Do not wait until you are behind bars to understand the weight of the word "compliance."

Recently, Lawyer Deng's team received a consultation from a student.

Xiao A (pseudonym) saw someone on Xianyu "buying back USDT at a high price," with an exchange rate two or three mao higher than that of exchanges. Believing he had spotted a business opportunity, he bought USDT from an exchange, added the buyer on WeChat via Xianyu, and carried out the transaction.

On the first order, he made 50 yuan, and it went smoothly. On the second order, he made 200 yuan, and it also went smoothly. On the third order, he pooled 50,000 yuan in principal, intending to make a big score, but as soon as the money arrived, his bank card was frozen.

When he checked at the bank,it was a "public security freeze," for a term of six months.What devastated him even more was that a few days later, he received a call from the police station in the place where his household registration was located,requiring him to go and explain the situation, on the ground that he was "suspected of aiding information network criminal activities."

Xiao A felt aggrieved: "I was just earning the exchange-rate difference—how did I become a criminal?"

Drawing on recent consultations about bank cards being frozen in connection with USDT arbitrage, Lawyer Deng takes everyone behind the scenes of this hidden "digital black market" to see how those seemingly attractive "arbitrage" businesses push ordinary people step by step into the abyss of criminal offenses.

 

Reasons for frozen cards: you think it is arbitrage, but it is actually money laundering

Searching "USDT" on Xianyu usually returns a blank page, but if you switch to "selling U," "game top-up on behalf," or "payment on behalf," you will discover a bustling underground market. It is flooded with a large number of posts about "buying back at a high price" and "arbitrage on exchange-rate differences."

Always remember a basic business principle: USDT, as a stablecoin, has a price that is publicly transparent on all major exchanges. If someone is willing to acquire your USDT atabove the market price(for example, the exchange sells at 6.8, but he offers 7.2), or asks you to make a payment on his behalf, there is only one reason:his money is not clean.

Criminals engaged in telecom fraud and online gambling hold large amounts of dirty money. They dare not buy coins directly on exchanges (because they would be flagged by risk controls), so they use C2C platforms such as Xianyu to transfer the dirty money to you and take away the clean USDT in your hands.

In the entire chain,you act as a "human money-laundering machine"The few hundred yuan of "price difference" you earn is in fact the "money-laundering fee" paid to you by the criminals.

 

In-depth analysis: criminal characterization behind three high-risk transactions

According to the large number of criminal cases involving crypto handled by Attorney Deng's team, these transaction models on Xianyu can easily constitute the following offenses under the Criminal Law. This is by no means alarmist; these are real examples occurring in judicial practice.

Scenario one: "proxy top-up/proxy payment" — the crime of concealing or disguising criminal proceeds

1. Modus operandi: The buyer claims to have no foreign-currency card and asks you to help purchase Steam top-up cards, gift cards, or pay for overseas goods on their behalf using USDT or foreign currency, promising to pay a high commission.

2. Legal characterization: This is a typical form of "physical isolation" money laundering.

  • Objective conduct: You received funds from an upstream source (which are in fact proceeds of crime) and, by purchasing goods or top-up services, "laundered" or transferred the funds.
  • Subjective determination: Many people argue, "I did not know it was illicit money." However, in judicial practice, when a mentally competent adult is confronted with a stranger offeringa commission clearly above the market rateandan unreasonable transaction request(such as bypassing formal payment channels), the law presumes that you "should have known" the source of the funds was suspicious.
  • Consequences: This constitutes the crime of concealing or disguising the proceeds of crime, punishable by fixed-term imprisonment of not less than three years but not more than seven years in the most serious cases.

Scenario 2: "Selling USDT at a high price" — the crime of assisting information network criminal activities (the crime of aiding and abetting)

1. Modus Operandi: Simple and crude: the other party buys back your USDT at a price above the exchange rate.

2. Legal Characterization: This is a high-incidence area for the crime of assisting information network criminal activities.

  • Key evidence: Under the Interpretation on Several Issues Concerning the Application of Law in the Handling of Criminal Cases Involving Illegal Use of Information Networks and Assisting Information Network Criminal Activities, "a clearly abnormal transaction price"is one of the core criteria for determining that the actor had "subjective knowledge."
  • Logical chain: You provided your own bank card to receive fraud-related funds and used USDT to complete thepayment settlementof the funds. Such conduct directly assisted upstream criminal offenders in transferring illicit proceeds and constitutes "providing payment settlement assistance" in the legal sense.
  • Consequences: Where the case-filing threshold is met, a sentence of fixed-term imprisonment of not more than three years may be imposed.

Scenario Three: "Buying and Reselling" — the Crime of Illegal Business Operations

1. Modus Operandi: If you do not merely sell USDT occasionally but do so as a business, buying low and selling high to profit from the price difference,

2. Legal characterization: such conduct may be characterized asillegal business operations。

  • Judicial interpretation: In China, disguised foreign exchange trading that disrupts the order of the financial market and is serious in nature constitutes the crime of illegal business operations. Although it remains disputed whether USDT is equivalent to foreign exchange, judicial practice in some regions has already produced judgments characterizing the "reselling of USDT" as the crime of illegal business operations; once convicted, the sentencing is often heavier than for the crime of assisting information network criminal activities.

 

Civil risk: a state of "running naked" under national-level notices

Beyond exposure to imprisonment, crypto transactions on Xianyu are also in a position where, as regards civil rights and interests, there is no one to turn to and no remedy to be found.

Since the September 24, 2021 notice, national-level announcements have clearly defined that:business activities related to virtual currency constitute illegal financial activities.

What does this mean?

  • The contract is invalid, and losses are borne by the parties themselves.If you are defrauded while selling USDT on Xianyu (for example, the counterparty sends a fake transfer screenshot, or blocks you after receiving the coins), and you bring a lawsuit in court demanding that the counterparty return the money, the court will most likely, based on the provisions of the Civil Code concerning "offending public order and good morals" or "violating the mandatory provisions of laws and administrative regulations," find the transaction contract between you invalid. Put plainly: the law does not protect "black market" transactions. Your losses can only be swallowed by yourself.
  • Not only may you be unable to recover the money, you may also face fines.If your trading conduct is determined by an administrative authority (such as the industry and commerce authority or the public security authority) to constitute illegal engagement in token issuance and financing or illegal business operations, you will not only be unable to recover the money you were defrauded of, but may also face administrative penalties in less serious cases or criminal charges in more serious cases.

 

Three practical recommendations for "side-hustlers"

For the sake of a small profit, to carry a criminal record that affects three generations—this is not a worthwhile trade by any calculation. Here are three recommendations for all "side-hustlers":

1. Stay away from all "payment on behalf" and "purchase on behalf" arrangements: No matter how plausible the other party's reasons may sound ("my study-abroad quota is insufficient," "I don't have a foreign card"),if it involves having you use your own account to route funds for someone else, block them without exception. You are doing a side hustle, not charity, and certainly not acting as a "money-laundering tool."

2. Be wary of "premium" transactions: There is no such thing as a free lunch. Any purchase of coins at a price above the exchange market price necessarily involves something suspicious. Do not, out of greed for a tiny exchange-rate differential, place yourself within the scope of enforcement under the "Operation Card-Breaking" campaign.

3. What should you do if your card is frozen?

  • Do not trust online "unfreezing fixers", that is a secondary scam.
  • Do not panic, and contact your bank immediately to inquire which authority imposed the freeze (usually public security authorities in another jurisdiction).
  • Preserve evidence: organize your Xianyu chat records and transaction statements. Although your conduct may have violated rules, in criminal defense, proving that you "lacked subjective intent" (you were merely seeking a small advantage and did not know the funds were illicit) is key to seeking a decision not to open a case or not to prosecute.

 

Conclusion

You thought the "flipping arbitrage" on Xianyu was just that, but you are merely serving as the lowest-level "cannon fodder" in a vast illicit-industry chain. Many young people mistakenly believe that the anonymity of blockchain is a natural barrier to crime, unaware thatthe "immutability" of on-chain data has precisely become the most solid "ironclad evidence" for judicial authorities in conviction and sentencing.

The upstream operators hide overseas, enjoying blood-soaked windfall profits; while you, downstream, because of your real-name-verified bank cards and Alipay, have become the easiest to identify and lowest-cost target in law enforcement's crackdown chain.

Do not wait until you are behind bars to understand the weight of the word "compliance."

 

Author

Deng Xiaoyu,Partner at Mankun (Shenzhen) Law Firm. Mr. Deng specializes in criminal cases and has participated in handling nearly 300 cases, with solid theoretical grounding and extensive practical experience. He is particularly adept in the field of Web3.0 crime and has provided criminal defense for several well-known digital currency exchanges, effectively safeguarding the rights and interests of clients. He has received the "Special Contribution Award for the 30th Anniversary of the Shenzhen Lawyers Association" and has been interviewed by several well-known domestic media outlets and invited by the industry to give lectures on multiple occasions.

 

Li Haojun, a practicing lawyer at Mankun (Shenzhen) Law Firm. Bachelor of Laws, Beijing Normal University (Zhuhai). Lawyer Li Haojun has been deeply involved in multiple difficult and complex litigation cases, possesses a solid professional foundation and a high degree of focus, and is committed to providing clients with solutions to complex and difficult issues. His goal is to become a dispute resolution lawyer who "understands both the profession and the industry." He currently focuses on criminal, civil and commercial cases in new economy fields such as Web3, blockchain, and cryptocurrency.

 

About Mankun

Mankun Law Firm was established in 2015 and is a boutique law firm in China focused on the Web3.0 new economy and deeply engaged in the blockchain industry. Mankun's team members possess unique and diverse industry backgrounds, coming from well-known legal service institutions, state judicial organs, internet technology companies, crypto assets institutions, blockchain industry think tanks, and other organizations.

Based on a deep understanding of the new economy, continuous attention to and research on policies and regulations, and extensive practical experience, the Mankun team is adept at providing comprehensive legal services from the perspectives of business models and legal practice to new economy enterprises in Web3.0, blockchain, AI, NFT, digital collectibles, crypto funds, crypto payments, DeFi, real-world assets (RWA), GameFi, and other fields, including commercial architecture design, project investment and financing, transaction planning, business compliance, resolution of complex civil and commercial disputes, criminal risk prevention and risk management, and criminal defense.

Mankun Law Firm is headquartered in Shanghai and has branches in Hong Kong, China, Silicon Valley in the United States, Shenzhen, Hangzhou, Zhengzhou, Chengdu, and other locations. In response to the global compliance development needs of Web3.0 industry clients, Mankun has established local offices in major global crypto finance cities and selected local professional blockchain service partners to provide clients with professional legal and compliance services with global breadth and China depth.