Succession battles among business dynasties are far beyond anything television screenwriters could imagine.
Yesterday, a real-life version of a high-profile family inheritance dispute reached a temporary pause. Zheng Yonggang, founder and former chairman of Ningbo Shanshan Co., Ltd. (hereinafter "Shanshan Co." or "Shanshan Shares," 600884.SH), died of a sudden heart attack.
Twenty-one months after his death, the "dynasty dispute" at Shanshan Co. has temporarily come to a pause in the form of an announcement that Zhou Ting, the second wife and widow, has officially been appointed chairwoman of the board. To date, the company's chairmanship has changed twice.
Why is it described as a temporary pause? Because the Shanshan group is a family enterprise, with many equity interests held by family members, including the Zheng family and the family of the first wife, the Li family. As the "patriarch" and founder, Zheng Yonggang tightly controlled Shanshan Co. through family ties and personal prestige. During his lifetime, Zheng Yonggang arranged for his son to serve as the top or second-ranking executive at affiliated companies, which should be understood as a deliberate effort to groom him as a successor and was also consistent with the family's interests. This brief cooperation can be understood as forced collaboration amid the company's instability. Whether the two sides have genuinely shaken hands and will move forward together while balancing the interests of the Zheng family and the first wife's Li family remains to be seen.
Let us review the timeline of this dispute over an estate worth tens of billions:
- Zheng Yonggang was born in 1958, with ancestral roots in Ningbo, Zhejiang. In 1989, he founded the Shanshan brand, and in 1996 he led the company to a successful listing. Ningbo Shanshan Co., Ltd. initially focused on garment production and sales, and later transformed into new energy industries such as lithium batteries.
- The controlling shareholder and largest shareholder of the listed company Shanshan Co. is Shanshan Group, with a shareholding ratio of 10.26%; the seventh-largest shareholder is Shanshan Holdings, with a shareholding ratio of 3.21%. Shanshan Holdings is also the absolute controlling shareholder of Shanshan Group, with a shareholding ratio of 54%. It can be said that Shanshan Co. is a subsidiary at the grandchild-company level of Shanshan Holdings. Through a look-through equity verification, Zheng Yonggang held 7.19% of the shares.
- Zheng Yonggang had two marriages. With his first wife, he had a son, Zheng Ju. Zheng Ju was born in 1991 and was sent by his father to study in the United Kingdom starting in high school. He is currently pursuing a Finance EMBA at Tsinghua University PBC School of Finance.
- Zheng Yonggang's second wife, Zhou Ting, was born in 1982 in Hangzhou, Zhejiang Province, and holds a master's degree in Journalism and Communication from Zhejiang University. The two formally married in 2017 and have three children together.
- In February 2018, Zheng Yonggang's eldest son, Zheng Ju, became the legal representative and chairman of Shanshan Holdings. In September 2019, Zheng Ju became a director and deputy general manager of Shanshan Group, and later was promoted to general manager of Shanshan Group in January 2020.
- In October 2018, in an interview with Zhejiang Business, Zheng Yonggang discussed the issue of corporate succession: "I am training my son (Zheng Ju) to take over. My son grew up in Shanghai and is now president of the company, which is part of learning to take over. I said publicly at an employee meeting that the company will definitely be taken over by my son. I am very traditional, just a farmer, and my philosophy is: my son was born into my family, so he should inherit." Zheng Yonggang was lavish in his public praise of his son's performance. He said that his son is only around 30 years old now but is already thoroughly "seasoned." "If you meet him, you can see that he was not born into a wealthy family. As he grew up, my son developed values of hard work and plain living. Many Zhejiang entrepreneurs say Zheng Ju makes them envious, because it is truly difficult to be able to endure such hardship."
- On February 12, 2023, Shanshan Co. announced that the company's actual controller, chairman and legal representative, Mr. Zheng Yonggang, died on February 10, 2023, at the age of 65 after emergency treatment for a sudden heart condition proved ineffective.
- On March 25, 2023, Shanshan Co., Ltd. held the 40th meeting of the 10th Board of Directors on March 23, at which the Proposal on the Election of Mr. Zheng Ju as Chairman of the 10th Board of Directors of the Company was deliberated and adopted. On that day, Zhou Ting, the widow of Zheng Yonggang, appeared at the meeting venue and alleged that the shareholders' meeting was non-compliant and erroneous. In response, relevant personnel of Shanshan Co., Ltd. stated that the election involved no non-compliance or error as alleged in relevant reports and was lawful and valid.
- On March 26, 2023, Shanshan Co., Ltd. announced that relevant market entities had recently paid considerable attention to matters including the election of Zheng Ju as Chairman, and made the following explanation: the procedures for the nomination and election of Zheng Ju as a non-independent director of the 10th Board of Directors of the Company and his appointment as Chairman of the Company complied with the relevant provisions of relevant laws and regulations and the Company's articles of association, and the election was lawful and valid.
- On May 6, 2023, media reports stated that Zhou Ting, the widow of Zheng Yonggang, and his three children had sued "stepson" Zheng Ju, seeking to freeze the 51% equity interest in Ningbo Qinggang Investment Co., Ltd. (Ningbo Qinggang) held in Zheng Yonggang's name.
- Zhou Ting and Zheng Ju announced a settlement shortly thereafter.
- On May 10, 2023, Cailian Press learned from Shanshan Co., Ltd. that at the Company's 2022 annual shareholders' meeting held that afternoon, Zheng Ju, the Company's current Chairman who had previously been embroiled in the dispute over control of the Company, and Zhou Ting, the widow of the Company's founder Zheng Yonggang, were elected as non-independent directors of the new Board of Directors.
- According to the announcement, in June 2024, the Ningbo Securities Regulatory Bureau issued an Administrative Regulatory Measures Decision to Shanshan Group in respect of issues including repeated non-operational occupation of funds over multiple years and related-party transactions that were not deliberated or disclosed in a timely manner, stating that Shanshan Holdings had repeatedly occupied funds of Shanshan Co., Ltd. through methods such as procurement prepayments and construction prepayments, in a cumulative amount of 1788 million.
- On August 6, 2024, Shanshan Group announced that a bank acceptance bill in the amount of 100 million with the Hangzhou Branch of Banco Nacional Ultramarino, S.A. (Macau) had matured without full payment of the bill amount, resulting in the Hangzhou Branch of Banco Nacional Ultramarino, S.A. (Macau) advancing bill payments totaling 59679900.
- On August 28, 2024, Shanshan Group announced that loan interest of 11707 thousand, originally scheduled to be paid to multiple banks on August 21, had not been paid on time. The banks involved included ten banks, including the Ningbo Branch of China Zheshang Bank, the Ningbo Sub-branch of Yinzhou Rural Commercial Bank, and the Ningbo Branch of China Minsheng Bank.
- On November 7, 2024, Shanshan Co., Ltd. announced that, due to overdue debts under margin financing and securities lending business of Shanshan Group, the 65230 thousand shares of the Company held by Shanshan Group through its Guotai Junan customer credit trading collateral securities account were at risk of forced liquidation.
- For the first three quarters of 2024, Shanshan Co., Ltd. reported operating revenue of 13284 million, a decrease of 9.69% compared with the same period of the previous year (year-on-year); net profit attributable to shareholders of the listed company was 23212900, a sharp year-on-year decrease of 98.07%. Regarding the decline in performance, Shanshan Co., Ltd. explained that during the reporting period, the decline in the Company's performance was mainly affected by cyclical changes in the polarizer business and anode business industries, and intensified market competition led to a decline in product prices and a sharp year-on-year decrease in net profit.
- On November 18, 2024, the latest announcement disclosed by Shanshan Co., Ltd. showed that Zheng Ju, son of Zheng Yonggang, had applied to resign as Chairman of the Company for work reasons, and the Board of Directors elected Zhou Ting, the second wife and widow, as Chairman of the 11th Board of Directors of the Company. That evening, Zhou Ting also published A Letter to All Shanshan Colleagues. "Today, Zheng Ju and I completed the handover of work. We will unite as one, make concerted efforts, and lead Shanshan forward with determination."
The legal issues behind the inheritance dispute in a billionaire family:
- During his lifetime, the late chairman did not provide his heirs with a legally valid will.
During his lifetime, the late chairman had publicly stated in the media that he intended to groom his son as his successor; however, after the late chairman's death, a dispute over the estate still arose. The reasons behind this are ones we have encountered more than once in our practice: he believed he could still take on burdens despite his age and did not foresee the unexpected risk of suddenly becoming outdated, and therefore,
did not leave a legally valid will
Had a legally valid will been left, the stepmother would not have been able to openly file a lawsuit in court, seek property preservation, and have the equity sealed.
Some may ask: did the late chairman not already say during an interview that he wanted his son to take over, and did he not also mention this at a public employee meeting? Can that not serve as a will?
Of course not! A will is subject to strict formal requirements, and once it is confirmed invalid, even what the decedent wrote in black and white may be invalid.
The Succession Part of the Civil Code of the People's Republic of China retains the five forms of wills under the former Succession Law: holographic wills, witnessed wills, audio-recorded wills, oral wills, and notarized wills, and adds two statutory forms of wills, namely printed wills and video-recorded wills.
Given the limited space, I can only first illustrate with examples the common circumstances in which holographic wills are invalid:
① The holographic will is not signed at the end; instead, only the words "My name is Zhang San" are written at the beginning of the will.
② The testator has the ability to write, but the holographic will is not signed with a name at the end; instead, only a name seal is affixed or a fingerprint is pressed.
③ The holographic will does not state the year, month, and day at the end; instead, the will content states, "I am ninety-three years old today."
④ The validity of alterations, additions, and deletions in a holographic will. A holographic will should avoid extensive alterations, additions, and deletions as far as possible; the testator should sign and confirm the places altered, added, or deleted and state the year, month, and day.
- The listed company, which appears to be thriving, has long had holes that cannot all be plugged, and the actual controller still faces a risk of change.
At present, approximately 633 million shares of Shanshan Co., Ltd. held by Shanshan Group have already been subject to successive rounds of freezing, accounting for 80.89% of the total shares of the company held by it and 28.08% of the company's total share capital. As of the date of the announcement, Shanshan Group's total interest-bearing liabilities on a consolidated basis (excluding the listed company Shanshan Co., Ltd.) amounted to 12265 million yuan, of which short-term debt due within one year amounted to 11420 million yuan.
Such a capital chain condition undoubtedly brings enormous risk to Shanshan Co., Ltd. Once the debt cannot be repaid in a timely manner, the company's equity may be subject to forced liquidation, which in turn may trigger a change of control. For any listed company, this is an unbearable burden.
In order to resolve the Group's debt problems, there are indications that before Zheng Yonggang's death, he very likely took money from the listed companies under his control in certain ways to plug the holes. According to public information, the main listed companies currently controlled within the Shanshan system are Shanshan Co., Ltd. and Yongshan Lithium (603399.SH); as of November 18, the market values of the two companies were 21700 million and 5600 million, respectively.
In fact, due to the rupture of the Shanshan system's capital chain, control of Yongshan Lithium is already precarious.
On November 14, Yongshan Lithium (603399.SH), a listed company under the Shanshan system, issued an announcement stating that 102 million shares of the company held by its controlling shareholder, Ningbo Jutai, had been subject to judicial auction, and Yongrong Zhisheng, a company under Yongrong Holdings, won the bid for the aforementioned shares at a consideration of 804 million yuan.
After the judicial auction is completed, Yongrong Zhisheng will replace Ningbo Jutai as the company's new controlling shareholder, and the company's actual controller will also change to Fujian wealthy individual Wu Huaxin.
For Shanshan Co., Ltd., a stable management team is key to maintaining the company's stable development. If this battle for control is allowed to continue, it will not only have a greater impact on the company's performance, but may also trigger a larger crisis.
It is speculated that behind the change of power of the actual controller in this instance there will be
legal steps to divest high-quality assets and poor-quality assets
, so as to overcome the difficulties; this may be the price of yielding power.
We can wait and see how things develop.

