SpecialDisclaimer: This article is an original article by Attorney Shao Shiwei and represents only the personal views of the author. It does not constitute legal consultation or legal advice on any specific matter. To repost the article | seek legal consultation | engage in business exchanges, please add: sswls66
For entrepreneurs in the Web3 industry,against the backdrop of the first major revision of the PRC Anti-Money Laundering Law, it is necessary to fully understand the potential money laundering and other security risks in the industry, the legal risks and the serious consequences they may give rise to, and to adopt corresponding measures to prevent and reduce these risks. This concerns not only the stable operation of projects and the healthy development of the entire industry, but also national security, the public interest of society and financial order.
Author of this article | Attorney Shao Shiwei
This article is the third part of this topic:
"How should entrepreneurs in the Web3.0 industry respond against the backdrop of increasingly stringent global anti-money laundering regulation?"
The crime of money laundering can be described as a catch-all offense for the Web3 industry. Given the anonymity of transactions, it is difficult for exchanges, crypto wallets and similar platforms to trace whether the source of each transaction is lawful and compliant. Moreover, because transactions are not subject to geographic restrictions, the customer base may be spread across the world. At the same time, consistent with the traditional financial industry, this is an industry that sits closest to money. Therefore, in future anti-money-laundering supervision, Web3 entrepreneurs will be subject to higher duties and obligations than those in other industries. Once a business activity is characterized as a crime by a given country, the possible consequences include, but are not limited to, payment of huge fines, criminal penalties imposed on the actual controller, and an order for the project to withdraw from that country's market.Therefore, establishing an effective anti-money-laundering internal control system and performing anti-money-laundering legal obligations are important issues that Web3 entrepreneurs need to take seriously.Specifically, work can be carried out in the following areas:
01
Customer identity verification (KYC)
To many people this seems contradictory: blockchain is decentralized, yet real-name registration is required.Therefore, a correct understanding of decentralization is needed. The decentralized philosophy of blockchain does not mean completely eliminating all centers; rather, it emphasizes fairness and freedom among centers. This kind of decentralization aims to promote fairness and prevent a small group from gaining control over the entire system. Blockchain technology does not reject regulation; on the contrary, it can facilitate regulation. Absolute anonymity only breeds the evil in human nature. If absolute anonymization were achieved in the web field, money-laundering crimes would become even more rampant.
With the continued efforts of governments and financial regulators around the world, KYC (Know Your Customer) and anti-money laundering (AML) have gradually become rules that the Web3 industry, especially virtual currency exchanges, must implement. Through KYC, exchanges can ascertain users' true identities, so that if a transaction involves risk or other problems, the user can be directly identified. This helps combat crime and protect the security of user assets.
If the business isa domestic Web3 startup,under the Cybersecurity Law, the Provisions on the Administration of Blockchain Information Services and other rules, real-name verification of users is required. For example, for NFT digital collectible platforms and Web3 game platforms, where transactions and withdrawals involving funds are concerned, it is recommended to use real-name verification through mobile phone number + verification code + ID card + bank card + live facial recognition, among other measures.
Mainstream virtual currency trading platforms, such as OKX and Binance, also require users to complete real-name verification. In July 2022, Celsius Network, one of the world's largest crypto lending platforms, announced that it had filed for bankruptcy under Chapter 11 of the Bankruptcy Code in the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the Southern District of New York.
In the bankruptcy filing submitted to the court, the platform described in detail Celsius's financial condition, main business, list of creditors and reasons for filing for bankruptcy. When these data are made public, users' identities can be linked to their corresponding on-chain transactions. The sacrifice of anonymity can better protect the basic rights and interests of the broad user community.
Customer due diligence
An important element of the Anti-Money Laundering Law of the People's Republic of China (Revised Draft) is the requirement that entities subject to anti-money laundering obligations shift from a "rules-based" approach to a "risk-based" approach. The "risk-based" approach is a regulatory regime established by the Financial Action Task Force (FATF) in its 2012 "FATF New 40 Recommendations." Accordingly,the anti-money laundering efforts of Web3 projects must also achieve "substantive compliance."
KYC only fulfills a formal review obligation; achieving substantive compliance review requires considerable additional review work. For example, under the 924 Notice, "overseas virtual currency exchanges providing services to residents within China via the Internet likewise constitute illegal financial activities." If a foreign virtual currency trading platform, when providing USDT-to-USD exchange services to a client company, neglects to look through the client company's upstream equity ownership, to understand the company's actual controller, and fails to conduct detailed due diligence on the client company's source of funds, transaction background, transaction purpose and the like, it may very well become a "tool" for the client company's disguised foreign exchange trading, tax evasion or other unlawful transactions. The corresponding consequence may be exposure to charges from the regulatory authorities of the relevant countries.
Only through comprehensive, multi-dimensional due diligence—understanding the client's true identity, the lawfulness of the source of funds, the legitimacy of the transaction purpose and the like—and by achieving substantive review in the true sense, can a platform effectively avoid its own legal risks.
03
Know Your Transaction (KYT)
KYC focuses on the static identity of platform customers, whereas KYT (Know Your Transaction)focuses on the dynamic transaction process of customers.。
As a deepening and supplement to KYC, KYT enables real-time monitoring of transactions on the platform (for example[1]: frequently changing the IP address used for transactions or doing so within a short period; sending transaction instructions from IP addresses that may carry higher risk; buying or selling virtual assets with no obvious purpose, or where the nature, scale or frequency of the transactions appears unusual, etc.). Through comprehensive quantitative risk statistical analysis of transactions and addresses, the risk profile of address transactions can be grasped in all respects. This risk assessment helps the platform quickly identify suspicious or anomalous behavioral patterns, thereby effectively preventing and responding to potential money laundering, fraud, gambling and other illegal activities. Once these potential risks are identified, the exchange can promptly take corresponding measures, such as issuing warnings, temporarily freezing funds or reporting to the relevant authorities, to ensure the compliance and security of transactions.
For example,DeFi project teamswhen conducting investment and lending business, can use KYT to assess the authenticity, value and liquidity of assets, preventing assets from being tampered with, forged or improperly manipulated in any form, thereby safeguarding investors' lawful rights and interests and their trust in the market.
For another example,Web3 wallet project teams, while committed to creating a smoother cross-chain transfer experience for customers, also face the risk that funds in cross-chain transfers may encounter security hazards, such as asset loss or malicious hijacking. KYT technology can monitor every stage of a cross-chain transfer throughout the process, and the historical records and status of each transfer transaction can also be traced.
04
Building the internal control system
Platforms need to provide regular compliance training to employees so that employees understand the harms of money laundering activities and methods for identifying them, thereby enhancing employees' anti-money laundering compliance awareness and encouraging employees to actively report suspicious activities and participate in anti-money laundering work.
Platforms must also establish and improve a sound internal control system internally to ensure that anti-money laundering policies and measures are effectively implemented. In addition, conducting regular compliance audits can promptly assess the effectiveness and compliance of the platform's anti-money laundering work.
05
Large-value transaction and suspicious transaction reporting system
On the basis of KYC, KYT and related due diligence, in order to more effectively address potential risks, Web3 platforms or projects must alsostrengthen technical measures and enhance their ability to monitor and analyze abnormal transactionsconduct in-depth suspicious transaction analysis for transactions whose amounts exceed preset thresholds or display abnormal characteristics and, where necessary, report to the anti-money laundering regulatory authorities and cooperate with the relevant authorities in the investigation and handling of money laundering criminal activities.
06
Comply with local policies and regulations
Although virtual currencies have decentralized characteristics and the convenience of cross-border transactions, the users served by Web3 platforms each belong to their own countries. Therefore, ifIf a Web3 platform provides services to users in a certain region, it is essential to become familiar with and comply with local laws, regulations and regulatory policies.。
For example, with respect to users' gambling income, can the platform provide virtual currency exchange services? This requires understanding not only local legal provisions on gambling (for example, the Philippines has licensed, lawful gambling platforms, but there are also many unlawfully operated gambling companies locally), but also whether the Philippines has any relevant policies and regulations on virtual currency transactions.
07
Maintain close contact with anti-money laundering regulators
Web3 platforms need to maintain good communication and cooperation with the regulatory authorities in the regions they serve, so as to understand the latest money laundering trends and regulatory requirements,the local government's attitude toward platform operations and virtual currency transactions, and obtain necessary support and guidance.
For example, on November 21, 2023, Changpeng Zhao, CEO of Binance, signed a plea agreement with the U.S. Department of Justice. The plea agreement stated that, as a money services business (MSB) operating in the United States, Binance had not applied for an MSB license from the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN) of the U.S. Department of the Treasury. The U.S. Department of Justice found that, as Binance's CEO and day-to-day manager, Changpeng Zhao "willfully" failed to conduct effective transaction monitoring for a considerable period of time and tolerated Binance's failure to implement effective customer identification (KYC) and anti-money laundering (AML) measures. For this reason, Binance failed to effectively restrict transactions between U.S. users and users in regions subject to U.S. sanctions, such as users in Iran and Cuba, and Binance earned substantial fees from such transactions.
08
Seek guidance and assistance from professional institutions to improve the platform's anti-money laundering capabilities
Web3 platforms may cooperate with third-party technology companies such as professional blockchain security companies and on-chain analytics companies to audit trading platforms, wallets, smart contracts and the security of on-chain funds, and to technically prevent and intercept hacker attacks, so as to avoid the platform becoming a tool for on-chain money laundering.
Web3 platforms may cooperate with third-party corporate service providers such as law firms and consultants to help the platform become familiar with local regulations and policies and to clarify the negative list for conducting business locally; to review the platform's business, maintain smooth communication with regulatory authorities and build an anti-money laundering compliance internal control system that meets local regulatory requirements, and establish a compliance culture; and, in the course of day-to-day operations, to help business personnel accurately assess business risks, effectively identify high-risk customers and high-risk business, and avoid the possibility of the platform incurring potential legal liability arising from anti-money laundering risks in the course of operations, causing economic or reputational losses, or other negative impacts.
Conclusion
With blockchain technology as its cornerstone and by virtue of features such as decentralization and privacy protection, Web3 is sweeping the globe, attracting large numbers of entrepreneurs and users to participate continuously, and its application scenarios are rapidly expanding and becoming more diverse.
Statistics show that more than 100 thousand decentralized applications worldwide already use Web3 technology. Industry forecasts suggest that by 2025, Web3 may become the core of the global digital economy. However, as this market continues to expand, it has also attracted an influx of wrongdoers, causing traditional crimes such as fraud and money laundering to begin penetrating the Web3 space and bringing security risks to the industry that cannot be ignored. Exchanges, digital wallets, cross-chain bridge technology, DeFi, NFTs, mixers and others can all serve as tools for wrongdoers to launder money.
In addition, given that the Web3 industry serves clients across the globe, and that in reality different countries, and even different localities within the same country, display diverse understandings and interpretations of Web3, blockchain and virtual asset transactions, and that national criminal justice systems more or less bear the features of "long-arm jurisdiction," entrepreneurs in the Web3 space face a task of critical importance: continuously tracking and updating the latest regulatory policies in the regions they serve, so as to ensure the compliance and adaptability of their business operations.
In short, the anti-money laundering compliance challenges facing the Web3 space remain severe, and Web3 entrepreneurs both at home and abroad are all confronted withstringent regulatory red lines, broad jurisdictional rules, legal risks that are hard to guard against, and unpredictable black swan eventsBeyond industry practitioners, compliance in the Web3 industry also requires the joint efforts of all parties, including legal, technical and policy stakeholders. Only by moving forward together can all parties jointly promote the healthy, compliant and sustainable development of the Web3 industry.

[1] Tongfudun Web3 Feature | KYT/AML: A Necessary Condition for Compliant Business Development in Web3https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/PV7spVqYzvZQGjV-i8pz2A


