Special Notice: This article is an original article by Attorney Shao Shiwei and represents only the author's personal views. It does not constitute legal consultation or legal advice on any specific matter. To repost the article, seek legal consultation, or communicate with peers, please add: sswls66.
Introduction:
The so-called "driver," also known as a "professional withdrawer," refers to an intermediary specifically responsible for carrying out withdrawals and transferring illicit funds, helping criminal groups "launder" illicit funds in exchange for commissions.
Due to the anonymity of USDT virtual assets, money-laundering teams recruit drivers to "launder" funds by buying and selling USDT through OTC merchants (see the figure below).
So does a driver's cashing out and transferring of illicit funds constitute joint commission of the crime of fraud together with the upstream party, or the crime of concealing or disguising criminal proceeds or the proceeds derived therefrom (hereinafter referred to as the crime of concealment and disguise)?
Author | Attorney Shao Shiwei
01
Subjective knowledge: Did the actor know that the funds were fraud-related?
In cases involving telecom and online fraud, illegal payment-settlement schemes, and money laundering, one of the important factors in determining the charge is the degree of the actor's "subjective knowledge," that is, whether the actor knew or should have known the nature of his or her conduct. This involves two levels of concepts:
① Whether the actor knew that the funds he or she helped transfer were proceeds of an upstream crime;
② Whether the actor knew that the funds he or she helped transfer were proceeds of an upstream fraud crime.
No actor will voluntarily tell the police during interrogation that he or she knew the upstream funds were criminal proceeds and helped transfer them; therefore, it is generally inferred from the evidence in the case that the actor "knew or should have known."
First,If the actor had no knowledge whatsoever and acted entirely under deception (for example, a university student taking a part-time job), then the actor does not meet the first-layer concept described above and does not commit a crime.
Second,, if it can be inferred from the actor's statements and the evidence in the case that the actor knew or should have known that the funds were proceeds of crime, but there is insufficient evidence to prove that the actor knew the funds were proceeds of telecom fraud, the actor cannot be characterized as a joint offender in the crime of fraud.
This is because, for money mules and other persons assisting in money laundering, if they deal with multiple upstream parties at the same time, the illicit funds they help transfer may originate from fraud, online gambling, dissemination of obscene materials, and other crimes. In addition, between the money mules and the persons carrying out telecom and online fraud there may also be "money laundering rooms," "illegal payment-settlement platforms," "mule organizers," "second-tier" and "third-tier" intermediaries, and the cash-withdrawal mules have a de facto information asymmetry with these upstream persons. It is very difficult to prove that, when the upstream offenders carried out the fraud, the actor had reached an agreement with the upstream to transfer illicit funds; consequently, it is also very difficult to prove that the actor knew the specific nature of the upstream funds.
However, for the organizers of money mules, if they have long served a particular telecom fraud group, then depending on their degree of participation, they may be found to have "subjective knowledge" (but can such "subjective knowledge" always be characterized as joint commission of the crime of fraud? This will be discussed later).
In practice, money mules may know that the upstream funds are proceeds of crime, and therefore, to make their conduct in assisting the transfer of illicit funds safer, they adopt many methods to evade investigation, such as the recently prevalent method of using ride-hailing vehicles to transport gold and cash to transfer illicit funds (see the figure below), and creating many script templates for responding to the "uncle in the cap" (the police), among others.
The purpose of these methods is to evade the crackdown by public security organs, but to determine that the money mules knew or should have known that the funds they helped transfer were proceeds of telecom fraud, it is still necessary to make a comprehensive determination in light of other evidence (such as the statements of co-defendants, Telegram group chat records, and the actor's prior experience, among others).
Therefore, where there was no prior collusion between the upstream and downstream parties, and the money mule joined only after the upstream crime had been completed and merely knew in general terms that the nature of the funds was proceeds of crime, the mule can only be convicted of the crime of concealing or disguising criminal proceeds.
Finally,, if it can be inferred from the actor's statements and the evidence in the casethat the actor knew or should have known that the funds were proceeds of telecom fraud, does this then constitute the crime of fraud or the crime of concealing or disguising criminal proceeds?This is the question to be discussed next.
02
Where a person knows that the funds are involved in fraud and assists in transferring the payments, what criminal charge does such conduct constitute?
2015 Edition - Interpretation of the Supreme People's Court on Several Issues Concerning the Application of Law in the Trial of Criminal Cases of Concealing or Disguising the Proceeds of Crime and the Gains Derived Therefrom
Article 5 Prior to the offensewith criminals committing theft, robbery, fraud, snatching, or other such crimesin collusion, where a person conceals or disguises the proceeds of crime and the gains derived therefrom, such person shall be punished asfraud, snatching, or other such crimes as anaccomplicebe punished in accordance with the law.
2016 - Opinions of the Supreme People's Court, the Supreme People's Procuratorate, and the Ministry of Public Security on Several Issues Concerning the Application of Law in Handling Criminal Cases Such as Telecommunications and Internet Fraud
III. Comprehensive Punishment of Related Crimes
Where a person, knowing that the funds are proceeds of the crime of telecommunications and internet fraud or the gains derived therefrom, transfers, converts to cash, or withdraws such funds by any of the following means, the person shall, in accordance with the provisions of paragraph 1 of Article 312 of the Criminal Law,be held criminally liable for the crime of concealing or disguising criminal proceeds or the gains derived from criminal proceeds, except where evidence proves that the person genuinely did not know:
1. assisting in converting or transferring property through illegal channels such as using point-of-sale (POS) terminals to process card transactions and obtain cash;
2. helping another person to deposit large amounts of cash in a scattered manner across multiple bank accounts, or to frequently transfer funds between different bank accounts;
3. repeatedly using, or using multiple, credit cards or funds payment and settlement accounts opened under another person's identity documents, or repeatedly employing abnormal means such as covering cameras or disguising oneself, to help another person transfer funds, convert funds to cash, or withdraw cash;
4. after providing another person with credit cards or funds payment and settlement accounts opened under another person's identity documents, further helping that person to transfer funds, convert funds to cash, or withdraw cash;
5. converting funds to cash at prices clearly different from market prices through means such as mobile phone top-ups or trading game point cards.
Where a person commits the above acts pursuant to a prior conspiracy, the person shall be dealt with as a joint offender.
2018 - Notice on Issuing the Guidelines of the Procuratorial Organs for Handling Telecommunications and Internet Fraud Cases
(II) Review of the Forms of the Crime
1. Attempted fraud where the amount of the fraud can be verified
For telecommunications and online fraud, the standard for determining consummation should be that the victim has lost actual control over the defrauded funds.
(V) Review of prior collusion in related crimes
Under the Opinions, where a person, knowing that the funds are proceeds of telecommunications and online fraud or the income generated therefrom, assists in converting or transferring property through five methods including using point-of-sale terminals (POS machines) to swipe cards for cash withdrawal and other illegal channels, and transfers, cashes out, or withdraws cash,joint crime liability is imposed only where there was prior collusion with the suspect directly committing the telecommunications and online fraudTherefore, review should focus on whether the person assisting in converting or transferring property, before the fraud was consummated, colluded with the suspect committing the fraud, or, although there was no collusion, provided assistance while knowing that another person was committing a crime.
2021 - Opinions of the Supreme People's Court, the Supreme People's Procuratorate and the Ministry of Public Security on Several Issues Concerning the Application of Law in Handling Criminal Cases Such as Telecommunications and Online Fraud (II)
XI. Where a person, knowing that the funds are proceeds of telecommunications and online fraud or the income generated therefrom, transfers, cashes out, or withdraws cash by any of the following methods, and the conduct conforms to Article 312, Paragraph 1 of the Criminal Law, criminal liability shall be pursued for the crime of concealing or disguising criminal proceeds or the income from criminal proceeds. This does not apply where evidence proves that the person truly did not know.
(1) repeatedly using, or using multiple, payment collection codes, online payment interfaces, or the like opened under identity documents other than the person's own, to assist others in transferring funds, cashing out, or withdrawing cash;
(2) converting property or cashing out at prices clearly different from the market through e-commerce platforms, prepaid cards, virtual currency, mobile phone recharge cards, game point cards, game equipment, or the like;
(3) assisting in converting or transferring property and charging a "service fee" clearly higher than the market rate.
Where the above conduct is carried out with prior collusion, it shall be punished as a joint crime; where it also constitutes another crime, conviction and punishment shall be determined in accordance with the provisions imposing the heavier punishment. This does not apply where laws and judicial interpretations provide otherwise.
2022 — Meeting Minutes on Issues Concerning the Application of Law in the “Card Disconnection” Campaign
V. On correctly distinguishing the boundaries between the crime of aiding information network criminal activities, the crime of concealing or disguising criminal proceeds or the proceeds derived therefrom, and the crime of fraud.
In handling criminal cases involving the “two cards,” there is an issue of accurately defining the boundaries among the three aforementioned offenses. The nature of the conduct shall be determined based on the content of the actor’s subjective knowledge and the specific criminal acts committed. Taking credit cards as an example:
(1) Where a person knows that another person is committing the crime of telecommunications and internet fraud, joins a fraud gang or forms a relatively stable cooperative relationship with a fraud gang, and provides credit cards or transfer and cash withdrawal services to others over a long period, such person may beconvicted and punished for the crime of fraudbe punished in accordance with the law.
(2) Where, after leasing or selling a credit card to another person, an actor, knowing that the funds are criminal proceeds or the proceeds derived therefrom, transfers funds, cashes out, or withdraws cash on the other person’s behalf, or provides facial recognition or other verification services to facilitate another person’s transfer, cash-out, or cash withdrawal, such actor may beconvicted and punished for the crime of concealing or disguising criminal proceeds or the proceeds derived therefrombe punished in accordance with the law.
On this issue, based on the above legal provisions, the situations can be summarized into three categories:
-
Knowledge of telecom fraud funds + assistance in transferring funds after completion of the offense + no prior conspiracy ➡️ crime of concealment and disguise
-
Knowledge of telecom fraud funds + assistance in transferring funds after completion of the offense + prior conspiracy ➡️ joint commission of the crime of fraud
-
Knowingly handling telecom-fraud proceeds + participating before the offense is completed ➡️ joint commission of the crime of fraud
The specifics are set out below:
1. Where the money mule knowingly knows that the upstream funds are fraud proceeds and, after the upstream offense is completed, assists in transferring the illicit funds, and beforehand alsodid notconspire with the upstream offender, this should be determined asthe crime of concealing or disguising criminal proceedslegal characterization
2. Where the money mule knowingly knows that the upstream funds are fraud proceeds and, although assisting in transferring the illicit funds after the upstream offense is completed, beforehanddidconspire with the upstream offender, this should be determined asjoint commission of the crime of fraudlegal characterization
Regarding the above two categories of circumstances, the following issues require attention:
-
How is a perpetrator's "subjective knowledge" that the funds are telecom-fraud proceeds established?
In July 2024, the Shanghai Railway Transport Court published a case on its official WeChat account (see the image below): Xu, seeking profit, organized others via Telegram to withdraw illicit cash for an overseas fraud syndicate and to transfer it abroad by converting it into virtual assets or by deposit and transfer.
The article analyzed the legal characterization of his conduct in assisting an upstream telecom-fraud syndicate in transferring fraud-related funds:
This case illustrates that if a perpetrator who assists in transferring illicit funds is to be found to have committed the crime of fraud,there must be evidence proving that the perpetrator knewthat the nature of the illicit funds he transferred was fraud proceeds.
-
Where the perpetrator has subjective knowledge and the upstream crime has been completed, the key to distinguishingthe two offenses is whether the money mule had a prior conspiracy with the upstream crime.。
So what is meant by "Prior conspiracy before the fact, and transfer of illicit proceeds afterwardWhat about it?
According to Zhang Mingkai[i], “a perpetrator who repeatedly helps a specific, identical principal offender of telecommunications fraud to cash out and withdraw funds may be found to be an accomplice to the crime of fraud even where there is no prior conspiracy in words or writing on the surface. In other words, although the first withdrawal constitutes only the crime of concealing or disguising criminal proceeds, where a psychological understanding is in fact formed, the subsequent withdrawals should constitute an accomplice to the crime of fraud.”
That is, Zhang Mingkai considers that the first withdrawal carried out by the withdrawer constitutes the crime of concealing or disguising criminal proceeds. After the first instance of assisting with withdrawal, the withdrawer knows the nature of the upstream criminal conduct; where a long-term cooperative relationship is then established, this strengthens the upstream offender's confidence in carrying out telecommunications fraud, and the withdrawer's first withdrawal becomes an act of prior conspiracy with the fraudster for the next fraud, bearing a psychological causal relationship to the fraud results later achieved by the upstream fraudster. Therefore, the withdrawer should be punished as an accomplice to the crime of fraud.
Moreover, judicial cases in practice, such as the fraud case of Huang Xinghui, Zhong Xuheng, Yang Jinxiong and Shao Yicai, the fraud case of Wu Ruikang (2016) Ji 08 Xing Zhong No. 97, and the fraud case of Huang Zhuying (2018) Liao 08 Xing Zhong No. 130, also support this view.
3. Where a money mule (che shou) participates in the course of carrying out the upstream fraud, the money mule constitutes a joint offender in the crime of fraud.
If the person assisting with withdrawal participates in the telecommunications fraud before the victim transfers the funds (for example, knowing that another person is carrying out telecommunications fraud, the person informs the upstream personnel in advance of their bank card number, virtual currency wallet address, etc., so as to receive the fraud proceeds), because the telecommunications fraud has not yet reached completion, the conduct of the person assisting with withdrawal at that time may be characterized as a successive accomplice to the crime of fraud. If the assistance with withdrawal occurs after the upstream fraud is completed, it constitutes the crime of concealing or disguising criminal proceeds.
However, the determination of the point in time at which the crime is completed is rather vague under the law.
The 2018 Notice on Issuing the Guidelines for Procuratorial Organs in Handling Telecommunications Network Fraud Cases provides only that “telecommunications network fraud shall be deemed completed when the victim loses actual control over the defrauded funds.” That provision does not clarify the point in time at which the victim loses control over the funds—whether it is when the victim transfers the funds to the perpetrator's account, or when the victim transfers the funds to an account designated by the perpetrator. For example, in the multi-level card fraud model, the victim remits the funds to an account designated by the perpetrator (which is also why so many people engaged in buying and selling USDT have their cards frozen). If completion is determined only when the funds are transferred to the perpetrator's account, then all persons assisting with withdrawal would be characterized as joint offenders in the crime of fraud.
In addition, Article 7 of the 2011 Interpretation of the Supreme People's Court and the Supreme People's Procuratorate on Several Issues Concerning the Specific Application of Law in the Handling of Criminal Cases of Fraud provides that “where a person, knowing that another person is carrying out the crime of fraud, provides such assistance as credit cards, mobile phone cards, communication tools, communication transmission channels, network technical support, or fee settlement, the person shall be punished as a joint offender.”
But does “fee settlement” in that provision include the act of assisting with withdrawal? Even if it includes assisting with withdrawal, does it include assistance with withdrawal after completion? Some scholars consider that it is precisely the lack of clarity in that provision that has caused divergence between the crime of fraud and the crime of concealing or disguising criminal proceeds in relevant judgments[ii].
03
Conclusion
The Supreme People's Procuratorate's Report on Procuratorial Work in Combating and Governing Telecom and Online Fraud and Related Crimes (2023)[iii] notes that the number of telecom and online fraud criminal cases prosecuted by procuratorial organs showed a clear year-on-year upward trend, and that the crime of concealing or disguising criminal proceeds became the second-largest category of telecom fraud-related crime, after the crime of assisting information network criminal activities. In judicial practice, because those who actually carry out the fraud have strong counter-investigation capabilities and are generally abroad, making it very difficult to apprehend them, the entities in the intermediate links—such as those who assist in withdrawing cash and transferring illicit funds—have become key targets of enforcement.
From the perspective of lawyer defense, an accurate delineation of the two charges affects not only the defendant's term of imprisonment but also the amount that must be returned or compensated; therefore, an accurate delineation of whether conduct constitutes one offense or the other is of significant importance to defense work.

Recommended Reading
The Police Ask You to Sign a Plea of Guilty and Acceptance of Punishment: Should You Sign or Not?
Lawyer's Warning: Beware of Cross-Border E-Commerce Scams Under the No-Source-Goods Model!


