Special Statement: This article is an original article by Lawyer Shao Shiwei and represents only the personal views of the author. It does not constitute legal consultation or legal advice on any specific matter. For article reprints | legal consultation | business exchanges, please add: sswls66
For entrepreneurs in the Web3 industry, against the backdrop of the first major revision of the PRC Anti-Money Laundering Law, it is necessary to comprehensively understand the potential money laundering and other security risks and legal risks within the industry, as well as the serious consequences they may cause, and to take corresponding measures to prevent and reduce these risks.This concerns not only the stable operation of projects and the healthy development of the entire industry, but also national security, public interests and financial order.
By | Lawyer Shao Shiwei
This article is the second part of this topic:
『Whether in China or abroad, Web3.0 entrepreneurs should attach importance to anti-money laundering compliance』
01
Overview of Domestic Regulatory Policies
1. Blockchain-related regulatory policies
The Notice on Preventing Bitcoin Risks dated December 3, 2013 mentioned that "Bitcoin should be a specificvirtual goods,do not have the same legal status as currency and cannot and should not be circulated or used in the market as currency.", "the branches of the People's Bank of China shall closely monitor the developments and trends of Bitcoin and other similar virtual goods characterized by anonymity and the convenience of cross-border circulation, carefully assess money-laundering risks, and study and formulate targeted preventive measures."
The Announcement on Preventing Risks from Token Issuance Financing dated September 4, 2017, states that "token issuance financing is a form ofunauthorized and illegal public financing," and addresses "illegal financial activities carried out under various names using the word 'coin'."
The Risk Notice on Preventing Disguised ICO Activities dated January 12, 2018, the Risk Notice on Preventing Risks from Overseas ICOs and "Virtual Currency" Trading dated January 26, 2018, and the Risk Notice on Preventing Illegal Fundraising in the Name of "Virtual Currency" and "Blockchain" dated August 24, 2018, state that "raising funds by issuing so-called 'virtual currency,' 'virtual assets,' 'digital assets' and the like" is characterized by obvious online and cross-border features and by strong deceptive, enticement and concealment features.
The Notice on Rectifying Virtual Currency "Mining" Activities dated September 3, 2021, states that "violations of the rules on virtual currency 'mining' activities in all localities shall be seriously investigated and rectified." In addition, the Risk Notice on Further Preventing "Virtual Currency" Trading Activities was issued on September 15 of the same year.
The Risk Notice on Preventing Illegal Fundraising in the Name of the "Metaverse" dated February 18, 2022, states that activities carried out under the banner of the "Metaverse" are highly enticing and strongly deceptive.
The Initiative on Preventing NFT-Related Financial Risks dated April 13, 2022, states that"NFTs" carry hidden risks such as speculation, money laundering and illegal financial activities.
In December 2023, the People's Bank of China released the China Financial Stability Report (2023), which states that "the governance mechanism of decentralized finance (DeFi) in substance has 'centralized' features and is susceptible to control by a small number of insiders, harming the interests of other investors; and that the anonymity of assets and the difficulty of recovering them give rise to anti-money-laundering and counter-terrorist-financing risks, among others."; "In recent years, regulatory authorities in many countries and international organizations have begun to assess crypto asset risks and have introduced regulatory policies and response measures, generally in accordance with "the same business, the same risk, the same regulationprinciple, regulate crypto asset business in a manner commensurate with its risk level, and minimize regulatory data gaps as far as possible, reduce regulatory fragmentation, and eliminate regulatory arbitrage.”
2. Legislative history of anti-money laundering crimes
In 1997, the Criminal Law of China provided forthe crime of money laundering, and subsequent amendments to the Criminal Law have continuously improved the provisions on the crime of money laundering. In the more than 10 years since the Anti-Money Laundering Law came into effect, China's anti-money laundering regime has become increasingly complete, and the number of anti-money laundering and counter-terrorist financing provisions at the level of departmental rules and departmental normative documents is close to one hundred (which may be roughly divided into: comprehensive provisions, identity identification provisions, suspicious transaction provisions, risk rating provisions, provisions on cooperation with administrative investigations, etc.).
In 1997, the Criminal Law provided for the crime of money laundering, and there were only three types of predicate offenses, namely drug crimes, crimes committed by organizations of a triad nature, and smuggling crimes.
In 2001, Amendment (III) to the Criminal Law made the first amendment to the crime of money laundering, mainly adding terrorist activity crimes as predicate offenses for the crime of money laundering, bringing the number of types of predicate offenses for the crime of money laundering to four, and increasing the severity of punishment for natural persons where a unit commits the crime of money laundering.
In 2006, Amendment (VI) to the Criminal Law made the second amendment to the crime of money laundering, incorporating corruption and bribery crimes, crimes of disrupting the order of financial administration, and financial fraud crimes into the scope of predicate offenses for the crime of money laundering, bringing the number of types of predicate offenses for the crime of money laundering to the current seven.
On January 1, 2007,the Anti-Money Laundering Law officially came into effect, and on June 28 of the same year,China's accession to the FATF (Financial Action Task Force on Money Laundering)。
In 2020, the Criminal Law Amendment (XI) made the third amendment to the money laundering offense, mainly reflected in four aspects: first, the two concepts of "knowingly" and "assisting" were deleted, so that "self-laundering" constitutes a crime; second, item three, "other settlement methods," was changed to "other payment and settlement methods," adding "payment" methods of transferring funds as a money laundering method; third, the scope of combating cross-border money laundering was expanded; fourth, the provisions on fines were amended, changing proportional fines to unlimited fines,intensifying the penalties。
On January 22, 2024, Premier Li Qiang of the State Council presided over an executive meeting of the State Council, at which the Anti-Money Laundering Law of the People's Republic of China (Revised Draft) was deliberated.
On April 23, 2024, the Anti-Money Laundering Law of the People's Republic of China (Revised Draft) (hereinafter referred to as the "Revised Draft") was submitted to the ninth session of the Standing Committee of the 14th National People's Congress for deliberation. The draft includes "timely monitoring of new types of money laundering risks."
02
Against the background of domestic blockchain and anti-money laundering policies and regulations, can Web3.0 still be pursued in China?
1. Being used formoney launderingDue to the anonymity of virtual currency transactions, their untraceability, their inability to be linked to a specific person, and the fact that such transactions are not subject to supervision by banks and other authorities, and further compounded by the concentrated rectification of the public security authorities' "card-cutting" campaign in recent years, wrongdoers have "no choice but" to upgrade their criminal methods, using virtual currency as a tool for illegal transactions and to conceal or disguise the proceeds of crime.
2. Easily gives rise tospeculative hypeA review of China's policies on virtual currency over the years shows that the prohibition of ICOs and mining, and the prevention of risks of illegal fundraising related to the metaverse and financial risks related to NFTs, all share a common point: preventing speculative hype triggered by the relevant concepts, which would harm the interests of the general public.
3、foreign exchange outflowOwing to the convenience of cross-border virtual currency transactions, a relatively common practice in recent years is that wrongdoers, in order to earn price-difference service fees, use foreign exchange matching arrangements and virtual currency to make cross-border remittances, resulting in a massive outflow of domestic funds, or the loss of foreign exchange that should originally have been remitted into China.
But technology itself is not culpable; the problem lies with those who use it.
In China, there are many application scenarios for blockchain. On February 22, 2024, the China Blockchain Innovation Application Development Report (2023) (hereinafter the "Report"), guided by the Informatization Development Bureau of the Cyberspace Administration of China and compiled under the leadership of the Data and Technical Support Center of the Cyberspace Administration of China, was officially released at the National Blockchain Innovation Application Pilot Summary and Exchange Meeting. At the same time, the Data and Technical Support Center of the Cyberspace Administration of China carried out a nationwide solicitation of 2023 blockchain innovation application cases; after preliminary review, re-review, public announcement and other stages, 66 blockchain innovation application cases were selected and compiled into the China Blockchain Innovation Application Case Collection (2023) (see the figure below), providing reference for all regions and industries to further advance blockchain innovation and development.
In releasing the China Blockchain Innovation Application Development Report (2023), the Cyberspace Administration of China also noted: "General Secretary Xi Jinping emphasized when presiding over a study session that 'the integrated application of blockchain technology plays an important role in the new round of technological innovation and industrial transformation. We must take blockchain as an important breakthrough for independent innovation of core technologies, clarify the main direction, increase investment, focus on tackling a number of key core technologies, and accelerate the development of blockchain technology and industrial innovation.'"
From this it can be seen thatalthough at the regulatory level China takes a negative attitude toward virtual currency transactions, it is at the same time continuously encouraging domestic exploration and application of blockchain.
03
Overseas regulatory developments on anti-money laundering in the Web3 industry
Constrained by multiple factors, the domestic Web3 industry remains at a preliminary stage of development overall. In practice, many Web3 entrepreneurs, for various practical reasons, choose to relocate themselves overseas and operate their projects abroad. However, while some foreign countries are more inclusive and open toward the Web3 industry, their relevant regulatory rules are also stricter and more detailed.
1. Regulatory rules in major countries worldwide
On stablecoin regulation.
Governments of many countries are increasingly recognizing the broad prospects and enormous potential inherent in stablecoins. In May 2023, the European Parliament approved the first cryptocurrency regulation, the Markets in Crypto-Assets Regulation (MiCA), making the EU the world's first major jurisdiction to introduce comprehensive crypto regulation. In August 2023, the Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS) announced the final regulatory framework for stablecoins. According to the PwC Global Crypto Regulation Report 2023 published on December 19, 2023, as many as 25 countries/regions enacted stablecoin legislation or regulation in 2023, including France, Germany and Japan.
On the compliant operation of crypto platforms.
In the United States, regulation is primarily carried out by the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN), with a focus on money transmission and anti-money laundering (AML). Under the Bank Secrecy Act, FinCEN regulates money services businesses (MSBs). In March 2013, FinCEN issued guidance determining that cryptocurrency transaction service providers are MSBs. Under this framework, cryptocurrency trading platforms must obtain FinCEN authorization and implement comprehensive AML risk assessment and reporting mechanisms.
In June 2023, the Hong Kong Securities and Futures Commission issued the Guidelines for Virtual Asset Trading Platform Operators and the Guideline on Anti-Money Laundering and Counter-Financing of Terrorism (For Licensed Corporations and SFC-licensed Virtual Asset Service Providers), introducing a licensing regime for virtual asset service providers.
On regulation of sub-sectors of the Web3 industry.
For example,DeFi, in October 2021, the international organization the Financial Action Task Force (FATF), in its updated virtual asset AML guidance, recommended that DeFi be brought within AML obligations as virtual asset service providers (VASPs). On April 6, 2023, the U.S. Department of the Treasury released the 2023 DeFi Illicit Finance Activity Assessment Report, the world's first assessment report on illicit finance activity based on DeFi.
2. Enforcement Actions and Anti-Money Laundering Sanctions
On August 24, 2023, according to a press release from the U.S. Department of the Treasury, the Department of Justice filed charges against Roman Semenov and Roman Storm, the second co-founder of Tornado Cash; the latter was arrested today by the FBI and the IRS on charges of conspiracy to commit money laundering, conspiracy to operate an unlicensed money transmitting business, and conspiracy to violate sanctions regulations. The Treasury stated that even though they knew the Lazarus Group had, for the benefit of North Korea, laundered hundreds of millions of dollars' worth of stolen virtual currency through its mixing service, the founders of Tornado Cash continued to develop and promote the service and took no meaningful measures to reduce its use for illicit purposes.
On November 29, 2023, the U.S. Department of the Treasury sanctioned the cryptocurrency mixing service Sinbad on the grounds that the service supported transactions connected to a North Korean hacking group. Sinbad.io (Sinbad) is a virtual currency mixer and a primary tool used by the Lazarus Group to launder money for North Korea. Sinbad was responsible for assisting in the laundering of millions of dollars' worth of stolen virtual currency and was the Lazarus Group's preferred mixing server. Sinbad operated on the Bitcoin blockchain and indiscriminately facilitated illicit transactions by obfuscating their source, destination and counterparties.
04
Relevant Provisions on Domestic and Foreign Jurisdiction
Whether Web3 startups are based in China or abroad, they need to pay attention to anti-money laundering compliance. In China, businesses related to virtual currency token issuance, financing and trading have long been prohibited. So, if a project chooses to launch overseas, can it avoid criminal legal risk?
1. Domestic Criminal Jurisdiction Provisions
Articles 6 to 9 of China's Criminal Law are the legal provisions on criminal jurisdiction, namely the principles of territorial jurisdiction, personal jurisdiction, protective jurisdiction and universal jurisdiction. Therefore, China's judicial authorities have jurisdiction where either the act or the result of the crime occurs within Chinese territory, where a Chinese citizen commits outside Chinese territory an offense prescribed by this Law, or where the offense is one prescribed by an international treaty to which China is a party or has acceded.
2. International Jurisdiction Provisions
3、Long-arm jurisdiction(long arm jurisdiction), that is, bringing cases that originally fall outside the scope of jurisdiction within that scope. The concept originated in 1945 with International Shoe Co. v. Washington, a judgment that established the interstate jurisdictional principle of "minimum contacts": so long as the defendant purposefully conducts activities in the state where the court sits through some act, and that activity is related to the plaintiff, the court has jurisdiction over the defendant."Minimum contacts"The ambiguity and flexibility of this principle have allowed its content to expand indefinitely in practice, and its application has extended from domestic to foreign contexts. Antitrust, anti-money laundering and financial compliance of listed companies are also common pretexts for the United States to exercise long-arm jurisdiction. In the anti-money laundering field, Section 317 of the USA PATRIOT Act provides: "If a foreign person or a financial institution established under foreign law is involved in money laundering, the U.S. courts may exercise long-arm jurisdiction over it so long as process has been served on it in accordance with the U.S. Federal Rules of Civil Procedure or the foreign law of its location." On the basis of the PATRIOT Act, relevant U.S. authorities may freely examine the details of bank accounts opened in the United States as correspondent accounts; under that Act, courts may issue subpoenas to any foreign bank maintaining a correspondent account, and examine or freeze all funds in that account both within and outside the United States. This provision is commonly used in conjunction with financial sanctions.
3. Relevant cases
The cross-chain bridge project Multichain has ceased operations, and its CEO has been taken into custody by Kunming police.
At the end of May 2023, the cross-chain interoperability protocol Multichain experienced abnormal cross-chain delays. In July 2023, Multichain officially disclosed that its CEO Zhaojun had been taken away by Chinese police from his home on May 21, after which he lost contact with the Multichain global team. The team later contacted Zhaojun's family and learned that all of his computers, mobile phones, hardware wallets and mnemonic phrases had been confiscated by the authorities. Lacking other sources of information and the corresponding operating funds, the team was forced to cease operations.
According to public information, Multichain (formerly Anyswap) was founded in July 2020 and had received USD 60 million in financing from Binance Labs. In addition to financing support, Multichain also established a partnership with Binance Smart Chain (BSC). Although the project was set up overseas, it is in fact a project founded by Chinese nationals.
No information has yet been found regarding the reasons for the case as stated in the police notification, but there is no dispute that the domestic judicial authorities have jurisdiction over the case.
Binance founder sentenced by a US court to four months' imprisonment。
The Binance exchange is registered in the offshore financial jurisdiction of Malta, and Changpeng Zhao, in order to circumvent legal supervision, managed the company's day-to-day affairs online for a long time and obtained UAE nationality. There is no extradition treaty between the UAE and the United States, so as long as Changpeng Zhao does not leave the country, the United States cannot apprehend him across borders.
The US PATRIOT Act provides that where a foreign entity is involved in money laundering and the transactions occur in the United States or a bank account is opened in the United States, US jurisdiction may reach extraterritorially. As for the business in which Binance is involved, although its main transactions are distributed in a decentralized manner, a considerable portion of the transactions took place within the United States, including transactions between Americans and individuals in sanctioned jurisdictions, which gives the United States jurisdiction. Under US anti-money laundering law, where a person transfers funds from outside the United States to within the United States, or from within the United States to outside it, in order to conceal illegal activity, this may constitute the crime of money laundering. Therefore, when announcing the sentence, the judge of the US District Court for the Western District of Seattle said that Changpeng Zhao is responsible for complying with US law, regardless of how much wealth he has.
[1] Professor Zhao Binghao was invited to attend the "2023 Hong Kong Web3 Carnival" to re-examine the Web3 industry from a legal perspective — Institute of Financial Technology Rule of Law, China University of Political Science and Law http://lfi.cupl.edu.cn/info/1053/1207.htm

Recommended Reading


