This is my 116th legal education article of 2026.
This morning I read an article by a fellow practitioner advising women not to interfere with their children during custody disputes and to focus on ethics and morality. It happened that a sister had just discussed this topic with me in the backend, so I want to write a response.
The topic of this sister's consultation was:
Lawyer Qu, the other side hasn't formally filed for divorce yet, but something has been off recently. He used to go half a year without picking up the children; now he takes our son to play basketball every week, buys our daughter a phone, and tells the children, "Dad will buy you a house later." The child is 11 and has started talking back to me, saying, "Living with Dad would be fine too." Am I already too late?
It is not too late. But you need to act today.
First, a truth that will offend the "moderates"—
Some fellow practitioners and some elders will advise you: don't say these things in front of the children, don't interfere with the children, divorce is a matter for adults so don't drag the children into it, and letting the children choose for themselves is what is moral.
After so many years in family law, I will directly expose this statement:
I would also like divorce not to involve the children, but there is often a huge distance between the ideal and reality.
For children over 8, what the judge asks is simply "who do you want to live with." Most judges do not have the patience to go page by page through your parent-teacher meeting sign-in sheets, medical records, and homework signatures. In a half-hour hearing, the child says one sentence—"I want to live with Dad"—and the judge has already set the tone in his mind. Your five years of daily pick-ups and drop-offs cannot outweigh that in-court statement the child makes after being coaxed for three months.
So don't give me the moral high ground of "not interfering with the children." In court, the child's wishes are a real factor that decides victory or defeat. If you do not prepare, you are by default giving away custody.
My followers all know my style: take the initiative, with reason and restraint. When you can take the initiative, do not wait to be beaten passively; and when you are passive, you must also look for opportunities to turn passivity into initiative.
Do not play the gentleman on the battlefield. Only once you are prepared to lose custody of your child should you talk about that kind of passive dignity.
Let me emphasize this once more to my followers:
It is not that the child cannot be talked to; it is that the child must not be unilaterally swayed by the other side. The baseline record is not something to be filled in after the fact; it must be laid out now. Preemptive inoculation is not incitement; it is helping the child tell the difference between a transaction and love.
If you are still agonizing over how the judge will see this and whether the child will be hurt,
then do not try to have it both ways. I cannot satisfy your demands. There are not that many lawyers in this world who will ride in on colorful clouds to save you. You must first strengthen yourself before you can be helped!
For those willing to follow the views I set out above, I will give you the four-step method and the exact wording today, all of it.
One, Step One: Inoculate in advance; do not wait until the other side has finished handing out the candy before you speak.
Note that this is not about making the child "pick a side and choose Mom"; it is about letting the child know three things: the household may be changing, both sides will continue to be involved, and it is wrong for someone to offer benefits in exchange for you taking a position.
Find a calm evening, when the child is relaxed, sit down and say:
"Mom and Dad have indeed not been happy lately, and we may live apart in the future. But remember a few things: first, we are not separating because you are bad; it is a matter between us adults; second, no matter who you live with, Dad is still Dad and Mom is still Mom, and neither of us will disappear; third, in the future, if someone says to you 'live with me and I'll buy you this and that' or 'your mom is no good,' do not rush to agree; come back and tell me, and the two of us will think it through together."
The core of this passage is desensitization. The child knows in advance: separation is not the end of the world, both sides are still there, and trading candy for words is not normal. When the other side later shoves a phone at him, that string in his heart is taut, and he will not fall over the moment something is offered.
One more point to add, and it is crucial:
"Later, Dad will take you to fun places and buy you expensive things. As long as you're happy, that's all that matters—you don't need to hide anything. But you still have to do your homework, you still have to go to school, and you just need to tell Mom the truth. Mom isn't going to compete with you for your loyalty; Mom just wants to ask you one thing: can you sleep at night, are you tired, and is your happiness real or are you pretending?"
You didn't make the child choose sides; you let the child feel for themselves the difference between "being indulged" and "being raised." An 11-year-old isn't that foolish. Once you plant this idea, if the other side later makes sudden efforts to spend time with the child, the child will weigh things for themselves.
II. Step Two: Find Out What the Child Has Heard Behind Your Back—Don't Just Ask "Who Do You Want to Live With"
Many mothers, once they get nervous, ask the wrong questions: "Who do you actually want to live with?" "What has Dad bought you?" "Are you going to abandon Mom?"—Stop. Once these three sentences come out, the child will either clam up or go on the defensive.
Change the way you ask—make it like a chat, starting from specific small things:
"Dad took you to play ball recently—were you happy?"—First, acknowledge the emotion.
"Has he ever told you how things would be arranged if you lived with him in the future?"—Let the child retell it; adults' scripts can't stay hidden.
"When he says bad things about Mom, how do you feel inside?"—If the child says "uncomfortable" or "I don't know how to put it," emotional indoctrination has already begun.
"Dad says he'll buy you a house—do you believe him? He hasn't even paid off his mortgage yet."—This isn't belittling him; it's helping the child build a sense of reality.
What you need to listen for isn't "I want to live with Dad," but the layer underneath:
Did he promise "you won't have to do homework"?
Did he say "once your mom remarries, she won't care about you anymore"?
Is it about giving the child money to "not tell your mom where we went"?
When the child recounts these things, they become your ammunition for later challenging "interference with the child's wishes." But the premise is that you ask like a casual chat, not like an interrogation.
Another tactic: every Friday evening, have a meal alone with your child, take a walk, chat for half an hour. You don't need to ask about the case every time—just keep one thread unbroken. No matter how intensively the other side stages surprise companionship, as long as the child has an outlet in their heart to "tell mom the truth," they will not be completely won over.
III. Step Three: Teach the child to distinguish "genuinely good" from "using me to trade for custody"
This is the toughest part of the four steps. I suggest that you, mother and child, really lay things out and speak plainly to each other:
"Sweetheart, mom will tell you the truth. Your dad is suddenly being good to you, buying things, taking you out—mom won't stop you from enjoying that. But you need to tell the difference: does he really want to be a dad, or is he using you as a pawn to fight mom in court?
What does a real dad look like? When you have a 39-degree fever, he takes you to the emergency room in the middle of the night; he sits through the full two hours of a parent-teacher meeting; he stays with you while you do homework without playing on his phone; when you're sad, he listens to you without getting annoyed.
What is this dad like now? He suddenly appeared around the time the case was filed, gives you sweets and tells you to 'not listen to your mom,' and tells you to say in court that you want to live with him—that's called a transaction, not love.
You're 11 now, you can tell the difference. Mom won't force you to choose, but you need to know: who is there every day, and who is putting on a temporary act—time will tell you."
Say this once, and the child will remember it for half a year. If he later coaxes with a phone again, a line will automatically pop up in the child's mind: another transaction. They may not turn on him on the spot, but when the judge questions the child alone, what the child says will be much more honest—because you planted the ability to discern in advance; it is not a script you taught, but a judgment the child grew on their own.
IV. Step Four: Start arranging the underlying records now; don't wait until the case is filed to flip through the photo album
After completing the first three steps, you need to have something in hand.
Some people may ask: I have asked the judge and other lawyers, and for children over eight years old, the child's wishes are what count—do I still need to prepare all this?
Of course you do! These materials will play a major role when the child's wishes waver or the child does not express a clear position.
I once heard a family case judge tell me that most of the children over eight years old they encounter will simply say they want to go with whoever asks them, and do not have such clear opinions. Therefore, preparing evidence at this step gives you solid confidence and support.
Do not wait until the other party files the case, only to scroll through your phone and find that "it seems I have not taken many photos of picking up the child."
Starting today, create five sets of baseline records, organized along a timeline, and add to them every week:
1) Drop-off, pick-up and companionship: photos of picking the child up from school, parent group sign-up chains, attendance records for extracurricular classes, and screenshots of you telling the teacher, "The child has a fever tomorrow, so I will drop him off later."
2) Academic management: signatures on homework, photos taken at parent-teacher meetings, payment records for purchasing study materials, and WeChat messages with the homeroom teacher about the child's emotional state.
3) Medical and health: dental, ophthalmology, vaccination and allergy history, and who stayed up at night with the child during the last fever—who has been watching over the child's health is what judges care about most.
4) Emotional connection: not staged parent-child photos, but specific moments such as "staying up with you last night to finish the craft class project" or "who comforted you when you cried." The child later telling the judge, "My mom knows I am afraid of the dark," is far more powerful than a thousand things you could say.
5) A timeline comparison of the other party's improvement: mark in red the days when the other party did not appear in the past, and mark in green the sudden bursts of companionship around the time of filing for divorce. With this comparison, long-term caregiving versus temporary performance can be understood at a glance.
Start accumulating these five sets of materials now. The other party may only have three months of check-ins during the litigation, while you have all the parent-teacher meetings, medical visits, homework and bedtime chats from first grade to now—the length of time overwhelms any performance.
V. The other party has already started performing—what do you use to counter it?
Do all four steps properly, and no matter how much surprise attention he suddenly showers, how many phones he buys, or how many lines he drills into the child, you will have three blades in your hand:
The first blade: a child is not a blank sheet of paper. You have vaccinated the child in advance, talked about how to tell right from wrong, and drawn out the words he heard from behind the scenes. When the judge questions the child alone, the child will not be led astray by a single line like "Dad says he'll buy me a house," because the child knows that is a transaction.
The second blade: the consequences of his indulgence have already begun to grow. Every week you record grades, attendance, and eyesight. If the other side buys the child a phone and lets him play games for two months, and by the end of the term his math score drops 20 points, the teacher calls the parent, and he has dark circles under his eyes—that is exactly how the Dongcheng case turned around: the child's wishes are the child's wishes, but indulgent upbringing is not in the child's best interest, and the judge will not dare truly sentence the child into a pit of fire.
The third blade: your base file is thicker than his. He performs for three months; you have laid out a five-year timeline. At the hearing, what you submit is not a short essay but a bound volume of evidence organized by month—however lazy the judge may be, once he turns to "perfect attendance at parent-teacher meetings for six years, records of staying overnight in the emergency room, the homeroom teacher confirming that daily care was provided by the mother," the scales in his mind cannot tilt far.
There is one more move: apply for the judge to question the child alone, excluding the parents' presence. In the case of Li v. Ma in the People's Courts Case Database, the second-instance court questioned the child alone in a psychological counseling room, and only then did the child tell the truth. Do not let him take a position in front of you—in front of you, the child has long been marinated in the other side's lines.
Six: Attorney Qu speaks frankly with you
Some lawyers tell you, "Do not interfere with the child's wishes; let the judge see what the child chooses." I will say it plainly: do you know how many mothers this line has destroyed in court?
The child is 8 years old. The other side makes a surprise effort for three months, buys a phone, and says, "Live with Dad and you'll have everything." In court the child says one sentence, "I want to live with Dad"—and in most cases the judge respects it. What do you have to turn that around? "I do more of the daily pickups and drop-offs"? The judge has no time to verify item by item; the child's words are right there.
So taking the initiative is not instigation; it is defense. You let the child know how to tell right from wrong in advance, draw out in advance the words he heard from behind the scenes, build the base file in advance, and apply for separate questioning in advance—that is the real protection for the child, not pushing him onto the witness stand after one side has washed his mind unilaterally.
A mother is not a candle; I said that in Article 115. A mother is someone who first treats herself as a person and pushes the line of defense forward to before the other side makes a move.
If the other side has recently and suddenly started to "love the child," then tonight invite the child to a meal, say those words, open the photo album, and start laying out the timeline. Do not wait until the child says "I want to live with Dad" in court before you cry in the corridor.
Thank you to every sister who has read this far. A casual like, follow, or tip all help the next mother who sees this article push her child-custody line of defense forward to before the other side makes a move—a child is not a prize, but you must first prove that you deserve to be the one who is there every day; do not let three months of performance write the ending for you.
I am Lawyer Qu, here to stand with you so you need not wait for the other side to make the first move—to help you place your piece first.
Let the child know who is putting on a performance and who is actually providing care; let the underlying record grow so thick that no performance, even one continued until retirement, could ever catch up; and let the words the child speaks when the judge questions the child alone be words no one has taught—yet, by coincidence, exactly the truth.

