Special Statement: This article is an original article by Attorney Shao Shiwei and represents only the personal views of the author. It does not constitute legal consultation or legal advice on any specific matter. For article reprints | legal consultation | business exchanges, please contact: sswls66
Introduction:
On December 29, 2023, the Pudong Branch of the Shanghai Public Security Bureau traveled to Yunnan and carried out a cross-provincial operation to arrest a group of criminal gangs suspected of fraud in online live-streamed rough-stone gambling, as shown in Figure 1 below. At present, 35 criminal suspects including Jiang have been lawfully approved for arrest by the procuratorial organ on suspicion of fraud, and the case is under further investigation.
The above is public information related to this case. Because the case is still being handled, we will not comment on matters related to the case. However,is the rough-stone gambling business lawful?That is indeed a question worth discussing.
Author of this article: Attorney Shao Shiwei
01
What is the "rough-stone gambling" business doing?
The surface of rough jadeite is wrapped in mineral crusts of varying colors and uneven thickness. What is the quality of the jade flesh inside? It is difficult to judge. Even if part of the rough stone is cut open, there will still be many variables before it is made into a finished product. Therefore, rough jadeite trading is also called "rough-stone gambling." Whether it will rise or fall in value in the future is, for both parties to the transaction, a contest of experience, skill and courage. In the jadeite industry, there is"one cut to poverty, one cut to wealth, one cut to sackcloth"as the saying goes.
In Yunnan, Guangdong, the China-Myanmar border and other regions, rough-stone gambling transactions are very prevalent.
02
Legal Analysis of the Compliance of Gambling on Rough Jade Transactions
On June 15, 2020, the Ruili Municipal People's Government published the Ruili City Administrative Norms for Internet Live-Stream Trading of Jadeite (Trial Implementation). In these provisions, we can see that rough jadeite is defined as a special commodity carrying relatively high transaction risk.
Ruili City Administrative Norms for Internet Live-Stream Trading of Jadeite (Trial Implementation)
Article 8: For the purposes of these Norms, rough jadeite refers to unprocessed rough jadeite ore (including preliminary processing such as cutting openings and windowing); its commodity quality is subject to numerous uncertain factors, and it is generally valued based on the various aspects of the commodity's appearance. With many uncertain factors affecting the commodity's value, relatively high transaction risk, and investment expectations that are difficult to guarantee, it is a special commodity.
Gambling on rough jade transactions can be regarded as a type of aleatory act (aleatory refers to acts that rely on contingent events and luck to obtain benefits; such acts may be lawful, such as lotteries, or unlawful, such as gambling). At present, no relevant laws or regulations expressly provide for the legal characterization of gambling on rough jade transactions.
Precisely because there is no established standard, disputes in the rough jade gambling transaction industry are incessant and disorder is rampant.
If you say it is illegal, some courts hold that buyers should assume the risk voluntarily and do not support buyers' claims for return of the purchase price.For example, in February 2023, the Shanghai No. 1 Intermediate People's Court concluded a dispute over an online information network sales contract. Ms. Fang saw a jadeite live-streaming room while browsing her phone and, attracted by the lively atmosphere in the live-streaming room, purchased rough jadeite worth 98 thousand. After receiving the goods, Ms. Fang felt she had bought at a loss and wanted a refund, but the shop refused on the grounds that "the material had already been windowed and this affected secondary sale." Ms. Fang engaged an institution on her own to conduct an appraisal, and the appraisal conclusion was that it was dry green stone. Ms. Fang believed that dry green stone is not jadeite and therefore brought a lawsuit before the court. After two instances of judgment, the court found that the merchant had not committed fraud, that Ms. Fang should assume the risk voluntarily, and that no refund would be granted.
If you say it is legal, then we have to discuss the "China's first rough jade gambling case" from three years ago.—In April 2021, the Bazhou City People's Court of Hebei Province held a three-day hearing in the rough jade fraud case involving three Yunnan jade merchants.
03
Does gambling on rough jade transactions constitute the crime of fraud?
The previously much-watched "China's first rough jade gambling (criminal) case" originated from a transaction in 2019. Jade merchant Zhang Yousheng, introduced by an intermediary, brought a piece of rough jadeite weighing approximately 18 kilograms to Beijing, intending to sell it to a Hebei entrepreneur, Ma Moubo. Ma Moubo brought Zheng Mousheng (commonly known in the industry as a "rough jade eye"), an expert engaged in jewelry and jade auctions for many years, to Beijing to meet Zhang Mousheng. After Ma Moubo and Zheng Mousheng carefully observed the entire piece of rough jadeite with a flashlight specially used for examining jadeite and negotiated the price, they ultimately settled on80 million yuanto purchase this rough stone. Ma later cut open the jadeite and found that its quality was below expectations, so he chose to report the matter to the police and demanded a refund. Subsequently, Zhang Yousheng and the two intermediaries were arrested.
[Legal Analysis]
Rough-stone gambling transactions do indeed exploit buyers' desire to "risk a small stake for a large gain." Attorney Shao has mentioned in previous articles: what constitutes gambling? Three elements must be satisfied: (1) the user puts in cash; (2) the user has the motive of risking a small stake for a large gain; and (3) the final outcome may involve the possibility of loss.
However, whether it is the first rough-stone gambling case or the livestream rough-stone sales case handled by the Pudong police mentioned above, both were characterized as the crime of fraud, rather than the crime of gambling or the crime of running a casino. This is because rough-stone gambling transactions are not themselves gambling conduct prohibited by law; as long as it is a normal, lawful rough-stone buying and selling business that fully informs consumers of the risks, it is permitted, as in the above civil judgment of the Pudong court. "Buy and the deal is final" is also the rule of this trade.
Under what circumstances, then, does a rough-stone gambling transaction constitute fraud?Simply put, it is where, under the name of rough-stone buying and selling, the substantive purpose is to defraud the victim of money by fabricating facts and concealing the truth. We take China's first (criminal) rough-stone gambling case as an example forreverse(The reason it is called "reverse" is that, based solely on the currently available public online materials, Attorney Shao considers that this case is very difficult to characterize as the crime of fraud.)analysis:
At the time, the Yunnan Provincial Stone Industry Promotion Committee specially convened a thematic seminar and press conference to conduct a thematic discussion on the matter and release relevant information. After hearing an introduction to the case, 12 top jewelry and jade experts and scholar representatives held that the transaction fully conformed to the industry practice of rough-stone trading. The reasons can be summarized as follows:
1. The buyer reported the case as fraud on the ground that the seller fabricated the place of origin (known in the trade as the "chang kou"). However, the basis for appraising and distinguishing the authenticity of rough stones is whether the rough stone has been artificially counterfeited; place of origin is not a basis for determining counterfeiting. In the national standard "Jewelry and Jade Identification" formulated in 2017, there is no identification of the place of origin of jadeite. In practice, it is also not necessarily the case that rough stones from a certain place of origin are of higher value. Moreover, rough-stone transactions pass through multiple resales, and the original place of origin is very difficult to determine.
2. The rough stones involved did not involve unlawful acts of artificial tampering, such as counterfeit crusts, counterfeit openings, counterfeit cores, counterfeit coloring, tampering to conceal defects, hollowing out to increase transparency, or tampering with the viewing windows.
3. During the transaction, the seller made no representation as to what degree of color or texture the rough stones could achieve after being cut open.
In summary, the seller did not fabricate facts or conceal the truth from the counterparty.
Paradoxically, China's first (criminal) rough-stone gambling case, which caused a major shock in the rough-stone gambling industry, went through two years of investigation, and the court held a three-day hearing. Press releases were overwhelming, and even the confidential indictment circulated widely online. Yet, according to the author's research, no public information about the outcome of the case can be found. If any reader is familiar with this case, you are welcome to contact Attorney Shao via private message or leave a comment.
04
Conclusion
Rough-stone gambling transactions are not unlawful. However, due to a lack of regulation, many disputes do objectively exist. In addition, with the rise of livestream selling, some buyers, under the influence of the livestream atmosphere, easily make impulse purchases.
Therefore, livestream sellers should also be reminded that rough-stone gambling is a relatively niche industry, and there is significant information asymmetry between buyers and sellers. If engaging in similar livestream selling, be sure to provide consumers with full disclosure and risk warnings and fulfill the merchant's due obligations; otherwise, there may be relevant civil and even criminal legal risks.

1. Earn 2 thousand in a few minutes? A Shanghai netizen became addicted to "trying their luck," unexpectedly_ Kankan News https://www.kankanews.com/detail/g4QZDL5zD2Y
2. Can you get a refund if you feel a rough stone bought in a livestream is not worth it? See how the court ruled https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/DOonTfG-ta83MK5ajNwa5g
Recommended Reading
Gambling in livestreams—what are the legal risks for livestream guilds?
Is a livestream lottery a form of gambling or a lawful prize promotion?


