Special Statement: This article is an original article by Attorney Shao Shiwei and represents only the personal views of the author. It does not constitute legal consultation or legal advice on any specific matter. To repost the article, seek legal consultation, or communicate with peers, please add: sswls66.
Recently, a friend consulted Attorney Shao: he is an employee of an immigration and exit-entry services company, mainly responsible for providing clients with consulting services on immigration, study abroad, overseas planning, exit-entry services, and related matters.
However, in his daily work, many clients ask him about how to transfer large sums of money out of the country. At such times, his boss asks him to connect clients with overseas currency exchange companies. He is somewhat concerned whether the company's business involves relevant legal risks and whether those risks could implicate him.
In fact, forstudy-abroad agencies, immigration intermediaries (exit-entry services companies), overseas real estate brokers, or practitioners in the financial industry such as banks, securities firms, insurance companies, and fund companies, clients frequently ask such questions. This is because their clients, for purposes such asasset allocation, investment and wealth management, overseas property purchases, and daily living expenses, have demands for large-sum cross-border inward and outward remittances.
Under China's foreign exchange control policies and regulations, each domestic individual enjoys only a facilitated foreign exchange purchase quota of the equivalent of 50 thousand US dollars per year, but this quota does not cover capital account purposes such as overseas home purchases, securities investment, purchases of life insurance, and investment-type return-of-premium or dividend-paying insurance. Therefore, lawful and regular domestic foreign exchange channels cannot satisfy the above needs of clients.
Therefore,introducing qualified and licensed foreign exchange companies abroadto connect clients for foreign exchange,What risks do clients, introducers and currency exchange companies face?This question essentially involvesdisguised foreign exchange trading.
Given that Attorney Shao is asked about this type of question fairly often, we will discuss it systematically today.
In the first part of this article ➡️ “Is It Reliable to Exchange Money Through a Legitimate, Licensed Foreign Currency Exchange Company Abroad? What Legal Risks Do the Person Exchanging Currency, the Introducer and the Currency Exchange Company Respectively Face? (Part One)”, we took the collapse of Changjiang Currency Exchange as the entry point, discussed the legal risks that clients, introducers and currency exchange companies may face, and conducted an in-depth analysis of the legal risks faced by currency exchange clients.
Next, we will continue to explore what legal risks currency exchange companies and introducers may face in private currency exchange transactions.
3
Analysis of Legal Risks
2. Currency exchange companies — can obtaining a license in an overseas jurisdiction avoid domestic legal risks?
For currency exchange companies operating in countries or regions without foreign exchange controls, if they have obtained the relevant qualification license, operating a currency exchange business itself is not problematic.
For example,Australia: under the ASIC Act, any financial institution engaging in financial transactions in Australia must be certified by ASIC and apply for and obtain an Australian Financial Services (AFS) licence;the United Kingdom: the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) classifies regulatory licences into four categories—EU licences, full licences, payment licences and authorised licences;the United States: the MSB licence in the United States, regulated by the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN) under the U.S. Department of the Treasury;Canada: the MSB licence in Canada, regulated by the Financial Transactions and Reports Analysis Centre of Canada (FINTRAC); inHong Kong SAR, China, operating a foreign currency exchange business requires obtaining an MSO licence (Money Service Operator) issued by the Hong Kong Customs and Excise Department.
Under the legal systems of the above countries or regions, the local regulators focus on whether currency exchange companies engage in unlawful conduct such as money laundering, rather than on whether such companies provide services to users in mainland China.
If overseas currency exchange companies use a covert transaction method such as "mirroring" (dui qiao) to exchange currency for their clients, where do they obtain such ample capital reserves to provide domestic and international remittance services for their clients? Underground banks and virtual currencies are their main channels.
For example, the reason the Changjiang Currency Exchange company mentioned in this article had its case exposed is that it received a large amount of funds from unlawful transactions, which involved cooperation withunderground banksand others.
However, currency exchange companies that wish to operate over the long term and safely will choose the virtual currency exchange method: RMB within China ♻️ exchanged for USDT on a virtual currency exchange ♻️ exchanged for US dollars or other national fiat currencies, to conduct mirroring exchanges for clients, which is both covert and leaves no worry about having sufficient funds to pay out to clients.
However, if China's judicial authorities find relevant leads and discover that a currency exchange company is conducting business directed at users in mainland China, then in view of the principles of personal jurisdiction and territorial jurisdiction in China's Criminal Law, China has jurisdiction over the relevant personnel of the currency exchange company.
Here is a brief explanation of what personal and territorial jurisdiction mean:
Personal jurisdiction means that if the perpetrator is a Chinese citizen, domestic judicial authorities have the power to exercise jurisdiction. Therefore, if the actual controller, operators, and staff of offices established within China of a currency exchange company are Chinese, criminal risk exists for all of them.
Territorial jurisdiction means that in currency exchange transactions carried out through the "mirroring" method, the client remits funds to a domestic bank account designated by the currency exchange company; after the currency exchange company confirms receipt of the funds, it remits the local currency abroad to an overseas account designated by the client. The fund flow in the domestic remittance stage is within China, and therefore China is the place where the crime of illegally buying and selling foreign exchange is committed.
For currency exchange companies, they are themselvesengaged in the business of illegally buying and selling foreign exchange for the purpose of profit, and there is no dispute that this constitutes the crime of illegal business operationsBut some may wonder: the currency exchange company operates overseas, and in the case of mirroring transactions,Domestic users merely transfer funds to a domestic account designated by a currency exchange company. How would the authorities discover the existence of an illegal foreign exchange transaction?That is a good question, but Lawyer Shao will keep it confidential.
3. Introducers — What risks arise from referring clients to private currency exchange channels?
As the foregoing discussion shows, for clients purchasing foreign exchange, the risk lies primarily in administrative penalties. Does that mean, by reasoning from the greater to the lesser, that —if the clients themselves do not commit a criminal offense, then an introducer should be even less likely to face criminal punishment?As lawyers, from a defense perspective, we would of course like to reach that conclusion directly, but the reality is often more complicated.
Why would an introducer refer their own clients to private currency exchange channels??
Take financial practitioners, for example. They themselves provide asset allocation services to clients. Beyond the compliant wealth management business available domestically, clients may also have their own private needs and, for various reasons, wish to move funds overseas. To retain clients, some investment advisors or fund managers may use their own foreign exchange quota to exchange foreign currency on the client's behalf (which is of course non-compliant), or may directly connect clients with individuals who have foreign exchange (such as foreign trade merchants) or with currency exchange companies.
Another example: a friend in a central-western city who specializes in overseas property consulting previously consulted Lawyer Shao and mentioned that clients have a need to purchase property overseas, but domestic funds cannot be transferred out. If he did not provide support and assistance for clients' currency exchange, he would be unable to close any deals.
Moreover, in their position as intermediaries, they often alsodo not believe that referring clients for currency exchange entails significant legal risk,and very few think to consult a lawyer in advance.Their considerations are typically as follows:
-
Their clients are of relatively high quality, with strong professional track records and lawful sources of income, so it can be ruled out that the clients wish to exchange currency for money-laundering purposes;
-
Moreover, the lawfulness of the source of funds is vetted by the currency exchange company; if there is genuinely a problem with the client's money, the currency exchange company bears the risk, so there is even less reason for them to worry;
-
Although the client is exchanging currency privately, they have learned from researching the legal provisions that if the client does so for personal use, the worst outcome is an administrative penalty, and since it is not they themselves who are exchanging currency, they will not be exposed to risk;
-
The currency exchange company they found for the client is a large, locally licensed company overseas, and they have cooperated with it many times without any incident; by using that company, at least they need not worry that the client's funds will be absconded with;
The above considerations may seem comprehensive, but in reality the person seeking advicehas blind spots from a legal perspective:
The introducer typically considers only ruling out money-laundering risk and believes that the client will at most face an administrative penalty, so they themselves should be fine?
First, under the following provisions, introducing the buying and selling of foreign exchange where the amount exceeds 50 thousand US dollars likewise carries the risk of administrative penalties. In addition, according to judicial precedents, if the introducer's position is found by the judicial authorities to be that of objectively building an off-exchange trading platform for both parties to the foreign exchange transaction, and the currency exchange business reaches the criminal filing threshold for the crime of illegal business operations, then the introducer is suspected of the crime of illegal business operations in the category of buying and selling foreign exchange.
2008 Regulations on the Administration of Foreign Exchange
Article 45: Where a person privately buys or sells foreign exchange, buys or sells foreign exchange in a disguised form, buys and sells foreign exchange by speculation, or illegally introduces the buying and selling of foreign exchange in a relatively large amount, the foreign exchange administration authority shall issue a warning, confiscate the illegal gains, and impose a fine of not more than 30% of the illegal amount; where the circumstances are serious, a fine of not less than 30% of the illegal amount and not more than an equivalent amount shall be imposed; where a crime is constituted, criminal liability shall be pursued in accordance with the law.
Notice of the State Administration of Foreign Exchange on Issues Concerning the Meaning and Application Principles of Certain Provisions of Chapter VII (Legal Liability) of the Regulations of the People's Republic of China on the Administration of Foreign Exchange
III. The "relatively large amount" referred to in Article 45 of the Regulations means the amount of foreign exchange bought or sold privately, bought or sold in disguised form, or bought and resold for profit is the equivalent of USD 1,000 or more, or the amount of foreign exchange illegally brokered for sale or purchase is the equivalent of 50 thousand US dollars or more.
Second, the introducer believes that the exchange company will review the client's source of funds, and with the exchange company's gatekeeping, the introducer should be safer. However, as we have already explained above, in countries and regions with liberal foreign exchange policies, operating a currency exchange business is itself lawful, so the exchange company only needs to guard against its own business being deemed by regulators to be assisting money laundering because it received illicit funds. Even if the exchange company is characterized under mainland Chinese law as committing the crime of illegal business operations, under ordinary circumstances mainland police would not go so far as to make cross-border arrests. As for whether the introducer, far away in mainland China, faces legal risk, that is not their concern.
So,how significant is the introducer's legal risk, really?Lawyer Shao has discussed this issue before: if the introducer meets three conditions:introducing for the buyer+the buyer is using the foreign exchange purely for personal use+the introducer is helping for free, then the introducer does not commit a crime.
However, two issues can be further discussed here:
First, situations involving free assistance are still relatively rare in practice, because for a currency exchange company, the introducer is also its own client. When a client introduced by the introducer completes a transaction with the currency exchange company, the company will also pay the introducer a certain percentage of rebate. Imagine: if you were the introducer and received introduction fees wired by the currency exchange company, would you return them? Generally, people quietly keep them and then continue to introduce business to the currency exchange company next time. However, the money received will all be characterized by judicial authorities as proceeds from illegally introducing foreign exchange trading.
Second, some friends who genuinely did not receive money may identify themselves with the above and believe they fully meet the above three conditions. However, think again carefully: your introduction conduct will be characterized by judicial authorities as introducing forbuyersor forsellersWhat about the introduction?
Only introductions for buyers that meet the above circumstances do not constitute a crime. Introductions for sellers such as currency exchange companies, however, do constitute a crime, because there is no dispute that the currency exchange company itself constitutes the crime of illegal business operations. Therefore, an introducer who introduces clients for a seller at least constitutes an accomplice to the crime of illegal business operations (and may also be a principal offender; given space constraints, this will not be elaborated further).
Imagine:if an introducer has for years introduced unspecified clients whom they serve to a particular currency exchange company, is this an introduction for buyers or for sellers??
For introducers who do not simultaneously satisfy the above three conditions, the extent of their liability must be analyzed on a case-by-case basis according to the actual circumstances, because in addition to considering the following circumstances,judicial authorities in different regions may also hold different views on the same conduct involved in a case, which is also whyAn important reason why different judgments may be rendered in similar caseslies in this.
(Image source article: "Is private foreign currency exchange illegal? At what amount does it constitute a crime?》)
Readers who remain confused after reading this may scan the QR code below to add Lawyer Shao's WeChat for a one-on-one consultation and obtain a targeted assessment opinion.Scan the QR code to add
4
Final remarks
In recent years, virtual currencies, due to their anonymity, cross-border nature and other characteristics, have been used by some wrongdoers and have become a tool for illegally transferring assets abroad.
At the end of December 2023, the Supreme People's Procuratorate and the State Administration of Foreign Exchange released a batch of typical cases concerning "cross-border mirror-trade illegal foreign exchange trading cases," including 2 criminal cases involving the disguised purchase and sale of foreign exchange using virtual currencies [for the lawyer's interpretation, please click ➡️→ "Is buying USDT and selling USDT illegal? Lawyer's interpretation: The Supreme People's Procuratorate and the State Administration of Foreign Exchange jointly release criminal cases involving virtual currencies》
On February 14, 2025, the Supreme People's Procuratorate held a press conference on "Progress and Achievements in Comprehensively Deepening Procuratorial Reform," which mentioned that in 2024more vigorously punish the use of virtual currencies to illegally transfer assets abroadetc.criminal activities。
(Image source:the Supreme People's Procuratorate held a press conference on "Progress and Results of Comprehensively Deepening Procuratorial Reform")
Illegal transactions using virtual currency to conduct disguised foreign exchange trading, including activities involving currency exchange companies and underground banks, are among the types of crime that China's judicial authorities have focused on punishing in recent years. Such conduct is in essence the use of virtual currency to illegally transfer assets abroad, in violation of relevant Chinese laws and regulations.
Therefore, ordinary individuals must not harbor any hope of getting away with it and participate in private currency exchange transactions. For overseas currency exchange companies, the review of clients' source of funds must be strengthened to ensure that their business does not involve domestic funds. For introducers, if a client raises a request for private currency exchange, they must never provide such assistance. Otherwise, they may not only lose their jobs but also face serious criminal risk.

Recommended Reading
Is private exchange of foreign currency illegal? At what amount does it constitute a crime?
Trading through "virtual assets" listed as one of the money laundering methods
Major revision of the Anti-Money Laundering Law: how should Web3 entrepreneurs respond?


