Hello everyone, this is my 60th legal education article of 2026, and the second in the series Labor Contract Full Lifecycle Management.
In the opening piece of the previous installment, we discussed how the essence of recruitment is a “resource exchange” (Labor Contract Full Lifecycle Management (Part 1): Seeing Through the “Traps” in Job Postings).
Once you have successfully passed the interview and seen through the employer's designs on your “resources,” the next step is the most practical part—talking money.
When signing a contract, many workers do not focus only on the “base salary”; their eyes light up at “performance commissions” and “bonuses,” which they see as future “excess returns.”
But in labor law practice,commissions and bonuses are precisely the areas most prone to disputes and where employers plant the most landmines.
Today, we continue the discussion on how to turn “paper wealth” into “money in the pocket.”
I. The Essence of Commissions: They Are Not a Benefit, but Labor Remuneration
First, a legal concept must be made clear:Commissions are a type of piece-rate wage and an important component of labor remuneration, not a gift from the company.
However, in contracts, employers often engage in "obfuscation."
As a lawyer, I recommend that you insist firmly on the following three elements:
1. The base must be clear; reject the "sales revenue" trap
- Pitfall:The contract states "a 5% commission on the amount of performance completed." It looks great, but if the company's finance department lowers the unit price of the product when keeping accounts, or excludes freight, packaging fees, and taxes before calculating, your commission will shrink significantly.
- Avoiding the pitfall:The contract must clearly state whether the commission is "based onthe contract signing amount" or "based onthe actual amount collected." If it is based on collections, the criteria for determining collection must be specified (whether it is based on the bank statement showing receipt of funds, or on the issuance of an invoice).
2. The calculation must be transparent; reject "final interpretation rights"
- Pitfall:"The specific commission rates and calculation methods shall be implemented with reference to the company's relevant provisions." This sentence is almost an "invalid clause," because the "relevant provisions" can be amended at any time without your consent.
- **How to avoid the pitfall:**Anything that can be written into a contract annex must never be left to internal rules and regulations. Require that the specific tiered commission rate table be attached as a contract annex. If a policy must be referenced, specify the version number of the policy and agree that "any amendment to the policy requires mutual agreement of both parties." If you are willing to accept, for the sake of this job, that the employer will not put it in the contract, then record the content the other party orally promises, or ask the other party via a workplace chat tool such as WeCom or DingTalk, and after receiving an affirmative reply, secure the evidence.
\3. Payment must be on time; reject "indefinite delays"
- Pitfall:"Commission shall be paid after the project is completed." What does "completed" mean? The warranty period has expired? The final payment has been received? The definition is unclear.
- How to avoid the pitfall:Specify the payment milestones. For example: "Pay 50% of the commission within X days after the client pays the down payment, and settle the remaining commission within X days after the final payment is received."
II. The hidden mechanics of bonuses: Are they a "gift" or a "debt claim"?
Compared with wages and commissions, which are strictly protected by law,The legal nature of bonuses leans more toward the category of 'corporate operational autonomy'.This means that if the contract is not drafted properly, the year-end bonus really does become a 'year-end story' (a tall tale).
\1. The difference between 'thirteenth-month salary' and 'year-end bonus'
- Thirteenth-month salary:Generally regarded as part of fixed remuneration; as long as the employee has completed one full year of work, even if they leave midway, a pro-rata claim will usually be supported.
- Year-end bonus:It has an incentive nature. A common one-sided clause in contracts is: 'Employees who leave during the current year shall not be paid a year-end bonus.'
- Lawyer's tip:Where such a clause exists, in judicial practice, if the employee has completed the annual work tasks, the court is unlikely to support the bonus.The best approach is to specify the preconditions for bonus payment in the contract, for example 'payable upon completion of the annual KPI', rather than 'subject to the company's operating conditions'. If the other party refuses to write it in? Then write it on the contract yourself, and obtain evidence proving that it was written at the time the contract was signed.
\2. Beware of the 'target bonus' trap
Many foreign-invested enterprises or high-tech enterprises include a "Target Bonus."
- Pitfall:The contract states a "target bonus of 100 thousand," but adds that it is "adjusted according to the company performance coefficient and the individual performance coefficient." As a result, at year-end the company sets the coefficient to 0, and you receive nothing.
- How to avoid the pitfall:Ask HR about the historical fluctuation range of that coefficient. If possible, seek to set a guaranteed minimum percentage. At the same time, ask the company to quantify the performance scoring criteria and reject "subjective scoring by the boss." Everything is negotiable; what you should fear is retreating on your own before you have even spoken up, without ever having raised the issue at all.
III. "Commissions and Bonuses" upon Departure: What If the Company Settles Scores After the Fact?
Across the full life cycle of an employment contract, the termination stage is often where conflicts erupt. Regarding commissions and bonuses, there are two frequently encountered pain points:
\1. "No payment until payment is received"
When many sales employees leave, the company says: "The client hasn't paid yet, so your commission will not be paid."
Lawyer's view:If the delay in payment collection is attributable to the company (for example, failure to actively pursue payment or product quality issues), the employee cannot be blamed. It is advisable to provide in the contract: "Where payment collection is overdue for reasons not attributable to the employee, the payment shall be deemed to have been collected, and the company shall pay the commission on schedule."
\2. "Those who leave before the annual bonus payment date are not entitled to it"
As noted above, although this clause is common, it is not absolutely effective.
Lawyer's recommendations:Keep the bank statements and email notifications for the bonuses you receive each year. During negotiations over a forced resignation, you can use the pro-rated bonus corresponding to the period already worked as a bargaining chip to increase the range of negotiable amounts. For example, in a case I once advised on, the employer wanted to negotiate my client's departure on the grounds of poor business performance, and we sought compensation exceeding 2N (the unvested stock awards at the large company, when actually calculated, exceeded 2N). We therefore treated the bonus as a loss and included it in the actual losses, negotiating a departure compensation far exceeding 2N.
(See in detail:When You Are Optimized Out, How to Protect Millions in Stock? Negotiation Strategy Beats Head-On Litigation)
IV. The Lawyer's Tips for Signing
- Overcome your internal barriers and dare to speak up: many people fear that the employer will think they are difficult to deal with and regret hiring them. But you need to make it clear: (1) you are a person who likes to clarify rights and obligations, and you apply the same principle at work, without ambiguity; (2) it is precisely because you want to work well here over the long term that you are willing to set out all your concerns clearly, and what you raise are all solutions; (3) if the employer refuses to hire you simply because you raised these points, then there is no need for internal friction either; it shows the employer has something to hide, and disputes are highly likely to arise later in the work. With a bad employer, identifying it sooner rather than later means smaller losses.
- Refuse blank contracts: (1) wherever there is a blank space, it must be filled in completely and followed by punctuation; (2) where amounts or percentages are involved, figures must be filled in (both in words and in numerals), and no blanks may be left; (3) if the employer orally agrees to your proposed amendments on the grounds that the printed contract cannot be modified but in fact is unwilling to change it, you may propose that both parties' contracts bear handwritten notes, with signatures and dates, and that the process be recorded as evidence.
- Seal the attachments: For attachments such as the compensation system and commission calculation tables, be sure to have the company affix a straddle seal.
- Evidence preservation: Be sure to keep the payslip for the first month after joining and the details of each commission payment. These are ironclad evidence for proving the remuneration standard actually performed by both parties in any future labor dispute.
Final thoughts:
Talking about money does not hurt relationships; failing to discuss it clearly is what causes real damage.
At the recruitment stage, we must identify resource traps; at the contract-signing stage, we must lock down the details of remuneration.
Only by locking the rules on commissions and bonuses firmly into the contract can we prevent them from becoming mere empty promises in the employer's mouth.
In the next installment, we will enter the most sensitive area—"Confidentiality Agreements and Non-Compete Restrictions: Where Is the Boundary Between Taking Someone's Money and Giving Them a Guarantee?"—and teach you how to find a balance between career development and legal liability.
I am Lawyer Qu. Follow me, so that every employment contract can withstand legal scrutiny.
Discussion topic:
Have you ever encountered a situation where your commission was discounted or your year-end bonus fell through? How did you handle it? You are welcome to share your experience in the comments section.

