Special Notice: This article is an original article by Attorney Shao Shiwei and represents only the author's personal views. It does not constitute legal consultation or legal advice on any specific matter. For article reprints | legal consultation | business exchanges, please add: sswls66
Introduction:
Most U merchants do not intend to violate the law when engaging in arbitrage trading, so why is the criminal risk for U merchants so high?
Some U merchants with basic legal risk-management awareness assess their own risk through KYC review of counterparties when transacting with them, and must guard not only against the possibility of frozen cards but also against criminal risks such as the crime of assisting information network criminal activities, the crime of concealing or disguising criminal proceeds, and the crime of illegal business operations.But sometimes, it is truly impossible to guard against.
Virtual currency serves different purposes in different people's eyes. Some use it to earn profits from the price difference between buying and selling, while others merely treat it as a tool for illegal and criminal activities. When these two groups come together, a peculiar chemical reaction occurs.
For legal analysis related to the crime of assisting information network criminal activities and the crime of concealing or disguising criminal proceeds, please refer to 👉🏻👉🏻👉🏻"A Comprehensive Review: Criminal Charges That May Be Involved in Providing Accounts to Help Others Transfer Funds》《Case Analysis | The Tricks and Traps of the Crime of Assisting Information Network Criminal Activities》《Can the Crime of Concealing or Disguising Criminal Proceeds Be Reclassified as the Crime of Assisting Information Network Criminal Activities? Which Carries a Lighter Sentence?". Today we will mainly discuss how U merchants' transactions are characterized as "disguised foreign exchange trading”, involving
suspectedillegal business operationsrelated legal issues.
Author of this article: Lawyer Shao Shiwei
01
Lawyer Shao Tells Stories
*Special disclaimer: This story is purely fictional. Any resemblance to actual events is... well, quite normal.
1, from the perspective of a U trader [Above the Iceberg]
One day, a client said they wanted to buy U. A was delighted, thinking: Great, another order! Day after day, wealth is bound to follow! The two parties exchanged U for ¥ hand to hand and happily completed the transaction.
Which businessperson doesn't want repeat customers? As this transaction was completed, A also looked forward to the client coming back next time, satisfied with A's high-quality, efficient, lightning-fast transaction service.
Sure enough, the client was very satisfied. As the trust relationship between the two parties accumulated, transactions became more and more frequent, and the transaction amounts grew larger and larger.
One day, A transferred a very large amount of U to the client (this order was larger than all previous transactions between the two parties combined!), but did not receive the client's payment, because the client became unreachable...
Unable to find anyone, A could only wait in regret, thinking that this side business had cost A all the money earned from A's main job.
A few days later, early in the morning, the police suddenly came to the door to arrest A, presented the relevant credentials, and said that A was suspected of constituting the crime of illegal business operations; thus, in full view of the neighbors, A was taken away...
Because A had previously read many articles by Lawyer Shao, A knew that one absolutely must not help others engage in foreign exchange arbitrage through buying and selling virtual assets, and A had never personally engaged in foreign currency trading, always adhering to the one-way transaction principle between RMB and USDT—one could say A was extremely cautious.
But what was the actual situation?
2, full-case perspective [below the iceberg]
*The actual situation would be more complex than the diagram; to explain it simply and clearly, the diagram has been greatly simplified.
Client B in the above diagram was in fact a subordinate of a big boss running an underground bank. To simplify the chain, let us temporarily center the story on B.
B controlled a large number of domestic and overseas clients with foreign exchange needs and earned the price difference through foreign exchange "matched trades" (duiqiao), doing extremely large business. How did B help clients exchange RMB and foreign currency? Virtual assets were a good thing!
(1) Exchanging foreign currency into RMB for clients abroad
B received the $ of an overseas client (the "father"), transferred it to USDT dealer A1, obtained USDT from USDT dealer A1, then transferred it to USDT dealer A, obtained ¥ from USDT dealer A, and transferred the ¥ to a domestic person designated by the overseas client.
(2) Exchanging RMB into foreign currency for clients in China
B received the ¥ of a domestic client (the "father"), transferred it to USDT dealer A, obtained USDT from USDT dealer A, then transferred it to USDT dealer A1, obtained $ from USDT dealer A1, and transferred the $ to an overseas person designated by the domestic client.
Summary:
It follows that the wool comes from the sheep's back: the spread earned by the USDT traders is the very wool that the underground banks fleece from their deep-pocketed patrons!
02
Attorney Shao's Legal Analysis
In fact, the images above make it clear at a glance, and I think astute readers will already have grasped instantly why A is suspected of the crime of illegal business operations.
In A's eyes, he was merely engaging in one-way transactions with B; buying and selling virtual currency is not illegal in our country, and friends around him have worked as USDT traders for many years without anyone he knows being arrested, so in A's view this was an extremely ordinary and normal transaction.
But B is a landmine. As long as there is a transaction with B for even one day, one must be constantly prepared to be blown up at any moment...
A's likely plain understanding is: you do your business, I do mine, and I just need to manage myself well. [So it must be said, this line of work is truly not suited to honest people; to do it, one mustBe 800 times more vigilant + make a lawyer friendfriend】
So let us still briefly analyze:
Everything stated above concerns A being suspected of the crime of illegal business operations; it does not mean that this conduct by A is already beyond dispute as constituting a crime.
Whether A can be convicted hinges on whether he subjectively knew that B was exchanging foreign currency for others.
1. A was completely unaware and bears no criminal liability; everyone is happy with that outcome.
2. A clearly knew what business B was engaged in, and A and B constitute joint crimes.
3. A was also curious why B had such a large daily demand for buying and selling USDT. A asked B, but B answered vaguely, and A's slow mind could not figure it out. A's wife also told A: just do your own thing and do not concern yourself with others. A is suspected of the crime of assisting information network criminal activities, the crime of concealing or disguising criminal proceeds, or the crime of illegal business operations, among others.
However! All of the above requires evidence in the case file, transaction records, and witness testimony to substantiate. It cannot simply be understood as: if I say I was unaware, the police will determine that I was unaware. It is also possible that the public security authorities have already obtained relevant evidence and are waiting for you to make a truthful statement. The consequence of persistently insisting on a claim of unawareness may be a heavier sentence...
Therefore,when you are confused, you may wish to trust that professionals can give you the best assessment of the current situation and assist you in making the most advantageous choice.
03
Lawyer Shao's reminder
Finally, one sentence for friends who work as USDT traders:Never trust your counterparty; what you see is always only the tip of the iceberg.。

Recommended Reading
Is over-the-counter (OTC) trading of digital currency a crime?
Is buying and selling USDT (Tether) illegal? These days, being a U trader is really tough!
Defrauded when transferring USDT — how can USDT worth 40 million be recovered?
A quick guide: potential criminal charges for providing an account to help others transfer money


