When you gaze into the abyss, the abyss gazes also into you.

As a lawyer who has long handled cases in the crypto space, I have imperceptibly become a crypto player myself. During the market turmoil earlier this year, when ETH plunged, I was holding USDT and had intended to add to my ETH position, but then I saw the copy-trading signals in the community and suddenly thought: why not take advantage of the market and try futures trading once?

Fortunately, I asked a few players around me, and they all said, "Don't trade futures; it's just gambling," and "Don't trade futures; you won't be able to sleep."

In the end, looking at the messages posted by the signal providers in the group and recalling the cases I had handled in which copy-trading rebates were found to constitute running a gambling establishment, I knew I should not "gamble."

 

What are virtual currency exchange futures copy-trading rebates?

There are actually three levels of meaning here:

Virtual currency exchange

As the name suggests, a virtual currency exchange is an online platform dedicated to providing trading services for virtual currencies. Users can register an account, deposit virtual currency or fiat currency into the exchange's wallet, and carry out buy and sell operations. These exchanges not only support trading between virtual currencies but also allow users to use fiat currency (such as US dollars, euros, renminbi, etc.) to purchase virtual currencies.

Exchange futures

Exchange futures are standardized agreements uniformly formulated by the exchange. In current virtual currency exchanges,futures tradingis derived from traditional futures contracts.

A futures contract provides for the delivery of a specified quantity of an underlying asset (such as a commodity or a financial asset) at a particular time and place in the future. The main terms of a futures contract include the trading product, delivery date, delivery location, delivery method, contract size, and so on. The standardization of these terms gives the contract relatively high liquidity and tradability.

At present, however, most offerings on virtual currency exchanges are perpetual contracts, and within the industry, references to contracts generally default to perpetual contracts. Unlike futures contracts, which have a delivery deadline, perpetual contracts have no delivery date and no term limit. Investors use their principal as margin and, through the leverage provided by the exchange, speculate on whether the virtual price will rise or fall, thereby making a profit (or incurring a loss).

Exchanges derive their revenue mainly from charging fees. The practice of setting high leverage in perpetual contracts exposes investors to extremely high risk, while the exchange can obtain higher fee revenue.

Contract lead-trading rebates

Contract lead trading refers to experienced traders (lead traders) sharing their contract trading decisions and operations, while other investors (follow traders) choose to follow or copy the lead trader's trading operations in the hope of obtaining similar returns. This model is similar to social trading or copy trading: the lead trader usually plays the role of a leader, while follow traders seek returns by imitating the lead trader's trades.

Lead-trading rebates, in turn, means that these traders (consisting basically of KOLs and retail investors) have previously acceptedthe engagement of a virtual currency exchange and, using their influence in their own communities, conduct promotion to attract follow traders, and obtain from the follow traders' trades commissions rebated by the exchange.

 

Why are more and more lead-trading rebate arrangements now being found to constitutethe crime of running a gambling establishment?

Obviously, the crime of running a gambling establishment requires that a gambling establishment first be set up.

First, a lead trader does not separately engage in the act of setting up a gambling establishment. What a lead trader generally shares is an invitation code for registering an exchange account; for users who register through the invitation code, the exchange pays the KOL a corresponding proportion of the fees, including those for contract trading on the exchange, generated thereafter.

Therefore, if a lead trader is to be found to constitute the crime of running a gambling establishment, it must necessarily be found that the exchange's contract offerings constitute a form of gambling, and that the exchange is therefore found to be an online venue providing gambling activities.

However, whether exchange contracts are characterized as running a gambling house has always been controversial.

On the one hand, if the contract products offered by a virtual currency exchange fully replicate the traditional futures contract model (non-perpetual contracts), in the cases we have encountered, some defense counsel have, by applying to regulatory authorities for a determination of the trading model, succeeded in defending a charge of running a gambling house asthe crime of illegal business operationsIn such a case, even if the lead trader (daidan yuan) accepts commission rebates from the platform, because the platform does not constitute the crime of running a gambling house, the lead trader's conduct likewise cannot be characterized as the crime of running a gambling house (as an accomplice).

On the other hand, if the virtual currency exchange offers perpetual contracts, in current judicial practice they will basically be found to constitute the exchange's act of running a gambling house. According to a search of publicly available cases, the logic by which judicial authorities characterize perpetual contracts as gambling is mainly as follows:

1. The rise and fall of virtual currencies is characterized by irregularity, randomness and contingency.Users of the exchange choose to buy and open a long position (betting on a rise) or sell and open a short position (betting on a fall) based on their expectations of the rise and fall of the virtual currency. This is a form of binary options trading, but the basis for the expectation of a rise or fall is an index derived from a weighted average of the trading value of the virtual currency obtained by the exchange. There is no unified price formation mechanism for virtual currencies; prices fluctuate violently, and rises and falls are contingent and follow no discernible pattern.

2. The exchange amplifies speculative risk through high leverage, carrying high risk.。Ordinary perpetual contracts can be leveraged up to 100 times, and aggressive contract products may reach 1000 times. Once high leverage is used, it is extremely easy to cause a "forced liquidation" (baocang). In addition, the platform sets up bots to place orders and take the opposite side of players' bets, inducing players to engage in contract trading; by estimating market conditions for the rise and fall of virtual currencies and through risk control, it sets caps on buying long or buying short, thereby increasing users' contract trading costs.

3. Moreover, in accordance withcurrent policy provisions, "virtual currency perpetual contract trading" constitutes illegal financial activity.Its obvious difference from futures trading is that no delivery time is agreed, as it is a perpetual contract, with trading hours of 7x24 hours, extremely high leverage multiples, and no physical or cash delivery. The trading model offered by the exchange is essentially no different from the gambling conduct of "betting on big or small and wagering on win or lose."

Therefore, persons who participate in lead trading for perpetual contracts will be deemed to have formed an agency relationship with the casino, thereby constituting the crime of operating a casino.

 

Final remarks: two points to note

Lead trading with commission rebates for contracts carries obvious legal risks.

On the one hand, persons engaged in lead trading with commission rebates for contracts should not harbor the wishful thinking that perpetual contracts on overseas exchanges are not unlawful, and that soliciting clients within the territory for overseas exchanges is also not unlawful. National conditions and policies differ; do not apply overseas frameworks to the mainland environment.

On the other hand, if lead trading with commission rebates is determined under local law to violate relevant regulations such as securities law or futures law, the rebate amounts may be determined to be illegal income and subject to restitution; even lawful income may be subject to tax payment in accordance with local regulations. When that time comes, do not ask why, if lead trading in the mainland requires no tax payment, foreign countries should require tax payment.