Special Notice: This article is an original work by Attorney Shiwei Shao and represents only the author's personal views. It does not constitute legal consultation or legal advice on any specific matter. To repost articles | seek legal consultation | engage in business exchanges, please add: sswls66

 

Given the generally negative attitude of domestic policy toward virtual currencies and related transactions and investments, many KOLs (Key Opinion Leaders, also known as internet influencers) have moved from domestic social media platforms such as Weibo, Zhihu and Douyin to overseas platforms such as Twitter (i.e., Twitter, X) and YouTube. In addition, according to incomplete statistics, in the first half of 2023, Chinese-language crypto content increased by 87% compared with the same period last year. After adult-content accounts and political accounts, the crypto world has become another top-tier category on Chinese-language Twitter.

 

Monetizing traffic after attracting a large following through the accumulation of information output over time is the main objective of most KOLs.KOLCommon monetization methods include paid knowledge, project promotion, referral commissions for trading signals, SocialFi and others.
Attorney Shao has previously also provided legal analysis on the risks related to KOLs engaging in paid knowledge (What legal risks should be noted in paid virtual currency community groups?) and referral commissions for trading signals (Is the business of crypto influencers earning referral commissions for trading signals lawful?), SocialFi (Is it lawful for internet celebrity KOLs to issue tokens so that fans can share the dividends? See how Friend.tech and Time Store make the most of the fan economyconduct a legal analysis of the relevant risks.
What occurs more frequently in practice is the risk arising from KOLs promoting projects for project teams.Attorney Shao has handled many KOL-related consultations and has also handled multiple criminal cases and criminal legal risk prevention and control cases involving KOLs.
Author of this article | Attorney Shao Shiwei

 

01

Case examples

1. KOLs promoting virtual asset trading platforms

The collapse of the virtual asset trading platform JPEX has been regarded as "Hong Kong's first criminal case in the crypto circle." Previously, a number of celebrities and internet influencers had promoted the platform. Celebrities and internet influencers who had endorsed or promoted JPEX include Hong Kong entertainer Julian Cheung, Taiwanese singer Nine Chen, Hong Kong model Zhuang Simin, Hong Kong internet influencer and wealthy second-generation figure Lin Zuo, and YouTuber Chen Yi, among others.
According to the JPEX official website, JPEX claims to have "already obtained licenses in Canada, the United States and Australia" and describes itself as a "licensed virtual currency platform." In July 2022, the Hong Kong Securities and Futures Commission (SFC) placed JPEX on its list of unlicensed companies and suspicious websites, and on September 13 of this year issued a warning statement that none of JPEX's physical stores had been licensed by the SFC, nor had they applied for a license.
On September 18, 2023, the Hong Kong police announced that eight people, including Hong Kong internet influencers Lin Zuo and Chen Yi, had been arrested on charges including conspiracy to defraud.

2. KOLs endorsing and calling for purchases of crypto projects

The project team Xirtam described itself as the world's first advanced non-KYC blockchain reputation-building system. According to the project team's white paper, XIRTAM sought to build a free Play-to-Earn game world in which players could participate without purchasing any entry ticket. Starting in March 2023, the project team entered a peak period of promotional efforts, and the phenomenon of KOLs in the Chinese-language community calling for purchases was pronounced. Shiguang, Momo, Crypto Compass, Chongdi and others carried out extensive promotion of the project and called on retail investors to buy. The project team defrauded more than 2,000 ETH in funds through seed-round investment, Dutch auctions, public offerings and other means, and several thousand people were defrauded. The project team subsequently absconded, and the token price fell by more than 90% within a few hours.
According to publicly available information online, the Xirtam project team has been brought to justice in Mianyang, Sichuan, while the KOLs Shiguang and Momo, regarded as the largest suspects, have made no further updates since that tweet on May 3.

3. KOLs posting tweets for project teams to attract traffic and followers

According to a user consultation Attorney Shao recently received (the case content has been slightly adapted to protect user privacy), a certain KOL is a major influencer with 300 thousand followers on a social platform. One day TA received a private message from a project team asking TA to help promote it, with a quoted price of 900 U per tweet. The user posted three tweets with identical content for the project team within two weeks and received a total of 2,700 U.
Unexpectedly, the KOL then received messages from followers one after another stating that the project team TA had previously recommended was a "pig-butchering scam," that many users had purchased large-denomination wealth management products on the platform operated by the project team, that the platform could no longer be opened, and that the project team had become unreachable.

02

Criminal Charges That Crypto KOLs May Face When Promoting Projects

If a project team is suspected of a criminal offense and the KOL played a clear promotional or publicity role in the project involved, the KOL may to some extent be found by judicial authorities to be an accomplice and bear criminal liability. Common criminal risks include fraud, running a casino, and pyramid-scheme offenses.

1. Fraud

In April 2024, the decentralized betting game platform ZKasino was reported to have allegedly absconded with funds. Attorney Shao previously analyzed this case as well (→"Has ZKasino, a Web3 gambling platform valued at 350 million, absconded with the funds? Can domestic investors pursue remedies?"). A few days later, the individuals involved on the project side were arrested by the Dutch Fiscal Information and Investigation Service on suspicion of fraud.
If the project team's conduct is established as fraud, KOLs who previously promoted or publicized the project may, depending on their degree of knowledge, the depth of their involvement in the project, and the extent of their profits, be suspected of forming a joint crime of fraud.

2. Running a Casino

A Weibo user posted in April 2024 that participating in commission rebates on perpetual contract platforms and, as an agent, developing downlines constitutes an accessory to the crime of running a casino.
A KOL may merely post the platform's referral code in a tweet or place an invitation link below a YouTube video, without the KOL itself trading the contracts it promotes. However, the platform system will bind in the backend the persons who enter the platform through the KOL's link and trade, thereby making the KOL an agent in the crime of running a casino.
Under the law, "participating in profit-sharing of a gambling website" or "acting as an agent of a gambling website and accepting bets" falls within "running a casino" as provided in Article 303, Paragraph 2 of the Criminal Law.

3. Crime of Organizing and Leading Pyramid Schemes

For example, in the Plus Token 40 billion virtual currency pyramid scheme case handled in Yancheng, Jiangsu, the project team created the Plus Token wallet and continuously carried out pyramid selling under the guise of providing digital currency value-added services. The court ruled that Chen and others were guilty of the crime of organizing and leading pyramid selling activities, and the persons involved were sentenced to terms ranging from 2 to 11 years. (→"Explaining the Law Through Cases | What Can the 40 Billion Crypto Pyramid Scheme Case Teach Web3 Games About Avoiding Pyramid Scheme Risks?") In addition, according to inquiries Attorney Shao has recently received, police departments in various localities are still continuously arresting agents of this platform.
Under the law, "persons who assume duties such as publicity and training in pyramid selling activities" may be identified as organizers or leaders of pyramid selling activities. Therefore, if a project promoted by a KOL is suspected of pyramid selling, even if the KOL argues that he or she is not a member of the project team, there remains a possibility that the promotional conduct may be found to be suspected of the crime of pyramid selling.

03

Final Thoughts

Since KOLs are called "key opinion leaders," they naturally bear corresponding responsibilities. In every word and deed, they must consider whether they are being responsible to their followers and to the public.
To avoid potential legal risks as much as possible, KOLs must make prudent decisions regarding promotional cooperation with project teams. In legal industry terminology, "due diligence" must be conducted before entering into cooperation, that is, a prudent investigation, analysis, and assessment must be carried out regarding the background and operating conditions of the intended counterparty and the possible risks of the intended cooperation. Whether a KOL is physically in China or abroad, criminal risk must be the primary consideration. After all, criminal jurisdiction in countries around the world all carries a certain degree of "long-arm jurisdiction."
Of course, if it is difficult to determine whether promoting a project will give rise to legal risks for oneself, a lawyer may be consulted when necessary.

[1] An Ordinary Person's "Get-Rich-Quick" Shortcut in Crypto: Become a KOL (2023 Edition) https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/hFs-CQVWUV1H51sv9L5Ijw

Image

Recommended Reading

Lawyer Commentary | On "Guilt and Innocence" in the Nation's First "AI Game Cheat" Case
What Legal Risks Should Paid Virtual Currency Communities Watch Out For?
Is it legal for crypto influencers to offer copy-trading with rebates?
Is it legal for influencer KOLs to issue tokens and let fans share the returns? A look at how Friend.tech and Time Store make fan economy work