Special Statement: This article is an original work by Lawyer Shao Shiwei and represents only the personal views of the author. It does not constitute legal consultation or legal advice on any specific matter. For article reprints | legal consultation | business exchanges, please contact: sswls66
Xiao Li has always been interested in investment and wealth management and has joined several virtual currency investment communities. Many so-called "signal-calling teachers" in the groups share their trading strategies. At first, Xiao Li merely followed along and learned, and he himself made quite a bit of money through crypto trading and playing contracts.
After making money, Xiao Li believed he had fully figured out the market. He began frequently posting his investment returns in the groups and quickly gained the trust of many people. At the same time, he learned that "signal-calling" could allow participation in investment profit-sharing with considerable profits, so he decided to become a "signal-calling teacher" himself. Signal-calling teachers in the communities generally share crypto industry news and market conditions with users in WeChat groups and Telegram groups, while adding interested investment users as friends.
Xiao Li also imitated the practices of other "signal-calling teachers," sharing market news and information on platforms such as WeChat groups and Xiaohongshu, adding interested investment users as friends, and directly accepting user funds for operations, with a total amount of several million yuan. Xiao Li and the users agreed that: a 10% monthly rebate of returns would be given to users, and users would pay Xiao Li a certain percentage as remuneration.
At first, Xiao Li led the users to make some money, and his confidence gradually increased; he then began trying high-risk trades. As a result, a single liquidation caused almost all of the users' funds to be lost. To maintain the users' trust, Xiao Li chose to use funds from newly joined users to pay returns to old clients. This "robbing Peter to pay Paul" approach could not be sustained, and news of the losses spread in the groups. A large number of users began accusing Xiao Li of being a fraudster and said they would report the matter collectively, hoping the police would intervene and investigate and bring him to justice.
While Xiao Li was afraid, he also felt wronged: he had previously led everyone to make money, and this loss was caused by market fluctuations. Because the amount of funds was too large, he could not come up with enough money in a short time to compensate everyone's losses. Xiao Li's concern is: he had previously promised users a rate of return; if users report to the police claiming that he had made a principal-guarantee promise, what criminal legal risks would he face?
So, as a signal-calling teacher, is recruiting people to speculate in crypto and play contracts suspected of being a crime? Which specific charges are involved? Next, based on Xiao Li's situation, we will sort out the criminal risks that this type of "signal-calling" model may involve.
I Author: Shao Shiwei Lawyer Team
1、Crime of illegally absorbing public deposits
In Xiao Li's signal-calling model, he, throughpromising a monthly rebate of 10% and directly collecting user funds, even if the loss is from normal investment, after users report to the police, he may still be deemed by the police to be suspected of the crime of illegally absorbing public deposits. The risk points are: Xiao Li promised users principal and interest, and repeatedly and frequently sent screenshots of his own profits to the community.
The four characteristics of the crime of illegally absorbing public deposits are illegality, openness, sociality and inducement. If an actor's conduct meets these four characteristics and the scale of funds reaches a certain amount, it will be determined to constitute the crime of illegally absorbing public deposits.
-
Illegality: without lawful permission from the financial management department of the State Council or in violation of the State's financial management regulations;
-
Openness: through public means such as the internet, television stations and on-site promotion;
-
Sociality: absorbing funds from the general public, that is, from unspecified members of society;
-
Inducement: promising high returns, publicizing that the coin will only rise and never fall, a stable annualized rate of return, repayment of principal or equivalent tokens within a certain period, promises of compound returns, stable dividend income, and so on.
Without lawful qualifications, Xiao Li frequently posted screenshots of his earnings in community groups and publicly promised "monthly rebates", attracting others to transfer money directly to him for investment, which meets the four characteristics of the crime of illegally absorbing public deposits.
[Reference to Similar Cases]
In the case of Wang Mou for illegally absorbing public deposits [Case No.: (2021) Xin 4002 Xing Chu No. 124], Wang Mou, without approval,promoted high-return projects such as "Yingtai virtual shares," "CCL virtual currency" and "Poly Capital" to the general public, and throughmeetings, text messages and other means attracted investment, with a total of 29 persons investing approximately 4940 thousand.
The court found that the unlawful, public, social and inducement characteristics were evident, constituting the crime of illegally absorbing public deposits,and sentenced him to 5 years and 6 months of fixed-term imprisonment。
Xiao Li also engaged in another high-risk act that may constitute the crime of fund-raising fraud: he never dared to tell users the truth and continuously used funds absorbed from new users to repay the returns of old clients; such a practice of robbing Peter to pay Paul may be found to involve an "intent to illegally possess."
The crime of fund-raising fraud has two constitutive elements: first, the purpose of illegal possession; second, the use of fraudulent methods to illegally raise funds. Although Xiao Li knew the funds had already suffered losses, he falsely claimed the project was operating normally and continued to collect funds from new investors, using them to pay rebates to old investors; such conduct is readily understood by judicial authorities as involving an "intent to illegally possess" and carries extremely high risk.
The crime of fund-raising fraud and the crime of illegally absorbing public deposits share many similarities,and the core distinction is whether the persons involved had an "intent to illegally possess."
Under the laws of our country,The penalties for the two offenses also differ. Because the crime of fund-raising fraud involves conduct of absconding with the funds, the harm to investorsis greaterand the social impact is more egregious; therefore,the threshold for criminal case filingis lower and the punishment is more severe.。
[Reference to Similar Cases]
In the Chen XX fund-raising fraud case [Case No.: (2025) Wan 16 Criminal Final 12], Chen Xuwei and others established shell companies and, under the guise of "virtual currency investment" and "equity appreciation," promised users an "expected monthly return of 10% or more." In reality, the investment projects were loss-making, and returns to earlier investors were paid mainly out of new funds.
The court held that Chen XX and othersrepaid investors' principal and interest mainly by absorbing new investment funds, so that objectively there was no possibility of repaying investors' principal and interest,and they evaded returning the funds; Chen XX should therefore be found to have had a subjective intent of illegal possession, and his conduct met the constitutive elements of the crime of fund-raising fraud. He was sentenced to 9 years and 6 months of fixed-term imprisonment.。
3、Fraud
Most users lack professional legal knowledge and, when reporting a case, will say, "I was scammed." Although Xiao Li's conduct would generally not be characterized as suspected fraud, fraud is indeed an offense that occurs with relatively high frequency in judicial practice involving virtual assets and lead traders.
The core features of fraud are that the perpetrator has the purpose of illegal possession, carries out acts of fabricating facts or concealing the truth, and causes the victim to dispose of property based on a mistaken understanding. If Xiao Li manipulated the market and created false price movements, then he carried out fraudulent means.
In judicial practice, "lead traders" are often used as key figures to attract traffic and create a sense of trust. At first, they may genuinely let investors make small profits, then induce them to add more investment, and finally manipulate prices through back-end controls to cause a sharp drop, leaving investors with nothing. Courts generally find that the above conduct constitutes fraud.
[Reference to Similar Cases]
For example, in the case of Yang and Zhou et al. [Case No.: (2020) Wan 0603 Xing Chu No. 435], the group used the names of virtual assets such as ICCT, SIT and SDS, and the "lead traders" touted the value and appreciation potential of the virtual assets, claiming they could lead investors to achieve wealth explosion.When the victims' investment amounts reached a certain target set by the criminal group, the group manipulated the virtual assets into a cliff-like decline, creating the appearance of client losses, thereby achieving the purpose of defrauding the victims of their property. The persons involved were sentenced to fixed-term imprisonment ranging from 3 to 6 years respectively.。
4. Attorney Shao's Notes
Under the 924 Notice, no entity or individual may engage in illegal financial activities without approval, including helping others invest in stocks, speculate in crypto assets, trade contracts, and absorbing public funds in disguised forms.
Investing on one's own is a personal act, but once a person brings others in to participate together, operates accounts on behalf of others, or directly receives other people's funds to invest on their behalf, especially where the person promises returns or principal protection to friends or community groups, then it is no longer mere investment. Once others suffer losses and report the matter to the police, the person may face criminal legal risks such as the crime of illegally absorbing public deposits and the crime of fund-raising fraud.

Recommended Reading


