A Quick Guide to Identifying High-Risk Criminal Projects in Web3
Introduction
Opportunities and legal risks often coexist.Web3Workers may encounter an overseas company that suddenly goes incommunicado, or may be found to have engaged in pyramid selling or fraud through the content of their work and consequently be imprisoned... and so on. Due to the attractive features of the Web3 industry and the gradual tightening of regulation in China, people who venture into high-risk projects because of an unclear understanding of legal boundaries have been appearing in the industry one after another.
Risk of involvement in opening a gambling establishment
"Opening a gambling establishment" is the most common, most concealed, and also the highest-risk category of criminal charge. In current judicial cases, project members and developers have already been found to have engaged in related business and been characterized asopening a gamblingestablishmentas accomplices. We have summarized the following 4 common high-risk scenarios:
1. Establishing a gambling platform directly on-chain
2. Using virtual currency as chips on traditional gambling platforms
3. Building a virtual currency trading platform with no real transactions, where users only guess price movements
4. Providing exchange services for gambling websites
Article 8 of the Interpretation on Several Issues Concerning the Specific Application of Law in the Handling of Criminal Cases of Gambling provides what constitutes gambling conduct: users contribute a certain amount of legal tender; through certain activities or gameplay they are ultimately able to obtain more or less currency or a convertible equivalent; and a funds-to-funds chain is formed.
Viewed in light of the above cases, crypto assets or blockchain are often embedded in the key stages of gambling activity: first, they are used as chips, directly replacing legal tender in the betting process; second, they serve as settlement tools, providing cross-border and anonymous transfer pathways for gambling funds; and third, they enable free conversion with legal tender through exchanges, completing the closed loop of monetizing funds. For this reason, although the surface form is a "blockchain application" or "virtual asset gameplay," on a substantive analysis its operating logic still satisfies the three elements of the crime of gambling: users contribute consideration funds, they rely on games of chance to obtain returns, and a complete funds-to-funds chain is formed.
It should be noted that in judicial practice, not only are project parties that build or operate gambling platforms characterized as operating a casino; persons who provide agency, promotional publicity, fund settlement, technical support or other direct or indirect assistance to such platforms may likewise be characterized as accomplices or aiders.For Web3 practitioners, whether developers, marketing personnel, or those engaged in settlement or community operations, it is necessary when coming into contact with a project to identify whether gambling elements are involved, so as to avoid being drawn into criminal risk without knowledge.
Risk of involvement in organizing pyramid schemes
1. Novel forms of payment:payment of virtual currency or other forms as a condition of participation;
2. Multi-level promotion models:multi-level commission splitting through smart contracts, multi-level promotion across cross-chain platforms, multi-level rebates for user acquisition through tasks, and the like;
3. Multi-tier compensation:Compensation methods such as tiered profit-sharing of transaction fees, multi-tier profit-sharing rebates, and tiered dividends for community members.
For a detailed understanding of this case, our firm's lawyer Shao Shiwei has previously written relevant articles analyzing the case.Case Analysis | What Can the 40 Billion Crypto Pyramid Scheme Case Teach Web3 Games About Avoiding Pyramid Scheme Risks?。
Under the definition of pyramid schemes in the Regulations on Prohibition of Pyramid Schemes and the State Administration for Industry and Commerce's Risk Warning Regarding New Types of Pyramid Scheme Activities, a pyramid scheme is an illegal business activity in which an organizer or operator recruits personnel and calculates or pays remuneration based on the number of personnel recruited, or requires recruited personnel to obtain eligibility to join by paying fees or through other means.
1. Payment of fees:Paying, or paying in disguised form, an entry fee, membership fee, or subscription for virtual or actual products, such that only after payment may a person obtain eligibility to receive calculated remuneration and to recruit downlines;
2. Recruiting downlines:Directly or indirectly recruiting downlines, that is, bringing in new participants and forming tiers in a certain order. Article 1 of the Opinions on Several Issues Concerning the Application of Law in Handling Criminal Cases of Organizing and Leading Pyramid Scheme Activities clearly sets the threshold: forming more than three tiers and recruiting more than 30 persons constitutes a crime;
3. Tiered compensation:Uplines calculate remuneration from the sales performance of directly or indirectly recruited downlines, or calculate remuneration or rebates based on the number of directly or indirectly recruited personnel, and the tiered returns are evident.
Combining the PlusToken case and the three characteristics in the judicial interpretation, although pyramid scheme models in Web3 scenarios are more concealed, they still possess the three characteristics of payment of fees, recruiting downlines, and tiered compensation. Cryptocurrencies may serve both as a means of paying entry fees and as a promotional gimmick to attract participants, and ultimately also serve as a means of rebates. Once these three characteristics are met and the tier and headcount thresholds prescribed by law are reached, the scheme may be found to be a pyramid scheme.
Therefore, if you are an employee of a project party and, while knowing or ought to know that the project has the above characteristics, you remain deeply involved in promotion and design, collection and distribution of funds, recruitment of downline members, and other such stages, you may bear criminal liability.
Risk of involvement in illegal fundraising
In practice, raising start-up funds directly or in disguised form has gradually become the primary way to launch blockchain projects. Raising funds to launch a project often requires extensive promotion,many people who are unclear about the legal red lines commitofcertain acts, such as exaggerating returns, promoting that prices will only rise and never fall, guaranteed profits with no losses, and principal protection, which are oftenleading tobeing characterized as illegal absorption of public depositshigh-risk conduct。
Taking the "Shenyang Maker" case6as an example, Huo established the Shenyang Maker Era Big Data Asset Management Center, and inthe absence of the corresponding qualifications, usinghigh rebatesas a selling point tomore than 400 peoplepromote three types of projects and illegally raise more than 60 million yuan. The projects were specifically: (1) a Bitcoin mining machine sale-and-leaseback project, under which customers invested in Shenyang Chuangke to purchase mining machines, Shenyang Chuangke paid investors 230 yuan per day, the contract term was 15 months, and at the end of the contract the mining machines belonged to Shenyang Chuangke, with the 20 thousand yuan paid for the mining machines not returned; (2) a Gravity-Free ICO fund investment project; and (3) a blockchain investment project, promoted as offering 20- to 30-fold returns.
Under the Regulations on the Prevention and Handling of Illegal Fund-Raising and the above-mentioned Interpretation, illegal absorption of public deposits means the activity of absorbing funds from unspecified members of the public without lawful permission from the financial management department of the State Council or in violation of state financial management regulations, issuing certificates, and promising to repay principal and pay interest within a certain period.
In addition, under Article 2, Item 8 of the Interpretation of the Supreme People's Court on Several Issues Concerning the Specific Application of Law in the Trial of Criminal Cases of Illegal Fund-Raising, conduct such as virtual currency trading is expressly brought within the scope of regulation of the crime of illegally absorbing public deposits. Applied to the Web3 projects in the statutes and cases, although the promotional methods of high-risk projects differ, in essence they still target unspecified members of the public and exaggerate profits in order to illegally raise funds.
Therefore, a project that simultaneously meets the following four characteristics carries an extremely high risk of suspected illegal fund-raising, and participation in such projects requires vigilance:
1. Illegality:without lawful permission from the financial management department of the State Council or in violation of state financial management regulations;
2. Publicity:through public means such as the internet, television stations, and on-site promotion;
3. Social nature:raising funds from the general public, i.e., an unspecified segment of society;
4. Inducement:promising high returns, promoting that the token will only rise and never fall, stable annualized yields, return of principal-equivalent tokens within a certain period, compound-interest return promises, stable dividend income, and so on.
Based on the "Shenyang Maker" case and the above judicial interpretations, it can be seen that illegal fundraising in Web3 scenarios takes many forms, with various models such as mining-machine sale-and-return, token issuance, and on-chain wealth management raising funds through public promotion. However, the core still possesses the four characteristics of illegality, openness, social nature, and inducement; once a project meets these, it may be found to constitute illegal fundraising. Moreover, if you are an employee of the project party and, while knowing or ought to have known that the project possesses the above characteristics, still deeply participate in model design, publicity and promotion, fund raising and distribution, and other stages, you may likewise bear criminal liability.
Fraud-related risks
In practice, fraud methods are varied, but their core characteristic remains the purpose of "illegal possession" under Article 266 of the Criminal Law of the People's Republic of China and the relevant judicial interpretations, using fabrication, concealment, and other conduct to cause property loss to the victim.
In the "Xiong Mou fraudcase”7, the team involved recruited practitioners in China, used the establishment of a company as a cover, and exploited communication tools, the Internet, and other technical means, with its employees playing roles such as "teacher," "assistant," and "senior stock investor," to induce victims to invest in the company's fake "virtual currency." It initially created the appearance of small profits for the victims, then encouraged them to invest large amounts, and through back-end operations controlled the fake digital currency to plummet, creating a false appearance of loss, causing victims to mistakenly believe the investment had failed, thereby obtaining the victims' money. Regarding"Xiong Moufraud”In the context of a case, the specific manifestations of fraud involving blockchain projects are as follows.
1. Fabricating facts/concealing the truth:During the project preparation period, fabricating a false profit model;
2. Having the purpose of illegal possession:After raising funds, failing to carry out project research and development in accordance with the contents of the white paper, but instead squandering the funds recklessly and absconding with the money;
3. The victim disposing of property based on a mistaken understanding:After issuing tokens, maliciously manipulating the token price to create a false impression, causing the victim to dispose of property based on that false impression, thereby making off with the victim's funds.
In addition, where a person, knowing that another person is carrying out telecommunications and internet fraud, providespayment and settlement assistance, in practice such a person has also been found to bean accomplice to the crime of fraud.In "Xie fraud case8In,Xie was able to provide assistance to others in committing telecom fraud crimes. To evade investigation, Xie sought cooperation with others, transferring funds obtained from illegal and criminal activities through bank transfers to other persons' Alipay, WeChat, bank card and other accounts, then using these funds to purchase virtual currencies such as "Tether." The other persons transferred the virtual currencies to Xie through online accounts. After Xie sold the virtual currencies and converted them into cash, Xie delivered the proceeds to the persons committing the fraud crimes and received a commission therefrom.
Therefore, before joining a company, it is not only necessary to carefully evaluate the project party,but alsonecessaryto the greatest extent possibleto understand the upstream business of the settlement party; otherwise, as an employee therein, one willinevitablybearrelatively highcriminalRisk。
Mankun Criminal Team Recommendations
Overall, to determine whether working in Web3 carries criminal risk, the risk of the project itself must first be examined. This requirespreliminary screening of high-risk projects in light of the actual work involved,identifying and avoidingparticipation inrelatedhigh-risk business activities that exhibit the following characteristics.
1. Risk of involvement in operating a gambling establishment:If a project involves the model of “paid input + randomized gameplay + a monetization chain”, extreme caution is required.
2. Risk of involvement in organizing a pyramid scheme:When a project requires incoming personnel to “pay fees + develop downlines + calculate remuneration by tier”, it has in essence already constituted the characteristics of a pyramid scheme.
3. Risk of involvement in illegal absorption of public deposits:If a project satisfies the four elements of “illegality + openness + targeting unspecified persons + promising principal and interest repayment”, it constitutes a typical act of illegally absorbing public deposits.
4. Risk of involvement in fraud:When the project party, by means of “intent to illegally possess + fabricating facts/concealing the truth”, induces users to “disposing of a certain amount of property by mistake", this may constitute suspected fraud.
Conclusion
Career choices in the Web3 industry are like a double-edged sword: they carry the aspiration of achieving financial freedom, while also entailing potential crises that cannot be ignored. The content discussed in this article is for reference only. If you encounter more complex or specific legal issues in your actual work, it is recommended that you promptly consult a professional lawyer or institution.
If you still have doubts, such as: I am only an outsourced worker or a person in a non-core position, and I am not the boss—will I also be held criminally liable? If I am held liable, should I bear primary or secondary responsibility? The next installment will address these concerns for you.



