Hello everyone, I am Lawyer Qu, who focuses on family matters and labor disputes involving high-end talent (Lawyer Qu Xiaojun: An expert in resolving family and high-end talent disputes, safeguarding individual and family rights and interests through diverse professional expertise).

Today, I would like to launch the series of articles titled "Full Lifecycle Management of Labor Contracts," explaining, in the form of public legal education, the pitfalls that may be encountered throughout the entire process from the initial intent to establish a labor relationship to management after departure, as well as the corresponding risk responses.

Article illustration

This article is the first in the series.

I will not lecture on grand principles; instead, I will first take you through recruitment notices to identify the "pitfalls" hidden behind "job responsibilities."

This article began with a cooperation invitation from a matchmaking company.

The person in charge of the matchmaking company contacted me, saying there was a consulting cooperation opportunity in family matters. After discussing the details, it turned out that the person in charge of the matchmaking company actually wanted to use family lawyers to expand client resources with marriage needs; even unmarried female lawyers of older age in the legal profession (a group that is not small) would also become client resources that the matchmaking company could reach through business cooperation.

This made me think that many people often compare recruitment to "blind dating," but in my view, with the development of the times, labor relationships are increasingly no longer simply employers purchasing workers' time, and many new elements have developed.

The new type of labor relationship today is, in essence, more like a transaction of "resource exchange."

Recruitment requirements are more like the buyer's application for resource exchange. The employer is the "buyer," actively extending an olive branch.

What they write in the recruitment requirements is exactly what they want to "buy"—The most traditional is purchasing your working time; but increasingly, what they have their eyes on is the resources behind you.

I. When Recruitment Becomes "Resource Plundering"

Beyond your professional capabilities, what else are employers scheming for?

Identifying hidden demands and avoiding pitfalls in time can help you avoid not only potential economic losses but also an indelible stain on your record.

Based on my practical experience, there are mainly three types of "hidden demands":

\1. The "brings their own traffic" type: they want your client resources

Commonly seen in sales, BD, and marketing director positions.

  • Recruitment pitch: "Those with client resources in the XX industry preferred," "brings their own traffic, favorable compensation."
  • Lawyer's perspective: The company may be hiring you precisely so that you will "transfer" your former employer's client list over. This can easily trigger the legal risk of trade secret infringement.Once you join, you may become a defendant before you have even created any value.

\2. The "monetizing connections" type: they want your social network

Commonly seen in construction engineering, financial legal affairs, and government affairs positions.

  • Recruitment pitch: "Possesses solid relationships with courts/government/banks" and "has extensive industry connections."
  • Lawyer's perspective: These positions often come with extremely high performance pressure. If you cannot use "relationships" to close business, the risk of layoffs is significant. Even more alarming, some employers may even expect you to use these relationships to cross compliance red lines (which may trigger criminal liability; many companies have such positions, and even large law firms have them).

\3. The "exploit acquaintances to raise funds" type: they want the money behind you

This is the most covert and also the most easily overlooked category, commonly seen in insurance, wealth management, securities, and credit card centers.

  • Recruitment pitch: "Comprehensive employee welfare protection," "internal employee wealth management products," "team building, everyone opens a card."
  • Lawyer's perspective: This kind of recruitment is often not only about buying your labor, but even more about the "purses" of your relatives and friends behind you. Your onboarding is often accompanied by mandatory "self-purchase" targets or "sales promotion" tasks.Your social circle imperceptibly becomes the company's free billboard and potential source of funds.

II. Spotting the Traps: Three Key Questions at the Interview

Now that the true nature of recruitment is clear, workers must learn to conduct their own "counter-reconnaissance" before joining a company.

For the different types of positions described above, I recommend raising these three questions directly at the interview to gauge where the contract is headed:

  1. For "resource-based" positions: "What specific compliance requirements does the company have regarding 'client resources'? Is there a defined list covering 'non-compete restrictions' and 'confidential information'?" (This prevents you from being used as a tool to misappropriate trade secrets.)
  2. For "relationship-based" positions: "What are the core metrics for assessing this position? Do they include a budget for non-business 'relationship maintenance' expenses?" (Clarify authority and responsibility to avoid taking the blame.)
  3. For "wealth management/sales" positions: "Will the labor contract specify particular sales performance targets? What are the legal consequences of failing to meet them? Are there mandatory internal purchase quotas?" (This is key to protecting your wallet.)

III. Contract Review: The Starting Point of the Entire Life Cycle

Many people think:

  • "The job posting doesn't reveal much; I'll get in first and see how it goes—worst case, I'll just resign."
  • Signing a contract is treated as a mere formality, with terms fixed by the employer; if workers want the job, they have no choice but to sign.
  • Only after a dispute arises do people think to look for the contract, and in many cases the contract can no longer even be found.

That is not actually the case.

How a contract is signed determines whether, if a dispute arises in the future, you hold the winning hand or are left at the mercy of others.

For certain high-end talent, having worked at a company that set traps will become an experience in your record that is examined to assess your judgment, and the stain cannot be erased.

At the beginning of an employment law relationship, there is still much we can do.

For example, in light of the different recruitment purposes described above, the emphasis of the labor contract is entirely different:

  • If what is being purchased istime, the focus should be on the working-hours system and the base for calculating overtime pay;
  • If what is being purchased isresourcesfocusing on confidentiality clauses, intellectual property ownership, and non-compete restrictions (and compensation);
  • If you are being hiredfor money(your sales ability), focus on how commissions are calculated, performance assessment standards, and the conditions for paying commissions after departure.

Final thoughts:

The full life cycle of an employment contract begins with recruitment and ends with post-departure ancillary obligations.

We began by discussing "identification" becauseonly by seeing through the employer's true intentions can you take the initiative in negotiating contract terms.

In the next installment, we will take an in-depth look at "Ten 'Fatal' Clauses in the Employment Contract Signing Stage" and break down for you the traps hidden in specific employment contract clauses.

I am Lawyer Qu. Follow me to avoid pitfalls in employment and avoid losses while employed.


Discussion topic:

Disclaimer: This article is provided for exchange and study purposes only and does not constitute formal legal advice. For case-specific consultation, please send a direct message.