Core Points for Structurally Avoiding Criminal Risk
In recent years, the Web3 sector has become an important growth area in the digital economy through technological innovations such as decentralization and smart contracts. However, as the regulatory system has continued to improve, the criminal risks of the industry's "barbaric growth" phase have gradually emerged—from illegal absorption of public deposits to fraud-type cases, many projects have become embroiled in criminal disputes due to improperly designed models, which has not only brought projects to a standstill but also exposed core teams to imprisonment.
How can criminal risk be avoided at the top-level framework? Based on extensive experience in criminal legal services in the Web3 industry, the Mankun criminal lawyer team proposes a dual-path approach of an "ideal plan" and a "realistic plan." This article aims to clarify the core considerations for project parties and provide actionable criminal compliance guidance.

Ideal Plan: Cut Off Mainland Users and Block Risk at the Source of Jurisdiction
In avoiding criminal risk for Web3 projects, "jurisdiction" is the core logical starting point—if a project has no connection to the criminal jurisdiction of mainland China, there is naturally no need to worry about the application of mainland criminal law.The essence of the ideal risk-avoidance plan is to sever the project's connection with users in mainland China through a strict user screening mechanism, thereby excluding the application of mainland criminal jurisdiction。
In terms of specific operations, project parties should establish strict KYC(identity verification) mechanisms at the user registration and participation stages, and explicitly prohibit users in mainland China from participating in the project (including but not limited to core stages such as purchasing tokens, participating in staking, and joining nodes). From the perspective of legal practice, where a criminal act or its result occurs within the territory of China, China's criminal law applies; if a project completely excludes users in mainland China and its servers and operating team are all outside the mainland, then judicial authorities in mainland China generally have no jurisdiction.
From industry practice, Web3 projects with leading market capitalizations and relatively strong compliance (especially top overseas projects) mostly adopt this model. However, its limitations are also very clear: mainland China is an important digital economy market globally, and abandoning users in mainland China means losing a large number of potential users and funds. For small and medium-sized projects with weak financial strength and a small user base, it is almost impracticable—therefore, we are more inclined toward the practical value of the "realistic plan."
Realistic Plan: Hold Two Bottom Lines and Reduce the Probability of Criminal Risk
For small and medium-sized projects that cannot completely cut off mainland users, the Mankun criminal team proposes a realistic plan of "holding two bottom lines"—the core logic is:The essence of criminal law is to combat "conduct that is socially harmful." If a project does not touch the constituent elements of key offenses and does not cause negative social consequences, the probability of being held criminally liable will be substantially reduced。
Bottom line one: do not cross the red line of thecrime of illegally absorbing public depositsthe red line of”
The crime of illegally absorbing public deposits (hereinafter referred to as the "illegal absorption crime") is one of the criminal offenses most easily triggered by Web3 projects. Under Article 176 of the Criminal Law of the People's Republic of China and the relevant judicial interpretations, the illegal absorption crime requires four constitutive elements: illegality (absorbing funds without approval), publicity (attracting the public through promotion), inducement (promising principal and interest repayment or returns), and sociality (absorbing funds from an unspecified segment of the general public). Project parties can precisely avoid these risks from the following three dimensions:
1. Eliminate "inducement" in promotions
Do not promise "principal protection," "guaranteed returns," "high-interest returns," "guaranteed profit with no loss," or similar content on official websites, community channels, social media, or other channels—whether through direct promises or through suggestive statements such as "historical return rate of 100%" or "zero-loss cases" that lead users to believe there is "no risk," any of which may be deemed "inducement." In practice, promotional points such as "20% annualized staking yield" and "lock-up rebates" have become important evidence for judicial authorities in finding the illegal absorption crime.
2. Limit the scope of "fundraising targets"
If a project involves financing (such as token issuance or private placement financing), it must be strictly limited to "qualified investors" rather than fundraising from an unspecified segment of the general public. "Qualified investors" here must meet clear standards (such as monetary thresholds for financial assets and average annual income over the past three years), and the project party must retain documentary proof of investor qualifications to avoid being deemed to have "sociality" due to "fundraising from ordinary people." At the same time, investors must be clearly informed that they "bear the risk themselves," and a written risk disclosure statement must be signed, with the evidence chain retained.
3. Avoid a finding of "illegality"
A finding of "illegality" for a Web3 project must be assessed in light of regulatory policy—currently, if a project involvestoken issuance and financing, trading speculation, or similar conduct, it may be deemed to be "engaging in financial activities without approval." Therefore, project parties must avoid engaging in "quasi-financial" business, such as absorbing user funds through a "fund pool" model or conducting "deposit coins to earn interest" and other business with wealth-management characteristics, and should minimize fund-pooling operations.
Bottom line two: reduce “social harm” and avoid triggering negative consequences
Criminal law is not a law that picks faults; it is a law that targets conduct with “social harm.” Therefore, if a project operates steadily, users can clearly understand that they are participating in a commercial project with reasonable risks, and the project provides reasonable guidance on profits and losses, it will generally not provoke reports from the public and is unlikely to be characterized as socially harmful. This can effectively prevent the project from being handled through criminal measures:Social harm is the precondition for criminal law intervention; absent harm, there is no punishment。
For a project party to reduce social harm, two points require particular attention:
1. Ensure the stability of project operations
Avoid designing “high-risk, high-bubble” models, such as pyramid-scheme-like mechanisms such as “referral rewards for new users” and “tiered rewards” (which easily lead to a collapse after users rush in), or “one-way token price increases” under amarket-manipulation model(which easily causes large-scale losses for later users). In practice, some “refining” and “order-grabbing” projects, because the model itself has the attributes of a Ponzi scheme, inevitably cause losses for later users; even if compliant in the early stage, they cannot escape criminal liability.
2. Attach importance touser feedbackand dispute resolution
If individual users incur losses, they must be resolved promptly through negotiation, mediation, or other means, so as to avoid collective user complaints, petitions, or police reports. When judicial authorities decide whether to open a case, they will focus on the “number of victims,” “amount involved,” and “social impact.” If it is merely a dispute involving individual users and the project party actively handles it, it will usually not rise to the criminal level; however, if there are collective reports or the amount involved is relatively large, the probability of judicial intervention will increase substantially.
Additional considerations: avoid absolute red lines and conduct advance compliance health checks
Beyond the "ideal solution" and the "realistic solution," there are two further categories of risk that cannot be ignored and that project teams must focus on avoiding:
1. Absolutely prohibit the development of gambling or fraud-related functions
Some Web3 projects, in pursuit of short-term gains, develop gambling and fraud-related functions such as "card and board game-style yield extraction," "Ponzi schemes," and "fake NFT minting"—such projects are unlawful from the very outset of their model design, and even if they use KYC to segregate users and obtain acknowledgments that users bear the risks themselves, they cannot avoid criminal risk. For example, "card and board game-style yield extraction" projects usually operate under the name of "game mining," but in substance involve users contributing tokens to gamble on "betting on rises and falls," which meets the constitutive elements of the crime of gambling; "Ponzi schemes" restrict the sale of tokens and use false publicity to drive up prices, which is in essence fraudulent conduct. The Mankun criminal team reminds that gambling and fraud-related projects fall within the "absolute red line," where no compliance space exists, and project teams must eliminate them entirely.
2. Cooperate with lawyers in advance and carry out a "criminal compliance health check"
The legal rules in the Web3 field still contain considerable ambiguity, and project teams relying solely on their own understanding will find it difficult to identify all risk points. Therefore, before a project launches, it is best to engage criminal lawyers familiar with the Web3 industry to conduct a "full-process compliance health check" of the project model—lawyers will proceed from the perspective of legal practice, investigate whether the project presents risk points such as illegal absorption of public deposits, fraud, or gambling, and put forward specific revision suggestions (such as adjusting promotional language, limiting the scope of investors, and deleting high-risk functions), thereby helping project teams avoid the zone of legal red lines.
From a practical standpoint, an ex ante compliance health check can substantially reduce criminal risk—after some projects adjusted their models through lawyers, they not only avoided potential risks but also enhanced user trust; whereas projects that did not carry out a compliance health check often saw their projects halted after "stepping into pitfalls," and their core teams may face criminal investigation.
Compliance is not a cost, but the "lifeline" of a Web3 project
Against the backdrop of increasingly clear regulation in the Web3 industry, "compliance" is no longer an "optional item" but the "lifeline" of a project's long-term development. For project teams, it is necessary to choose a suitable risk-avoidance plan based on their own scale and resources.
The analysis in this article also confirms a core logic: innovation in Web3 must be built on a foundation of legality and compliance, and "innovation" detached from the legal framework will ultimately only face criminal accountability. Only by integrating compliance thinking into every link of project framework design can one, while enjoying the dividends of technological innovation, avoid criminal risk and achieve the project's long-term, steady development.


