This is my 61st legal education article of 2026. Today I am sharing LV's first public statement, which flooded my feed this morning, on the "lawsuit against Molly Tea."

In the early hours of this morning, at LVMH Group's first-half results briefing, the CFO's remark that "intellectual property is our absolute core asset" essentially explained why LV sues so frequently and so aggressively.

I am not a lawyer who specializes in intellectual property, but this case reminded me of a similar case I once handled, and it struck a chord (What the LV v. Molly Tea case reveals about the consequences of treating lawyers as a business).

Recently I have frequently seen netizens comment that LV has "gone mad," even suing over toilets (the claim that a Xiamen developer was sued over a four-leaf flower pattern used on a wall has already been debunked).

But LV's first response, which I saw this morning, suddenly made me understand why LV is so insistent about the use of the four-leaf flower.

Because it touches on a fascinating intersection of law and social psychology: can a brand, and indeed should a brand, "privatize" a visual element to the extreme?

I. LV's logic: preserving "distinctiveness" is instinctive

To outsiders, LV suing a milk tea shop always looks like "the big bullying the small." But under trademark law logic, LV's conduct has its own inherent necessity.

We learned in law school that the lifeblood of a trademark lies in its "distinctiveness." Once the association between a mark and a specific source weakens and it becomes a generic name or common decoration for a certain kind of goods, the trademark right faces the risk of "dilution" or even invalidation.

LV's monogram pattern is the core of its brand assets. It is expensive to a large extent because consumers recognize that this pattern represents a particular quality and status.

If similar patterns are seen everywhere in the market, even if only on milk tea cups, over time the neural connection in consumers' minds—"see this flower and think of LV"—will loosen.

Therefore, from a legal strategy perspective, LV's initiation of this lawsuit is a way of fulfilling a kind of "defensive obligation."

It must demonstrate to the market and to the court that it genuinely protects this pattern and will not permit any possibility of confusion.

This is not only for the sake of the ten million in damages, but even more to preserve that priceless "distinctiveness."

II. A Delicate Conflict: When Private Rights Meet Public Culture

But what makes this case unusual—or rather, the greatest risk LV faces—lies not in the legal provisions, but in cultural perception.

We note that the court of first instance upheld LV's claims. This is easy to understand, because under the current legal framework, LV holds a lawful registered trademark that, through long-term use, has acquired extremely high recognition. From the perspective of prior adjudicative approaches, the court's finding of a "likelihood of confusion" has a legal basis. In similar cases I have handled, judges have indeed told me of their own predicament.

However, a legal victory does not mean the commercial logic forms a closed loop.

The core of the problem is that after the first-instance judgment, public opinion began to ferment, and more and more members of the public asked: on what grounds?

The four-leaf floral pattern asserted by LV has deep visual roots in the traditional Chinese baoxiang flower and persimmon-calyx pattern. Such motifs, having endured for a thousand years, have long settled into a public cultural resource.

Although LV created a distinctive composite design in 1896, in the plain understanding of ordinary consumers, "I have never used your products, yet the trademark pattern you applied for exists in my daily life"—and upon further digging, they discover it was created by our ancestors; and digging further still, they find that the creation of this pattern very likely derives from direct copying after the Eight-Nation Alliance forces entered Beijing in 1860 and carried Chinese traditional culture back to Europe (LV first used the four-leaf floral pattern only after Owen Jones's 1867 publication, "Examples of Chinese Ornament," had been in circulation as a best-selling book for 40 years)!

This is exactly where the problem lies! Using the law to privatize public resources—the law has become a tool for profiting from information asymmetry!

This gives rise to a delicate tension: the law confers a private property right, yet the public increasingly perceives it as "public resources being privatized."

Can a trademark with insufficient distinctiveness and innovativeness be forcibly enforced when the information gap disappears?

The answer to this question is: in the perception of the general public, the law should serve to uphold fairness; once it becomes a tool for wrongdoing, those who wield the law as a tool will suffer a backlash.

Therefore, even if LV wins every lawsuit, it has long since lost the public's goodwill in the court of public opinion.

This is especially true of today's young consumers, who possess a strong sense of cultural confidence and fairness.

When they see a large conglomerate using elements derived from Eastern culture to sue local small and micro enterprises, the resulting resistance may quickly and irreversibly offset the sense of high-end prestige that the brand spent enormous sums to build.

In other words, LV is attempting to use legal means to build a wall, but if that wall encloses the space for cultural sharing, it will provoke resentment among those outside the wall.

III. The True Moat Lies in Looking Forward, Not Looking Back

As a lawyer, I have seen too many disputes over the boundaries of rights. I have found a pattern: great brands often win not by holding on to the past, but by defining the future.

LV's Monogram pattern was created in 1896, a miracle of the industrial age. But this is now the digital age, and consumer attention is extremely fragmented. If LV's current exposure comes more from whom it has sued than from what new products it has released (and in fact no new innovations appear to have been seen), then the aging of the brand began long ago.

I have always believed that although the core of intellectual property is protection, its purpose is to incentivize innovation. If a brand relies excessively on a design from a hundred years ago to obtain monopoly profits while neglecting contemporary cultural integration and innovation, then its brand equity is in fact depreciating.

The more you live off past achievements, the less there is left. The fact that it has survived until now already shows that its past achievements were substantial enough to sustain it for so long.

For LV, rather than expending enormous effort on lawsuit after lawsuit over old patterns, it would be better to devote more resources to product design that genuinely fits the contemporary Chinese cultural context.

After all, no one falls in love with a brand because it is ruthless in defending its rights; people pay for a brand because its products are good.

Conclusion

The application of law has never been merely about the law itself

Looking back at the LV case, the court's judgment upheld the authority of the registered trademark, which reflects the legal effect.

However, the pressure on LV's performance in China, together with the subtle backlash in public opinion, reminds us of another dimension of reality.

The application of law has never been confined to the law itself. It is embedded in the fabric of social culture and constrained by public sentiment and perception.

This is not only a challenge for LV, but also a reminder for all of us in the legal profession.

In the many cases I have handled, whether in negotiations or courtroom contests, I have increasingly come to appreciate that:

the value of a lawyer lies not only in helping a client win a lawsuit, but also in helping the client see the social evaluation and long-term impact behind that lawsuit.

For example, the end of a marriage is no longer merely a matter of two people divorcing; it represents the smooth severance of the interpersonal and asset relationships behind the two individuals, and also represents the transition of social relationships from a family community to two independent individuals. More and more people are paying attention to addressing the impact of public opinion in advance.

In many cases, knowing how to weigh "social effects" and how to discern human nature beyond legal doctrine is the key to our success.

After all, the law safeguards the bottom line of the rules, while human nature is the final tribunal that determines victory or defeat.

(This article is solely a personal legal essay and does not constitute any legal advice.)