We have received many similar messages in our back office:

"The divorce was granted and the child was awarded to him/her, but I get scolded even for wanting to see the child once." "We agreed that I would pick up the child every Saturday, but when I arrived at the door, the other party simply blocked me." "The child was secretly transferred to another school, and I do not even know which school he attends."

Many people assume that visitation rights are a "moral issue" and that if the other party refuses to allow visits, they have no choice but to endure it.

That is wrong. Visitation rights are statutory rights, and obstructing visitation is unlawful conduct.

But merely knowing the law is not enough;litigation is about evidence.Today, no empty talk: here is a "Core Evidence Checklist for Seeking Visitation Rights" that courts accept and judges like to see.

I. First, to be clear: visitation rights are not a "favor" but a "right"

Under Article 1086 of the Civil Code:

After divorce, the parent who does not directly raise the child has the right to visit the child, and the other party has the obligation to assist.

This means:

  • the other partyYou cannot be denied visitation on the ground that "child support has not been paid"(child support is a separate matter, and the law expressly prohibits offsetting one against the other);
  • the other partymay not hide the child, transfer the child to another school, or move to another home in order to prevent you from seeing the child;
  • if the agreement or judgment specifies visitation times, the other party must comply; if it does not, you may alsofile a separate lawsuit for visitation rights(Article 65 of the Interpretation (I) on the Marriage and Family Chapter).

The core of a visitation rights case is not "how much I want to see the child," but "how much the other party is obstructing visitation, and how suitable I am to have visitation."

II. "Securing Visitation Rights: Core Evidence Checklist"

Ordered byprobative value from highest to lowest, prepare accordingly, and your chances of winning will be much higher.

\1. Basic evidence proving that “you have visitation rights” (where the right comes from)

  • The child's Birth Medical Certificate (the strongest evidence, proving the parent-child relationship)
  • Divorce certificate + the filed version of the divorce agreement (with the visitation clause highlighted)
  • Divorce judgment / mediation statement (extract the paragraphs concerning visitation rights)

\2. Core evidence proving that “the other party obstructs visitation” (the key to winning the case)

This category of evidence is the most important and directly determines whether the judge will support you.

  • WeChat / text message / email records
  • Call recordings / on-site video recordings
  • Police reports / police response receipts
  • Records of the residents' committee / women's federation / mediation committee
  • Witness testimony
  • “Visitation log”
⚠️ Note: Do not usecovert GPS installation, forced entry and covert photographyor other privacy-infringing methods to obtain evidence; doing so makes it easy for the other party to countersue you, and the evidence may also be excluded.

\3. Evidence showing that "your visitation is beneficial to the child" (to prevent the other party from turning the tables on you)

The other party often argues that "his/her visiting the child will cause the child to break down/affect the child's studies." You need to prove the opposite:

  • Youhave a stable residence(property ownership certificate/lease contract)
  • Youhave a stable income(salary bank statements, social security records)
  • YouNo bad habits such as domestic violence, alcohol abuse, or gambling(certificate of no criminal record, character reference from employer)
  • PastPhotos/videos of parent-child interaction(child running to you, calling you Mom or Dad, celebrating birthdays together)
  • ChildSchool schedule(to show that the visitation times you request do not conflict with classes)
  • Children aged 8 or olderStatement of willingness to see you(the court will question the child separately; you may have the child draw a picture or write a note in advance, butdo not coach the child)

4. Evidence to strengthen special scenarios

  • The other party is hiding the childPhotographs of the former residence emptied out, returned mail sent to the former address, proof that the child changed schools without notice, and screenshots showing that the other party has blocked you from viewing their social media posts
  • Refusing visitation on the ground that "child support was not paid"Your transfer records for child support payments (proving that you did not stop paying and refuting the other party's excuse)
  • A prior visitation rights judgment exists but cannot be enforcedThe original judgment + the notice of case registration for enforcement + the "Enforcement Record" for each occasion on which the enforcing judge attended but was still refused

III. When filing the case, how should the materials be bound? (The order judges prefer)

  1. Civil complaint(State the claims clearly: pick up the child for visitation every Saturday from 9:00 to 18:00, 7 days each during winter and summer vacations, and video calls every Wednesday evening)
  2. Plaintiff's identity card
  3. Birth certificate + household register
  4. Divorce certificate + divorce agreement/judgment
  5. Printed copies of communication records (with the refusal statements highlighted in red)
  6. Audio recording disc + written transcript
  7. Police report receipts, mediation records
  8. Visitation log
  9. Evidence of own residence/income/absence of bad habits
  10. List of witnesses and their contact details

IV. One-sentence advice from the lawyer

In visitation rights litigation,do not play the emotional card of "who loves the child more"; instead, rely on "rights with a legal basis + obstruction with evidence + a feasible arrangement".

Many people lose not because they have no rights, but becausethe evidence was not properly preserved:

  • Chat records were deleted;
  • the police were visited only once, and no receipt was obtained;
  • several refusals occurred, but none were recorded.

Evidence is not to be sought only when the hearing begins; it must start being preserved each time a refusal occurs.

Lawyer's Summary

  1. Visitation rights are statutory rights, and the other party may not refuse them on the ground of unpaid child support (Article 1086 of the Civil Code).
  2. The core evidence falls into four categories: the basis of the right, facts of obstruction, one's own suitability, and special circumstances.
  3. Obstruction evidence (chat records, police receipts, visitation logs) is key to winning, and must be continuous and lawful.
  4. Case-filing materials should be arranged in the court's order, and the claims must be specific (time, place, method).
  5. Evidence must begin to be preserved from the first refusal; do not wait until the hearing to look for it.

If you are also experiencing "your child being taken away and visitation being refused" and are unsure whether your evidence is sufficient, you may contact me (Lawyer Qu, WeChat and mobile number are the same: 18721502447).

— Notes of a Family Lawyer · Written for all those who wish to see their children but are shut out —