I have worked hard for the Web3 industry, and in 2026 I will continue working to make Web3 lawful in China.

(February 2026 marks exactly one year since I accepted the engagement from one of the largest domestic crypto exchanges. I joined the case at the second instance. Although I am truly dissatisfied that the outcome did not overturn the original conviction, the case nonetheless achieved a rare second-instance reversal of judgment, which is enough to warrant this written record and to encourage my work this year.)

 

Engagement

At the beginning of 2025, when my lawyer relationship was still in the process of transferring to Mankun, I received the family member of the party in this crypto exchange (hereinafter referred to as the "Exchange") in Shenzhen.

During the meeting, I learned that this was a well-known case (it should be thelargest exchange in China by volume). The party was currently identified as a principal offender in the crime of running a gambling establishment because he was responsible for the perpetual contract segment. For the first instance, a university professor of criminal law was engaged for the defense, and two leading criminal law authorities in the legal academic community, Zhang and Chen, were invited to issue expert demonstration opinions. All of these expert opinions held that —perpetual contracts are not gambling, and this case does not constitute the crime of running a gambling establishment。

(Image material is from the internet and unrelated to the case)

ButThe first-instance judgment did not meet the family's expectations, and for the second instance they wanted to replace counsel with a criminal lawyer who has Web3 industry knowledge, so they contacted me.

The engagement discussions went very smoothly. The family is well aware of the difficulty of securing a changed judgment on appeal, but they are very willing to make further attempts. Because my practicing certificate must be surrendered for a period of time due to my transfer to another firm, I at the same time had the family engage another criminal lawyer at Mankun Law Firm—Lawyer Gao Mengyang(this was my first collaboration with Gao, and it laid the foundation for a revolutionary friendship). We moved quickly to arrange a meeting and to review and obtain the case file, so that we could promptly study and assess the case.

 

The investigation-support company

Soon afterward, Gao and I met Leo (hereinafter referred to as "Second Brother") in this city that has no high-speed rail service. After more than a year in custody, he had grown accustomed to it; he was in good spirits and thinking clearly.

Because we both understand Web3, many information concepts no longer needed to be explained, and trust was established quickly. He took the initiative to describe the background of the "long-range fishing" operation in this case (previous articleRecording What I Saw of Long-Range Fishing)—for example, that in the early stage of custody he was tortured to extract a confession and was arbitrarily held in an intensive care center, and that whenever he failed to cooperate he would be sent to an infectious disease ward. After our meeting, we verified these circumstances with the family and learned that during the first instance the family had reported the above circumstances to the case-handling authorities—among the materials was a recording in which Second Brother could be heard telling his family, "Give the equipment in xxx to the police, or I'll be beaten to death"—but the case-handling authorities did not respond.

According to his statement, at the time the case-handling authorities were simply out to get money.At first, the investigation-support company believed his assets were worth nearly ten million, and the case handlers told him to return the money and keep about one million for his family to live on, and that his case would then be easier to handle. But unexpectedly, after he handed over the assets in the safe, his virtual assets that had previously been unrelated to the case were also targeted, and the amount attributed to him personally in the case was made out to be over one hundred million.

What he mentioned,the investigation-support companies, are a malignant presence in the industry—referring to certain on-chain technical analysis companies in mainland China thatostensibly make their living from cybersecurity business but in fact cooperate with certain law enforcement agencies in the business of gathering leads, and whose egregious practices even extend to dispatching personnel to embed themselves with project parties (such as the mainland teams of overseas crypto exchanges) to investigate the specific identities of mainland colleagues and the status of project fund pools, and thereafter to extort the project parties or sell the information to mainland law enforcement units, sharing in the profits during the law enforcement units' subsequent disposal of virtual currencies—a type of business model.

In this connection, in the defense arrangements that Lao Gao and I subsequently made, we advised the family to continue reporting the situation upward; right and wrong must reach a conclusion. I have always believed that achieving good results in any case is inseparable from the joint efforts of the lawyers, the client, and the family,The cards available for the second-instance defense were originally few, but procedural violations have always been a card that can be played.

 

The bizarre phenomenon of adjudication before trial

After the meeting concluded, we hurried to the Intermediate People's Court and obtained the case file. The judge of the Intermediate People's Court arranged for an assistant to liaise with us. Given the earlier background of long-arm fishing and the restrictions on lawyers' meetings, we were initially highly tense about whether the court system could safeguard lawyers' rights. Fortunately, however, the file review proceeded smoothly, and during the review we discovered a document that appeared to be internal file material—At the outset of the investigation in this case, a social risk assessment was conducted, and the assessment materials scored various aspects of the investigation in this case。

(Image material sourced from the internet and unrelated to the case)

This assessment report, taking the former Panda Exchange as an example, concluded that there was no dispute over the finding of the crime of operating a gambling establishment, that all departments actively cooperated, and it directly confirmed in the report the principal and accessory status of each suspect. On this basis, we became deeply aware that,This is a case where the verdict was predetermined before trial, and moreover it is at the second-instance stage (over the years, the second-instance reversal rate has been roughly one in ten), so the defense will turn into an extremely tough battle to fight.

 

The case is already at second instance, yet the police still came to interrogate him

Old Gao and I quickly finished reviewing the case file in sync, and after reviewing the file we hurried to meet Second Brother—The main point is that we found in the case file that the data materials relied upon to determine the amount of the crime had not been appended to the file, and after cross-checking with Second Brother we found that at first instance there was also the problem that data materials had not been transferred, and that many witnesses' statements in the case file were scattered and placed in the files of other cases (the dozens of people in this case were split into multiple cases).

When we went straight from the county seat to the city court, submitted applications for supplementary file review and for a hearing, and then came back to meet Second Brother. Second Brother said he had been interrogated—we figured it was the judge or the second-instance prosecuting prosecutor—but on second thought that was unlikely, since during the interrogation period we were still in contact with the case handlers at the court and the procuratorate.

Second Brother said outright that it wasthe police officer who had handled the case earlier; we never expected him to come interrogate him at this time, and the implication of his words was nothing other than to have him return the money so that the case could be handled favorably, which is quite a violation of the rules and also instilled fear in the client. After the family learned of this, they became firm in their determination to complain about the rule-violating handling of the case.

 

We are conducting out-of-court defense

to postpone the hearing.

In the blink of an eye, two months had passed since the second-instance case was docketed. Although the court agreed to our application for a hearing, it contacted us in April to hold the hearing. Both of us defense counsel refused, because the complexity of the case is the root cause, and more importantly, our previously submitted application for supplementary file review had received no response, and we could not see several materials that the first-instance court used as the basis for its judgment.

We are filing a complaint.

At the same time, we made it clear to the court that, as lawyers, we had filed a complaint against the appraisal institution, and that the appraisal materials used as evidence at first instance might no longer be usable. The family members filed a complaint against the public security authorities, and the earlier interrogation records might also be unusable owing to torture to extract confessions. We asked for some time for the case, and the judge agreed and said that they had contacted the case-handling unit and the appraisal institution on our behalf and that they agreed to let us review the case file.

At this point we were still grateful for the sense of responsibility shown by this female judge at second instance; over the following two to three months or so we were in communication regarding the supplementary review of the case file at second instance,We separately obtained more than 70 GB of electronic data materials from the public security authorities and the appraisal center, and saw that it was the company's technical staff who, in order to earn merit, had taken the initiative to recover and download them from the cloud server.

Through the coordination of this female judge at second instance, we also obtained from the court of first instance the materials in the three cases that had been split off, among which the company's finance staff clearly stated that our client's criminal proceeds were not that large, which contradicts the audit report in the case file.

We are conducting research.

During this period I did not slack off either; I wrote several articles arguing that perpetual contracts are not gambling. In those articles I asserted that perpetual contracts are simply not gambling, rather than timidly writing that perpetual contracts may in some circumstances be gambling and may in other circumstances not be gambling.

This was grounded on the one hand in a fundamental understanding of the difference between investment activities and gambling activities, and on the other hand in the courage given to me by two leading legal scholars.Moreover, while writing an article today, I saw that a judge in Shanghai had also published an article arguing that perpetual contracts are not gambling.

Even though in 2025 all the exchange perpetual contract cases we handled were found to constitute the crime of running a casino, I firmly believe that history will give the correct answer, because the one who is wrong is definitely not me; but I must also reluctantly remind Web3 entrepreneurs not to step into perpetual contracts at present.

 

Confrontation Before the Hearing

After the supplementary case file came back, the family members' complaint against the public security authorities also drew the attention of the supervisory department; if the process were written out, this article would most likely be gone. Roughly, our lawyers were refused when lawfully meeting with the second brother and were told to go to the public security bureau for a little chat before coming back to the meeting; at the time we were quite nervous and reported our safety situation to the firm. Later, at the public security bureau we met the leadership,After several rounds of amicable communication, we helped the family recover part of the assets first.

We were also able to meet Second Brother under normal conditions, explain the situation outside to him, and convey that many of his acquaintances at home and abroad had expressed concern for his situation. Our work at this stage was also recognized by Second Brother.

With a defense approach that Second Brother approved, we went to see the prosecutor for the second instance. In appeal cases, the prosecutor's role differs from that at first instance: the first-instance prosecutor is called the public prosecutor and mainly supports the public prosecution, whereas the second-instance prosecutor must also supervise the first-instance case. We genuinely believed the case had major problems and wished to communicate candidly. After hearing our views, the prosecutor stated outright that he had handled the Panda firm's case and considered that the exchange in this case was not very different from Panda.

Old Gao and I had previously learned about the Panda firm's situation and had discussed with Second Brother the contract models of the two firms.Second Brother stated outright that the Panda firm had falsified data, and that characterizing it as fraud would not be excessive. By contrast, his own exchange, apart from the high leverage ratios in certain sections, used data entirely connected to Binance and operated fully according to the Binance model.

But the communication went no further than that. We did not harbor the extravagant hope that a simple conversation could change anything in the second-instance case file.Still, we wanted to say a little more, so that the case-handling personnel would hear a little more, and so that the concepts and seeds of Web3 could take root in the judicial world as much as possible.This is no monstrous beast; and even if it were a fierce beast, these judicial personnel ought to understand it all the more, so as to better build the cage of regulation.

 

The hearing was held in the morning.

Before the hearing, we made frequent visits to Second Brother in this county town, which has no high-speed rail access. During that time, we found a hidden-gem hotel: extremely low-priced yet equipped to star-rated standards. Inside the hotel, we saw public notices concerning the hotel's bankruptcy proceedings and only then learned that this was a slow recovery plan arranged by the bankruptcy administrator, which was why the accommodation was so cost-effective.

A litigation process is also like major surgery; after the litigation ends, there is still a rehabilitation and physiotherapy period. Are we performing a second surgery? But ultimately, a lawyer can hardly become the chief surgeon; the scalpel is always held in the court's hands.

The judge borrowed the venue of the first-instance court and came from the city to hold the hearing in the county. The first instance had clearly already passed the mask era, and we did not know why it had been held by video. The first time Second Brother walked into the court, he seemed quite accustomed to it, and he also saw his family members, whom he had not seen for a long time.

We discovered thatmany unfamiliar faces were seated in the public gallery, and it was only during the lunch recess that we learned they were the case-handling personnel from the various stages prior to the first-instance trial.Our senior colleague Gao divided the work: I would mainly conduct questioning, while he would mainly conduct cross-examination and present evidence. In the course of the questioning and cross-examination, both Gao and I raised the issues of torture to extract confessions by the public security authorities and the unlawful disposal of virtual assets—when Second Brother realized that the more he cooperated, the more he was mistreated, he ultimately did not agree to the case-handling unit entrusting a third-party company to dispose of the virtual assets, but the public security authority forcibly disposed of them, and this was also a point we pressed repeatedly at the second-instance trial.

Time flew by, and by the end of the morning our case had not yet reached the debate stage. The judge proposed adjourning for lunch and resuming at 1 p.m., and hoped that we lawyers would speed things up so that they would not have to spend the night in the county. As the recess approached, I had wanted to add the court clerk on WeChat and send her a long video on the theme of "Futures" posted by the well-known content creator "Xiao Lin Shuo," so that she could forward it to the judges to help them understand the history of the development of futures, in which perpetual contracts are essentially a new form of futures development. In order to rebut the first-instance finding that perpetual contracts, lacking physical delivery, constituted gambling, I had supplemented a great deal of knowledge about futures: stock index futures likewise have no physical delivery, and all of this content could be popularized in that video about futures.

But to my great surprise, the cover of that video about futures by the content creator "Xiao Lin Shuo" prominently displayed the title "What Is a 'Financial Casino'…" Although "Xiao Lin Shuo" had put it in quotation marks, in order to avoid causing misunderstanding among the judges, I decided not to forward it after all. We would simply continue the defense at the afternoon hearing.

In fact, in the many economic crime cases we have handled, we have heard a great deal of outrageous rhetoric, not least case-handling personnel treating stock trading and futures trading as gambling. People in the crypto circle also jokingly call contracts gambling-addict behavior, but such descriptions emphasize the speculative nature of these financial activities rather than treating them as true gambling akin to betting on football or horse racing.

What is the difference between the two? What is it? If you have read this far, it is truly worth thinking about carefully.

 

Afternoon hearing

Lunch with the family members was very rushed. I forced down a few bites, truly had no appetite, and smoked repeatedly. When the hearing resumed at one o'clock, we entered through the lawyers' passage and happened to overhear a certain case-handling officer on the phone in the corridor seeking outside assistance and inquiring in detail about what perpetual contracts are. At this I felt rather pleased with my pre-hearing preparation: I had used Binance's demo trading platform to simulate perpetual contracts and had prepared several PPT printouts to display in court.

When the hearing resumed, Gao was reading out the evidence materials,We gathered the regulatory policies and handled cases concerning perpetual contracts in the United States, Singapore, and Hong Kong, and not one of them treated it as gambling, and we also mentioned that we had complained to the appraisal institution but received no reply for a long time, in an attempt to show that the evidentiary effect of the materials on which the first-instance judgment was based is questionable. We also once again presented the opinions of two leading legal scholars from the first instance, who argued from a criminal law perspective that perpetual contracts are not gambling.

What is worth pondering is that the family members attending the hearing were not allowed to enter the courtroom because it was outside working hours; the debate stage began before the family members came in. During the debate, I really wished the family members could see it!

When my second brother made his self-defense, he stated the views we had discussed during our many meetings, and said frankly that if a conviction were truly necessary, he could at most accept illegal business operations, because the state does not support business operations involving virtual currency transactions, but he truly could not accept gambling,because if they had known this was gambling, they definitely would not have engaged in it; doing no evil is the bottom line of them as Web3 practitioners.

Before I presented my defense opinion,I proposed showing the PPT on perpetual contracts to the case-handling personnel participating in the trial activities, and explained in conjunction with the PPT that perpetual contracts are not a gambling game of betting on big or small, because in betting on big or small, if one guesses wrong, once the dice cup is lifted, the win or loss is determined. But contracts, as financial speculation activities, do not necessarily cause losses if one guesses the direction of the coin price wrong; traders can hold the contract order and wait for the coin price trend to move in the direction of their long or short position. Moreover, if only one-time leverage is opened, one will never be liquidated; the core difference between financial activities and gambling activities lies in whether participants hold the power of risk control. The so-called leverage multiple is not the core; there is gambling without leverage, and there are also a large number of high-leverage financial activities.

I saw several judges exchanging views while listening to our defense opinions, and I heard subsequent defenders agree with our defense views, and the comrade prosecutor also recognized our opinion that the public security authorities' illegal disposal of virtual currency is an illegal act and is worth addressing. Everything seemed to be moving in a good direction.

In the final closing statement, I made clear that I didnot believe that perpetual contracts are not gambling because I was a defender; rather, it was precisely because I had a deep understanding of this industry and a deep understanding of perpetual contracts that I firmly made a not-guilty defense.My second brother did not engage in a gambling game in order to do evil. If contracts were characterized as gambling, a large number of people in mainland China would be found to have committed illegal and criminal acts of gambling. Is that really conducive to social management?

 

Conclusion

Around the National Day holiday, we received the outcome of the case: the second-instance judgment was amended, the sentence of the second brother was reduced, and together with the portion of assets the family recovered before the hearing, we were fortunate to have a clear conscience and to have lived up to the trust placed in us.

However, the legal characterization of the charge remained unchanged, which is a frustration I find hard to put into words.But I want to say that I have worked hard for the Web3 industry, and we firmly believe that seeds sown in spring will surely be harvested in the future; in 2026 we will continue to make Web3 happen lawfully in China.

Go alone and you go fast; go together and you go far. The path of Web3 compliance is long and requires more legal professionals with solid professional grounding to sow the seeds together. March 7-8, we welcome everyone to the offline cryptocurrency legal training camp in Hangzhou. We will not talk in empty terms; we will only discuss how to address real compliance challenges. You are welcome to join us in exploration and exchange.

Representing Lawyer

Deng Xiaoyu,Partner at Mankun (Shenzhen) Law Firm. Lawyer Deng specializes in criminal cases and has participated in handling nearly three hundred cases, with solid theoretical grounding and extensive practical experience. He is particularly adept in the field of Web3.0 crime and has provided criminal defense for several well-known digital currency exchanges, effectively safeguarding the rights and interests of clients. He has received the "Special Contribution Award for the 30th Anniversary of the Shenzhen Lawyers Association" and has been interviewed by several well-known domestic media outlets and invited by the industry to give lectures on multiple occasions.

 

About Mankun

Mankun Law Firm was established in 2015 and is a boutique law firm in China focused on the Web3.0 new economy and deeply engaged in the blockchain industry. Members of the Mankun team have diverse and distinctive industry backgrounds, coming from well-known legal service institutions, state judicial organs, internet technology companies, crypto assets institutions, blockchain industry think tanks, and other organizations.

Based on a deep understanding of the new economy, continuous attention to and research on policies and regulations, and extensive practical experience, the Mankun team is adept at providing, from the perspectives of business models and legal practice, comprehensive legal services to new economy enterprises in Web3.0, blockchain, AI, NFT, digital collectibles, crypto funds, crypto payments, DeFi, real-world assets (RWA), GameFi, and other fields, including business structure design, project investment and financing, transaction planning, business compliance, resolution of complex civil and commercial disputes, prevention and control of criminal risks, and criminal defense.

Mankun Law Firm is headquartered in Shanghai and has branch offices in Hong Kong, China, Silicon Valley in the United States, Shenzhen, Hangzhou, Zhengzhou, Chengdu and other locations. In response to the global compliance development needs of Web3.0 industry clients, Mankun has established local offices in major global crypto-finance cities and selected local professional blockchain service partners to provide clients with legal and compliance services that offer global breadth and China depth.