Special Statement: This article is an original work by Attorney Shao Shiwei and represents only the personal views of the author. It does not constitute legal consultation or legal advice on any specific matter. For article reprints | legal consultation | business exchanges, please add: sswls66

 

When a criminal case reaches the procuratorate stage, the direction of the case is often undecided. For most criminal cases, whether to prosecute, the charge on which to prosecute, the severity of the sentencing recommendation, and even whether the case can be directly concluded at this stage will all reach a conclusion during this stage.

 

For the parties involved, this stage is also a turning point in their fate. At this time, the intervention of a lawyer at the procuratorate stage can often substantively influence the direction of the case.

 

This is especially true for new types of economic crimes involving digital collectibles, virtual currencies, and the like. Because such cases are complex and highly disputed, a lawyer's professional opinion is more likely to become an important reference for the procuratorial authority in assessing the case.

 

I Author of this article: Attorney Shao Shiwei

 

 

 

1

Digital collectible cases head toward extremes: two outcomes, heavy sentencing risk and non-prosecution

 

In recent years, criminal cases such as fraud and fund-raising fraud triggered by the "collapse" of digital collectible platforms have occurred frequently. Attorney Shao Shiwei's team has to date handled more than ten cases related to digital collectible fraud, nearly half of which ultimately resulted in a decision to withdraw the case or not to prosecute.

 

To be honest, such a ratio is rare among similar cases. After all, while we were handling such cases, the public reports that kept appearing in the public eye concerning criminal cases involving digital collectible platforms looked like this:

 

(Image: Criminal cases involving digital collectibles, official media reports)

 

For this very reason, we were under considerable pressure in handling each case. But even against the backdrop of high regulatory pressure and focused public attention, we still successfully completed one defense after another.

 

Based on practical experience, once a digital collectible project is involved in a criminal case, the vast majority of convictions will fall on the two high-frequency charges of fraud or fund-raising fraud. The amounts involved typically start at one million yuan. Therefore, in such cases, as defense counsel, one must carefully choose a defense strategy. Where the case is disputed, we are more inclined to take a gamble and firmly push a not-guilty defense through to the end.

 

Because once the fraud charge is established, the party involved, as the person in charge or principal responsible person of the digital collectible platform, may face a prison term of more than ten years.

 

 

 

2

Deputy Chief Prosecutor Personally Handles the Case: The Procuratorate's Heightened Attention

 

Last year, I took on a case in which the legal representative of a digital collectibles platform was prosecuted on suspicion of fraud. Setting aside the legal issues of the case itself, what, to me, distinguished this case from the other digital collectibles criminal cases handled by my team was perhaps this: the person actually handling the case was the deputy chief prosecutor of the procuratorate in that region.

 

Based on practical experience, when a criminal case is personally handled by a deputy chief prosecutor, this often conveys certain signals:

the case is major, complex or sensitive; it requires higher-level coordination and decision-making; it reflects the procuratorate's heightened attention to the case and, at the same time, imposes higher demands on the handling prosecutor's professional competence and experience, among other things.

 

Accordingly, I inferred that this case was very likely assessed internally by the procuratorate as a new-type, difficult and complex case. Such cases often require a prosecutor at the level of chief prosecutor to "gatekeep," not only to ensure high-quality handling of the case, but also because the outcome of the case may have guiding significance for the handling of similar fraud cases throughout the region.

 

From the perspective of defense counsel, this is instead a positive signal. It means that the defense arguments on fraud that I submit are more likely to receive full attention and be adopted. This also left me full of expectation for the communications to come.

 

 

 

3

The Case's Direction Remains Undetermined: How a Lawyer Engages with the Prosecutor at the Procuratorate Stage

 

After completing the engagement formalities, I contacted the procuratorate at the first opportunity to obtain the case file and spent several consecutive days carefully studying the case materials. I then held the first detailed telephone conference with the client, going through the contents of the case item by item.

 

Based on the evidence in the file, my preliminary assessment was that although some evidentiary defects existed, there was still a certain prospect of persuading the procuratorate to make a non-prosecution decision.


However, the ultimate direction still depended on the engagement with the prosecutor. After all, in my view, the existing materials were insufficient to establish that the client constituted fraud, but the procuratorate could fully remand the case to the public security organ for supplementary investigation to fill gaps and remedy deficiencies. Therefore, remaining cautious at the procuratorate stage rather than blindly confident is the basic attitude of defense counsel.

 

 

 

4

Half a Year of Offense and Defense: The Contest Between Prosecutor and Lawyer After Two Remands for Supplementary Investigation

 

One day, I called the prosecutor handling the case and first communicated my defense arguments on fraud. From her tone, I could clearly sense her capability, decisiveness and the professional temperament peculiar to legal practitioners. After hearing my reasoning, she said: "How about this: organize your arguments into written materials, and I will study them carefully."

 

From that point on, I engaged in six months of communication and back-and-forth with the prosecutor. The case was twice returned to the public security authority for supplementary investigation. This process was more like a contest of attack and defense: the prosecutor kept searching for evidence that might point to guilt, while I had to prove, through detailed legal argumentation, that the client did not constitute the crime of fraud.

 

At the same time, it also resembles a joint effort. Lawyers and prosecutors both review the evidence gathered by the public security authorities, considering what materials may be supplemented and submitted, what may be used to establish guilt, and what may instead support innocence. In other words, although defense lawyers and prosecutors hold opposing positions, they are not in absolute conflict at the procuratorate stage. Whether the facts of a case can be clear and the evidence credible and sufficient ultimately depends on whose legal arguments are more persuasive.

 

In this process, there is no absolute right or wrong; what matters more is the professional exchange and mutual respect among legal professionals. (As for the detailed legal opinion in this case, I have placed it at the end of the article for the reference of fellow lawyers handling similar cases.)

                                                                                                                            (Communication with the client on the day the decision not to prosecute was issued)

                                                                                                                                                  (The exhilaration that can only be felt at the moment the result comes out)

 

 

 

5

Reflections on handling a novel case: the true embodiment of a lawyer's professional value

 

Over the years, whether because of the interpersonal "chemistry" or my personal preference for researching novel, difficult and complex cases, generally speaking, most of the prosecutors I have encountered are willing to engage in in-depth communication with lawyers.

 

In some traditional types of criminal cases (such as drunk driving, brawling, and "two-card" crimes), because unified handling rules and fixed case-handling opinions already exist, prosecutors often occupy a stronger dominant position, and lawyers' opinions struggle to have a substantive impact.


By contrast, in novel criminal cases (such as digital collection cases, Web3, and virtual currency cases), because ready-made experience and precedents are lacking, prosecutors are more in need of reference to lawyers' professional analysis and are more likely to listen carefully to and adopt defense opinions.

 

At the same time, frontline case-handling personnel often handle dozens of cases at once and must also attend to administrative affairs; even if they wish to devote more energy, they often lack the capacity to do so.

 

Therefore, when handling novel cases (such as Web3 and virtual currency) or cases with a strong industry dimension (such as digital collectibles and loan-assistance companies), lawyers must fully put themselves in the other's shoes when communicating with prosecutors—because many prosecutors may be encountering this type of case for the first time. Law is an applied discipline; only by understanding industry logic and business models can the law be correctly applied. Otherwise, even if case-handling personnel are familiar with the legal provisions, if they cannot understand the behavioral patterns involved in the case, they are prone to make "misjudgments" that are unfavorable to the client.

 

For this very reason, when submitting legal opinions, lawyers need to explain several core issues as clearly and plainly as possible: what the client and the industry in which the client operates are actually doing; what unique characteristics and industry practices that industry has; how those industry characteristics should be legally evaluated; and how the client's conduct itself should be accurately characterized, among other matters.

 

Clearly deconstructing the industry logic, precisely characterizing the nature of the conduct, and presenting it in a manner that prosecutors can understand and accept—this is not only the key strategy for an effective defense in criminal cases with industry-specific characteristics, but also the true embodiment of a lawyer's professional value.

 


 

Attachment: Legal Opinion in This Case

Special Note: During the procuratorate stage, in order to fully demonstrate that the client did not constitute a crime, I communicated and discussed with the prosecutor multiple times both orally and in writing. The following content is an integration and distillation of the key points of prior communications, for the reference of fellow lawyers in similar cases. To protect the client's privacy, specific details involving the case have been necessarily deleted.

 

 

Legal Opinion on the Suspected Crime of Fraud by xx

 

The defender is of the view that xx does not constitute the crime of fraud, for the following reasons:

 

I. xx lacked both the subjective intent and the objective conduct for this crime

1. The xx platform did not fabricate facts, conceal the truth, or defraud others of property

 

We first need to discuss a question: Is purchasing digital collectibles an investment activity or a consumption activity?

 

This question is important. The reason many users reported to the police that they had encountered platform fraud is that they bought collectibles, but then no one was willing to take them over, the price fell, and they were left holding them.

 

In the course of representing the platform side, we also received inquiries from quite a few users. Setting aside whether the platform's initial offering price was reasonable and whether it had market value, we observed that few users genuinely purchased out of an affection for the collectibles themselves. More people were motivated by an investment mentality—buying initial-offering collectibles and, after the price rose, selling them on the consignment market to profit from the price difference.

 

Although there are currently no laws or regulations specifically targeting digital collectibles, local financial bureaus, market supervision departments, and other authorities have repeatedly reminded the public that digital collectibles must not be used for speculation, money laundering, tokenization, financialization, securitization, or other listed or private illegal transactions. They have also explicitly warned consumers—do not expect to achieve wealth appreciation through investing in digital collectibles, and remain calm.

 

In regulatory documents and judicial practice, digital collectibles are generally characterized as "online virtual goods" or "consumer goods," and the legal status of purchasers is that of "consumers," not "investors."

 

But the reality is that digital collectibles are based on blockchain technology and have asset attributes, and many purchasers naturally harbor investment intent. Across the multiple platforms we serve, even where conspicuous risk warnings are displayed on the purchase page, it remains impossible to prevent large numbers of users from entering the market with a speculative mindset. This is an almost universal phenomenon in the industry.

 

Therefore, even if a platform has not promised any premium and has not engaged in false or exaggerated promotion, it remains difficult to avoid users choosing to file complaints, bring lawsuits, or even make criminal reports to assert their rights after suffering losses.

The same is true in this case.

 

From the users' statements in their police reports,they generally treated the purchase of digital collectibles as a form of investment. Before purchasing, many of them would research market conditions and assess potential value. In other words, even if the platform engaged in a certain degree of exaggeration in its promotion in order to attract users, such influence did not reach the level of causing users to be completely mistaken. Users had expectations regarding risk and return, and were not in a state of "discovering they had been defrauded only after purchase."

The price of digital collectibles themselves is highly volatile, and a loss after purchase is very likely a normal investment risk brought about by market changes, rather than something caused by the platform's promotional conduct.

 

From the platform's perspective,to determine that it constitutes fraud, there must be evidence proving which specific acts the company carried out during its operations. Was it merely exaggerated promotion, or was it false promotion? Were there acts manipulating the market, such as excessive issuance or maliciously driving up prices?

If the platform did not create a false appearance of market prosperity through price manipulation, fictitious transactions, or other means, and the trading rules were open and transparent, with users free to trade and withdraw funds, then the platform does not satisfy the subjective intent and objective conduct elements of the crime of fraud.

 

2. Platform xx did not carry out deceptive conduct sufficient to cause others to be mistaken

The crime of fraud in criminal law requires not only the subjective intent of illegal possession, but also the objective carrying out of deceptive conduct sufficient to cause others to be mistaken. In other words, the verification and determination of objective conduct is a prerequisite for conviction.

 

(1) The existing evidence cannot prove that the platform engaged in false promotion, for the following specific reasons:

 

Authenticity of Promotional Content

Upon review of the evidentiary materials in the case file, there is currently no evidence showing that the company involved made explicit return commitments such as fixed returns, principal-guaranteed repurchase, or metaverse rights and interests through external channels such as WeChat official accounts, user groups, or promotional posters, nor is there any conclusive evidence of fabricated partners (such as museums or cultural associations) or exaggeration of the scarcity of the collectibles.

 

Performance Capacity and Performance Status

In light of the company's operating conditions, it is necessary to examine whether it possesses qualifications such as blockchain filing and art trading licenses, as well as the flow of platform funds. Based on the current evidence, the company has performed in respects such as physical redemption and honoring of rights and interests, and it has not been proven that it made false commitments. If the committed content has actually been performed, or has not materially misled users, it is difficult to find that deceptive conduct exists.

 

Trading and Market Manipulation

The evidence at this stage also fails to prove that the platform involved created a false appearance of appreciation by manipulating the secondary market (such as fictitious trading or price intervention), nor is there evidence that it used methods such as "airdrops" or "blind boxes" to induce users to invest funds and then discontinued services or restricted withdrawals.

 

In summary, the evidence in the case file is insufficient to prove that the platform involved fabricated facts or concealed the truth during its operations. Its trading rules were relatively open and transparent, and users had the right to trade and withdraw funds freely. Under these circumstances, whether as the crime of fraud or the crime of fund-raising fraud, there is no basis for establishment in terms of subjective intent or objective conduct.

 

(2) The existing evidence cannot prove that the platform's business model is suspected of a criminal offense, for the following specific reasons:

Proceeding from the platform's overall business model, several key facts in this case still require further investigation:

 

Corporate Operating Structure and Division of Business

Based on the employee statements, WeChat chat records, and promotional materials in the case file, it is currently insufficient to prove that the company's management had a clear fraudulent plan. On the contrary, the materials only show that employees in various positions and volunteers were performing their respective duties normally, and there is no evidence of conduct that actively drove up product value, published false information, or deliberately induced users to make purchases.

 

Issuance and Technical Aspects

At present, there is no evidence capable of proving that the platform engaged in excessive issuance, off-chain sales, or the use of 'rat trading' to channel benefits. There is even less evidence indicating subjective malice or specific responsible persons in the relevant links.

 

Performance of publicity and commitments

The materials at this stage do not show that the company generally made profit-related commitments to users such as 'guaranteed buyback' or 'fixed dividends.' Even if individual promotional statements contain exaggeration, fraud intent cannot be directly inferred therefrom. Based on the existing performance situation, the platform does have records of honoring some of the users' rights and interests, and this cannot be characterized as an overall false commitment.

 

Source and value of the collectibles

The digital collectibles currently issued all have corresponding creation and authorization sources as supporting evidence, and some are also accompanied by signed contracts or authorization documents. No evidence has been seen proving that the company involved infringed copyrights, trademarks, or other rights, and this is also insufficient to support criminal charges.

 

The company's financial condition

Based on the existing financial materials, the company's asset scale and income and expenditure situation conform to normal commercial logic. No clear evidence has been seen of capital withdrawal, malicious squandering, or abnormal flows.

 

In summary, the evidence in the case is still insufficient to prove that the overall business model of the platform involved is deceptive or unlawful, and still less can it directly lead to the conclusion that a criminal offense is constituted. In accordance with the principle that 'where there is doubt, the accused shall be treated as innocent,' it is inappropriate at this stage to characterize the platform and the relevant responsible persons as having committed fraud or other economic crimes.

 

II. xx Platform did not have the purpose of illegal possession

In criminal cases, where an actor carries out fraudulent conduct with the purpose of illegal possession, this is generally manifested as follows:

 

knowingly lacking the ability to repay yet obtaining a large amount of funds by fraud; absconding after illegally obtaining funds; wantonly squandering fraudulently obtained funds; using fraudulently obtained funds to engage in illegal or criminal activities; withdrawing or transferring funds or concealing property in order to evade return of funds; concealing or destroying accounts, or engaging in false bankruptcy or false closure in order to evade return of funds; and other conduct of illegally possessing funds and refusing to return them.

 

In digital collectibles cases, when determining whether a platform has the purpose of illegal possession, it is necessary to conduct a comprehensive analysis in light of the reasons why the platform ceased operations, the performance of its pre-notification obligations, and the manner in which funds were handled. In such cases, the reasons users give when reporting to the police are often described as: the platform cannot process withdrawals, and customer service cannot be reached.

 

In this case, the digital collectibles market as a whole was in a downturn at the time, and the platform's shutdown was caused by objective operational risks rather than a deliberate absconding with funds. More critically, before ceasing operations, the platform had issued a public announcement to users and initiated refund arrangements, making proportional refunds to users. The above conduct shows that, in handling funds, the platform did not exhibit the intent of 'illegal possession' in the sense of criminal law; its purpose was not to defraud users of their property and appropriate it, but rather to be forced to exit the market due to the overall industry environment.

 

III. The determination of the amount of crime in this case lacks legal basis and factual basis

First, most of the losses alleged by the complainants are the shrinkage in value arising after they purchased digital collectibles on the company platform's secondary market and were unable to resell them. These losses were not paid directly to the company, but rather were price fluctuations in the ordinary course of transactions on the secondary market. In this process, the company only charged a small handling fee based on the transaction amount; therefore, the amount of the complainants' losses on the secondary market cannot be directly determined as the amount of crime involved in the case.

 

Second, as to the company's revenue: revenue from the platform's primary sales was approximately xx million yuan. The company has a business license, and this portion constitutes normal business operations and should not, according to law, be directly counted as the amount of crime. Commission from transactions on the platform's consignment market was approximately xx million yuan. This portion likewise constitutes lawful platform revenue.

 

In summary, where the existing evidence is insufficient to prove that the company's revenue was obtained with the purpose of illegal possession, and the so-called 'amount of loss' did not flow directly into the company's accounts, treating the entire amount of the complainants' losses as equivalent to the amount of crime lacks both a factual foundation and compliance with legal provisions.

 

IV.The complainants in this case are 'imperfect victims'

Since the rise of the digital collectibles industry, our team has provided services to hundreds of platforms and has had extensive contact with industry users, and therefore has a relatively deep understanding of the user characteristics of this industry.

Unlike the victim groups in traditional wealth management company collapse cases, digital collectibles users differ markedly in their overall profile, trading motives, and risk perception.

Take the illegal absorption of public deposits cases I have handled as an example. In such cases, the victims are often induced by the company's long-term high-yield publicity to invest their retirement savings and all their savings, and once the company collapses, their personal and family finances completely collapse.

In the digital collectibles field, however, most users participate in trading based on speculative psychology. They are generally active on multiple platforms, seeking price-difference profits through buying low and selling high and speculating on hot trends; very few users purchase out of genuine collecting interest. After purchase, their main intention is to sell at an opportune time on the secondary market, rather than to hold long term or purely collect.

Therefore, once a loss occurs, such users often form groups to report the matter and defend their rights. What is more, some users have long moved among various platforms to trade and are well aware that such conduct carries investment risk, yet they are still willing to put in funds to 'test the waters,' with the psychological expectation of 'investing a portion first and leaving once I make money,' which in essence carries an obvious gambling mentality.

 

Therefore, in this case, I also addressed the characteristics of the victims in light of the actual circumstances of the case.

 

The complainant in this case is an "imperfect victim."

This case was initiated by a report filed by the victim xx. Counsel can understand that the public security authority, motivated by a desire to "maintain stability," opened an investigation into the platform, and objectively speaking, at the time the case was opened, because digital collectibles were an emerging industry, the case was opened to a certain extent because the public security authority lacked sufficient understanding of whether the platform's business operations constituted a crime. This is also one of the reasons the case entered criminal proceedings.

 

From the perspective of the business model, the platform's profits in this case came mainly from initial sales and transaction fees in the consignment market, which conformed to the prevailing industry rules at the time and were lawful and reasonable. As the unique digital certificate of a specific work or artwork, digital collectibles are empowered by blockchain technology and possess features such as uniqueness, immutability and non-replicability, and thus have a certain collectible and appreciative value in themselves. The sale prices in the consignment market were determined by market supply and demand and had no direct relationship with the platform; the platform merely provided the trading venue and technical support and did not participate in price setting.

 

In light of the facts of the case, the group of complainants, including XX,exhibits the typical characteristics of "imperfect victims.":

 

They did not purchase the collectibles out of a genuine interest in collecting, but rather moved transactions among multiple platforms, adhering to a speculative mentality of "only making money, never losing money." Once losses occurred, they sought so-called "rights protection" through concentrated reporting. In this case, such conduct to a large extent exploited the background at the time, in which the judicial authorities lacked sufficient understanding of the digital collectibles industry and the legal provisions were not yet clear.

 

Therefore, in determining the nature of such reporting conduct, it should be carefully assessed whether it truly falls within the category of "victims" protected by criminal law, and normal investment risks should be prevented from being shifted onto criminal liability, thereby causing improper occupation of judicial resources.

 

V. Authenticity and Applicability of the Statements of Other Victims

In a large number of traditional cases of the crime of assisting information network criminal activities, the crime of concealing or disguising criminal proceeds, and telecommunications fraud, when the public security authority prepares victim interview records, it usually uses relatively fixed question-and-answer templates, focusing on issues such as anti-fraud publicity, installation of anti-fraud apps, whether the victim received dissuasion, and the time and amount of transfers. This templated questioning method may be feasible in telecommunications fraud cases, but it is not applicable to criminal cases involving the digital collectibles field.

 

From the records of several complainants in this case, there are obvious characteristics of "template application":

  • The complainants stated that they "saw promotional activities for the platform involved in the case, learned that the platform was a profit investment, and then deposited money into the platform,"

  • "Later, it was discovered that the platform could not process withdrawals,"

  • The public security authorities then directly asked questions such as "Have you ever received anti-fraud publicity?" "Have you installed an anti-fraud app?" and "Have police officers ever warned or dissuaded you?"

 

The above question-and-answer pattern clearly follows the template used in traditional telecom fraud cases and does not match the actual operating model of a digital collectibles platform or the transaction logic of its users. Defense counsel has reason to suspect that these transcripts do not fully reflect the reporting parties' true intentions, but rather are records made by the receiving police officers based on their own understanding and established patterns.

 

In addition, the bank statements in the case file are inconsistent with the transcripts of at least 3 reporting parties—the deposit and withdrawal amounts they stated do not match the actual transaction records. If this case is ultimately to be characterized as fraud, it is necessary to contact each reporting party individually to further verify:

  • whether the platform engaged in fabricating facts or concealing the truth;

  • whether they fell into a material misunderstanding as a result of such conduct and disposed of property;

  • and to provide complete bank statements in order to verify the actual deposits and withdrawals.

 

Only after the above key facts are clarified can it be determined in accordance with law whether there is a direct causal relationship, in the sense of criminal law, between the platform's conduct and the users' losses.

 

VI. The Authenticity and Objectivity of Employee Testimony Are Questionable

In such cases, judicial authorities typically question the platform's responsible persons, shareholders, and employees regarding the disputed facts and confirm them through cross-verification. For example, whether there were excessive issuances, off-chain sales, "rat trading," or similar conduct can be fully verified through technical backend data, rather than relying solely on employee statements.

 

In this case, we believe that some employees' testimony incriminating the parties lacks authenticity and objectivity, for the following reasons:

 

  • The employees concerned have only witness status, not accomplice status, and do not bear criminal liability; therefore, their statements lack self-risk constraint;

  • Due to poor business operations in the company's later period, there were indeed wage arrears, and some employees harbored resentment and complaints toward the company's legal representative, alleging during testimony that the platform engaged in conduct such as 'front-running'; their statements cannot be entirely freed from subjective bias;

  • At present, no other direct evidence has been seen that can corroborate such testimony, and it is still insufficient to serve as a basis for determining the facts of the case.

 

In this case, employee testimony must be examined together with the full picture of the case and other objective evidence, and cannot be relied upon alone as a basis for deciding the case. In the absence of corroboration by technical data or other objective evidence, the employees' adverse statements should not be directly accepted.

 

In summary, the defense holds that, after two supplementary investigations, the finding that xx constitutes the crime of fraud remains unclear in facts and insufficient in evidence, and respectfully requests that the procuratorate make a decision not to prosecute.

 

Defense counsel: Attorney Shao Shiwei

 

Month x, Day x, 2025