In the second half of 2025, Attorney Shao's team successively received multiple criminal judgments from courts in Hunan, Hubei, Northeast China and other regions concerning Web3 crypto asset exchanges convicted of the crime of operating a gambling establishment. At the same time, criminal proceedings in several other exchange cases will continue to advance in 2026.
Through frequent communication and engagement with judicial authorities in various localities, we have gradually come to recognize that such cases differ in many respects from the handling of traditional criminal cases—these cases have never been a purely legal-application issue, but rather a complex amalgam of law, policy, social effects and judicial orientation.
Based on our practical experience in handling multiple criminal cases involving virtual asset exchanges, this article systematically reviews the common features and key defense points of this new type of case as they appear in judicial practice, and, drawing on specific case-handling experience, offers cautious warnings regarding the criminal risks that Web3 practitioners may face.A excerpt of more than 10,000 words of defense opinions is appended at the end of this article, for the reference of colleagues in the legal practice community.
I Author of this article: Attorney Shao Shiwei
1
The Complexity of Handling Criminal Cases Involving Exchanges
The adjudication of criminal cases involving virtual asset exchanges differs considerably from that of traditional criminal cases.
When handling such cases, judges must weigh far more than the legal provisions themselves and the question of guilt or innocence of an individual; they must also consider comprehensively the industry impact a judgment may cause, its educational and deterrent significance for society, and the balance to be struck in the current context of financial regulation and technological innovation. This weighing stems from the real-world position in which case handlers find themselves.
For them, this is not an isolated, purely legal determination. Situated within a complex judicial system, they must carefully assess the systemic professional risks accompanying each decision: will an apparently "correct" acquittal be overturned on appeal because it touches upon currently clear regulatory red lines? Will a ruling that seeks to break new ground be "corrected" through internal supervision procedures at a later date because it is inconsistent with the judicial policy orientation at a higher level?
For this reason, representing such cases is also a profound test of defense counsel's professional wisdom and strategic balancing.
2
Core defense strategy in Web3 casino-establishment cases: pursuing an acquittal defense to achieve a substantively lenient outcome
Therefore, in the face of this judicial reality and drawing on practical experience from multiple successful cases, our team has distilled an effective core defense strategy: using the most rigorous standards and a tightly structured system of an acquittal defense as a realistic path to achieving the best possible outcomes for the client, including a lesser offense, a suspended sentence, or even non-prosecution.
The essence of this strategy lies in the fact that it does not unrealistically pursue an acquittal on paper; rather, by constructing irrefutable acquittal logic and evidence-based offense and defense, it maximizes the exposure of major disputes over the legal characterization of the case and the inherent defects in the chain of evidence, thereby laying a solid foundation for securing the broadest possible scope for lenient treatment of the client.
We assert an acquittal defense and systematically raise the points of dispute, with the fundamental aim of conveying the following core points to the court:
The nature of this case is doubtful: this is by no means a traditional casino-establishment case. Equating trading in complex financial derivatives such as "perpetual contracts" directly with "gambling" is subject to major and fundamental disagreement, both in legal doctrine and in judicial practice.
The client's subjective awareness was insufficient: for the vast majority of employees in ordinary positions such as technology, operations, and customer service, it was objectively impossible at the time of joining to foresee that their daily work would be characterized by judicial authorities as complicity in "establishing a casino."
It is precisely on the basis of the above—that "the legal characterization is fundamentally disputed" and that "there is a natural gap in subjective awareness"—that even if the court ultimately finds the client guilty based on various considerations, itfully should, and must,impose a lesser or mitigated punishment on the client, and fully apply non-prosecution, a suspended sentence, or conviction without punishment, so as to achieve a true fit between culpability, responsibility, and punishment.
In a word,through the utmost professional argumentation and a rigorous logical system of an "acquittal defense," we strive, within the domestic judicial environment and in the realistic crevices between law and policy, to seek every possible path of lenient defense for the client.
3
The "combination-punch" defense strategy in new types of casino-establishment cases
Therefore, in recent years of practice, we have not only developed a clear defense strategy but also refined a complete, replicable "combined-punch" approach:
-
Combining in-court and out-of-court defense: while engaging in vigorous contest in the courtroom, we use reasonable out-of-court defense strategies to guide case-handling personnel to focus on the core disputes of the case.
-
Focused and refined cross-examination of key evidence: in particular with respect to judicial appraisal opinions, audit reports and the like, we conduct in-depth cross-examination from the perspectives of their scientific validity, relevance, methodology and procedural legality, dismantling the prosecution's evidentiary system.
-
Working backward from the charged offense to identify evidentiary gaps: starting from the statutory elements of the crime of "operating a casino," we reverse-test the prosecution's evidentiary system and precisely identify breaks in the chain of its gambling-related logic and insufficiencies of proof.
-
Rigorously examining procedural and substantive details: we do not overlook any procedural defect or evidentiary contradiction, and through the accumulation of details we systematically argue that "the facts of the case are unclear and the evidence has not yet reached the statutory standard of proof of being reliable and sufficient."
At the same time, we are well aware that,when facing such highly specialized and highly contested new types of cases,how to enable case-handling personnel to accurately understand the business logic of Web3 is likewise key to determining the effectiveness of the defense.Therefore,our communication strategy is not to become locked in absolute confrontation with the case-handling officers, but rather to work to establish a professional, rational and sustained channel of dialogue.Because no matter how incisive a defense argument may be, if it cannot be effectively conveyed and understood, it will be hard-pressed to move the adjudicator's inner conviction. We will therefore always maintain positive, full and constructive communication with the case-handling officers. Our core objective is not to require the case-handling officers to master every technical detail of finance, but to guide them to clearly recognize the following three fundamental issues:
-
Does the case-handling procedure contain unavoidable defects?
-
Is there a major dispute in law and in fact regarding the legal characterization of the case?
-
Is the evidence in the case sufficient to tightly support the charge of "operating a casino"?
Once the case-handling officers are able to fully perceive the above three points, their judgment will naturally incline toward a more prudent and lenient direction, thereby producing a penalty significantly lighter than that in a traditional casino-operation case. This is precisely the concrete manifestation, at the communication level, of our defense strategy of pursuing "the substance of leniency" through "a defense of innocence."
In summary, the defense path for such cases is, while adhering to the core concept of an innocence defense, to ultimately achieve practical results most favorable to the client—such as a downgraded sentencing range or a suspended sentence—through the utmost refined defense and professional strategic communication.
4
Criminal risks that all Web3 positions may face
So, stepping outside the individual case and based on the multiple criminal cases involving exchanges that we have handled, we also need to issue a risk warning to all Web3 practitioners working remotely in China—regardless of whether the position you hold istechnical development, operations and maintenance, product, design, operations, business development (BD), marketing, customer service, or even finance or human resources (HR)in such support positions, once the platform you serve is investigated, the personnel in the relevant positions may all be drawn into a criminal investigation. This is not alarmism or an attempt to spread anxiety; it is the objective fact that we have genuinely seen in the case files of criminal cases.

Therefore, for domestic Web3 job seekers, before deciding whether to accept an offer from an exchange or a project team, it is advisable to carefully assess the potential legal risks after joining, in light of the specific business model and the objective circumstances of domestic judicial practice, and after consulting professional lawyers.
5
Returning to the essence of the law: are "perpetual contracts" actually gambling?
In most litigated cases, crypto asset exchanges have been legally characterized as "operating a gambling establishment," and their contract trading modules are often regarded by law enforcement authorities as key evidence of a gambling nature.
However, are "perpetual contracts" actually gambling? This remains a highly controversial question.
Through handling multiple "contract-type" gambling-establishment cases and conducting in-depth analysis of the business logic of different platforms, we have found thatwhether the contract module of a virtual asset exchange constitutes operating a gambling establishment is not a simple question that can be answered yes or no in a one-size-fits-all manner(this is essentially similar to the debate previously discussed by Lawyer Shao over whether virtual assets should be defined as "data" or "property" ➡️The dilemma of legal characterization in the illegal acquisition of virtual assets: judicial divergence between property attributes and data attributes (III)) but rather requires specific analysis of specific issues in light of actual scenarios, and must be analyzed on a case-by-case basis in light of the specific business logic, risk control measures, settlement mechanisms and profit models of different exchanges' contract modules.
Therefore, any abstract and general discussion of "whether perpetual contracts are gambling"—a discussion divorced from the specific facts and evidence of a case—is, in Lawyer Shao's view, actually of no substantive significance.
Furthermore, even if the contract module displays certain features in its design that may be regarded as "gambling-related," the core of the case immediately transforms into a purely legal-technical question:
Has the judicial authority fully discharged its burden of proof? Is the evidence it has presented indeed and sufficient to prove beyond any doubt that the business meets all the statutory constituent elements of the "crime of operating a gambling establishment" under the Criminal Law? This is precisely the key point on which professional criminal defense must focus its efforts and where weaknesses in the prosecution's case may be identified.
6
Final Remarks
Of course, we are fully aware that, regarding the legal characterization of such cases, differing views and ongoing discussion persist in both academic circles and practice, and no absolute consensus has yet been reached; its complexity merits in-depth consideration by legal colleagues. Attached below are some of the defense points we developed during the handling of the case (the content has been anonymized), which we respectfully submit for the criticism and correction of fellow practitioners in professional exchange.
Appendix: Defense Statement in the Case of a Virtual Currency Exchange Suspected of Operating a Gambling Establishment

Recommended Reading


