Summary:
If your family member has been listed as a "Red Notice subject" and arrested in Thailand, what you most want to know right now is surely: can we still get in touch with them? How long until they can return? If they return, how severe will the sentence be? This article will explain what a Red Notice actually is, how Thailand will handle the matter, how they could be repatriated in as little as a few weeks, and one crucial opportunity—even if they were arrested and brought back, as long as they voluntarily return to China to stand trial, it may still be possible to be recognized as voluntary surrender and receive a lighter punishment. After reading, you will clearly understand what family members should do right now.

Keywords:
Red Notice, extradition and repatriation, recognition of voluntary surrender, transnational criminal proceedings, how families should respond in criminal cases

Special Statement:This article is an original article by Lawyer Shao Shiwei and represents only the author's personal views. It does not constitute legal consultation or legal advice on any specific matter. To repost the article, seek legal consultation, or communicate with peers, please add: sswls66.

 

Main Text:

As China intensifies its efforts to pursue fugitives abroad and as joint law enforcement cooperation between China and overseas countries becomes increasingly close, more and more fugitives are being arrested and brought back to China.

 

For a family, one day they may see their own family member in the news—he has become a "Red Notice subject."

 

At this point, a series of questions will arise in the family's mind:

  • How is he now? Why was he arrested?

  • What exactly did he do? Was he wronged or implicated by others?

  • Is the case serious? When can the person come back?

 

This article addresses several issues of greatest concern to family members in such cases from the perspective of family members in criminal proceedings.

 

I Author of this article: Lawyer Shao Shiwei

 

 

1

After a family member is listed as a "Red Notice subject" and arrested in Thailand, can the family still get in touchwith them?

 

(1) What exactlyis a "Red Notice"?

 

When family members learn that a relative has been arrested abroad, the first thing they often encounter is a concept: their family member is a "Red Notice subject." So what exactly does Red Notice mean?

 

The full name of the Red Notice is the "Red Notice," one of the five types of international notices issued by INTERPOL among member states, and it is the highest-level and most urgent rapid wanted notice.

 

Its targets are fugitives for whom the judicial authorities of the relevant country have already issued an arrest warrant and have requested member states to assist in extradition.

 

A Red Notice is initiated by the home country and published by INTERPOL. In China, the initiating authority is the "INTERPOL National Central Bureau for China" under the Ministry of Public Security.

 

The process is: the domestic case-handling authority has already opened a case and issued an arrest warrant → the National Central Bureau for China submits an application to INTERPOL headquarters → after review, headquarters publishes it to 194 member states worldwide.

 

(II)How can family members get in contact with their relative?

 

The first questions family members care about most are: what condition the person is in now, why they were detained, what exactly they are alleged to have done, whether they have been wrongly accused, and how serious the case really is, among others.

 

One point here is very different from the domestic judicial system: in some countries and regions, under local law and consular protection arrangements, family members of a person in a criminal case may communicate directly with the person concerned and learn about the case.

 

Taking Thailand as an example, if the person was detained in Thailand, family members may apply for a consular visit through the Chinese embassy or consulate in that country, and with the embassy or consulate's assistance in arranging the meeting, they can learn the specific circumstances of the case directly from the person concerned.

 

The problem, however, is that family members often lack legal knowledge and may not be able to draw out all the key information about the case during the meeting. At the same time, if the person concerned also agrees to be extradited back to China, then the value of engaging a local foreign lawyer to intervene is in fact limited.

 

In such circumstances, it is more advisable to seek the assistance of a domestic criminal lawyer — the lawyer can assist family members in focusing their questions during the meeting on the key issues of the case, rather than merely expressing concern about daily life, so as to form aclearer and more comprehensivejudgment of the case as a whole。

(Image from the internet)

 

 

2

After a Red Notice subject is detained in Thailand, will they be extradited or repatriated?

 

For persons who have fled abroad and been detained, China has a variety of ways of handling the matter.

 

Taking China and Thailand as an example, the two countries have signed an extradition treaty. In August 1993, China and Thailand signed a bilateral extradition treaty, but extradition proceedings are usually rather lengthy.

 

In addition to extradition, there are also alternative measures such as deportation (that is, using grounds such as the individual's visa overstay or illegal residence in Thailand, with the Thai side expelling the person from the country and the Chinese police receiving the person at the airport), as well as a hybrid model of "persuasion to return plus escorted repatriation."

 

As for the extradition route, the usual process is as follows:

The individual is first apprehended on the basis of an International Criminal Police Organization "Red Notice" or a provisional arrest request received by the Thai side. After arrest, the first step is generally a medical examination and admission registration, after which the person is usually held in a facility specially designated for persons in pretrial detention, such as Bangkok Remand Prison, pending subsequent judicial proceedings.


Next, the Office of the Attorney General of Thailand (as the country's "central authority" for extradition matters) initiates the judicial process: after reviewing whether the Chinese request complies with the requirements of the China-Thailand Extradition Treaty and Thailand's Extradition Act, the Attorney General submits an application to the Thai Criminal Court, and the court conducts a review hearing on whether the conditions for extradition are met.

 

It should be noted that Thai law itself requires the court to hear the case continuously and without delay, but owing to factors such as the complexity of the individual case and whether the person has retained counsel to contest the matter, in practice this stage often lasts anywhere from several weeks to several months, and may thereafter be followed by appeal and by a stage in which the Thai government (the executive branch) makes the final decision.

 

If, upon court review — under Thailand's Extradition Act, the review examines whether the principle of dual criminality is satisfied, whether the offense is a political or military offense, whether there exist other circumstances under that Act warranting refusal of extradition, and so on.

 

Generally speaking,the final outcomeis usually extradition back to China to stand trial.

 

One point needs to be explained further here, as it is easily misunderstood and may be a concern for family members:

 

The Thai police detain persons subject to a Red Notice on the basis of the International Criminal Police Organization "Red Notice" and Thai immigration law (such as visa overstay or illegal status), and not because the person's criminal conduct in China itself violates Thai criminal law.

 

For acts committed by the individual in China, Thailand does not have criminal jurisdiction (unless the criminal act itself occurred within Thai territory).

 

Therefore, what a Thai court hears is only the extradition proceedings concerning whether the conditions for extradition are met, or the immigration court proceedings concerning whether the individual should be repatriated; it will not hold a trial on the crimes committed by the individual in China.

 

In other words, the ultimate purpose of the Thai judicial proceedings is “to send the person out of the country”, rather than to directly convict and sentence the individual.

(Image from the internet)

 

 

3

After a Red Notice subject is arrested in Thailand, how long will it take before the person is sent back to China?

 

The question many family members care about most is actually: after a Red Notice subject is arrested in Thailand, will the person be repatriated to China immediately? Or will there be lengthy extradition proceedings?

 

This timeframe can vary greatly depending on the manner of return to China and the differences among individual cases.

 

For example, in practice, some individuals, in order to evade arrest and avoid investigation, will enter a third country in a lawful form such as tourism by applying for citizenship of another country. For instance, they obtain a Vanuatu passport and flee to Thailand under the pretext of tourism to stay there.

 

In such circumstances, because their entry was lawful, the Thai authorities often find it difficult to repatriate them directly on grounds such as illegal residence, and thus the lengthy extradition proceedings are more likely to be pursued.

 

We can refer to two past cases:

 

Path One: Standard Extradition Proceedings

 

From the time the individual is taken into custody until the Thai court conducts its review under Thailand's domestic extradition law, during which the individual may also retain Thai counsel to mount a defense and appeal, the entire process often takes years. For specific reference:

 

  • The Zhang Yufa case (MBI pyramid scheme)

 

Lawyer Shao previously provided a dedicated introduction to this case; those interested may refer to ➡️ "Virtual currency involved in a pyramid scheme: in what circumstances is it not a crime?》《Can fleeing abroad or changing nationality evade criminal sanctions?》

 

From being arrested in Thailand to being extradited back to China, it tookmore than two yearsof time:

 

In November 2020, the Chongqing police, in accordance with the law, opened an investigation into Zhang Yufa. In March of the following year, the China National Central Bureau of INTERPOL issued a Red Notice against him. On July 21, 2022, the Thai police apprehended Zhang Yufa. Subsequently, the Chinese side submitted an extradition request to the Thai side. On May 21, 2024, the Thai Court of Appeal issued a final ruling to extradite Zhang Yufa to China, and on August 14, 2024, the Thai government made an administrative decision supporting the court's aforementioned ruling. On August 20, 2024, the working group of the Ministry of Public Security's "Fox Hunt" operation successfully extradited Zhang XX, a major economic crime suspect suspected of the crime of organizing and leading pyramid scheme activities, from Thailand back to China. This case is the first economic crime suspect extradited from Thailand to China since the China-Thailand Extradition Treaty came into effect in 1999.

 

Path Two: Deportation under Immigration Law

 

If the individual has an expired visa in Thailand, is residing illegally, holds a false passport, or is determined to be a "threat to Thailand's national security," the Thai Immigration Bureau may directly deport the person under immigration law.

 

This route: no Thai court review of extradition conditions is required, no dual criminality review is required, and the party has very little room to mount a defense. In practice, from capture to boarding, at the fastest it may take onlya few weeksto complete.

 

  • The Zhu Dawei case (crime of on-lending at high interest)

 

In July 2022, when Zhu Dawei flew from Laos into Thailand, he was detained by Thai police on account of his "Red Notice" status and was escorted back to China on July 25, 2022. On September 20 of the same year, the case was transferred to the Longgang City People's Procuratorate of Zhejiang Province for review and prosecution.

 

From being detained upon entry to being escorted back to China took only a few dozen days—such a pace is possible only through immigration-law processing.

 

 

4

Will persons subject to a Red Notice be sentenced more severely after being repatriated?

Many people mistakenly assume that once listed on a "Red Notice," a person will inevitably receive a heavy sentence upon returning to China.

 

This is in fact a misconception among family members.

 

The status of being a "Red Notice subject" does not in itself directly lead to a heavier sentence; it is a procedural status, not a statutory aggravating circumstance.

 

A person is listed as a "Red Notice subject" because he is suspected of a serious crime and has fled abroad to evade legal sanction. What determines the severity of the final penalty is the criminal facts themselves, the amount involved, the harm caused, and a series of behaviors during the flight and the process of being brought to justice; "Red Notice" is merely a label recording this series of conduct.

 

The key issue is the obstructive conduct after fleeing abroad. When determining the sentence, the court will focus on the attitude of the fugitive during the process of being brought to justice.

 

Therefore, as family members, what you should focus on even more ishow to help the individual involved obtain a finding of voluntary surrender。

—this is also the clear opportunity for lenient treatment that the law leaves open to persons subject to a Red Notice.

 

Under the general rules, a person who is arrested passively will generally not be found to have voluntarily surrendered; however, where a person has been placed on a Red Notice and is arrested in a foreign country (not surrendering voluntarily), China has special rules for determining whether such an overseas fugitive who returns for trial can be found to have voluntarily surrendered.

 

Even if arrested abroad, so long as the person can proactively express a willingness to return to China to stand trial, give up using local legal procedures to resist, and voluntarily accept repatriation, upon return to China the person may be found to have "voluntarily surrendered" and thus to have voluntarily surrendered, thereby obtaining a mitigated or lighter punishment.

 

A typical example is the case of Yu Zhendong, Xu Chaofan and Xu Guojun, the three successive heads of the Guangdong Kaiping Sub-branch of the Bank of China, who jointly embezzled and misappropriated public funds.

 

After the case came to light in 2001, the three fled to the United States with RMB 483 million. After the Jiangmen Intermediate People's Court delivered its judgment in the case in December 2023, the court, in answering reporters' questions[1], specifically responded to the differences in the findings on the three individuals' voluntary surrender:

Reporter: Xu Chaofan, Yu Zhendong and Xu Guojun were all repatriated to China; why were Xu Chaofan and Yu Zhendong found to have voluntarily surrendered, while Xu Guojun was not?

 

Court: After committing the crime, Yu Zhendong fled abroad; after being detained by a foreign law enforcement agency, he was able to voluntarily choose to return to China to accept trial by China's judicial organs and truthfully confessed his crimes. His conduct meets the legal characteristics of voluntary surrender and he should be found to have voluntarily surrendered.

After committing the crime, Xu Chaofan fled abroad; after being detained by a foreign law enforcement agency, he expressed to the relevant U.S. authorities his willingness to return to China to stand trial, and during the process in which the U.S. government initiated immigration removal proceedings, after it was ascertained that he held not only Chinese citizenship but also Honduran citizenship, he refused the U.S. side's suggestion to remove him to Honduras and insisted on returning to China; after arriving in China he truthfully confessed his crimes, and he too was found to have voluntarily surrendered.

After committing the crime, Xu Guojun fled abroad for 20 years and consistently refused to return to China to stand trial; he was forcibly repatriated to China, and his conduct does not meet the legal characteristics of voluntary surrender and cannot lawfully be found to constitute voluntary surrender.

 

It can thus be seen that even if arrested abroad, so long as the person can proactively express a willingness to return to China to stand trial, give up using local legal procedures to resist, and voluntarily accept repatriation, upon return to China the person may be found to have "voluntarily surrendered" and thus to have voluntarily surrendered, thereby obtaining a mitigated or lighter punishment.

 

Similarly, in the Yao Moumou bribery case [2], during his temporary detention in Bulgaria, he repeatedly expressed in writing his willingness to return to China and waived his right to appeal in court, and was ultimately extradited back to China in only 44 days and was found by the court to have voluntarily surrendered.

 

 

5

Conclusion

Red Notice cases often involve not merely the judicial procedures of a single country, but the interweaving and coordination of legal systems and procedural rules among multiple countries, and their complexity far exceeds that of ordinary criminal cases.

 

In reality, many fugitives have long resided abroad and are susceptible to various one-sided or even inaccurate information, developing strong resistance to and fear of returning to China to face judicial proceedings; at the same time, in the same Red Notice case, the legal rules, extradition procedures and judicial standards applicable in different countries may differ enormously.

 

Therefore, as family members of a person involved in a criminal case, upon learning that a family member has been taken into custody, arrested or is involved in Red Notice proceedings, it is advisable to consult a professional lawyer as early as possible to obtain systematic and accurate legal advice.

 

If direct contact with the person concerned can be established (or communication can be established through local lawyers), true and objective legal information should be conveyed to him or her as early as possible, so as to avoid missing critical opportunities due to erroneous judgments and, as far as possible, to seek more favorable outcomes for the person concerned in terms of the litigation timeline, choice of procedure, and conviction and sentencing.


 

[1] How was sentencing considered? Why was voluntary surrender not found? The court's answers to questions on the first-instance trial of the Xu Guojun case http://s.cyol.com/articles/2023-12/14/content_3n5mEmS0.html

[2] Criminal Trial Reference (2022, Volume 1, Total Volume 131) [No. 1466] Yao Moumou bribery case—Accurate application of the criminal policy of balancing leniency and severity in international fugitive pursuit and asset recovery cases

 

 

Recommended Reading

Can fleeing abroad or changing nationality evade criminal sanctions?

For telecom and online fraud committed abroad, can Chinese public security authorities make cross-border arrests?

If a person is involved in a case abroad, will he or she still be arrested? Is fleeing abroad really useful?

Behind the Repatriation of Individual C: A Full Breakdown of a Cross-Border Criminal Group's Chain of Offenses — Which Charges May Apply to Different Roles?

 

 

About the Author

 Lawyer Shao Shiwei has long focused on criminal defense and compliance in the Web3 and cryptocurrency fields, and has accumulated substantial practical experience in economic crimes, cybercrimes, and new types of cases involving virtual assets. She is experienced in handling major, difficult, and complex criminal cases involving suspected casino operation, fraud, illegal business operations, and occupational embezzlement. She provides legal services including full-process criminal defense, the establishment of corporate criminal compliance systems, and criminal legal risk prevention and management for individuals and enterprises. Since beginning practice, she has handled more than 300 criminal cases in total, of which more than 60 achieved substantive defense outcomes such as withdrawal of the case, non-prosecution, application of a suspended sentence, or reduction of charges to a lower tier.