Recently, in See You Again Season 4, owing to the intervention of teacher Zhang Quanling, the conflict between Huang Shengyi and Yang Zi evolved from an apparently irregular daily routine into a deeper conflict of economic interests.
Teacher Zhang Quanling asked Huang Shengyi, do you have any personal property?
Huang Shengyi said in surprise, are you referring to our joint property?
Teacher Zhang Quanling asked very pointedly, do you understand what personal property is? Only property that you can dispose of is personal property.
Teacher Zhang Quanling asked Huang Shengyi, if the two of you were to separate, have you thought about what you could obtain?
Huang Shengyi said, I should be able to find out, shouldn't I.
The topic ended there, and the voiceover was filled with the evidentiary investigation obstacles encountered in lawyers' practice.
I do not know how many married couples in real life are like this, but at least I have encountered quite a few. The typical profile of this type of woman should be: the husband runs a business, while she mainly takes care of the family; the wife receives 20,000 to 30,000 per month for household expenses, and the rest of the money is in the husband's business. It appears that the family has substantial assets, but the wife does not know where the money is or in what form it exists.
The wife comes to consult a lawyer, full of insecurity, wanting to investigate but having no means to do so.
Some even suspect that their husband is having an affair, hire private investigators to tail him, and seek investigations through black-market channels. Moreover, most corporate fund transfers are not that formal; a boss may simultaneously use dozens of accounts for expenditures, and everything appears reasonable and lawful, so how easy is it to investigate?
However, this type of woman is usually also afraid of alerting the other side and damaging the seemingly harmonious family relationship as well as the stable monthly household expenses.
Returning to today's topic, if Huang Shengyi and Yang Zi separate, what can she obtain?
In theory, Huang Shengyi could be allocated half of the collectibles; if Yangzi wishes to keep his collectibles, he would need to pay Huang Shengyi half of their appraised value in compensation.
Perhaps in Huang Shengyi's view, Yangzi is an entrepreneur who earns more than she does, so receiving half of the joint property would be a good deal for her.
However, according to the shareholding information under Yangzi's name, Juli Sling has annual revenue of 2 billion, while nearly 1.2 billion is uncollectible. Even more serious are the payables: payments to suppliers that must be made imminently amount to nearly 700 million, and short-term bank debt has reached as high as 696 million.
The same is true of the film and television companies Yangzi can actually control: every investment loses money. The money Huang Shengyi earned during the marriage all went into the companies, and when she asked Yangzi for that money, the answer was already given on the show: there is no money, it has all been converted into collectibles. There is no money to give; if Huang Shengyi asks for a share of the company equity, Yangzi would probably say with perfect confidence that all the profits were lost, and if you want equity, you can have equity.
If Huang Shengyi proposes to divide the collectibles, in practice a list of the collectibles would be needed: what these collectibles are, what their market value is, and what evidence exists that they are in Yangzi's possession and control. This burden of proof would be very difficult, because Huang Shengyi and Yangzi are already separated, and it is unclear whether the collectibles are in Yangzi's hands or someone else's. Even with the show's video, Yangzi could say that he bought collectibles but never said how many or how much they were worth, which would make the division and proof extremely difficult.
Huang Shengyi is also a contracted artist of Yangzi's company; if the divorce involves Huang Shengyi no longer continuing to perform, she could face a claim for substantial liquidated damages.
Even so, Yangzi mocked the company's most successful IP, Huang Shengyi, saying that she always fails at business: just stay 18, don't grow up, don't try to do anything.
As a family lawyer analyzing what Huang Shengyi could obtain if she divorces Yangzi: what would she get?
Roughly, it would be one lawsuit after another, and finally freedom, along with the two children Yangzi least wants to take.
So, as we often say, in a marriage one must have a self, not only an independent personality but also financial independence. Even if you choose to return to the family for the sake of the children, you should ensure that the other party, who has not sacrificed their own time, gives you a sense of security for returning to the family. If everything is discussed early, we have many negotiation methods to ensure that the self-sacrifice of returning to the family can obtain corresponding consideration.
Some people say, isn't housework compensation very small? Generally, courts support no more than 50 thousand.
I want to say that as long as you negotiate while you still have bargaining chips, you should definitely pursue a negotiation outcome that exceeds expectations. This exceeding of expectations is not functional value but a manifestation of emotional value.
Today I can introduce a very important economic concept within emotional value—the “mental account.” This concept comes from behavioral economist Richard Thaler, a Nobel laureate in economics. In broad terms, when making consumption decisions, people add past inputs and present outlays together as the total cost in order to measure the consequences of a decision. This psychological process of classifying, managing and budgeting money into separate accounts is the valuation process of the “mental account.”
Below are some quantitative calculation methods I previously developed in order to achieve mediation outcomes that exceed expectations—that is, methods for calculating the value of the mental account. I recently shared this quantitative calculation method with a very excellent lawyer colleague, who praised it, saying that he “felt it could not have been devised through knowledge or intelligence alone; it truly takes a person of wisdom to come up with it.”
1. Methods for quantifying contributions made within the marriage:
(1) Directly borne household consumption: classify and calculate our side’s income during the marriage and the amounts paid from our side’s account for the family, including daily living expenses, major expenditures during festivals and holidays, and other expenditures made from our side’s account.
(2) Indirect economic loss from caring for the family: use income such as the income before returning to the family and the average wage in the contributing party’s occupation and industry (for those who have been away from the family for a relatively long time) multiplied by the time spent returning to the family, to derive the indirect loss of time and effort contributed to caring for the family.
(3) A greater contribution to joint property (in circumstances where our side’s income or parental support is greater), and the capital contribution circumstances.

2. Methods for quantifying divorce losses:
(1) Before calculation, expectation management must be done well with our side: if negotiations fail and the matter goes to court, the amount awarded by the court is usually within 100 thousand, and the highest amount I have personally obtained in litigation is 210 thousand. Therefore, negotiating is beneficial to us no matter what.
(2) Optimal expectation: identify alternative loss items that can be benchmarked and specifically calculated, and calculate a specific amount. Taking economic compensation for housework or compensation for emotional distress as an example: ① It is recommended that the amount be calculated on the basis of the other party’s or our side’s two years of annual income (whichever is higher). For example, in Shenzhen, ordinary wages are 10 thousand to 30 thousand, so calculate on the basis of 500 thousand. Psychological research has shown that it takes at least six months to two years to move past a trauma, so the optimal expected amount is the other party’s or our side’s two years of wages.
② Taking abortion loss as another example, this is usually calculated on the basis of the price the other party would need to pay if the child were born, such as at the very least child support calculated up to age 18, estimated at 400 thousand to 500 thousand. ③ Money given to a mistress may serve as a reference basis for property compensation. ④ Where shares cannot be valued, calculate according to registered capital or the average dividends of the past three years multiplied by the remaining operating period.
(3) The most likely achievable outcome: take the midpoint between the two, with compensation for emotional distress of 250 thousand to 300 thousand, which is usually acceptable.


