This is my 82nd public legal education article of 2026. Today I will share a breakdown, using Justin Sun's long post as a sample, of a tool that we matrimonial and family lawyers often use when handling relationship disputes: the statement of circumstances.
On the evening of August 27, 2026, Justin Sun published a roughly 6,400-character first-person long post on X titled "My Girlfriend Jing Tian." It began with a secret crush in 2007 triggered by a QQ pop-up while at Peking University, moved through nineteen years of fixation, a reunion at the Rosewood Hotel, surrogacy arrangements, a proposal in the Maldives, and a transfer of 30 million to the woman's parents, and went all the way to the egg-retrieval scene in Los Angeles where Jing Tian demanded 50 million US dollars and Claude Code advised him "don't give it," finally closing with "This article is purely fictional; any resemblance to actual persons or events is purely coincidental."
On the same day, his attorney Zhang Qihuai confirmed that Justin Sun had filed a marriage-contract property dispute in the Yanta District Court of Xi'an against Jing Tian and her parents, with an amount in dispute of "more than 30 million yuan," seeking return of the "bride price," and had applied for property preservation.
The most worthwhile aspect of this matter to break down is not whether the 30 million can be recovered—that is for the judge, and many matrimonial and family lawyers will analyze it as well. I want to say something different.
In my view, what is most worth breaking down is this:This long post itself is a textbook-level outward-facing statement of circumstances.In six thousand characters, it turned a bare ledger of "a wealthy businessman transferred 30 million to a celebrity" into a tragic narrative of "nineteen years of secret love ending in nothing, giving everything only to be met with a price increase."
It is by no means an ordinary short essay; every paragraph is laying groundwork for the court's discretionary power.
This article does not discuss predictions of the judgment; it only breaks down how the statement of circumstances is written—how it lays things out layer by layer and step by step pushes the reader (and the judge) into a preset framework.
I hope this will be helpful to readers who need a statement of circumstances.
I. What a statement of circumstances is, and why relationship disputes need it most
In the practice of relationship disputes, one strategy we often use is "telling the story behind the legal claim," usually called a statement of circumstances.
Its core logic is:Legal provisions provide only the skeleton, while the judge's discretion requires flesh and blood to fill it in.
Especially in cases such as betrothal property, custody, and division of marital property upon divorce, the core dispute is often not "what the legal provision says," but "how the flexible factors within that provision are to be filled in."
A statement of circumstances has two versions.
The inward-facing version is attached directly after the complaint or the statement of defense, shown only to the judge, strictly tied to the evidence, and not published publicly.
The outward-facing version is published publicly; it appears to be addressed to the public, but in reality it uses public dissemination to complete the "laying of the foundation for a version of the facts"—by the time the judge reviews the case file, it already exists in public-opinion summaries, the opposing party's defense, and lawyers' case-review notes.
Justin Sun's 6,400-character piece is a typical outward-facing statement of circumstances.
Why do marriage and relationship disputes most need a statement of circumstances?
Because Article 3 of the 2024 Supreme People's Court Provisions on Betrothal Gifts requires that the scope of betrothal gifts be determined by reference to "the purpose of the payment, local customs, the time and manner, the value, and the recipient and payer"; and Article 6, on the proportion to be returned where there is no registration but the parties lived together, requires consideration of "the circumstances of cohabitation and childbearing, the fault of both parties, the actual use of the betrothal gifts, and local customs." Among these elements, "purpose," "fault," and "actual use" are not matters that bank statements can establish on their own; they must be filled in through narrative.
The same screenshot of 30 million transferred to a parent's account: narrated as "nineteen years of unrequited love culminating in a betrothal, with gifts given according to marriage customs," it leans toward betrothal gifts; narrated as "a wealthy man supporting his girlfriend's household during their relationship," it leans toward an ordinary gift; narrated as "joint preliminary expenditure on a surrogacy project," it falls outside the pool of betrothal gifts.
Whoever pins down the narrative first gives the judge a primary reference point for which way to marshal the evidence when forming his or her free conviction.
Therefore, the essence of a statement of circumstances is not "playing the victim" or "setting the tone"; it isPre-construct a causal chain for the same set of evidence, so that the story framework already in the judge's mind when reading the case file comes from your version.
Justin Sun's long letter takes this approach to its extreme. The following breaks down, layer by layer, how it was constructed.
II. First Layer: Purifying Motive — Washing "Funder Mentality" into "Hopeless Romantic"
The first rule of a plea letter: establish motive first, then establish nature. If the motive is impure, all the money that follows looks like an allowance for a kept partner; if the motive is pure, all the money that follows looks like betrothal gifts.
The opening of Justin Sun's long post does not mention money, nor the acquaintance in 2024; instead, it pulls the timeline straight back to 2007 — a freshman at Peking University, an endorsement photo of Jing Tian in a QQ pop-up, clicking open the profile page, sending a friend request saying "Hello," which was not accepted, and never sending a second one over the following nineteen years.
This step accomplishes three things:
First, it packages "acquaintance from 2024 to 2026" as "nearly twenty years of one-sided waiting." Once the time span is stretched out, the nature of the relationship changes. Nineteen years without contact shows that this was not "casting a wide net to flirt," but rather "always having this person in mind." Once exclusivity is established, all the enormous payments that follow automatically acquire the label of "specificity" — and this is precisely the core of the "purpose of the gift" element in Article 3 of the Provisions for determining betrothal gifts.
Second, it lowers the posture to that of a "secret admirer" and "someone who dared not disturb." The brilliance of this posture lies in the fact that it reverses the power relationship. In public perception, Justin Sun is a "crypto billionaire" who "spends money like dirt," while Jing Tian is a "celebrity" and "the pursued." But with this opening posture, Sun becomes "the one looking up," and Jing becomes "the one being looked up to." All subsequent transfers, within this framework, are no longer "a funder throwing money around," but rather "a humble person finally having the chance to express sincerity."
Third, it establishes a "sense of destiny." The number nineteen years was not chosen at random — it is long enough to exceed the ordinary person's romantic cycle, long enough to feel like fate. When the reader reaches the later "finally together," they will not feel it is "two adults dating," but rather "fate brought them back together." Once this framework is established, the later breakup is not a "failed romance," but "fate playing tricks" — the emotional intensity is completely different.
Key points on drafting a statement of circumstances: the motive section never mentions money, only "the person."
Before the judge reads the transfer records, you must first plant in the judge's mind the impression that "this person gave another person many years of genuine affection." That impression will not appear in the factual findings section of the judgment, but it will permeate the weighting of discretionary factors such as "fault of both parties" and "purpose of the payment."
III. The Second Move: Framing the Scenario as an Engagement — Skipping the Ambiguous Phase and Going Straight into "Following the Procedure"
The second rule of the statement of circumstances: compress the everyday details of the romance and magnify the engagement milestones. The judge does not care how you went on dates; the judge cares only whether you were moving toward marriage.
After the meeting at the Rosewood Hotel, the text rapidly skips the ambiguous phase and goes straight into milestones such as "both sets of parents became involved," "discussing marriage," "the proposal in the Maldives," and "complaining the diamond ring was too small."
A normal romance narrative would leave a great deal of daily life — eating together, watching movies, traveling, quarreling, making up — but this piece has none of that. Every scene carries engagement attributes: an entire hotel floor, a private jet, meeting the parents, a proposal, a surrogacy plan.
This is not a matter of writing habit; it is strategy.
Because Article 3 of the Provisions is framed as "given for the purpose of marriage and in accordance with custom." What the statement of circumstances must do isdramatize each element of the legal provision for the reader, so that the reader (and the judge) first complete, on an emotional level, the confirmation that "they were following the marriage procedure".
In terms of concrete execution, every scene has a function:
- "both sets of parents became involved" → corresponds to the "sense of ritual between families" in bride price payments, as distinct from a "gift between individuals." This is also why the lawyer could list the woman's parents as co-defendants when filing suit — the long-form article has already characterized this relationship in advance.
- "Proposal in the Maldives" → This is the most direct evidence of "intent to marry." The act of proposing is, in the legal narrative, "the signature event establishing the marriage contract." The more elaborately the statement of circumstances describes it, the greater the subsequent fall from "frustration of purpose."
- "Complained the diamond ring was too small" → This detail appears incidental but in fact establishes the fact that "the woman participated in forming the marriage contract." It was not Sun alone unilaterally declaring an intent to marry; the woman made demands in the proposal scenario (complaining the diamond ring was too small = giving feedback on the terms of the marriage contract). This forecloses any fallback position in which the woman could claim she did not know he intended to marry.
Key drafting points for the statement of circumstances: cut all ordinary day-to-day romance; retain only scenes bearing the "attributes of a marriage contract."
You are not writing a love story; you are writing "why this counts as betrothal gifts." Each passage must correspond to an element in the legal provisions. When the judge reviews the file and sees condensed versions of these scenes (through a lawyer's summary or public-opinion report), the scales of free evaluation of evidence have already begun to tip.
IV. The Third Layer: Monetary Anchoring—Turning Transaction Records into "Gifts" and Payees into "Parents"
The third rule of the statement of circumstances: money must have a name, and a name must have a recipient. Money cannot run naked in the form of a "transfer"; it must be clothed in the garb of a "gift."
The text expressly states that more than 30 million entered the accounts of Jing Tian's father, Jing Guoqing, and mother, Tian Xin'ai, in the context of "betrothal gifts." This step is the most "litigation-oriented" part of the entire statement of circumstances, because it directly corresponds to the "payor and payee" element in Article 3 of the Provisions and the "co-defendant" structure in Article 4.
The specific approach has three levels:
First level: choice of accounts. The money went into the parents' accounts, not the woman's personal account. This detail is deliberately emphasized in the statement of circumstances because it has a dual legal meaning: first, it conforms to the traditional marital custom of "presenting betrothal gifts" (the man gives to the woman's parents); second, it directly locks in Article 4 of the Provisions, under which "the other party to the marriage contract and the parents who actually received the betrothal gifts may be joined as co-defendants." When the lawyer later actually brought suit, all three could be sued together, and the long-form article laid the public-opinion groundwork in advance.
Second layer: legal characterization of the label. The document does not write "loan," does not write "investment," does not write "gift/travel expenses," and does not write "breakup fee"; it calls it only "bride price." In a novel, this characterization is a narrative choice; in litigation, it locks in the cause of action. The function of the statement of circumstances is to bind the word "bride price" to this 30 million, creating a conditioned reflex—so that whenever anyone mentions this sum in the future, their first reaction is "that is a bride price," not "that is financial support" or "that is a gift."
Third layer: amount and pacing. Round figure, paid in installments, and given before marriage—in judicial practice these three features happen to match the appearance of a bride price that is "large-sum + pre-marital + conditioned on marriage." The statement of circumstances does not need to explain why it is 30 million; it only needs to make the reader feel that "this is money paid according to the logic of a marriage agreement," not "this is an expense incurred during a romantic relationship."
Key points for drafting a statement of circumstances: monetary passages must be short, hard, and specific.
Do not be lyrical, do not explain "why I gave so much"; directly write "to whom it was given, how much was given, and in what context it was given." What the judge needs are anchor points, not emotional appeal. The clearer the anchor points, the harder it is for the other side to break them down later into a "romantic gift" during legal characterization.
V. The Fourth Setup: Fault Placed Up Front—Using a Fictional 50 Million to Provide Moral Guarantee for the Real 30 Million
The fourth rule of the statement of circumstances: create a "greater evil" on the other side, so that one's own claims appear reasonable or even restrained.
Egg retrieval in Los Angeles, Jing Tian saying on the phone "no fifty million, no retrieval," and Claude Code calculating the cash and saying "don't give it"—this passage is the viral flashpoint across the internet, but it is not in the complaint. Its function is not to provide evidence, but toestablish a moral positioning.
Specific steps:
First, portray Jing Tian's side as "the one demanding a last-minute price increase." 30 million had already been given, and now another 50 million was demanded before she would "retrieve the eggs"—once this narrative framework emerged, Jing Tian's image shifted from "the pursued" to "one who inflates the price on the spot." By contrast, Sun Yuchen's 30 million appeared to be "the sincerity of a marriage engagement into which he had been drawn," rather than "money he actively scattered."
Second, use AI to mediate the quarrel and manufacture a "rational persona." Claude Code finished its calculation and said "don't give it"—this remark seems like a joke, but in reality it is establishing "I am a rational person, not a gullible fool blinded by love." Within the judge's discretionary power, "whether the paying party was rational" will affect the judgment as to "whether the purpose of the payment was genuine." A person who was talked out of it by AI resembles "a serious marriage engagement that later turned out to be wrong" more than a person who actively gave money.
Third, use the gray term surrogacy to create the intuition that "the relationship was improper." Mainland China prohibits surrogacy agreements, and surrogacy itself cannot stand legally. But a statement of circumstances does not need it to stand legally—it only needs to make the reader (and the judge) instinctively feel that "in this relationship, the woman's conduct lacked legitimacy." Once this intuition is established, the "moral reasonableness" of the subsequent return of the 30 million is established.
Key points for drafting a statement of circumstances: the fictional layer is not meant to serve as evidence, but to serve as an emotional anchor.
A judge will not accept fictional circumstances, but a judge is also human and will also be influenced by the "narrative framework."
The brilliance of the statement of circumstances lies in this: it uses a fictional 50 million to provide a moral guarantee for the real 30 million—"Look, I did not even give the 50 million; the earlier 30 million was the real hole." What the reader remembers is this framework, not the details.
Six, the fifth layer: a disclaimer ending—"purely fictional" is both a shield and a hook
The fifth rule of the statement of circumstances: the final step is always to leave oneself a way out. You must tell the story convincingly enough that the judge feels "this should be the facts"; but you must also leave an opening so that, if the other side sues you for reputation rights, you can extricate yourself completely.
The closing line "This article is purely fictional; any resemblance to actual persons or events is purely coincidental"—these words are the safety valve of the entire statement of circumstances.
Its function has two layers:
For the public layer: "Purely fictional" turns the long-form piece into a novel, allowing readers to freely circulate, discuss, and gossip about it without worrying about the legal risk of "spreading rumors." Traffic is maximized and risk is minimized.
For the litigation layer: These eight characters are a shield prepared for Jing Tian's side in a reputation-rights lawsuit. If Jing Tian's side sues for defamation, Sun Yuchen can argue that "the characters use pseudonyms, the plot is fabricated, and it is purely literary creation." At the same time, however, three elements in the text overlap with the real litigation: the names of the people, the names of their parents, and the number of transfers and the number of cases the lawyer has already filed. This "semi-fictional" state makes "fiction" look like a clumsy cover-up, and instead reinforces the public perception that "the story in the novel closely matches the real litigation."
Key drafting point for the statement of circumstances: the disclaimer at the end is not meant for readers; it is meant for the opposing party's lawyers.
It means: "You may think I am alluding to you, but when you sue me you had better think carefully—what I wrote is a novel." This is a strategy of "telling you the rules only after the game is over," putting the other side in a dilemma over whether to counterattack: counterattacking amounts to admitting that the novel is about them; not counterattacking amounts to acquiescing in the narrative.
VII. The feedback mechanism of the statement of circumstances: how it travels from the X platform back into the judge's case file
The most ingenious aspect of an outward-facing statement of circumstances is not how well it is written, but that itcan flow back into the courtroomMany people assume that judges do not browse social media, so an outward-facing statement of circumstances cannot influence a judge. That is a misunderstanding.
Judges do not browse the X platform, but a judge's clerk will prepare a pre-trial case-file summary. The case-file summary will include: the complaint, the statement of defense, and the evidence list submitted by both parties, as well as—a summary of public reports related to this case.
On the day Sun Yuchen published this long article, it was shared widely across the internet, and the next day legal self-media outlets and entertainment media would all publish analysis pieces.
These articles will certainly cite the core narrative framework of the long article. When the assistant prepares the summary, the assistant will include as background information that "the plaintiff publicly stated in an article that the two parties had an engagement and that betrothal gifts had already been paid."
By the time the judge formally reviews the case file, what the judge sees is not only cold transfer records, but also a "version of the facts" carrying an emotional framework. This version is not necessarily accurate, but it will become the first filter through which the judge understands the evidence.
More critically, when opposing counsel drafts the statement of defense, they will have no choice but to respond to this long article—either by denying it or by rebutting it.
Once they respond, the narrative framework of the long article is formally introduced into the system of litigation documents.
When the judge sees in the statement of defense that "the defendant denies that an engagement relationship existed between the parties," the judge already has in mind the narrative that "the plaintiff says there was an engagement." This is the return path of the statement of grievance:public narrative → media summary → case-review background → citation in the opposing party's defense → becoming the foundation of the court's version of the facts.
VIII. Conclusion: The Boundaries and Risks of the Statement of Grievance
Sun Yuchen's long letter is a peak specimen of the outward-facing statement of grievance. It applies the five-step laying-out technique of "purifying motive → framing the scenario as an engagement → anchoring the money → placing fault first → closing with an exemption from liability" to the utmost; each step precisely corresponds to the discretionary factors in the legal provisions, and each paragraph lays groundwork for the judge's discretion.
But it also carries risks. The greatest risk is this:The fictional layer is too thick and may backfire on the credibility of the genuine claims.
When a statement of grievance is mixed with novelistic plot elements such as AI-mediated reconciliation, USD 50 million, and surrogacy and egg retrieval, the judge may develop a wariness that "the plaintiff's narrative is exaggerated" when forming the judge's inner conviction. This wariness will not be written directly into the judgment, but it will affect the weight the judge assigns to "fault of both parties" and "purpose of the payment."
Jing Tian's side has adopted a steady response strategy: no long-form rebuttals, only "baseless attention-seeking and see you in court." They will not engage with the novel, only with the complaint. This is the most restrained approach—arguing over plot with someone who writes 6,400 words will always end in defeat.
As for whether the 30 million can be recovered, that is a matter for the judge. But Justin Sun has already proven one thing with this petition:In marital and relationship disputes, the person who knows how to tell a story always holds one more hidden card than the person who can only produce bank statements.
That hidden card does not guarantee a win, but it does guarantee this—before the judge opens the case file, the version of the story has already been written.
If you also have a story you want to tell, but do not know how to tell it so that the judge will take it seriously and it will influence the judge's discretion, you can contact me by private message, and I will guide you on how to tell your story well!
The above content is solely an analysis of publicly available article content and does not participate in any public discussion of the matter.

