Special Statement: This article is an original article by Attorney Shao Shiwei and represents only the author's personal views. It does not constitute legal consultation or legal advice on any specific matter. For article reprints | legal consultation | business exchanges, please add: sswls66

Introduction:

In the information age in which we live, it may be increasingly obvious to everyone that various types of software seem to "understand" us better, able to push more precisely the products we like and the information we want to obtain, and to connect us with nuisance customer service calls about goods or services in which we happen to be interested... The precise recommendations of algorithms are in fact built on the results of our own "precise feeding," in other words, we exchange our own personal information so that big data becomes increasingly adapted to our own preferences.

For example, as soon as Taobao is opened, the homepage recommendations happen to display the product one intends to buy; when preparing to apply for a loan and browsing a mobile webpage, one then receives a customer service call about an online loan. Sometimes we also vaguely wonder, why does big data understand me so well? But because it has not produced adverse effects on our own lives, we do not look into it deeply.

But some people may not be so lucky and become victims of various types of online fraud cases. Therefore, this article today will discuss one link in the chain of online crime—infringement of citizens' personal information.

 

 

Author of this article: Attorney Shao Shiwei

01

Legislationand Regulatory Review

 

1. Article 253-1 of the Criminal Lawprovides that,the crime of infringing citizens' personal information refers to the act of selling or providing citizens' personal information to others, where the circumstances are serious.

This crime was added by Article 7 of Amendment VII to the Criminal Law in 2009. It was later revised by Article 17 of Amendment IX to the Criminal Law in 2015, which changed the subject of this crime from a special subject to a general subject, added provisions for heavier punishment, and raised the statutory maximum penalty for this crime from three years to seven years of fixed-term imprisonment.

 

2. Relevant laws and regulations of China on personal information protection

 

In 2012, the Decision of the Standing Committee of the National People's Congress on Strengthening Network Information Protection expressly set out the principles, obligations and legal liabilities that network service providers, other enterprises and public institutions, and state organs and their staff should observe in collecting, using and safeguarding citizens' personal electronic information.

 

On April 23, 2013, the Supreme People's Court and the Supreme People's Procuratorate issued the Notice on Punishing Criminal Activities Infringing upon Citizens' Personal Information in Accordance with Law,which defined the content of citizens' personal informationwas defined.

 

In July 2015, the National Security Law was issued and came into effect,elevating data security safeguards to the level of national security.The Law states that network management shall be strengthened with the aim of preventing, stopping and punishing in accordance with law cyber attacks, network intrusions, network theft of secrets, the dissemination of illegal and harmful information and other cyber illegal and criminal acts, so as to safeguard national sovereignty, security and development interests in cyberspace.

 

On June 1, 2017, the Interpretation of the Supreme People's Court and the Supreme People's Procuratorate on Several Issues Concerning the Application of Law in Handling Criminal Cases of Infringing upon Citizens' Personal Information came into effect.

 

In June 2017, the Cybersecurity Law officially came into effect, and in Chapter IV, "Network Information Security," it provided more comprehensive rules on the collection, storage, safeguarding and use of personal information. As for liability for infringement of personal information, although the Law mainly provides for the administrative legal liability of network operators for violating various statutory obligations to protect personal information.

 

On November 9, 2018, the Supreme People's Procuratorate issued the Notice on the Guidelines for Procuratorial Organs in Handling Cases of Infringing upon Citizens' Personal Information.

 

On January 23, 2019, the Cyberspace Administration of China and three other departments issued the Announcement on Carrying Out Special Governance of Illegal and Non-compliant Collection and Use of Personal Information by Apps.

 

In January 2021, the Civil Code came into effect. The Civil Code clarifies the scope, requirements and principles for processing personal information, as well as the circumstances exempting liability; it clarifies the rights of personal information subjects and provides for the obligations of information processors, among other matters.

 

In September 2021, the Data Security Law came into effect. This is China's first specialized law on data security, and for the first time elevates the overall decision-making and coordination of data security to the central national security leadership body. Its superior law is the National Security Law, and it optimizes thecross-border data transferrules.

 

In November 2021, the Personal Information Protection Law came into effect. This law establishes, for the first time in China, a complete and systematic legal regime for the protection of personal information.

 

On September 1, 2022, the Measures for Security Assessment of Cross-border Data Transfer came into effect, providing that these Measures apply to the security assessment of important data and personal information collected and generated in the course of operations within the territory of the People's Republic of China that data processors provide to overseas parties.

 

On August 3, 2023, the Cyberspace Administration of China [issued] the Measures for the Administration of Compliance Audits of Personal Information Protection (Draft for Comment)

 

In summary, with respect to the protection of personal information, China has established an all-domain, multi-level legislative system led by the Criminal Law, the National Security Law, the Cybersecurity Law, the Data Security Law, the Civil Code and the Personal Information Protection Law.

 

02

Data speaks

 

In order to understand how judicial authorities punish the crime of infringing citizens' personal information in practice, a search of publicly available judgment documents was conducted in the following manner.

 

Search date: September 5, 2023

Search time range: all cases in the Wolters Kluwer database up to September 5, 2023

Search charges: criminal; crime of infringing on citizens' personal information; crime of illegally selling or illegally providing citizens' personal information; crime of illegally obtaining citizens' personal information

 

Because cases where the second-instance judgment was altered or the first-instance judgment was revoked and the case was remanded for retrial number only slightly more than one hundred, a relatively small base, the data retrieved this time is limited to criminal first-instance judgment documents. On that basis, keywords were further set for retrieval, yielding the following data:

 

1. Regional distribution:

Mainly coastal regions; Jiangsu ranks first and Shanghai ranks fifth.

                                           

2. Distribution of case trial years:

The retrieval results show that the number of cases is concentrated in 2017 and 2018, and in recent years the number has shown a year-by-year declining trend.

 

In 2017 and 2018, compared with other years, the case volume was notably higher. As for the reason, the author offers only a conjecture here: it may be related to the Xu Yuyu case. That case had considerable social influence at the time; the principal offender involved was sentenced to life imprisonment after being convicted of fraud and the crime of infringing on citizens' personal information, with the punishments combined.

In addition, in June 2017, the Interpretation on Several Issues Concerning the Application of Law in the Handling of Criminal Cases of Infringing on Citizens' Personal Information and the Cybersecurity Law were successively issued.

Owing to social background factors, the issuance of laws and regulations, and other factors, the number of personal information cases handled in 2017 and 2018 surged, then leveled off. Because of the pandemic in the preceding years, the number of arrests by public security authorities decreased, and other uncontrollable factors[1] meant that the number of publicly available cases was not large.

According to the Shanghai Cybercrime Prosecution White Paper (2022) released by the Shanghai Municipal People's Procuratorate on March 1, 2023, "the leakage of citizens' personal information has become a key link in the chain of cybercrime, such as apps excessively or irregularly collecting citizens' personal information, lending out ID cards and bank accounts, using credential stuffing, using 'crawler' technology, and sending fraudulent links to phishing websites and other meth

ods to irregularly obtain citizens' personal information and platform data; the information leakage risks brought by data security vulnerabilities have provided fertile ground for crimes such as telecom and online fraud. The absolute number of cases of the crime of infringing on citizens' personal information has increased markedly."

With the implementation of the Personal Information Protection Law in 2021 and the continuous implementation of the Supreme People's Procuratorate's "Procuratorial Recommendation No. 6" in various localities, the author believes that in judicial practice, the crackdown on the crime of infringing on citizens' personal information and related criminal cases will not be relaxed.

 

3. Suspended Sentences and Unit (Entity) Offenses under This Crime

Based on the search, the following data was obtained:

 

①First, data from all publicly available years across the entire internet.

There were 5,270 first-instance judgment documents in total. Of these, 2,638 cases involved suspended sentences. Among them, 69 involved unit (entity) offenses, and 49 involved suspended sentences for personnel of units.

Among the first-instance cases, 3,127 involved release on bail pending trial, 2,638 involved suspended sentences, and 818 involved actual imprisonment. (Note: Because a large number of cases involve multiple defendants in a single judgment, with some receiving actual imprisonment and others suspended sentences, the search results will inevitably contain overlapping data. Therefore, two search methods were used for cross-verification, and the results are for reference only.)

 

②Second, data from the past 5 years was searched(limited to the period from January 1, 2018 to September 5, 2023).

There were 3,761 first-instance judgment documents in total. Of these, 1,951 cases involved suspended sentences. Among them, 35 involved unit (entity) offenses(none in the Shanghai region), and 31 involved suspended sentences for personnel of units.

 

From the above data, it is possible todraw the following conclusion:                                                          

Across all years of data, suspended sentences accounted for 50% of cases, and 71% of unit-crime cases received suspended sentences.Among cases where the suspect was released on bail pending trial, approximately 30% ultimately received a custodial sentence.。

Over the past five years, suspended sentences accounted for 51.8% of cases, and 88.6% of unit-crime cases received suspended sentences.

 

The above data show that, nationwide, the probability of a suspended sentence for this offense is relatively high, and the probability of a suspended sentence in unit-crime cases is even higher.

 

4. Non-prosecution by the procuratorate

Across all years of data, a total of 1,098 procuratorate non-prosecution decisions were retrieved, of which 4 involved non-prosecution in unit-crime cases.

Based on the data alone, non-prosecution accounted for 17% of cases for this offense. Considering the actual situation in recent years, in which the volume of publicly available judgment documents has decreased year by year, the author considers this figure abnormally high.

 

5. Judicial practice in the Shanghai region

Given that the documents published on China Judgments Online are not comprehensive, the author conducted further research.

According to a search conducted by the Research Office of the Shanghai High People's Court using the court's internal C2J intelligent judge case-handling assistance system[2] with "infringement of citizens' personal information" as the keyword, more precise and detailed data conclusions for the Shanghai region can be derived as follows:

Among the 354 judgment documents from Shanghai courts for 2019–2021, 339 resulted in conviction and sentencing for the crime of infringing citizens' personal information, while 15 did not result in conviction and sentencing for this offense.There were only 2 unit-crime cases.Approximately half of the individuals involved in the cases were sentenced to probation.

 

It may be inferred that Shanghai takes a relatively strict approach to the determination of unit crimes. Accordingly, where a unit crime is asserted, and a joint crime is also claimed (from a defense perspective, the purpose being to assert that the individuals involved are accessories and to seek the sentencing circumstances of a lighter or mitigated penalty), what is Shanghai's approach?The conclusion is that Shanghai is relatively cautious about whether a joint crime is established, and in judicial practice the determination of a joint crime is difficult.。

Among the 354 documents, 144 documents confirmed the establishment of a joint crime, and 91 documents did not mention whether a joint crime was established.

 

In addition, the crime of infringing on citizens' personal information is generally an upstream crime of other crimes; is an upstream or downstream crime determined to be a joint crime? The conclusion is that in judicial practice the determination of a joint crime is difficult.

Among the 354 documents, the defendants in 42 documents were punished for multiple crimes because their conduct constituted several offenses, and only 19 documents confirmed the establishment of a joint crime among the defendants.

 

 

03

The constitutive elements of this crime

1、Under Article 253-1 of the Criminal Law of the People's Republic of China, the crime of infringing on citizens' personal information, the following key points may be distilled:

① The conduct constituting the crime is "selling, providing, stealing or otherwise" obtaining citizens' personal information;

② Constituting this crime requires "serious circumstances"; the maximum penalty is 7 years;

③ Persons performing official duties who engage in such conduct are given a heavier penalty;

④ This crime includes unit crimes;

 

Criminal Law of the People's Republic of China (2020 Amendment)

Article 253A [Crime of Infringing on Citizens' Personal Information] Whoever, in violation of the relevant provisions of the State, sells or provides citizens' personal information to others, where the circumstances are serious, shall be sentenced to fixed-term imprisonment of not more than three years or criminal detention, and shall also, or shall only, be fined; where the circumstances are especially serious, shall be sentenced to fixed-term imprisonment of not less than three years but not more than seven years, and shall also be fined.

Whoever, in violation of the relevant provisions of the State, sells or provides to others citizens' personal information obtained in the course of performing duties or providing services shall be given a heavier punishment in accordance with the provisions of the preceding paragraph.

Whoever steals or illegally obtains citizens' personal information by other means shall be punished in accordance with the provisions of paragraph 1.

Where a unit commits any of the crimes specified in the preceding three paragraphs, the unit shall be fined, and the persons directly in charge and other persons directly responsible shall be punished in accordance with the provisions of each of those paragraphs.

 

2. What specifically does "citizens' personal information" refer to?

It includes the following information and data that can, alone or in combination with other information, identify a citizen's personal identity, reflect the activities of a specific natural person, or involve a citizen's personal privacy:

Name, identity document number, communications contact details, address, account password, property status, whereabouts and movement trajectories, marital status, employer, educational background, curriculum vitae, etc.

 

Interpretation of the Supreme People's Court and the Supreme People's Procuratorate on Several Issues Concerning the Application of Law in the Handling of Criminal Cases of Infringing on Citizens' Personal Information

Article 1 "Citizens' personal information" as provided in Article 253A of the Criminal Law refers to all kinds of information recorded electronically or by other means that can, alone or in combination with other information, identify the identity of a specific natural person or reflect the activities of a specific natural person, including name, identity document number, communications contact details, address, account password, property status, whereabouts and movement trajectories, etc.

 

Notice of the Supreme People's Court, the Supreme People's Procuratorate and the Ministry of Public Security on Punishing Criminal Activities Infringing on Citizens' Personal Information in Accordance with Law

II. Citizens' personal information includes citizens' name, age, valid document number, marital status, employer, educational background, curriculum vitae, home address, telephone number and other information and data that can identify a citizen's personal identity or involve a citizen's personal privacy.

 

This raises the question:if crawlers or other means are used to collect company contact information and similar data, does this constitute the crime?The answer is that it does not.

 

In the 2018 Supreme People's Procuratorate Guidelines for Procuratorial Organs Handling Cases of Infringement of Citizens' Personal Information, with respect to mobile phone numbers, telephone numbers and similar information contained in enterprise business registration and similar information, the purpose of the numbers should be confirmed; information such as mobile phone numbers and telephone numbers that are "purchased and used by the company" does not constitute personal information.

 

3. Conduct constituting this crime

Relevant legal provisions:Article 253-1 of the Criminal Law and the Interpretation of the Supreme People's Court and the Supreme People's Procuratorate on Several Issues Concerning the Application of Law in the Handling of Criminal Cases of Infringing Citizens' Personal Information

 

Based on the above circumstances, it can be determined that:

obtaining the consent of the person whose information is collected, and anonymization processing (removing personal associations), are lawful ways of providingcitizens' personal information and are not subject to criminal law regulation.

 

4. Unit crime in relation to this crime

Under the Criminal Law, an accomplice shall be given a lighter or mitigated punishment or be exempted from punishment.

Therefore, if the case involves conduct carried out by a company, defense counsel should strive to have the case ultimately characterized as a unit crime. Only in this way, from the perspective of the company's employees, can it be conducive to asserting accessory status and seeking a lower sentencing tier.

 

Does the mere establishment of a company mean it is a unit crime? No.

Where a company, enterprise, or public institution is established by an individual for the purpose of carrying out illegal or criminal activities and commits a crime, or where, after the establishment of a company, enterprise, or public institution, the commission of crimes constitutes its principal activity, it shall not be treated as a unit crime [3].

 

The statutory provisions are relatively clear, but in practice the judicial authorities apply a stricter standard in determining unit crimes. Based on cases the author has handled, some companies—even those that had previously operated other lawful businesses for a period before shifting to the buying and selling of citizens' information as their main business—were ultimately characterized by the court as individual crimes.

 

5. Filing standards for this crime

Only where the circumstances are serious is the filing standard for this crime met.

The judicial authorities convict the perpetrator based on the number of pieces of information or the amount of the perpetrator's profits.

For unit crimes, a comprehensive determination will be made by combining the number of pieces of case-related information processed by the company and the company's profits.

The importance of establishing that a company constitutes a unit crime, as mentioned in the preceding paragraph, is briefly illustrated by the following example: illegal gains of 5,000 yuan (i.e., the income of an employee during employment) meet the filing standard for this crime; if the income obtained by an employee during employment at the company exceeds 50 thousand yuan, the circumstances constitute "especially serious circumstances," for which the statutory penalty is three to seven years. Absent statutory circumstances such as voluntary surrender or meritorious service, only by being recognized as an accessory can a sentence of less than three years be sought, thereby creating an opportunity to obtain probation.

 

The Interpretation of the Supreme People's Court and the Supreme People's Procuratorate on Several Issues Concerning the Application of Law in the Handling of Criminal Cases of Infringing on Citizens' Personal Information

Article 5 Whoever illegally obtains, sells, or provides citizens' personal information and falls under any of the following circumstances shall be recognized as "serious circumstances" as provided in Article 253-1 of the Criminal Law:

(1) selling or providing location and tracking information that is used by another person to commit a crime;

(2) knowing or ought to know that another person will use citizens' personal information to commit a crime, yet selling or providing such information to that person;

(3) illegally obtaining, selling or providing 50 or more items of location and tracking information, communication content, credit information or property information;

(4) illegally obtaining, selling or providing 500 or more items of citizens' personal information that may affect personal or property safety, such as accommodation information, communication records, health and physiological information or transaction information;

(5) illegally obtaining, selling or providing 5,000 or more items of citizens' personal information other than those specified in items (3) and (4);

(6) where the quantity does not reach the thresholds specified in items (3) to (5), but the aggregate calculated according to the corresponding proportions reaches the relevant quantity threshold;

(7) illegal gains of 5,000 yuan or more;

(8) selling or providing to another person citizens' personal information obtained in the course of performing duties or providing services, where the quantity or amount reaches half or more of the thresholds specified in items (3) to (7);

(9) having previously been subjected to criminal punishment for infringing citizens' personal information, or to administrative punishment within two years, and again illegally obtaining, selling or providing citizens' personal information;

(10) other circumstances of a serious nature.

 

Where a person commits an act specified in the preceding paragraph and any of the following circumstances exists, it shall be determined to be "especially serious circumstances" as specified in Paragraph 1 of Article 253-1 of the Criminal Law:

(1) causing serious consequences such as the death, serious injury or mental disorder of the victim, or the victim being kidnapped;

(2) causing significant economic loss or egregious social impact;

(3) the quantity or amount reaching ten times or more the thresholds specified in items (3) through (8) of the preceding paragraph;

(4) other circumstances where the circumstances are especially serious.

Where, for lawful business operations, a person unlawfully purchases or receives citizens' personal information other than that specified in items (3) and (4) of paragraph 1 of Article 5 of this Interpretation, and any of the following circumstances applies, it shall be determined to be "serious circumstances" as provided in Article 253A of the Criminal Law:

(1) the person obtains a profit of RMB 50,000 or more by using the unlawfully purchased or received citizens' personal information;

(2) the person has previously been subject to criminal punishment for infringing on citizens' personal information, or has been subject to administrative punishment within two years, and again unlawfully purchases or receives citizens' personal information;

(3) other circumstances where the circumstances are serious.

 

Article 6 Where, for lawful business operations, a person unlawfully purchases or receives citizens' personal information other than that specified in items (3) and (4) of paragraph 1 of Article 5 of this Interpretation, and any of the following circumstances applies, it shall be determined to be "serious circumstances" as provided in Article 253A of the Criminal Law:

(1) the person obtains a profit of RMB 50,000 or more by using the unlawfully purchased or received citizens' personal information;

(2) the person has previously been subject to criminal punishment for infringing on citizens' personal information, or has been subject to administrative punishment within two years, and again unlawfully purchases or receives citizens' personal information;

(3) other circumstances where the circumstances are serious.

Where a person commits the acts specified in the preceding paragraph and illegally sells or provides the personal information of citizens that was purchased or received, the standards for conviction and sentencing shall be governed by Article 5 of this Interpretation.

 

04

Loan facilitation companies may become the primary enforcement target in the future

In the author's view, the primary enforcement target for this crime in the future will be loan facilitation companies. Judging from the uses to which illegally traded personal information of citizens is put, the traded information is mainly used for performance promotion in lending and related fields [4]. Therefore, the entities with a large demand for citizens' information that can readily develop on a large scale in the private lending market are loan facilitation companies.

 

Loan facilitation business has evolved from the traditional "offline loan facilitation" to the current "internet loan facilitation"; in essence, both involve loan facilitation institutions acting as "brokers" or "agents," matching lenders with borrowers and facilitating the parties' reaching a meeting of minds.

Loan facilitation business has its own advantages: financial institutions and loan facilitation platforms each leverage their respective strengths to broaden customer bases, reduce service costs, and achieve precision marketing of financial products.

At the same time, however, numerous problems exist. For example, a common industry-wide problem is obtaining users' blanket authorization and excessive authorization through generalized authorization on apps, failing to fully disclose to users the purpose and manner of collecting user information and whether it is shared with third-party partner companies, and potentially sharing the list of third-party companies with which user information is shared, among other issues. These problems will directly cause loan facilitation companies to violate the Personal Information Protection Law, the Measures for the Administration of Credit Reporting Business, and other laws and regulations, thereby violating the Criminal Law and constituting the crime of infringing on citizens' personal information.

 

In the past, many banks obtained loan customers by cooperating with loan intermediaries, and even delegated the business of reviewing customers' creditworthiness to intermediary institutions. On March 6, 2023, the China Banking and Insurance Regulatory Commission issued the Notice on Carrying Out a Special Campaign against Unlawful Loan Intermediaries, requiring all local banking and insurance regulatory bureaus and all banking financial institutions to deploy and carry out a six-month special campaign against unlawful loan intermediaries (March 15, 2023 to September 15, 2023). Banking financial institutions were required to acquire customers independently and not to rely entirely on loan intermediaries.

 

As a result, some time ago, we saw phenomena like this (banks do not have it easy when it comes to acquiring customers):

 

and like this

 

Typical Cases

Case One[5] The case of Xie Moumou, Xin Moumou and others infringing on citizens' personal information 

The company initially focused mainly on online commercial promotion, but later incurred losses. Xie and Xin then decided to sell citizens' information for profit. From January 2018 to June 2019, Xie and Xin hired employees to attract people with loan needs to fill in information such as 'name, mobile phone number, whether they had local social insurance and housing provident fund, whether they had liabilities, real estate and vehicle ownership status, salary income, whether they had insurance, credit status, loan demand, and repayment cycle' by publishing loan advertisements online and setting loan advertisement links on the company's 'Dianyouqian' WeChat official account.

 

After obtaining the above information, they contacted credit officers. After the credit officers made payments, Xie, Xin and others, without the consent of the information rights holders, sold the information to the credit officers at a price of 30 yuan to 150 yuan per item.

According to the audit, the illegal gains of Xie, Xin and others totaledmore than 4500 thousand yuanThe public security organ extracted citizens' personal information from the website backend, totaling310 thousandmore than items.

 

In this case, the defendants Xie, Xin and others were sentenced for the crime of infringing on citizens' personal information to fixed-term imprisonment ranging from three years and six months to one year and four months, and were also fined.

 

Lawyer's comment:

a. This crime was not determined to be a unit crime. Although the public prosecution organ acknowledged that the company was initially engaged in lawful business, the court held that after January 2018, apart from selling citizens' personal information, the company had no other lawful business operations, so all the amounts alleged were criminal proceeds. Therefore, it still falls within the legal provision that 'where, after the establishment of a company, the main activity is the commission of crimes, it shall not be treated as a unit crime.'

 

b. Due to the massive volume of data in this case, it was objectively impossible to deduplicate the information, but there was reliable and sufficient evidence to prove that the illegal gains of each defendant were more than 50 thousand yuan. Therefore, the standard of 'especially serious circumstances' under this crime had been met.

 

Case Two[6] The "1.10" case of infringement of citizens' personal information in Xuancheng, Anhui Province.

In January 2023, the public security authority in Xuancheng, Anhui Province, received a report from a member of the public, who stated that after filling in personal information on an internet lending platform to apply for a vehicle loan, the person received a promotional call from another local lending company and suspected that the personal information had been illegally traded. Upon investigation, the platform on which the reporting member of the public applied for the loan had neither lending qualifications nor engaged in lending business; rather, it was an intermediary company engaged in "intermediary loan assistance."

 

The company disguised itself as a legitimate lending company and placed advertisements on search engines, online short-video platforms and other channels to attract persons with lending needs to fill in citizens' personal information; thereafter, without the authorization of the data subjects, it sold the relevant information through agents to lending companies in the locations to which the lenders belonged for profit. In May 2023, the public security authority in Xuancheng, Anhui Province, carried out a centralized arrest operation in the case, apprehending 39 criminal suspects and dismantling 3 "intermediary loan assistance" companies suspected of infringing citizens' personal information, with an amount involved of more than 16 million.

05

Specific manifestations of this crime and typical cases

In practice, apart from the loan-assistance industry, the industries involved in this crime and the specific circumstances of the cases are diverse.

 

1. The case ofa verification-code receiving platform infringing personal information[7] (handled by the Shanghai Fengxian People's Procuratorate)

Industry involved:

Telecommunications business operators. Real-name mobile phone numbers are linked to various important personal information such as names and ID card numbers and, in addition to their telecommunications function, are also widely used in social software, bank wealth-management software, public service software and the like to verify citizens' identity, and thus constitute important citizens' personal information; correspondingly, "verification-code receiving" services have emerged.

 

Modus operandi:

Employees of a telecommunications shop, without the customers' knowledge, downloaded video and shopping apps and then sent the obtained verification codes to their superiors; if successful login could be achieved, they could profit between 1 and 14 yuan.

 

Lawyer's Comment:

This type of conduct constitutes "selling to others, for profit, citizens' personal information obtained in the course of providing services" as stipulated in the Criminal Law, and is subject to a heavier penalty.

 

2. "AI Face-Swapping" Personal Information Infringement Public Interest Litigation Case[8] (Handled by the Hangzhou Xiaoshan District People's Procuratorate)

Modus operandi:

For the purpose of profit and without obtaining the consent of the persons edited, Yu used the above-mentioned "AI face-swapping" software to replace and synthesize face information of others collected from the Internet and other channels with face information in certain obscene videos, producing and generating fabricated face-swapped videos, which were then disseminated on online social software.

At the same time, Yu also created multiple groups on social software to provide customized face-swapping video services for others, producing face-swapped videos based on videos or photographs provided by customers.

In addition, Yu sold "AI face-swapping" software, provided face-swapping materials and taught usage tutorials on online social software.

 

Lawyer's Comment:

Because cases of infringement of citizens' personal information involve harm to the public interest, it is relatively common in judicial practice for procuratorates to file criminal incidental civil public interest litigation. In this case, while the procuratorate instituted public prosecution against the perpetrator on suspicion of the crime of producing and disseminating obscene materials for profit, it also filed a civil public interest litigation case for personal information protection.

 

3. Sale of Homeowners' Property Listing Information[9] (Handled by the Shanghai Jinshan District People's Procuratorate)

Industry:

An information technology company whose main business is selling information on second-hand housing for rent and sale in Shanghai.

 

Modus operandi:

Ke, the operator of an information technology company limited, developed and operated the "Fanglibang" website and an app of the same name. During its operation, Ke used cash incentives to reward website members who uploaded genuine property-owner listing information, and induced real estate agents who possessed such information to register as members and provide information to the website in bulk (without the property owners' consent or authorization), thereby obtaining for consideration a large volume of non-public listing information, including the door numbers of properties intended for transaction, owners' names, and telephone numbers.

After the information was uploaded, Ke arranged for employees to pose as real estate agents and contact the property owners one by one by telephone for verification, and then provided the genuine and valid information to website members in the form of membership packages for paid inquiry and use.

 

Lawyer's comment:

Although the defense in this case argued that commercial listing information not marked with real names does not fall within the scope of citizens' personal information protected by criminal law, the prosecuting authority held that the key content of property-owner listing information is the property door number and the owner's telephone number; even without the owner's real name being marked, the combination of the precise geographic location of the property and the mobile phone number is sufficient to identify the specific identity of a particular natural person, namely the property owner.

 

06

Conclusion

 

On August 10, 2023, the Ministry of Public Security held a press conference in Beijing under the theme "Public Security Follows the Party, Safeguarding the New Journey"[10], at which it was noted that, with the advent of the global digital economy era, "data" has joined the ranks of the fifth major factor of production and its value has been rising; cases targeting citizens' personal information occur frequently and are growing rapidly, spanning sectors including government, healthcare, education, real estate, logistics, and e-commerce.

 

In the author's view, in recent years the judicial authorities have cracked down with great force on the crime of assisting information network criminal activities and the crime of concealing or disguising criminal proceeds; these two offenses target the fund inflow and outflow links of cybercrime and the gray and black industries, while combating criminal offenses of infringing citizens' personal information and prohibiting the illegal buying and selling of information cut off the criminal chain at its source, which is of great significance for protecting China's market economic order and social management order and for protecting citizens' personal rights and property security.


[1] WeChat article, "Plummeting! Sharp Drop in China Judgments Online Documents Published in 2021!"

[2] Issue No. 225 | Judicial Statistical Analysis of the Crime of Infringing Citizens' Personal Information — Based on a Sample of 354 Judgment Documents from Shanghai Courts from 2019 to 2021 https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/MWVARFpcQsmjtAAQCB9n2Q

[3] Interpretation of the Supreme People's Court on Several Issues Concerning the Specific Application of Law in the Trial of Unit Crimes, Fa Shi [1999] No. 14, Article 2

[4] Against the backdrop of the successive promulgation of foundational laws such as the Personal Information Protection Law — Carrying out comprehensive governance of the crime of infringing on citizens' personal information in a targeted manner. Source: Procuratorial Daily - Theory Edition. Author: Chen Lisha. Date: 2023-07-24. https://www.spp.gov.cn//llyj/202307/t20230724_622373.shtml

[5] The Supreme People's Procuratorate releases five typical cases of punishing the crime of infringing on citizens' personal information in accordance with law_ Supreme People's Procuratorate of the People's Republic of China https://www.spp.gov.cn//xwfbh/wsfbt/202212/t20221207_594915.shtml#2

[6] The Ministry of Public Security announces ten typical cases https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/J2WXuUKFAIeoqwi-ZGIxvQ

[7] A new mobile phone came down with a full set of "old ailments," and the prosecutors stepped in... https://sghexport.shobserver.com/html/baijiahao/2023/05/03/1019115.html

[8] "AI face-swapping" is used at will, and you too could become the next victim... https://baijiahao.baidu.com/s?id=1775001398856045620&wfr=spider&for=pc

[9] Homeowners' property listing information must not be sold at will https://baijiahao.baidu.com/s?id=1738738691361666197&wfr=spider&for=pc

[10] The Ministry of Public Security holds a press conference to report on the results of combating the illegal and criminal acts of infringing on citizens' personal information  https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/E-