This is my 27th legal commentary article of 2026. Today's topic is a labor dispute that was recently concluded, in which stock rights worth over one million were preserved through negotiation.
In the current workplace environment, an important component of the income of many employees at major tech companies—long-term incentives (such as shares and options)—often becomes the focus of disputes when layoffs occur. Companies generally tend to cancel unvested equity outright, while employees may face the predicament of "a big pie at onboarding, nothing at departure."
I. Case Overview: When "Department Elimination" Meets Unvested Shares
My client, Mr. W, is a senior technical expert at a well-known major internet company and has been employed there for more than seven years. To attract and retain him, the company granted him several batches of shares over the years, the last of which has a vesting period extending to the end of March 2026.
In October 2025, on the grounds of "departmental business adjustment and overall elimination," the company initiated consultations with Mr. W to terminate the employment relationship by mutual agreement. The company's initial compensation proposal was the typical "N+1" economic compensation, but the calculation base was capped at three times the average social wage in Beijing, namely RMB 47,103. According to the calculation, the total cash compensation Mr. W could receive was more than 300 thousand yuan.
However, if he left at that point, Mr. W would immediately lose a batch of shares scheduled to vest at the end of 2025 and at the end of March 2026. Based on the share price at the time, the potential loss exceeded more than one million yuan. Aware of the seriousness of the issue, Mr. W came to me for help before signing any documents.
II. Case Strategy: Buying Time Through Delay, Exchanging "Work" for "Rights and Interests"
After learning the details and reviewing his Share Grant Agreement and other documents, I determined that the core conflict in this case was as follows:The company wanted to complete the workforce optimization quickly and at low cost, while Mr. W's core demand was to protect the long-term incentives he should have received.
If arbitration were initiated directly, asserting unlawful termination and claiming compensation equivalent to the value of the shares, the case would face risks such as a lengthy process, complex evidence, share price fluctuations, and uncertain outcomes. Therefore, I formulated for him a solution of "negotiation as the primary approach, with litigation as a potential means of pressure" and provided specific negotiation guidance:
Stage One: Clarify the Core Bottom Line and Negotiating Leverage:
I advised Mr. W to clearly convey to the company that, given his status as a senior employee, his familiarity with the project, and his recognition of the company and the work, his conclusion was that he did not agree to a negotiated termination. It is important to understand that HR has no decision-making authority; whatever HR says, HR is merely the messenger. To achieve a negotiating outcome beyond the ordinary, one must not negotiate with someone who lacks decision-making authority—no result can be negotiated that way, and it prematurely exposes one's bottom line.
Script: (1) At the company level, simply inform the company of one's recognition of the work and the company, and state that one does not agree to leave. (2) One must be assertive: during the term of the labor contract, the company has no right to unilaterally modify the contract; in the case of a large-scale layoff, the trade union must be notified and the matter reported, so ask them to produce the documents first—but do not raise this point proactively. (3) At this stage, do not respond on specific compensation standards.
Result: On the reply date mentioned by HR, one may take sick leave, annual leave, etc., and avoid direct conversation, requiring HR to reply via work software or email. After HR's communications became less smooth, Mr. W's supervisor proactively came to talk to him.
Stage Two: Grasp the Negotiation Rhythm and Manage the Other Party's Emotions:
I reminded Mr. W to remain calm and clear-headed during negotiations (there is no need to say that a lawyer has been retained, to avoid confrontation, but HR should be made aware that he is not someone to be trifled with or easily fooled), and to focus on "how to resolve this issue efficiently and without risk," avoiding emotional confrontation. The aim is to elicit empathy from the other party and steer toward the solution we want.
Script: (1) At appropriate times and strategically, mention past work performance and past cooperation with superiors' work; one may also talk about the current difficulty of finding employment, family circumstances, having devoted one's youth to the company, and so on, to elicit empathy. (2) Then, in connection with the difficulty of finding employment, mention that a former employee who left a year ago still has not found a job, and that if he were to leave suddenly, he would not know how to explain it to his family.
(3) Propose a transition period, which would conveniently coincide with the vesting of stock, so that it gives himself and his family a buffer period without harming the company's interests, and also allows a proper handover of the work. After all, he is a long-serving employee; if the company lays people off so abruptly and it turns into a dispute, it would also hurt the morale of other current employees.
(4) After going home and telling his family, they reacted quite emotionally and said they knew a very close lawyer; if no agreement could be reached through negotiation, he would have no choice but to assert all his due rights through legal channels, which would lead to greater costs in time, money, and company reputation. After all, it is a large company—if one lawsuit like this happens, others will follow suit, which would be very bad for the company.
Result: The supervisor agreed to communicate with the leadership. Mr. W said the content of this communication would never be disclosed externally, to prevent other employees from following suit.
Stage Three:
Propose a constructive alternative: after the supervisor replied that the position could not be retained, I advised Mr. W not to directly reject the company's proposal, but instead to make a "win-win" counter-offer.
Script:① I understand the company's business adjustment and am willing to cooperate. Is there any other position that could be arranged for me as a transition for a period of time? ② Given that a portion of my important shares will vest in a few months, and to avoid disputes and ensure a smooth handover, may I continue working until after the next batch of shares vests? ③ At that time, I will voluntarily resign, and the company will not need to pay any economic compensation."
III. Case Outcome: Continued working for 5 months, and the shares were safely secured
After several rounds of communication, the company's management, having assessed the legal risks, the smoothness of the project handover, and the potential litigation costs, ultimately agreed to this arrangement. Mr. W transferred to a position in another department and worked there for approximately 5 months, until April 2026. During this period, he successfully received the two batches of shares that were due to vest in that year (valued at more than 1 million), and after the vesting was completed, he went through voluntary resignation. At the same time, coinciding with the Chinese New Year, Mr. W also found a new job during the transition period.
Through this strategy, Mr. W avoided a lengthy arbitration and litigation process and, with minimal time cost and zero additional monetary cost, successfully secured the anticipated shares worth over one million and safely put them in his pocket.
IV. Lawyer's Advice: How Should You Respond to Layoffs and Equity Incentives?
- Proceed step by step; do not sign hastily: When receiving any notice of separation negotiation or termination, especially where unvested equity incentives are involved,negotiate step by step before signing any documentWhat you give up may be far more than you imagine.
- Review all entitlements and clarify negotiation objectives: Immediately review your labor contract, share/option grant agreements, vesting schedules over the years, current share price, etc., calculate all potential benefits (salary, bonus, compensation, equity value), and clarify where your core interests lie.
- Prioritize seeking a negotiated resolution and prepare a "constructive proposal": Litigation is a last resort. Prioritize attempting to negotiate with the company, and, as in this case, you may prepare an alternative proposal that benefits both parties (such as extending employment until the vesting date). This is often more readily accepted than direct confrontation.
- Preserve evidence comprehensively: Properly keep all relevant documents, including grant notices, agreements, screenshots of equity interests in the company's systems, and all communication records with HR and supervisors (emails, chat records, audio recordings, etc.), for future needs.
Conclusion: Equity incentives are rewards for long-term commitment and should not be readily sacrificed due to the company's unilateral business adjustments. When layoffs arrive, a professional legal strategy can not only help you clarify your statutory rights, but also, through effective negotiation, find a realistic, efficient path to resolution that maximizes your interests. Remember, your silence or hasty decision may be your greatest cost.

