This is my 158th legal education article of 2026.
The previous three articles covered the "preparation, offense, and defense" of negotiation. But in practice, what is truly difficult is often not the two hours spent sitting down to negotiate, but ratherhis hot-and-cold, push-and-pull probing before and during the negotiation.
A follower left a particularly typical comment in the backend, and I will quote her exact words:
"Attorney Qu, his attitude was extremely firm before, saying he wanted a divorce and wanted to be with the third party. From his previous behavior, I predicted he was about to confront me and negotiate a separation. But this time he suddenly took the initiative to say he wanted to return to the family—the contrast was so stark that I was momentarily at a loss. I guess it is very likely that my cold treatment over the past few days made him realize I am re-examining this marriage, and that I am no longer the person who would never leave him no matter what."
Is she right? The general direction is completely right. But I must add something even more pointed for her:
He believes that "whether to divorce and whom to choose" is within his control. That is why he dares to probe you with hot-and-cold behavior. The moment you lean in, he knows you are still the same as before; the moment you go cold, he panics and comes a little closer to test again.
Today's article is specifically about how, during the "probing period" before negotiation, to seize the initiative firmly through psychological offense and defense.
I. First, understand what his "probing" looks like
Do not be fooled by his superficial flip-flopping. Probing takes only these few forms:
- Hot and cold. The day before yesterday he would not even give you the time of day; today he suddenly takes the initiative to do housework and ask about the children. It is not that his conscience has awakened—he is testing the temperature of your reaction.
- Making threats and then retracting them. After saying "this marriage is unbearable," they see you did not try to hold them back, and a couple of days later they start talking to you again on their own initiative. This is pressure to make you declare your position and see whether you will be the first to soften.
- A sudden "return"-style show of affection. Just like what this follower encountered—previously insisting on divorce, then suddenly saying "I've thought it through; for the child's sake, let's make a good life together." This kind of reversal is often not a genuine change of heart, but ratherHe realized you had let go, and he panicked.
- Suddenly acting normal after cold violence. Not speaking to you for several days, then one day chatting with you as if nothing happened. This is observation: whether you will take the initiative to break the deadlock and seek reconciliation.
II. The essence of testing: he is confirming "will you still be unable to leave me"
Put plainly, it comes down to one sentence:All of his testing is to confirm whether your bottom line is still there.
The moment you take the bait, respond, or cling to him, he knows: oh, so I am still in control of the whole situation. Then the terms previously agreed upon, he can go back on; the mistakes previously admitted, he can deny again.
Conversely, if you stay cold, steady, and do not take the bait, he will panic. Because he discovers: so she really is reassessing, so she really can leave.
III. How to respond: respond to shifting circumstances by holding steady and letting him reveal his hand
In the case involving the follower, my reply was:
"Since he is giving you the cold shoulder, you should respond coolly as well. He may come closer to see whether you will immediately cling to him—do not cling. Continue to maintain a cold approach; the initiative is in your hands, not his. He is the one who made the mistake and, in legal terms, the one without justification. Once he understands this, he can come talk to you. For now, observe quietly and respond to shifting circumstances by holding steady."
There are three actions in this passage; follow them:
First, if he is cold, you should be colder than he is.
This is not the kind of coldness born of spite; it isa calm, distant coldness that puts your attention back on yourselfIf he does not speak to you for several days, go about your own business—exercise, work, spend time with your children, see friends. Do not press him for answers, do not try to please him, and do not take the initiative to break the deadlock.
Second, if he suddenly makes friendly gestures, do not rush to respond.
If he takes the initiative to do housework or show concern for you, you do not need to be immediately moved. Say lightly, "Mm, I see it," and then continue with your own affairs. Do not give emotional feedback right away; let him know: your kindness is not something I am in a hurry to have now.
Third, if he raises the idea of "coming back," do not state your position on the spot.
This is the most critical point. If he says, "Let us live well together," do not say "yes" or "no" on the spot. Just say:
"This is not something that can be settled in a single conversation. First, show me concrete action; we will observe for a period of time and then talk."
Then what should be observed? Observe whether he is willing to do three things:
- whether he is willing to confirm his fault in writing;
- whether he is willing to accept financial transparency;
- whether he is willing to give you time and not pressure you with "are you going to divorce or not."
If he cannot do these three things, then all the "coming back" is merely a delaying tactic.
IV. One Core Understanding: A Person at Fault Has No Standing to Negotiate Terms
The mistake many clients are most prone to making at this stage isbeing soft-hearted.
The moment he shows kindness, you recall the good times; the moment he cries, you think "maybe he really knows he was wrong." Then you take the initiative to back down and to seek reconciliation, handing the initiative back to him.
Remember:He is the party at fault. The one who is not on the right side of the law is him, not you.
If he wants to return, that is possible. But he must first prove that he deserves it. The proof is not sweet words; it isactions in black and whiteagreement, transparency, and time—not one of these three can be missing.
V. The signal that the trial period is over: he begins to proactively propose, "let's talk"
When he is no longer hot and cold, no longer makes harsh threats, no longer uses silent treatment, but instead proactively and formally proposes, "let's sit down and have a proper talk"—
only then do you enter the offensive rhythm discussed in the 155 articles.
Before that, all your actions come down to four words:wait and see how things develop.
He tests you, and you do not move. He panics, and you become steadier. Only when he shows his bottom cards do you respond.
VI. Attorney Qu's bottom-line remarks
At the negotiating table, the most feared thing is not the other side being fierce, but the other side being "soft." Because once he is soft, you become soft-hearted; and once you become soft-hearted, all the preparation you did before is wasted.
The trial period is your test of resolve. If you pass it, the initiative is yours; if you fail it, you return to the same old pattern.
You are the one who has been hurt, and you are the one the law stands with. You do not need to chase him for answers; you need him to understand: only when you do not hold on will he panic.
Giving him the cold shoulder is not a punishment; it is to make him see clearly that without you, he is nothing.
Follow me to understand one more layer, and your home will be a little less chaotic. Send me a private message; consultations are free of charge. Lay out the situation clearly, and I will help you.

