YesterdayCase notes on a divorce case involving a custody disputeAfter the hearing, I took the client (the wife in the case) to a quiet corner where no one was paying attention and told her:

I will now explain the following to you orally; please listen carefully. I will then send you a summary via WeChat as well.

Today it was obvious that the judge already had her own thinking and wanted to take the easy route, so things moved in that direction. You should have been able to sense after the hearing that it was originally possible to get a divorce and have the court rule on custody, but now that has changed. Still, we cannot just sit back and wait for an unfavorable judgment. Complaining is useless; we still need to keep moving forward and solve the problem.

We have two paths before us:

The first path is that I go in now and try to secure a negotiated divorce for you, accepting that custody of both children goes to the husband, negotiating that no child support is paid, and clearly agreeing on visitation rights. You also work on ordinary days, so I will fight for sufficiently long visitation time for you on weekends and holidays.

The second path is that we fight for custody. This time we have to face the possibility that the court may not grant the divorce. After the judgment, if you live apart for one year, you can file for divorce again. At that point the court will very likely grant the divorce. The husband and the husband's mother are very aggressive and difficult; wherever they are, they are not easy people to deal with. You must fight for custody of the children. Most likely the judgment would be one child each. One risk is that during this period the children have been living with the husband all along, and one child is over eight years old. When the judge asks her opinion, she may be influenced by the husband's combination of soft and hard tactics and say she wants to live with her father. In that case, it is quite possible that you will not get custody of the older child,

and because the younger child has been living with the husband for a long time, the court may consider that the child's daily life should not be changed, so it may award custody to the husband. That is also possible.

So the second path will be very difficult. If you want to fight for custody, you must be prepared: whether during the litigation or afterward, you will have to face the fierce attitude of the husband and his family, still demand to see the children, and record conversations in which the other side refuses to cooperate with your seeing the children and in which the children express dissatisfaction with the husband. In the end, the court only looks at evidence. No matter how much you suffer, without evidence the court will not accept it.

When you run into shameless people, you can only be fully on your guard. We are now in the litigation period. This weekend you should demand to see the children. If he refuses, record it, and we will send it to the court next week so the judge can see whether he has any sincerity in salvaging the marriage. This will also put the judge in a difficult position and prevent her from simply and easily issuing a divorce judgment.

Until the judgment comes down, none of us can give up. We must keep communicating continuously, preserve evidence, and expose the husband's lies.

Having said all this, you should see that the second path is not a simple one. If you choose the second path, it is impossible for you to simply wait for the lawyer and the court to handle matters. Whether actively or passively, you will have to face the husband.

Go back and discuss it with your family, and give me an answer before next Monday as to which path you want. Once you have chosen, walk it firmly. Of course, as you walk it, I will guide and accompany you at all times.

Neither of these two paths is superior or inferior; it all depends on the client's choice.

Some people choose the first path simply because they do not want to be entangled with a shameless family indefinitely. After drawing clear boundaries, they can still treat the child well in private. From an economic perspective, this is timely loss-cutting.

Some people have fighting spirit and will insist on obtaining custody of the child. If so, they will have to deal with the husband and the husband's family during the litigation and after it ends. Fairness and justice usually only come to people like this.

This morning the wife told me that she had made up her mind: she wants custody of the child. I said that then on Saturday she should contact the husband to take the child to a training class, and remember to record the conversation regardless of whether the other party agrees or not.

In this case, whether it was the judge's attitude yesterday or what I said to the woman today, both are in fact a test of the woman's determination to defend her rights.

If she gives up easily, then there is simply no need to seek custody of the child, because the other side is a family that makes scenes and behaves unreasonably; even if she obtains custody, the other side will most likely not comply with the judgment, and there will also be a lengthy enforcement process, during which conflicts are of course unavoidable.

If she remains firm, then seeking custody of the child is meaningful.

I recalled the judge asking her why, during the several months of separation, she had not taken the child away. She told the judge that she was afraid of affecting the child, that she wanted to resolve it in court, and that she did not want to grab the child back and forth in front of the child as if the child were an object, harming the child. The judge, as if accustomed to such things, said, your family is already like this, and you are still afraid that grabbing the child in front of the child will harm the child? Be realistic; you cannot expect all problems to be resolved in court.

What the judge said is reality. We are not the first to encounter a case of grabbing a child; when the child is grabbed, the child cries loudly, but that does not affect the adverse consequence that the child's existing growth environment has already become fixed as an established fact. A child will stop crying after crying for a while, and there will also be psychological trauma, but the court has no way to help you grab the child. Even if a judgment is rendered, it is difficult to enforce; if you expect to rely solely on court enforcement, the court will not rule that way.

The same is true for lawyers. I will do my best to help you defend your rights, but if you expect the lawyer to do everything for you, that is also unrealistic; where that cannot be done, it creates friction between the lawyer and the client, or even a client complaint. One of my apprentices, in the very first case he handled as a lawyer, was heroically injured, and it arose precisely because of this (People grow through the things they go through.). Having experienced the solitary courage of the early days of practice, a lawyer also becomes much more realistic.

All external forces are the icing on the cake, not timely help in the snow. Those who count on others to offer help in the snow are waiting for a low-probability event to occur.

Only when your resolve is strong and you are willing to take action will more and more people add momentum to your efforts.

I have always wanted to write in this public account about events and people embodying women's strength, and this piece is in fact one of them. When this client told me today that she had chosen to seek custody of her child, I felt her resolve.

This is not the resolve of one or two actions, but the resolve to fight to the end.

I often tell clients that what they gain from a case is not only the judgment outcome, but also the personal courage to face problems and the fighting spirit to dare to make decisions and persevere. This is a form of cultivation; people grow through the things they go through, and no one knows when transformation and elevation will quietly occur.

You see, in anything there is an opportunity to step out of helplessness and gain a positive driving force.

In the end she told me, I will insist on seeking custody of my child; even if I ultimately do not obtain it, I will still fight for it!

Article illustration