This is my 31st legal commentary article of 2026. Today I am sharing the litigation strategy used in handling a case — taking the initiative to open a second front, turning passivity into initiative! (My apologies — I recently rewatched Drawing Sword again, and every time I watch it my heart surges and I become fascinated by strategy and tactics!)

What I want to share with you today is, rather than a single case, a choice of "litigation strategy" — in a family dispute that appears to be an insoluble standoff, sometimes a single precise "tactical shift" can turn the entire battle around.

An inheritance case at an impasse

I once handled an inheritance case. When client Ms. Lin came to me, her brow was locked in sorrow that would not lift.

Her father had just passed away, leaving behind an inheritance lawsuit that was already underway and at an impasse (another lawyer had already been retained, mediation had already taken place, and after talks broke down the case was awaiting formal docketing and trial).

Ms. Lin is the daughter of her father and his former wife, and the opposing party is her father's second wife and her children.

After hearing Ms. Lin's troubles, I found that the true core battlefield of this case was neither the will nor the real property in plain view, but a quiet bank account — funds totaling 3200000 (3200 thousand).

The source of this money is clear: more than ten years ago, Ms. Lin's parents, in the name of Ms. Lin, who was then a minor, purchased eight commercial shops in the east of the city. When the parents divorced, the agreement stated in black and white: "All real property registered in Ms. Lin's name belongs to her personally." For many years thereafter, the shops were rented out and managed by her father on her behalf, and the rent naturally flowed into her father's account; accumulated over ten years, it became this sum.

After her father passed away, this large sum held "on behalf of another" became the focus of everyone's attention in the division of the estate. The opposing party's position was firm: the money is in whosever account, so it is that person's estate.

From holding the line and awaiting support to proactively opening a second battlefield

Initially, Ms. Lin's previous lawyer's strategy was to "hold the line and await support."

That is, in the inheritance dispute case, first answer by denying that this money is "part of the scope of the estate," and wait for the court's hearing; if the court does not support that it is Ms. Lin's personal property, then file a separate lawsuit claiming that this money is in fact Ms. Lin's personal property and demanding its return. The strategy sounded solid: advance step by step and avoid procedural confusion.

But Ms. Lin could not afford to wait. The other party had already applied for property preservation, and the funds were frozen. She was very anxious. What troubled her when she came to me was that the two sides had nearly reached a mediation agreement, but in the end it stalled over this sum of money. Was there no choice but to wait for lengthy litigation?

After I became involved, I proposed a completely different approach: arguing within the framework of "estate division" left Ms. Lin, both in legal theory and psychologically, always in the passive position of a "defender"—she had to strive to prove that what was rightfully hers should not be divided away by others. Why not take the initiative to open a "second front"?

"What is our core claim? It is that this 3200 thousand has been your personal property from beginning to end and has never belonged to the estate." I analyzed this for Ms. Lin: "In inheritance cases, many judges, to make things easier for themselves, will take the view that the property under the decedent's name should simply be divided, and that if you have other disputes, you can seek confirmation of rights afterward. If we lose at the outset, any other lawsuit we later file will proceed after the court's judgment is set down in black and white. In that case, even if we bring a separate suit, the judge in the new case will be influenced by a preconceived judgment. Once we are passive on one step, we are passive at every step.

It would be better for us to make a bigger move from the very start and take the initiative by directly filing a "dispute over return of property" action. The claim is very clear: we ask the court to confirm that the 3200 thousand in funds in the decedent's account should be returned to Ms. Lin."

This is like a large-scale campaign: when the main force is locked in a stalemate on the frontal battlefield, a surprise force goes around to the enemy's rear and strikes directly at its vital supply lines or command center. Once the strategy changes, the whole situation comes alive:

  • From positional defense to taking the initiative: we are no longer defending and explaining ourselves in the inheritance case, but rather establishing a separate case and openly and actively asserting our rights. This changes the psychological posture and litigation position of both sides.
  • Opening a new front and taking control of the overall situation: once the action for confirmation of rights is commenced, it is like opening a breach on the enemy's flank, and the trial of the inheritance case (the frontal battlefield) is bound to be greatly constrained and affected. If we gain the advantage on this new battlefield (our evidence is solid, and our prospects of winning are strong), then the core of the dispute in the inheritance case will be substantially weakened, and the other side may even be forced to seek a settlement.
  • Controlling the pace and the initiative: the other side is forced to fight on two fronts, dispersing its energy and resources. We, by contrast, rely on clear property-right evidence (property ownership certificates, divorce agreement, rental income records) to concentrate our superior "forces" on this battlefield that we have carefully chosen.

The result of the strategic adjustment: breaking the deadlock across the board

After the strategic adjustment, the effect was immediate. Do not forget that the focus of the judge hearing the inheritance case is the division of property under the decedent's name, not the legal characterization of the property. The focus of the judge hearing the dispute over return of property, by contrast, is confirmation of rights. Different focuses naturally lead to different positions in adjudication, and the adjudicative perspective will be influenced by the preconceived judgment formed at the very beginning.

When we submitted the notice of case acceptance for the "dispute over return of property" as new evidence to the court hearing the inheritance case and requested suspension of the proceedings, the direction of the entire "campaign" began to change. The other side had to reassess the cost and risk of fighting on two fronts at the same time, as well as our determination to defend our rights to the end.

Ultimately, before the hearing in the action for return of property, the two sides reached a "package" mediation: the 3200 thousand in rent was smoothly returned to Ms. Lin, and the other estate assets were also divided quickly and smoothly.

Another case: breaking the deadlock by fighting on home ground in a divorce dispute

The effort invested in a case at the early stage and the results it produces can genuinely have a substantial impact on the client's morale, and in turn influence the direction the case ultimately takes.

This brings to mind another case I handled. It was a divorce dispute, and the biggest point of contention was the nature of a property purchased by the wife's parents for the young couple: was it a gift or a loan? If we had proceeded with the divorce lawsuit in the ordinary course, we would have had to go to a remote border court in the husband's locality (somewhere in Tibet), which would be time-consuming and labor-intensive, with enormous uncertainty (if the other side wanted to drag things out, we would not only have to consider the cost of traveling to Tibet repeatedly to handle the case, but also the impact of altitude sickness in the Tibetan plateau on the firm resolve of both the client and the lawyer to press the fight).

In light of the above considerations, we did not choose a frontal "assault." Instead, in Chengdu, where the wife is located, we brought suit with the wife's parents as plaintiffs against their daughter and son-in-law, with the cause of action designated as a "private lending dispute." This took advantage of the rule that contract disputes may be subject to the jurisdiction of the plaintiff's locality, securing for us an absolute "home-ground advantage."

The result? In this private lending action, we clearly presented key evidence, including the transfer records for the property purchase and witness testimony as to how the parents-in-law expressed their intent when providing the funds. The court ultimately determined that the funds constituted a loan rather than a gift. This judgment, like a successful "clearing of the periphery," laid an indisputable factual foundation for the subsequent division of marital property. In the end, the divorce dispute was resolved accordingly and concluded peacefully.

Lawyers are the ones who break the deadlock in complex situations

Two cases, one principle: on the battlefield of family law cases, the ordinary ups and downs of family life make it all too easy for clients to get entangled, and linear thinking can sometimes sink one into a quagmire of protracted struggle. A precise "strategic shift" or "choice of battlefield" can avoid the strong and strike the weak, win by unconventional means, and achieve the strategic objective at the lowest cost.

An excellent family lawyer cannot merely be an applier of the law; he or she should also be the one who breaks the deadlock in complex situations. Amid the fog where emotion, ethics and interest intertwine, the lawyer must find the legal path that best protects the client's rights and interests and most efficiently resolves the problem, seizing the initiative through strategic thinking. This is not only a demonstration of professional capability, but also a weighty trust placed in our hands.

After all, what we seek to bring to an end is not merely a dispute, but the future our clients hope to restart.