Today I just finished meeting with a client, and once again it was a client utterly overwhelmed by child support.

Previously, some people asked about giving red envelopes in place of child support (Consultation Record: The red envelopes I regularly give my child—on what basis can they not be offset against child support?). Today, this client ran into a dispute over training fees.

The woman spent 8,800 on a summer intensive training class for her son. The man is unwilling to pay this money, saying it exceeds child support, and he also does not approve of the woman enrolling the child in so many classes, so he explicitly said he will not pay.

She asked me: Lawyer Qu, is there really no way I can get this money back?

I said, don't rush to think about how to get it first. Let's break this account down, layer by layer, and then you'll know how to communicate with the man.

The first layer: what child-rearing costs does the fixed child support agreed in the divorce agreement actually cover?

Most people think that the child support agreed in the divorce agreement is the entirety of the "obligation to raise the child."

In reality, it is a "package price for maintaining basic living."

What does that mean?

It means the law presumes only that this money is used for these things:

The child eats at home, buys clothes, takes the subway, attends a public school, pays for textbooks, and occasionally goes to the community hospital when running a fever.

Note these words: public, basic, routine.

1500–3000 is a common fixed child support amount, determined according to the cost of living in the place of residence and the financial circumstances of the parent paying child support.

This money can buy pork ribs, but it cannot buy private tutoring. It can cover public school tuition, but it cannot cover a bilingual school.

So the ex-husband of the person who consulted at the outset, when he said "I only recognize child support," was not trying to shirk his obligations; he was exploiting a loophole in the document—and legally, that statement holds up.

The second layer: why is it a necessity in your eyes but consumption in his?

The woman was unconvinced: Isn't Xueersi a necessity? Isn't swimming a required course?

I explained to her the actual reasoning a court applies.

When a judge examines a child's expenses, the judge does not look at whether "all the other children are learning it," nor at whether "I think it is useful."

The judge looks at only one word: necessary.

What counts as necessary?

If not learning it would prevent graduation, or if not learning it would violate the Compulsory Education Law, that is what counts as necessary.

Everything else is simply called "enhancement spending."

This includes:

Academic tutoring, foreign English teachers, physical fitness classes, piano and painting lessons, and coding and LEGO classes.

Even the commercial medical insurance and critical illness insurance you buy for your child fall, under the statutory provisions, within the category of "value-added services purchased voluntarily."

This is where it gets brutal.

You think you are lifting your child up, but the law sees it as you unilaterally giving your child a buff and then expecting your ex-husband to foot the bill.

If this was not agreed in advance, he genuinely can refuse to pay. And if you force the court to rule, the court will only support the minimum cost of raising the child.

The third layer: why is "splitting everything 50/50" such a trap?

Some clients are a bit smarter and wrote at the time: extracurricular training fees to be split equally between the two parties.

That is exactly what the woman wrote at the time.

And the result?

Back when the two of you were living together, you would at least glance at each other before signing up for a class.

Now that she is divorced, she feels that “since he pays half anyway, there is no harm in claiming it all.” She is swayed as soon as an institution markets to her.

Every time the other party receives a bill, it feels like a knife to the heart: private coaching for jump rope? Three years of Lego lessons?

The biggest problem with this kind of drafting is that decision-making power and the person paying the money are separated.

The parent raising the child does not have to worry about the money, because someone else shares the cost;

the parent paying the money has no veto power and can only serve as an ATM.

In the end, that parent either suppresses it until depressed or gives up entirely and simply refuses to recognize any of the classes.

I have witnessed no fewer than dozens of such child support disputes in my practice.

It can also be said that this is a continuation of the conflict arising from differing educational philosophies at the time of divorce.

The initial disagreement led to the divorce, but after the divorce, that disagreement was not properly resolved; the dispute continues and is growing increasingly intense.

The fourth layer: how is a plan that can truly be implemented designed?

What I am best at is breaking down conflicts, which is also a common method for resolving family disputes—reducing the big to the small.

The logic of the supplementary agreement I redrafted for her is as follows, and you can follow the same template:

Step one: first, lock down that dead money.

A fixed monthly child support of 2,500, covering only food, clothing, housing, transportation and public schooling; this money will never be disputed again.

Step two: draw a line, called the "no-consultation threshold."

For example, for interest classes and small insurance policies within 2,000 per month, whoever is caring for the child decides, without having to call and discuss every time.

After signing up, send a screenshot, and the other party transfers half directly.

Why set this line? Because for money that small, discussing it once damages the relationship once; better to fix it outright.

Step three: for anything above this line, advance notice must be given.

For example, transferring to a private school, signing up for a full-year intensive training program costing twenty or thirty thousand, or arranging study tours and educational trips.

First send the materials and discuss first; best to give the other party's child's opinion; once both parties confirm on WeChat, each pays half.

Whoever signs up first and notifies afterward bears the consequences themselves.

You see, there is no "take it or leave it," and no "unlimited backstop."

It is about tying money and decision-making power back together.

Fifth layer: looking back, where exactly did the loss occur?

Why can the woman not recover the RMB 8,800 summer intensive training fee now?

For two reasons:

First, at the time only “child support paid monthly” was written, with no rules on any value-added expenditures;

Second, she did not give advance notice before enrolling, so the other party can fully say they did not know and do not accept it.

These two pitfalls play out frequently in many family disputes.

When people divorce, everyone fights over the house and calculates savings, and no one treats “who approves the child's classes in the future” as a serious matter to write down.

By the time the child actually grows up and needs to learn things, people discover that the piece of paper simply cannot cover reality.

A few closing words

I am writing this today not to teach you how to scheme against your ex-husband or ex-wife.

On the contrary, I hope that in the future you will have to scheme a few fewer times.

When you go to the civil affairs bureau, or to court mediation, whatever you do, do not let the staff casually fill in for you that sentence, “pay X yuan in child support per month.”

With these words, you have personally closed the door on all the future extracurricular classes and tutoring lessons you might have given your child.

You need to spell things out in detail:

which portion of the money is fixed, which portion can be apportioned, how big a matter can be decided by one person alone, and how big a matter requires both of you to nod in agreement.

The more words there are, the fewer times you will have to meet in the future.

If you are not sure whether there are pitfalls in your own agreement, go back tonight and take a look.

If it only states the amount and does not say "anything exceeding this amount must be negotiated," then this landmine will eventually explode.

The above is merely a case analysis and does not represent an opinion on any individual case. For detailed consultation if needed (Lawyer Qu, WeChat and mobile number are the same: 18721502447).