Special Statement: This article is an original article by Attorney Shao Shiwei and represents only the personal views of the author. It does not constitute legal consultation or legal advice on any specific matter. For article reprinting | legal consultation | business exchange, please add: sswls66
Introduction:
01
Is a live-stream giveaway gambling or a lawful prize promotion?
Even before Douyu CEO Chen Shaojie was arrested on suspicion of the crime of operating a gambling establishment, news reports kept emerging that Douyu streamers were using the platform's live-stream giveaway rules to conduct gambling activities. Examples include the Douyu streamer "Shanshanjiu Huwai," who was sentenced by the Dujiangyan City Court in December 2022, and the "Changsha Rural Suicide Squad," once described by the media as "Douyu's largest casino."
In a case announced by the Jinzhou police on November 29, 2023, a certain "PUBG" game streamer was arrested on suspicion of operating a gambling establishment. According to police reports: from 2019 to 2022, in order to boost the popularity of his live-streaming channel and increase his income, Zhou introduced the live-stream giveaway module to viewers in his live-streaming channel and implemented gambling gameplay. After the games ended, he gave rebates to the winners. Investigation found that Zhou and others used a certain live-streaming platform to organize more than 5,000 gambling activities, with cumulative gambling funds of more than 17 million and illegal profits of more than 2660 thousand. If these facts are true, the circumstances of the streamer involved in this case may be broadly similar to those in the case of the Douyu streamer Shanshanjiu Huwai, who was previously sentenced to six years in prison by the Dujiangyan City Court, because they all conducted live-stream giveaway activities in their live-streaming channels.
So, when online live-streaming is used to conductlive-stream giveawaysactivities, is it lawful?
Previously, the Douyu platform publicly stated that live-stream giveaway activities are not gambling but prize promotions, and that as long as the giveaway amount does not exceed 50,000, they are neither illegal nor non-compliant.
So does this statement by the platform have any legal basis?
Article 10, Paragraph 3 of the Anti-Unfair Competition Law
provides that in conducting prize promotions, business operators must not engage in the following circumstances: "... (3) prize-based sales promotions in which the amount of the highest prize exceeds 50,000 yuan."
This appears to show that the platform's position has a legal basis,So what is a prize-giving sales promotion?It has two characteristics:
1. The prize in a prize-giving sales promotion is ancillary and is attached to the goods sold by the merchant;
2. The reward is the means, and selling goods is the purpose; the means serves the purpose, and the relationship must not be inverted.
What, then, is the gameplay of the live-stream lottery on the Douyu platform?It involves users invited into the live-stream room making a small payment by spending money to "open a card" to participate in the lottery. If a fan wins, the streamer will privately transfer to the winning viewer, through a payment platform, cash in an amount equal to the virtual currency. From this gameplay model, we can identify several characteristics:
1. The most obvious characteristic: drawing lots for the sake of drawing lots; what is sold is the "chance to win" itself;
2. It has the nature of risking a small amount to win a large amount; users need only pay a few yuan to enter the lottery and may win a large prize.
By comparing live-stream lotteries with the characteristics of "prize-giving sales" in the concept under the Anti-Unfair Competition Law, we can see that,why do live-stream lotteries involve suspected gambling?
Having users spend money to "open a card" is the streamer's sales revenue. The lottery activity itself is simply a game of risking a small amount of money to win a large amount. The streamer's profit is the difference between the money users spend to open cards and the amounts paid out to winning users, and this is also the sole purpose for which the streamer holds the lottery activity. Such activities are not attached to any product or service carrier.
The consumer conduct of risking a small amount to win a large amount is similar to a lottery, but it is obvious that users do not consider themselves to be purchasing lottery tickets, and the platform also does not hold the qualifications or licenses related to operating a lottery.
After the previous arrest of Chen Shaojie, Chairman of the Board and CEO of Douyu, many streamers suspended their broadcasts.
02
When a streamer is convicted of the crime of running a casino, under what circumstances is the platform also liable?
In fact, it is not only Douyu; cases in which streamers on other platforms have been convicted of the crime of running a casino are not uncommon, for example:
On August 4, 2022, because someone reported that he had recruited people to gather for gambling through game livestreaming in his livestream room, Chen was prosecuted by the Yanshi District People's Procuratorate of Luoyang and sentenced to six years' imprisonment [1];
In August 2023, after prosecution by the Haishu District People's Procuratorate, a sports event streamer on a certain livestreaming platform, who had promoted online gambling platforms in the livestream room and induced fans to participate in gambling, was sentenced by the court to two years' fixed-term imprisonment for the crime of running a casino [2].
On November 8, 2023, because streamer Ding and two others actively induced gamblers in the livestream room to send gifts and place bets for online gambling, the Yuzhou City People's Court sentenced the defendants at first instance for the crime of running a casino [3].
So, if a streamer is sentenced, can the platform remain "unscathed"?
1. Why do platforms face criminal risk?
If the platform argues that,"The platform is merely the carrier itself; the streamer's involvement in a crime is his own conduct and has nothing to do with the platform,"this is similar to a user using chat software such as WeChat or QQ when communicating with others to achieve his fraud purposes; the chat software itself, as the platform, would not be suspected of a crime. Another example: if a tenant consumes drugs in a room, the landlord does not necessarily constitute the crime of providing shelter for others to consume drugs.
Is such an interpretation meaningful? The answer is no.
The two examples of chat software and leased housing share one common feature:privacyIn other words, chat software itself does not proactively obtain and monitor all chat content between users; and, under ordinary circumstances, a landlord will not know what a tenant does inside the leased premises.
Live-streaming platforms, however, are exactly the opposite: their very existence is to be seen by a broad user base. Only with more traffic can a platform directly or indirectly obtain revenue through various means.
In fact, when analyzed from the perspective of the characteristics of the crime of operating a gambling establishment, live-streaming platforms possess a natural advantage that makes them highly prone to forming an online gambling establishment.
First, the commercial or operational nature.Operators of gambling establishments act for profit-making purposes and therefore regularly and continuously organize gambling activities.
Second, the public nature.Gambling activities are open to an unspecified audience.
Finally, the liquidity of gambling funds.Only where large amounts of gambling funds flow in and out can organizers take a cut and profit therefrom.
The operation of live-streaming platforms is for-profit and open to the unspecified general public. Gambling activities packaged in the guise of lucky draws will attract large numbers of users to top up and participate.
2. In which circumstances is a platform at high risk of criminal exposure?
We take the Douyu platform and its related streamers as examples to analyze the circumstances in which a platform is at high risk of criminal exposure.
(1) Examining the platform's degree of participation
For gameplay such as live-stream lucky draws, if the relevant game rules are set by the streamer, the streamer also has control over the configuration of the lucky draw system, the activity is conducted only in the streamer's own live-streaming room, and whether to carry out the reverse redemption described in point 2 below is also the streamer's personal decision, then it may be determined to be the streamer's personal conduct, and the platform is merely a vehicle chosen by the streamer.
In 2019, Douyu, in its capacity as the official platform, launched the "Lucky Treasure" lucky draw campaign. Due to the gambling-related risks, the platform subsequently took the campaign offline. However, the "card-purchase lucky draws" on the platform did not end there; Sansanjiu Outdoor, Changsha Rural Suicide Squad and others were similar forms of gameplay.
According to a report by Yema Caijing [4], although the gambling-related activities in live-streaming rooms such as Sansanjiu were not officially organized by Douyu, the platform was not entirely unaware and would even provide internal guidance, giving detailed instructions on streamers' lucky draw scripts. If true, the platform closely participated in the streamers' gambling-related activities.
(2) Examining whether the platform provided assistance in the reverse redemption of game coins
"Reverse redemption", as compared with users topping up money into the platform, refers to virtual coins/items obtained by users on the platform being converted back into cash.
Probability-based gameplay such as lucky draws is not itself unlawful and is a normal commercial promotion method. A key reason for determining that gambling is involved is the reverse redemption of game coins.
In the "card-purchase lucky draws" conducted by Douyu streamers in their live-streaming rooms, users need only spend a few yuan to purchase designated items in order to participate in lucky draws for tens of thousands of yuan in virtual coins. After a user wins, the streamer pays the prize money to the user through third-party channels such as Alipay or "backpack merchants." This appears to be the streamer's personal conduct, but according to various public media reports, the streamer "Changsha Rural Suicide Squad" had annual transaction volume as high as 177 million, "Sansanjiu Outdoor" had transaction volume of approximately 120 million over three years, and a certain "PUBG" game streamer arrested as announced by the Jinzhou Public Security Bureau on November 29 was involved in transaction volume of 17 million. If the platform had provided no assistance or support, it is difficult to imagine how the streamers could have redeemed the prizes with users one by one.
Although the platform officially states that "the gift props in this interactive feature cannot be reverse-exchanged into cash, fish fins, or other items of value; the Douyu platform prohibits and strictly combats any form of offline trading," users can sell the fish fins they obtain to fish-fin recyclers through other channels. This achieves the reverse exchange of virtual props for fiat currency.
(3) Whether the platform profits therefrom
The turnover in streamers' live-streaming rooms is directly linked to the platform's profitability. The virtual props that users contribute to live-streaming rooms must be shared according to the platform's rules. According to a report by Yema Caijing [5], Douyu streamers have high-stakes performance betting agreements with the platform, and under enormous turnover pressure, lotteries have become the best solution to streamers' anxiety over these bets.
3. If the platform is involved in criminal activity, what are the relevant charges?
Since the platform's revenue is directly tied to the turnover in streamers' live-streaming rooms, it is impossible for the platform not to know what activities streamers use in their live-streaming rooms to continuously generate enormous turnover.
Streamers and the platform are unquestionably a community of shared interests. Only if the platform knows that streamers' live-streaming rooms involve gambling but acquiesces to it can these streamers continuously hold card-purchase lottery activities for years.
If the platform is involved in criminal activity, what are the relevant charges?
(1) The crime of operating a casino
Based on the analysis in point 2 above, if the platform, while knowing that streamers are engaged in gambling-related conduct, commits any of the following acts, the relevant personnel face a relatively high risk of constituting the crime of operating a casino:
For example: participating in the formulation of game rules and providing guidance and assistance to streamers' live-streaming conduct;
the lottery uses the platform's system, and streamers have no control over the lottery system;
providing direct or indirect channels for reverse exchange into cash for gambling-related streamers;
Taking a cut of profits from gambling-related livestreaming activities.
(2) Joint commission of the crime of operating a casino
Unlike the foregoing, where relevant platform personnel constitute accomplices, this is premised on the streamers constituting the crime of operating a casino; the platform provides assistance and itself fails to diligently perform its relevant regulatory duties.
For example, knowingly tolerating or acquiescing in gambling-related activities organized by the relevant streamers;
providing relevant technical support for such gambling-related activities;
providing traffic support, advertising placement and platform endorsement for such gambling-related activities.
(3) Money-laundering-type crimes, such as the crime of assisting information network criminal activities and the crime of concealing or disguising criminal proceeds
If the platform does not subjectively know of the gambling-related activities and does not share in the profits, but is merely used by the relevant streamers as an online vehicle through which gambling-related conduct is carried out, and the funds recharged by users involve other upstream criminal conduct, the platform may be suspected of money-laundering-type crimes such as the crime of assisting information network criminal activities and the crime of concealing or disguising criminal proceeds.
03
What are the legal risks for livestreaming guilds when gambling is involved in livestream rooms?
Livestreaming platforms, streamers and livestreaming guilds are several basic entities in the online livestreaming industry. They may have various different models of cooperation, and the complex legal relationships and flows of interests among these entities determine thatif a streamer or platform is involved in gambling, it is very difficult for a livestreaming guild to "stay out of it."
1、What kind of entity is a livestreaming guild?
Before analyzing the legal risks of live-streaming guilds, we must first understand: what does a live-streaming guild do, and what is the relationship between a live-streaming guild, streamers, and live-streaming platforms?
To use a simple analogy, the normal operation of a shopping mall requires merchants to move in and open stores, and the stores need to recruit sales staff to sell goods. By analogy to the online live-streaming ecosystem, the live-streaming platform is like the shopping mall, each live-streaming room is equivalent to a store, and the streamer is the store's salesperson, selling virtual goods to internet users; the store's revenue depends on internet users' tips to the streamer, gifts, and other live-streaming room activities that require users to spend virtual coins/virtual items. The mall may not have the capacity to manage every salesperson, so guilds emerged, acting as the store merchants and managing each salesperson (streamer).
From the perspective of civil legal relationships, the three parties may form labor contracts, service contracts, brokerage contracts, service agreements, and the like, and the three parties may also adopt different types of cooperation models. A streamer may sign directly with the live-streaming platform or may choose to sign with a live-streaming guild; the live-streaming guild may be a third-party entity or may be directly invested in and held by the live-streaming platform; there are also complex interest relationships among the live-streaming platform's actual controller, the streamers, and the guild's actual controller. For example, Chengdu Jiutu Culture Media Co., Ltd. is a live-streaming guild on the Douyu platform; Fu Hailong, a member of its most famous streamer group "Shanshanjiu Outdoor," is the largest shareholder of that guild, and the Douyu platform has also taken an equity stake in the live-streaming guild.
This article takes the cooperation model in which a guild moves into a live-streaming platform and streamers sign with the live-streaming guild as an example to analyze: if a live-streaming room involves gambling, what are the legal risks for the live-streaming guild?
2. If a live-streaming room involves gambling, does the guild bear criminal liability?
If a live-streaming room hosts probability-based games such as live-streaming lotteries, treasure chest openings, or blind box openings, it is very difficult for the live-streaming guild to use lack of knowledge as a defense. After all, the guild has management responsibilities over the streamers, and the guild's main income is its share of the gift revenue from the live-streaming room with the streamers.
Regarding the settlement method for commission sharing, we can refer to the relevant signing rules of platforms such as Huya and Douyu. For example, according to the Huya Guild Signing Rules, Huya Company shares commission revenue according to the sharing ratio agreed upon by the streamer and the guild on the Huya platform; the streamer's live-streaming revenue is settled to the guild's account, and the guild withdraws it and uniformly withholds taxes on the streamer's behalf before distributing it to the streamer. According to the Douyu Guild Onboarding Agreement, the guild shall pay to the streamer the fees paid by the Douyu platform to the guild according to the sharing ratio agreed upon between the guild and its streamers.
Therefore, the usual settlement method for a streamer's revenue is that the platform first pays it to the corporate account of the contracting guild, and the guild then uniformly withholds taxes on the streamer's behalf before paying it to the streamer.
The composition and calculation method of commissions include gifts, items, various activities, advertising revenue, and so on. When the guild settles according to the ratio agreed upon with the streamer, it necessarily knows the composition of each commission payment to the streamer. Probability-based game formats that offer small stakes for large returns do not require the rule-makers to expend much mental effort and inherently attract huge traffic. Traffic brings users, and more users bring more revenue. Clearly abnormal transaction volumes will also make it "impossible" for the guild not to know what the streamers in the live-streaming room are doing.
So what is the situation in judicial practice?
In a judgment issued by the Guangdong Tianhe District Court in September 2020 [6], Zhao, in the name of a company, signed a cooperation agreement with a certain company. Zhao established the "Midi Guild" on the NetEase CC voice platform, served as the guild's person in charge, and recruited multiple streamers to organize gambling in interactive game rooms and launch video-interactive and card-interactive guessing activities, attracting players to bet virtual coins; the system then automatically settled wins and losses based on the guessing results. The guild and the streamers could both take a cut from the virtual coins players bet or tipped according to the agreed ratio, and the NetEase backend settled the amount into RMB, thereby taking a rake. According to the audit, the gambling funds amounted to more than 22 million yuan. Zhao, asthe guild's person in charge,was convicted of the crime of operating a gambling establishment and sentenced to a fixed-term imprisonment of four years and six months[7]; others also sentenced includedthe guild's finance staff, streamers, and personnel involved in cashing out virtual currencies.
In October 2022, the Ningyang police announced a case[8]: voice live-streaming game apps such as the "XX Planet" APP, under the guise of live-streaming tipping, embedded gambling mini-games such as "opening treasure chests," "blowing bubbles," and "interstellar travel." The police dismantled 2 gambling-related APP platforms and 3 gambling-related live-streaming guilds, and in one operation arrested back-end bosses, operations staff, technical staff,guild leaders, and streamers.
It can thus be seen thatfor gambling in live-streaming rooms, live-streaming guilds clearly face higher risk than platform operators.Under PRC criminal law, where the amount of gambling funds reaches 300 thousand or more, the threshold for serious circumstances of the crime of operating a gambling establishment is met, and a fixed-term imprisonment of 5 to 10 years may be imposed. For live-streaming rooms with enormous traffic, an amount of 300 thousand may be reached in just one live-streaming event.
3. When a platform is taken down for gambling, how can live-streaming guilds protect their rights?
When a live-streaming platform is taken down for gambling, if the guild and its streamers participated in probability-based game features such as lottery activities organized by the platform, criminal liability is difficult to avoid. However, if the guild and its streamers did not participate, they may still be implicated.
The most common type of rights protection involves the platform failing to settle commissions owed to the live-streaming guild.If a platform is taken down for gambling, the platform's fund accounts will be frozen by the police as gambling funds. However, not all of the funds therein are gambling-related funds. The lawful income of live-streaming guilds and streamers that did not participate in gambling activities may, due to the criminal case, no longer be settled by the platform to the guild.
In such a situation, two options are recommended: first, initiate civil litigation to fix the amounts payable in the form of a civil judgment; second, provide the judicial authorities handling the criminal case with written evidence such as cooperation contracts and a statement of circumstances, explaining that the relevant funds in the platform account are the party's lawful income. However, whichever option is chosen, the path to protecting rights is long.
04
Final Thoughts
In practice, it is common for streamers to be investigated by the police because a livestream room is involved in gambling, andguilds, as the entities most closely associated with streamers, are highly susceptible to being implicated.Therefore, persons in charge of livestreaming guilds must not adopt a mindset of "leaning on a big tree for shade," mistakenly believing that cooperating with a large online livestreaming platform will reduce their own risk. Guilds themselves must strengthen their management of streamers and eliminate all gambling-related activities in order to achieve more long-term development.
Except where a livestreaming platform is packaged as a legitimate platform but is in substance a gambling platform engaged solely in online gambling activities, generally a large online livestreaming platform will not have its persons in charge face joint criminal liability merely because some livestream rooms are involved in gambling.
To avoid platform risk arising from streamers' gambling-related conduct, the platform itself must strengthen its compliance framework, for example: improving the platform's risk management mechanisms, resolutely eliminating gambling, cash-out and similar conduct, and imposing penalties such as muting and account bans on relevant streamers and users once discovered; improving the platform's supervision and reporting mechanisms so that abnormal transaction flows and abnormal activities on the platform can be identified at the earliest opportunity and promptly tracked and handled; and the platform itself not providing, nor providing in disguised form, any reverse exchange services between virtual currency/virtual items and RMB, among other measures.

[1] http://www.hebi.jcy.gov.cn/yasf/202307/t20230713_5831457.shtml
Recommended Reading


