"Lawyer, the divorce judgment states that I may visit my child twice a month, but my ex-husband keeps telling the child 'your mother doesn't want you anymore' and 'if you go see her, she'll take you away.' Now the child hides whenever I show up and says he doesn't want to see me. I have the judgment in hand, but the child won't cooperate. What else can I do?"

This question really hits a nerve, because it strikes at the most helpless reality in the enforcement of visitation rights—a court can rule that you "have the right to visitation," but it cannot force a child to love you.

But that doesn't mean you have no options. Today let's sort out the legally viable paths and the practical order of proceeding.

I. First, distinguish: is the child "genuinely resistant," or was the resistance coached?

In handling this kind of matter, the first step is not to rush to court, but to determine the root cause of the child's resistance.

  • If the child is young (especially under 8 years old) and has long lived with the parent with direct custody, and that parent routinely instills negative evaluations and portrays visitation as "being taken away" or "being punished," the child's "not wanting to see you" is in essenceinfluenced by the parent with direct custody, with fear or distorted understanding, not the child's genuine independent will.
  • If the child is older (over 8 years old), the court will inquire into the child's genuine wishes, but it will still distinguish between "the child's spontaneous aversion" and "a statement made after being manipulated by one party."

The legal responses to these two situations are completely different. In the former, you can hold the custodial parent accountable and repair the relationship through gradual measures; in the latter, you can only slow the pace and use third-party support as a buffer—you cannot drag the child into a meeting by force.

II. If the other party "steers the child wrong" and obstructs visitation, the law offers three tools

\1. Apply for compulsory enforcement, but the penalty falls on the adult, not the child

Article 1086 of the Civil Code and Article 68 of Interpretation I of the Marriage and Family Section make it clear: for a direct-custody party who refuses to assist with visitation, the court mayimpose fines and detentionbutmay not compel enforcement against the child's person or the act of visitation.

In other words, you cannot ask the bailiffs to bring the child before you. But you can apply for compulsory enforcement, so that the court admonishes the other party, fines them, or even detains them, forcing them to stop the "brainwashing" and obstruction.

\2. If the other party conceals the child, snatches the child, or engages in long-term instigation of resistance, apply for an injunction against infringement of personality rights

Article 12 of Interpretation II of the Marriage and Family Section, effective February 1, 2025, provides a new tool: where one parent or a close relativesnatches or conceals a minor childthe other party may apply for a personal safety protection order or, by reference to Article 997 of the Civil Code, apply for an injunction against infringement of personality rights, and the court shall support it in accordance with law.

Although your situation is that "the child has been influenced to be unwilling to see you" rather than physical concealment, if you can prove that the other party has longinstigated the child to refuse visitation, falsely claimed that you do not want the child, and deliberately cut off contact between youSome courts have already shown a tendency to characterize this as an infringement of guardianship rights and the parent-child relationship, and it may be possible to apply for an injunction against infringement of personality rights, requiring the other party to cease the misleading conduct and cooperate with visitation.

3. Filing suit to modify the custody relationship — this is the last heavy weapon

If the other party obstructs you maliciously over a long period, causing a substantive rupture in your parent-child relationship, and the child is systematically led astray, while you have stable housing, income and a plan for accompanying the child, you may file suit tomodify custody.

The core standard for a court to order modification is "the best interests of the minor child." Where the party with direct custody continuously harms the other party's visitation rights and harms the child's interest in maintaining connection with both parents, this may itself constitute an adverse factor for modification. Note, however: the threshold for modifying custody is not low; it requires proof that "continued custody by the original party is detrimental to the child," and custody cannot be switched merely because "he won't let me see the child."

III. More critical than litigation: using "progressive visitation" to rebuild the relationship

Many clients demand from the outset that things be "enforced exactly according to the judgment, without the slightest deviation," with the result that the child cries and fusses, the other party records video, and you are accused of "disregarding the child's feelings," which instead confirms the other party's narrative that "you see, she only knows how to pressure the child."

In practice, a more effective approach is to use the "family affection care rooms," "companionship visitation homes" and "parent-child accompaniment stations" provided by courts or women's federations as a buffer:

  • Step one: do not rush into face-to-face contact. First, through WeChat voice messages, small gifts and cards, let the child know that "Mom/Dad is always here and has not abandoned you." These records will later also serve as evidence that you "continuously attempted to maintain the parent-child relationship."
  • Step two: rely on neutral venues. Apply to the court or the women's federation for short, low-frequency meetings at third-party venues such as "family affection care rooms" (for example, once a month, one hour each time, with a psychological counselor present), to avoid tug-of-war in the child's familiar living environment.
  • Step 3: Introduce psychological intervention. Ask the court to appoint a psychological counselor to conduct sandplay and projective drawing, so as to separate the "child's true wishes" from "instilled fear." Courts in many jurisdictions are already doing this. In cases such as those of Zhuangzhuang and Xiao Zhang, the children initially said they "did not want to see father/mother," and only after psychological intervention did they tell the truth.
  • Step 4: Obtain evidence of the other party's obstruction. Each time the other party says "the child does not want to see you," keep the WeChat records; each time the other party cancels visitation at short notice, keep screenshots; when the child says in their own words "dad says you don't want me anymore," keep a recording. Accumulated, these are your ammunition for the next application for enforcement, application for a personality-rights injunction, or even for changing custody.

IV. Pitfalls You Must Avoid

  • Do not forcibly seize the child at the other party's doorstep. This makes it very easy for the other party to countersue for child snatching or concealment, and you become the party at fault.
  • Do not tell the child "your dad/mom is a bad person." The more the child is pulled from both sides, the more resistant they become; courts and psychological counselors can see at a glance who is instigating.
  • Do not disappear just because the child says "I don't want to see you." Your "continued attempts" are themselves evidence. If you cut off contact for half a year and then reappear, the child will be more distant, and legally it is easy to interpret this as "you did not care that much."
  • Do not merely shout "follow the judgment." A judgment is the baseline, not negotiation rhetoric. First use flexible arrangements to repair the relationship; once the relationship recovers, visitation will follow smoothly.

V. The lawyer's suggested order of action for you

If you are currently stuck in the situation of "a judgment has been issued but you still cannot see the child," proceed in this order:

  1. Document evidence of the other party's obstruction(WeChat messages, audio recordings, records of canceled visits) for at least two weeks;
  2. Send a letter or file a lawsuit to apply for compulsory enforcement, have the court summon the other party for a meeting and issue a notice to assist with visitation, and if necessary impose a fine once to establish authority;
  3. At the same time,apply to the court or the Women's Federation for a family visitation room/psychological intervention, and include "progressive visitation" in the enforcement settlement;
  4. If the other party continues to instigate and the child is led astray with no improvement,assess filing a lawsuit to change custodythe feasibility of;
  5. Maintain the posture of "I just want to spend quality time with my child" throughout the process. Do not curse at anyone on WeChat and do not threaten or cause a scene—your composure is the most valuable asset you have in court.

Flowers bloom and fall in their season; relationships arise and end in their time. Divorce severs the spousal relationship, but it cannot sever the parent-child relationship. If your child is avoiding you now, it is not necessarily hatred—someone may have blocked the path.

You need to clear that path bit by bit, not batter the wall down harder.

If you too have obtained a visitation rights judgment but still cannot see your child, send me a private message with "visitation rights + your current situation."

I will help you with three things:

First, help you determine whether your child's resistance is the result of instigation or genuine willingness, and decide whether to pursue compulsory enforcement or first work on repair;

Second, help you organize the other party's obstructive fragmented chat records and screenshots of canceled visitations into an evidence chain that the court will recognize;

Third, help you design a progressive visitation plan (video calls → meetings at a third-party venue → short pick-ups and drop-offs), and schedule it together with the timing for applying for a personality rights infringement injunction and for modifying custody.

Last month, I helped a client whose child had not answered her calls for two years after being taken by her ex-husband. Using a combination of a "family care room + psychological sand tray + two enforcement interviews," by the third month the child ran into her arms voluntarily at the supervised visitation station. The judge later told me: you did not force it, and that is why the child came back.

Click follow; consultations are free—just consider it making a friend.

But do not wait until your child has been taken so far that they no longer recognize you—the parent-child relationship also has a window period, and once that point is passed, even the law cannot pull it back.

— Notes of a Family Lawyer · For everyone who holds a judgment yet cannot hold their child —