed actually stems from attention to and description of a large number of micro-level scenarios in the current industry. For example, it even mentions: virtual currency and related financial products must not be included in the scope of collateral or pledged assets; insurance business related to virtual currency must not be carried out, etc.
I do not know how everyone will understand this sentence. Because we know that some friends on the market now, when doing OTC, have changed to a different formulation, namely, "I am lending you money, but I will take cryptocurrency as collateral." I do not know whether everyone can understand what this means.
In the traditional buying and selling process, it is cash on one hand and goods on the other, which constitutes the buying and selling of crypto assets. But now some friends have become "clever" and may want to make an adjustment: namely, "I am lending you money, a pure lending relationship, but I am worried that you have performance risk. It just so happens that you have some crypto assets with economic value, so at this time you give the crypto assets to me as collateral through pledge or other means. I am not helping you complete the exchange between crypto assets and fiat currency; I am actually in a lending relationship." This is a very subtle scenario.
But can you imagine? In such a regulatory document, descriptions like this were actually put in directly. So from this perspective, we can also to some extent understand thatthe regulatory authorities are now actually very familiar with the entire cryptocurrency industry, especially certain practices or schemes in the mainlandOf course, conversely, it is also because there should be many insiders, or partners in the circle, who, when facing the regulatory authorities, will describe and recount many business details. So everyone must absolutely not feel that if you play a little clever trick, the relevant departments will not understand or see this way of doing things. That actually does not really exist.
I think this document indeed has many points that can be discussed and studied slowly, which is also why I will use a relatively long short video to talk with everyone about this matter.
The seventh point is"Strengthen the management of internet information content and access"Everyone should be able to understand this point, because at present, on many short-video media platforms, such as a certain social media platform, a certain short-video platform, and video accounts, we see many overseas exchanges or project teams using large numbers of "sock puppet" accounts to conduct publicity and promotion on these platforms, including even recruitment. The platforms, for their part, will also, in accordance with the requirements of the Cyberspace Administration of China, periodically tighten restrictions on certain sensitive words and exercise control over the relevant accounts. The regulatory authorities have in fact already noticed this trend, and therefore the regulatory requirements for such internet platforms are becoming increasingly stringent. When law enforcement coordination is involved, the relevant internet platforms or content platforms are also required to cooperate.
The eighth point is"strengthening the registration and advertising management of business entities"Here I can discuss two details with you.
The first detail concerns Khorgos in Xinjiang, where there is a free trade zone. What I have learned is that in the past two years, when the local management committee issued business licenses to certain enterprises within its jurisdiction, their business scope included a business category such as "judicial disposal of cryptocurrencies."
Therefore, such provisions or documents are specifically targeted at details of this kind. Because there are now many free trade zones that may believe they can conduct pilot programs for certain financial innovations within their zones. But this document in fact directly expresses a negative attitude.
Another small detail is that we know that last year on a certain e-commerce platform, wealth management products concerning cryptocurrency investment once appeared. Of course, it sold out that very day and was then taken down. That wealth management product was essentially a fund product for outbound investment. Among its underlying assets, if I remember correctly, roughly 10% of the fund's investment direction was allocated to Bitcoin ETFs and certain crypto-asset concept stocks, such as equity in Coinbase. So strictly speaking, it was not a cryptocurrency fund product as we understand it. However, advertisements for outbound investment in the relevant assets through such multi-layer nesting arrangements are also subject to restrictions by the regulatory authorities. Therefore, it was likewise taken down and could not carry out the relevant advertising and promotion.
The ninth point ison rectifying cryptocurrency mining activitiesThe point that requires particular attention here is that, in addition to the position consistently emphasized since 2021 that cryptocurrency mining discovered in the mainland must be shut down and that no new additions are permitted,
this is in fact also a response to signs over the past year or more that cryptocurrency mining activities in the mainland have been showing signs of revival. We know that onceBitcoin hash rate in mainland China accounted for 70% of the global totaland the output was very high. However, after 2021, in theory, all cryptocurrency mining across China has moved offshore.
Nevertheless, based on Attorney Honglin's observations over the past two years, from the perspective of Bitcoin mining statistics,China still accounts for at least 20% or more of the hash rateOver the past six months or more, in the news media, such as a certain social media platform, and on my WeChat Moments, I have seen many people directly selling mining machines and even providing mining machine hosting services.
Of course, these things are hidden relatively deeply, for example, inside cloud computing centers and computing power centers in many places. Some may be more brazen, believing that the state's attitude in this area may have softened somewhat. But in reality, this amounts to a renewed clarification and emphasis: it is not allowed.
There is another point that I believe requires particular attention:Mining machine manufacturers are strictly prohibited from providing services such as mining machine sales within ChinaThis is effectively saying that mining is not permitted, and selling mining machines in mainland China is also not permitted. Because I frequently see people peddling mining machines on WeChat Moments.
This amounts to saying that, going forward, mining machines may only be exported and may not be sold within mainland China. This requires particular attention from those friends who sell mining machines or hardware on WeChat Moments, or who sell so-called "nodes" or "servers" under the name of "DePin." Because there is a mistaken perception that as long as what is sold is not a Bitcoin mining machine, selling mining machines for certain other minor cryptocurrencies is acceptable. But the regulators have also become aware of this, meaning that this kind of edge-ball activity should no longer be pursued.
It is mentioned later that, beyond illegal financial activities, if a suspected criminal offense is involved, the matter will be referred to the public security authorities; we will not elaborate on this point. We will also not elaborate on strengthening industry self-discipline.
Further on, Part Four, which is the key content we want to discuss, concerns real-world assets (RWA) and the like. In such a document, it clearly defines that:If you are a domestic entity and wish to conduct relevant activities in mainland China under the name of RWA, this is not permitted. If you are a domestic company or project and wish to directly issue relevant RWA tokens overseas, this is also not permitted.
However, there is in fact a small opening here:if you have completed filing with or obtained the consent of the relevant regulatory authorities, you may then carry out the relevant operations overseas.This in fact echoes or corresponds to the CSRC's No. 1 Document of 2026. That document states that if a domestic entity or project wishes to issue real-world assets (RWA) products overseas, first, you certainly need to complete filing with the CSRC domestically. Although it is not an approval, I think its force may be slightly weaker than an approval, but the threshold and requirements are still relatively high.
Second, if you wish to issue real-world assets (RWA) products overseas, you must engage the overseas subsidiaries or branches of domestic financial institutions. At the same time, it also imposes certain requirements on business details, but my understanding is that it is basically the same logic and standards as overseas bond issuance.
Therefore,these points draw for us the line between what can and cannot be done in the real-world assets (RWA) field as understood in the Web3 industry.
What cannot be done is this: if the assets are domestic assets, you cannot directly issue the relevant tokens domestically; if the assets are domestic assets and you wish to carry out real-world assets (RWA) token issuance overseas, you cannot direct it at the public in mainland China; and even if your project and assets are overseas, you cannot sell to mainland Chinese residents.
What can be done is this: after completing filing with the CSRC in China, you may then engage, overseas, the overseas subsidiaries or branches of domestic financial institutions to provide the relevant issuance services. In addition, information throughout the operation of the product and project must be promptly synchronized with the regulatory authorities.
This is in fact what we see as what can and cannot be done in the real-world assets (RWA) area. Therefore, in the CSRC's No. 1 Document, certain negative lists (that is, what cannot be done, which companies cannot do it, and which persons cannot do it) are also described. Although its wording and expression do not use the term "real-world assets (RWA)" to describe it, my understanding is that this in fact counts as cautious innovation.
This morning, relevant journalists interviewed me and asked me to discuss my views on this matter. I believe that under the current circumstances, China's effort to resolve the problem of quality assets in the mainland, or the development direction that the state wishes to focus on encouraging, through this method of securities tokenization:on the one hand, can support Hong Kong's financial innovation and industrial application in Web3. On the other hand, it can also be regarded as a cautious financial innovation under the CSRC (securities regulation).
It may be a very long distance and there is a significant gap between that and the level that partners in our industry want to achieve. This is basically not a matter for small players or startup teams. Therefore, I believe that, like some of the things Ant was doing previously, it should engage further with the securities regulator, and it may well be among the first in China to pursue applications and implementation in this direction.
Therefore, I believe that either an internet giant with sufficient scale and fintech attributes can do this, or some listed companies in China may allocate a portion of their projects to run a pilot.The preliminary compliance procedures and compliance costs are in fact very high。
So I think that if everyone has real-world assets (RWA) on their minds, they can hold off a little longer, wait another six months or a year, and see how the situation develops.
Finally,regarding legal liability, this also responds to what many partners have been following after this news article came out. One point is: for individual participants, if they invest in relevant crypto assets or relevant financial products, what legal risks do they face? This view is actually not innovative and remains unchanged:civil acts are invalid, and the risk is borne by the parties themselves。
There is another point here: where there is suspected disruption of financial order or harm to financial security, the relevant authorities will investigate and deal with it in accordance with law. One point here is slightly subtle: "financial order" actually includes something like the foreign exchange management regime. This means that if your personal purchase of coins is purely for personal cross-border use, then in such circumstances, if it is discovered, there will still be quite significant legal risk. Everyone should be able to understand this, and we will leave it at that.
In addition to individual participants, we also know that a large number of KOLs and a large number of Chinese-language operations partners are in fact active in mainland China. Because friends have also told me that currently 40% of global crypto asset trading volume is in mainland China. Of the exchanges we see today that talk about compliance every day, apart from the two in Hong Kong, the vast majority of trading institutions still conduct business face to face; people call this "selective compliance": on the one hand applying for licenses overseas, and on the other hand still doing this kind of thing in China. We will not judge that for now, but what I really want to emphasize here to everyone is that KOLs who provide traffic referral and promotional services for these institutions, or partners who handle content distribution and traffic referral, should be a little more careful going forward.
I was talking about this at an event some time ago: many partners feel that there is not much problem with posting relevant referral commission links on foreign media such as X (formerly Twitter) and having users register so they can get commissions. But the actual situation is that the relevant content and information we publish on foreign media will all be noticed; everyone should be able to understand what that sentence means.
Therefore, for those of us in mainland China, whether through events or links, helping some overseas non-compliant exchanges (the word "compliance" here is also a gray-area expression) to acquire customers: if they are core large platforms, then this may be a matter of probability and luck; if they are small platforms, and everyone is helping them carry out large-scale promotion because of the high commissions, then if in subsequent enforcement the platform is found to be engaged in illegal business operations, or even involves some gambling-related content, for the party providing the traffic referral,The criminal risk is also very high.。
Therefore, with respect to legal liability, in addition to focusing on individual holding and investment, we also need to focus on partners who drive traffic and promote for these trading institutions or OTC dealers. This is what we particularly need to pay attention to.
The above is roughly what I spent nearly half an hour discussing with you about this regulatory document, combined with the CSRC's Document No. 1, and some of my personal views. Of course, I did not specifically prepare a written script for this, so the expression may not be so precise, but I believe the core viewpoints and meaning have been conveyed.
I hope this can provide some positive help for everyone's future business choices, overseas expansion directions, or personal investment and trading. If you have more detailed questions, you can add WeChat to communicate.
Author of this article
Liu Honglin, Founder of Mankun Law Firm. Member of the Youth Work Committee of the Shanghai Bar Association, Member of the Informatization Work Committee of the Shanghai Bar Association, and Member of the Legal Technology Committee of the Shanghai Bar Association. Lawyer Liu Honglin has 10 years of experience in legal and internet entrepreneurship. He previously served as Vice President of a legal technology company strategically invested by Tencent and as Legal Manager of a private equity fund of a listed company. He is skilled at proposing actionable implementation plans for cases from the perspectives of business models and legal practice, so as to maximize commercial interests for users.
About Mankun
Mankun Law Firm was established in 2015 and is a boutique law firm in China focusing on the Web3.0 new economy and deeply engaged in the blockchain industry. Members of the Mankun team have unique and diverse industry backgrounds. Team members come from well-known legal service institutions, state judicial organs, internet technology companies, crypto assets institutions, blockchain industry think tanks, and other organizations.
Based on a deep understanding of the new economy field, continuous attention to and research on policies and regulations, and rich practical experience, the Mankun team is skilled at providing, from the perspectives of business models and legal practice, comprehensive legal services for Web3.0, blockchain, AI, NFT, digital collectibles, crypto funds, crypto payments, DeFi, real-world assets (RWA), GameFi and other new economy enterprises, including commercial architecture design, project investment and financing, transaction planning, business compliance, resolution of complex civil and commercial disputes, prevention and control of criminal-related risks, and criminal defense.
Mankun Law Firm is headquartered in Shanghai and has branches in Hong Kong, China, Silicon Valley in the United States, Shenzhen, Hangzhou, Zhengzhou, Chengdu, and other places. In response to the global compliance development needs of Web3.0 industry clients, Mankun has established local offices in major global crypto finance cities and selected local professional blockchain service partners to provide clients with professional legal and compliance services with global breadth and China depth.


