This is my 63rd legal education article of 2026. Today I am sharing a question recently asked by a follower of my WeChat public account: I was subjected to PUA, we have broken up, can I claim compensation?

I guess most lawyers, upon seeing this question, would think: probably not.

The former me would also have answered directly: no.

However, after coming into contact with real clients in pain—many of whom were already severely depressed and had engaged in self-harm—I feel we still need to step into their world and ask: apart from self-comforting, is there really no legal avenue for protecting their rights?

I. What Is PUA? How to Identify PUA in Marriage

PUA (Pick-up Artist) originally referred to the "art of picking up" strangers; today, in intimate relationships, it has evolved into a form of psychological control centered on emotional manipulation. In psychology, it often corresponds to the "Gaslighting" effect—through persistently denying the victim's memories, feelings, and perceptions, the victim gradually comes to doubt themselves and lose their judgment, ultimately enabling psychological control.

PUA in intimate relationships usually cloaks itself in the guise of "for your own good" or "I love you," and is highly covert. Typical manifestations include:

  • Persistent belittling and denial: frequently mocking and demeaning the partner's personality and worth, such as "You can't even do this little thing right; without me, you are nothing." This is commonly seen in homemakers who are not financially independent.
  • Creating guilt and emotional blackmail: exaggerating one's own sacrifices, using "I have sacrificed so much for you" to induce guilt in the other party and force compliance. This is commonly seen in relationships with mother-in-law/daughter-in-law conflicts or problems in children's education, or in romantic relationships where one party relocates to another city for work.
  • Isolation and control: Belittling the partner's family and friends, restricting social contact, monitoring movements, economic control, and cutting off external support systems. This is commonly seen when the partner's family and friends do not support the intimate relationship, or when the partner has close friends of the opposite sex.
  • Distorting reality (gaslighting): Denying the partner's feelings and memories—"you remembered it wrong," "you're too sensitive"—making the partner doubt their own judgment. This type usually occurs after the first three stages have already been experienced, when emotional manipulation has reached the stage of inducing hallucinations.
  • Double standards: Being extremely lenient with oneself and unusually harsh with the partner, while constantly changing the rules so that the other person is never "qualified." Think of the eloquent partner and the reticent you.

Key indicators for identification: Normal criticism targets specific behavior ("you handled this poorly; let's improve it together"); PUA, by contrast, negates your entire person, and if you become increasingly self-deprecating, anxious, self-doubting, and socially withdrawn in this relationship—then you should be highly vigilant.

It is worth noting that, under Article 2 of the Anti-Domestic Violence Law,frequent verbal abuse, intimidation, and mental harm constitute domestic violenceThe Supreme People's Court's relevant typical cases and typical anti-domestic violence cases also make clear thatsustained PUA, personality suppression, and emotional manipulation within marriage may be legally characterized as domestic violence (mental violence), and victims may apply for a personal safety protection order.

II. Can compensation be claimed for PUA? The key is whether it has caused provable harmful consequences

The individuals who have consulted me about this type of situation usually begin by describing a mere "sense of being PUA'd and feeling distressed," and they need to be guided to recall and summarize whether there were more serious circumstances in their interactions with the other party.

Please remember: the more specific, the more profound.

If you also encounter a friend in such a situation, please ask them further whether there were more serious circumstances, because a mere feeling is relatively difficult to compensate directly in judicial practice.

Circumstances in which compensation may be claimed

\1. Personal injury caused, with a direct causal relationship

If PUA is accompanied by coercion to kneel, slap oneself, threats of self-harm, etc., resulting in physical harm such as a perforated eardrum or external injuries, claims may be made for medical expenses, nursing expenses, lost wages, and othercompensation for material damage, together with a claim for compensation for mental distress.

Of course, it must be noted that evidence must prove a direct causal relationship between the psychological control/threatening conduct and the personal injury.

\2. Serious psychological harm caused, with a formal medical diagnosis

Long-term PUA leading to anxiety states, depression, etc., requires the provision ofA formal diagnostic certificate from the psychiatry or clinical psychology department of a Grade 3A hospital + continuous treatment records + an evidence chain such as chat records/audio recordings/police receipts, proving a causal relationship between the mental harm and the PUA conduct. Emotional low mood caused merely by occasional quarrels or personality incompatibility does not constitute mental harm in the legal sense.

Important correction of understanding: Many people believe that "as long as I prove I am depressed," the court must award compensation; in fact, the key lies in—what conduct the other party committed, whether there is evidence, and whether it reaches the degree of unlawfulness and culpability under legal evaluation.

It must be proven that the PUA conduct is continuous and systematic mental infringement, and that a causal relationship exists between it and the diagnosis of the psychological illness.

Circumstances in which compensation is difficult to obtain

  • There are only subjective descriptions of feelings, with no medical diagnosis or objective evidence;
  • Occasional quarrels or a temporary emotional outburst do not reach the degree of "continuous and systematic mental infringement";
  • It is impossible to prove a causal relationship between the psychological illness and the other party's conduct.

If any of the above three circumstances applies, you have not yet reached the threshold for legal rights protection; you may contact a psychological counselor or seek treatment at the psychiatry department of a regular hospital, and wait for improvement, or for the situation to develop further.

III. What kind of compensation can be claimed?

\1. Divorce damages (Article 1091 of the Civil Code)

If PUA is found to constitutedomestic violence or abuse(psychological violence), the non-fault party may claim divorce damages upon divorce or separation, and the compensation that courts are able to support typically includes:

  • Compensation for material damage: actual expenses incurred as a result of PUA, such as medical expenses, psychological treatment costs, and nursing fees.
  • Compensation for emotional distress: in judicial practice, this is generally within50 thousand, and may be higher in serious circumstances (such as a suicide attempt, serious injury, etc.), but typically will not substantially exceed this range.

Courts find it difficult to support future psychological counseling fees that have not yet been incurred and remain necessary after separation.

\2. In my experience, we usually first seeknegotiated settlement.

During negotiation,family lawyers typically conduct a "well-reasoned and evidence-based calculation of the amount" to strengthen persuasiveness, for example:

  • Costs already incurred: invoices for psychological counseling fees and medical expense receipts;
  • Estimated future costs: reference the course of treatment recommended by clinical advice (for example, an estimate of two years of psychological counseling fees) as a bargaining chip in negotiation;
  • Propose a reasonable range based on the other party's financial capacity and the local standard of living.

The room for negotiation is usually greater than in litigation, which is also whycompensation related to PUA is more easily obtained in a relatively appropriate amount through consultation and negotiation, whereas pure litigation often yields a limited amount.

\3. You may wonder: since the damages awarded in litigation are lower, why would the other party be willing to negotiate?

This is what we have found in practice: people who engage in PUA typically have the following characteristics:

(1) Psychological level: the negotiation setting better suits their "sense of control"

  • PUA perpetrators typically care deeply abouttheir social image(being seen as a good person, a good employee, or a good parent outside the home). Litigation means that the complaint and the evidence bundle will be seen by the opposing lawyer, the judge, and even the court clerk, and some hearings may be open to public observers.
  • They fear thatevidence of belittling, verbal abuse, surveillance, and psychological controlwill be presented in court in a systematic manner, and they fear even more being formally recognized as committing "domestic violence (psychological violence)," which would leave a record akin to a criminal record.
  • Litigation has clear procedures, time limits, and compulsory force, which weakens their sense of control; at the negotiating table, by contrast, they easily fall into the mistaken belief that they canuse rhetoric, pressure, deception, and a mix of partial concessions and threatsto manipulate the situation.
  • Many PUA perpetrators are overconfident that "I can persuade or intimidate the other side," and they underestimate the professional adversarial capacity once a lawyer becomes involved.
  • For them, a finding of domestic violence under Article 1091 of the Civil Code is a kind ofhumiliating label, both morally and legally—something harder for them to accept than paying compensation. Negotiation can use vague reasons such as "for the sake of the children" or "an amicable separation" to conceal the substantive fault.

(2) Interest calculation: litigation is not cost-effective for them

  • In litigation, the court may, ex officio, investigate bank records and real property information, making hidden or transferred assets readily discoverable;
  • if the PUA conduct is found to constitute psychological domestic violence, then in addition to divorce damages, the division of property may also apply thefavoring the non-fault partyprinciple; although this would not necessarily result in leaving with nothing, there is indeed a risk of a tilted outcome;
  • once a personal safety protection order is issued, it may have a potential impact on their employment (certain public offices/specific industries) and social reputation.
  • PUA perpetrators are accustomed to suppressing their partners through quick, decisive action, whereas litigation is aprotracted, repetitive, and not fully controllableprocess requiring multiple court appearances and questioning, which disrupts their habitual rhythm.
  • Some also worry that prolonged litigation may trigger more intense retaliation from the parties and more complete disclosure of evidence.

In short, for them, usinga controllable economic cost in exchange for preserving reputation and retaining control, is a worthwhile bargain.

(3) How can lawyers use this to secure benefits for their clients?

  • Conduct thorough evidence-gathering at an early stage (chat records, audio recordings, medical diagnoses, police report receipts, and materials for applying for a protection order), so that the other party realizes that "if this goes to litigation, I will be in a very passive position";
  • Send alawyer's letter / invitation to negotiate, clearly listing: the legal consequences that may be faced if litigation is initiated (a finding of domestic violence, a protection order, a tilt in the division of property, and the risk of a public hearing);
  • Proposea conditional settlement proposal: reasonable economic compensation + custody/visitation arrangements + confidentiality and anti-harassment clauses.
  • Specify the amount of compensation, the payment time, and the liability for breach (such as doubling upon overdue payment, and compulsory enforcement);
  • Agree that both partiesNeither party shall pursue claims against the other for mental distress or domestic violence occurring during the marriage, and neither party shall disclose such matters externally—This is the part the other party cares about most, and it is also your leverage to obtain higher compensation;
  • Where child visitation is involved, it is advisable to add specific constraints stating that "the child shall not be denigrated or subjected to psychological manipulation in the child's presence."

IV. Evidence Checklist (for both negotiation and litigation)

The following is the "Notice on Evidence Collection in Marriage PUA (Psychological Control) Cases" that I typically provide to clients in this type of dispute.

To help you secure reasonable rights and interests in the divorce proceedings (including divorce damages, a favorable tilt in property division, and the like), we need to build a complete evidence system to prove to the court that you have been subjected to long-term psychological control (PUA) and that such conduct has caused severe psychological harm.

Please cooperate by collecting and organizing materials in accordance with the following guidance:

1. Regarding "what he did": securing evidence of psychologically controlling conduct

This is the foundation for proving that the other party is at fault. Please focus on collecting materials that demonstrate the other party's long-term, sustained belittling, verbal abuse, and intimidation of you.

  • Communication records: Please fully preserve chat records on WeChat, text messages, and emails in which the other party insults you (such as "worthless" or "psycho"), threatens you (such as "if you dare divorce me, I'll kill you"), or denies your memory and perception (such as "you remembered it wrong" or "you're overthinking it"). Do not delete any content, and do not clear your phone's cache. If you have previously deleted or trimmed anything, please recall the approximate time and content. What we need is the complete conversational context, to prove that this is not an occasional quarrel but a long-term pattern of interaction.
  • Audio and video materials: If you have audio or video recordings made in your own living room or inside a car in which the other party insults or pressures you, please back them up and preserve them separately. When recording, it would be better if you can naturally mention the date and the other party's name. In addition, please also pay attention to preserving footage from dashcams and home surveillance cameras.
  • Police reports and protective orders: If you have previously called the police because of his threats, stalking, or door-smashing, please locate the police report receipts from those occasions and try to obtain copies of the interview transcripts from the police station. If you have already applied to a court for a personal safety protective order, please locate the court's ruling. These are evidence recognized by public authorities and are very powerful.
  • Written materials: If the other party has ever written a self-criticism letter or a letter of guarantee, or has sent lengthy explanations and apologies on WeChat, please be sure to preserve them. Such written content often contains an admission of his abusive conduct.

\2. Regarding "what consequences were caused": securing medical evidence of psychological harm

Mere feelings of pain are not enough; we need formal diagnoses from hospitals to prove the severity of the harm.

  • Medical records: Please visit the psychiatry or psychology department of a Grade 3A hospital. When seeing the doctor, be sure to truthfully inform the doctor that your emotional problems are caused by "family conflict" or "long-term psychological oppression by your spouse." Please remind the doctor to write in the medical record that the cause is related to family conflict, and to clearly diagnose whether it is an "anxiety state," "depressive episode," or "post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD)," etc. Please do not only undergo psychological counseling; you must obtain a medical diagnosis and prescription.
  • Expense receipts: Please organize all invoices and payment receipts for registration fees, medical expenses, and psychological counseling fees. These are the basis for claiming actual losses.
  • Other effects: If you have taken sick leave due to emotional problems, or have been dismissed by your employer, please keep the employer's leave approval slips, deduction records, or notice of termination of the employment relationship. These can prove that the emotional distress has affected your normal life and work.

\3. Regarding "the connection between the two": assisting the lawyer in organizing the logic

This part of the work is mainly completed by the lawyer, but requires your cooperation.

  • Recalling the timeline: Please calm down and recall the approximate period when the other party began to exercise psychological control, as well as the point in time when you felt your emotional state clearly deteriorated. Do the two overlap? For example, did your condition worsen each time after he insulted you?
  • Details of daily life: Apart from seeking medical treatment, has your daily life changed because of his control? For example, being afraid to see friends, afraid to return to your parents' home, or afraid to spend money? Please record these details; they can more intuitively demonstrate the deterioration of your living situation.

\4. Important precautions

  • Do not delete the original data: All chat records, audio recordings, and videos must be kept on the original mobile phone or computer and must not be deleted. At the hearing, the judge may require viewing the original medium.
  • Lawful evidence collection: Please do not install pinhole cameras in private spaces in front of the other party (such as a bedroom or bathroom used by the other party alone); such evidence may be excluded by the court for infringing the right to privacy.
  • Stay calm: During evidence collection, especially when making audio recordings, try to remain calm and avoid provoking the other party excessively; let them naturally reveal their controlling intentions, as evidence obtained this way carries greater weight.

Please follow the guidance above to sort the materials you have on hand by category and hand them over to me. We will weave these fragmented materials into a rigorous web of evidence to protect your lawful rights and interests to the greatest extent possible.

The above is only a case sharing and does not constitute advice for an individual case. For detailed consultation, please contact Lawyer Qu (WeChat and mobile phone share the same number: 18721502447).