Recently, Mankun Law Firm received a legal consultation from a digital asset holder. According to the client, they began investing in crypto assets in the early years, and through long-term holding and trading,gradually accumulated investment returns of approximately USD 5 million, and previously liquidated part of the assets and transferred the proceeds to their own Hong Kong bank account.After the funds were credited, the bank initiated customer due diligence and a source-of-funds review, but the relevant review was ultimately not passed, and the bank subsequently notified the client that it would terminate account services within a specified period.
What is relatively unusual is that,according to the client, as of the time of consultation, the client's bank account had not been frozen,funds could still be transferred in and out normally, and the bank had not expressly stated that the relevant funds were suspected of being unlawful; it only required the client to complete the transfer of the account balance within a specified time.
Such situations easily cause confusion among digital asset holders: since the bank has not frozen the funds, why is the account still being closed? If the funds themselves come from genuine digital asset investments made many years ago, why might one lose account services merely because the bank review cannot be passed?
To truly understand this issue, it is first necessary to distinguish between two completely different concepts:whether funds are lawful and whether a bank is willing to continue maintaining a customer relationship are not the same determination.
I. If the funds have not been frozen, why does the bank still require account closure?
Many digital asset holders have a misunderstanding about bank reviews, believing that there are only two possible outcomes in a bank's handling of an account: either it determines that there is no problem with the funds and permits continued use, or it discovers that the funds are unlawful and freezes the account. Under this understanding, if the account can still make normal transfers, it means the bank has already recognized the lawfulness of the funds.
However, in the actual compliance management of Hong Kong banks, freezing an account and terminating a customer relationship are not the same thing.
Under the anti-money laundering and customer due diligence requirements of the Hong Kong Monetary Authority, banks are required to adopt a risk-based approach and to maintain an ongoing understanding of customer identity, transaction background, expected account activity and the relevant source of funds. Where a customer's transaction amount, flow of funds or manner of account use deviates significantly from the established pattern, the bank may require the customer to provide further explanation and, based on the outcome of its review, reassess whether to continue the business relationship.
For example, where a customer previously used a Hong Kong personal bank account mainly for day-to-day income and expenditure and savings, and then a large US dollar credit from a digital asset trading platform suddenly appears, the bank may still require the customer to explain the transaction background, the source of the original investment funds, and the process by which the digital assets were acquired, held and ultimately converted into cash, even if the funds do in fact belong to the customer. If the available materials are insufficient to satisfy the bank's customer due diligence requirements, or if the bank decides on the basis of its overall risk assessment not to maintain the account relationship, a situation may arise in which the funds have not yet been frozen but the account faces closure.
The Hong Kong Code of Banking Practice also sets out corresponding requirements for the termination of account relationships by banks. The Code is jointly issued by the Hong Kong Association of Banks and the Hong Kong Association of Restricted Licence Banks and Deposit-taking Companies and is recognised by the HKMA; it is a non-statutory industry code, but the HKMA incorporates compliance with the Code into its supervisory requirements for authorized institutions.
Undersection 20.2 of the Code of Banking Practice, version dated 7 December 2023, save in exceptional circumstances, banks should in principle give customers at least 30 days' notice of account closure and provide the customer with the reason for closure; where the customer so requests and it is practicable, the bank should give a longer notice period. Banks should also have in place appropriate mechanisms for customers to apply for a review of the account closure decision. Exceptions to the above requirements may exist in special circumstances, such as where the account is being, or is suspected of being, used for unlawful activities.
This means that, after receiving a notice of account closure, a customer is not limited to passively waiting for the account to be closed; depending on the circumstances, the customer may seek to understand the bank's reasons for closure, apply for a review of the relevant decision, and, where practicable, seek additional time to deal with the matter. Of course, an application for review does not mean that the bank will necessarily reverse its decision, nor does it automatically suspend the originally scheduled closure date.
This is also the most important first-level determination in cases of this kind:do not directly equate "the bank is unwilling to continue providing services" with "there must be something wrong with the assets", but equally, do not ignore the risk signals the bank has already sent merely because "no freeze has occurred".
II. Why is "this money was earned from trading crypto" insufficient to prove the source of funds?
When digital asset customers face bank inquiries, the most common answer is: "This money was all earned by me from trading crypto." From the customer's perspective, this statement already explains the source; but from the perspective of the bank's KYC and AML review, it is far from sufficient.
What the bank wishes to understand is not only how much money the customer currently holds, but also through what transactions the relevant funds were generated, where the original investment funds came from, and whether the final credited amount matches the customer's investment history. This involves two concepts that are easily confused, namelySource of Funds (SoF) and Source of Wealth (SoW)。
The former primarily focuses on the source of a specific sum of funds or assets, for example, through what transaction the US dollars that the client remitted into a Hong Kong bank account this time were obtained, and whether they can be matched against records of digital asset sales, exchange withdrawals and the final bank credit. The latter focuses more on the process by which the client's overall wealth was formed, including the client's income, business activities and investment history, and how those activities support the current scale of assets.
For example, if a client remits USD 3 million into a Hong Kong account and tells the bank that the funds came from selling BTC, that only addresses the first layer of explanation. The bank may still continue to ask: where did the money used to purchase the BTC originally come from? When was it purchased? Through which platform or counterparty was it purchased? Were the assets transferred between wallets in the interim? Are those addresses controlled by the client? Why did an initial investment of several hundred thousand US dollars ultimately become assets worth several million US dollars? Can the overall change in wealth be matched against the market conditions at the time, the transaction records and the client's personal background?This is also one of the biggest differences between source-of-funds review for digital assets and that for ordinary salary, real estate sale proceeds or company dividends.Traditional assets usually already have bank records, contracts, registrations or audit materials, whereas early digital asset investors often went through multiple trading platforms, multiple wallets and even over-the-counter transactions. Once the holding period spans five, eight or even ten years, the real difficulty is not proving that "the coins exist now", but reconnecting the missing asset-formation process in the middle.
III. How can crypto investments made years ago prove the process of wealth formation?
When handling such issues, merely providing the bank with screenshots of current wallet balances, exchange asset pages or a few screenshots of historical profits is usually unlikely to resolve the core issue, because such materials can only prove the asset status at a certain point in time and cannot explain how the wealth was formed.
Therefore, when preparing SoF materials, an evidence chain can be built around the following key elements.01 | Where did the initial funds come fromIf the client used personal savings or business income to purchase digital assets, the corresponding bank statements, exchange deposit records, purchase orders and, where necessary, materials on the source of income or assets should be provided as far as possible. If the early purchase records have been lost, the reasons should also be truthfully explained, and an assessment should be made as to whether other reliable materials can provide cross-verification.02 | What transfers did the digital assets undergoIf the assets were transferred between different wallets and exchanges, materials such as on-chain transaction hashes (TXIDs), deposit and withdrawal records and real-name account information can be used to explain the transaction path and the wallet control relationships. It should be noted that on-chain transfers can prove that assets once moved between addresses, but do not necessarily prove that those addresses were all controlled by the same person, still less necessarily prove that each transaction had a lawful source of funds. Therefore, on-chain data often needs to be combined with exchange records and other supporting materials.03 | How Investment Returns Are GeneratedIf a client has engaged in multiple purchases and sales, currency conversions, or asset migrations, it is also necessary to explain how the investment returns were generated by reference to available transaction records, historical prices, and changes in holdings. The focus of review is not simply whether the digital assets appreciated by a certain multiple, but whether the investment process described by the client can be reasonably supported.04 | How Digital Assets Are Ultimately Converted into Bank DepositsBefore assets enter the banking system, it is usually also necessary to complete steps such as the sale of digital assets, fiat currency settlement, and bank withdrawals. At this stage, efforts should be made to match exchange transaction records, withdrawal vouchers, account ownership information, and bank deposit statements, so that the key conversion process of assets from on-chain to bank accounts can be clearly explained. Of course, it may not be possible to obtain all historical materials in actual cases. Some exchanges may have ceased operations, some early wallet records may be incomplete, and some clients may not have developed systematic evidence-retention habits in the early stages of investment.
SoF / SoW Basic Evidence Checklist
The following materials may serve as a reference for digital asset holders to conduct self-checks and organize their records. The specific scope should be determined based on the client's actual transaction path, bank requirements, and applicable law; not all clients are required to provide all items.
● Source-of-funds documentation: Personal bank deposit statements, proof of salary or business income, asset sale vouchers, and other materials that can reasonably explain the source of the initial investment funds.
● Digital asset purchase and transaction records: Exchange historical orders, transaction records, deposit and withdrawal details, and available counterparty and payment vouchers.
● Account and wallet ownership materials: Exchange account real-name or KYC information, wallet addresses, and objective evidence relating to control over the account or wallet.
● On-chain asset transfer records: Key wallet addresses, transaction hashes (TXIDs), cross-chain and currency conversion records, and explanatory mappings between the principal transaction nodes.
● Materials evidencing the formation of investment returns: Available historical holding records, purchase, sale and token-swap records, an asset-change timeline, and necessary market data.
● Materials evidencing final fiat currency credits: Digital asset sale vouchers, USD withdrawal records, receiving bank statements, and an explanation confirming consistency of the account holder's identity.
● Materials relating to bank review communications: Notices requesting supplementary KYC information, inquiries regarding source of funds, records of all prior submissions, and formal bank notices.
Security reminder: Proof of wallet control does not mean submitting private keys or seed phrases. Under no circumstances should private keys, seed phrases or other sensitive credentials be provided directly to a bank, lawyer or other third party; verification should preferably be carried out using secure, necessary and verifiable methods.
For long-term digital asset investors,the focus of proof of source of funds is not merely to show how many assets are currently held, but to enable reviewers to understand how those assets were formed, what key changes they underwent, and why they ultimately entered the current bank account.
IV. What should be done first after receiving a bank account closure notice?
Returning to the consultation at the beginning of the article: the difficulty the client currently faces is not that the account funds have already become inaccessible, but that the bank requires the client to terminate the account relationship within a specified period and complete the transfer of the account balance. In this situation, many people's first reaction is to transfer the funds to another bank as quickly as possible, believing that as long as the funds successfully leave the original account, the problem is resolved.
However, if there are gaps in the explanation of the original source of funds, simply changing banks may not resolve the problem. The new receiving bank may likewise require the client to explain the source of large-sum funds, and may even further ask why the funds were previously transferred out of another bank. Therefore, when facing an account closure notice, a more prudent approach is to advance bank communications, preservation of materials, and subsequent fund arrangements in parallel.
Step one: verify the bank notice and the account status. The client should completely preserve the formal notice issued by the bank, confirm the specific date on which the account's services will be terminated, the deadline and method for transferring the funds out, and whether the account is currently subject to any transaction restrictions. At the same time, depending on the actual circumstances, the client may inquire with the bank about the reasons for closure, apply for review of the relevant decision, or request a reasonable extension of additional processing time.
Step two: promptly preserve transaction materials and organize the source of funds. In addition to the bank account closure notice, the client should also preserve, as far as possible, prior KYC emails, materials previously submitted to the bank, bank account statements, exchange trade and withdrawal records, wallet addresses, and relevant on-chain transaction evidence. These materials not only affect subsequent communications with the current bank, but may also affect other financial institutions' review of the client's source of funds.
Step three: assess the subsequent fund-receiving channels in advance. If the client intends to transfer the funds to another Hong Kong or offshore bank account, the client should, in advance, understand the receiving institution's account-opening conditions, anti-money laundering requirements, and risk policies regarding funds related to digital assets, and prepare corresponding materials in light of the client's identity, the account's purpose, and the actual source of funds.
Step four: avoid introducing new risks during the fund transfer process. For large-sum digital asset investment returns, the more complex the fund path, the more difficult subsequent explanation often becomes. If, in order to reduce bank scrutiny, the client deliberately splits or routes funds through multiple accounts or multiple entities without a genuine transaction background, this may not only fail to resolve the original KYC problem, but may also make the fund flow more complex and trigger additional anti-money laundering review. If the transaction involves different jurisdictions, further analysis is also required, based on the original source of funds, the client's tax status, the asset transaction method, and the actual transfer path, of possible foreign exchange, tax, and other regulatory requirements.
It should be emphasized that a bank account closure notice usually carries a clear time limit, and the client should not ignore the account termination arrangements in order to wait for all historical materials to be organized.Material preparation and subsequent funding arrangements should proceed in parallel as early as possible, but any transfer of funds should be based on a genuine transaction background and what is permitted under applicable law.
V. Review of the source of funds for digital assets: what can lawyers assist with?
When facing a bank's KYC review, some clients believe that all they need is to ask a lawyer to draft an English explanatory letter stating that the funds come from personal crypto asset investments. However, where the amounts are relatively large, the historical transactions are complex, or multiple jurisdictions are involved, the real issue that needs to be resolved is often not merely how to explain the matter to the bank,but whether the client can, through the existing facts and evidence, formulate a source-of-funds explanation that can withstand verification.
Once lawyers are engaged, they first need to examine, from a legal perspective, how the client acquired and transferred the assets, and determine whether there are legal risks requiring further verification. For example, whether early digital asset purchases involved payment through third-party accounts, over-the-counter transactions, or special foreign exchange arrangements; whether personal investment funds were commingled with corporate operating funds; and whether asset transactions at different stages were subject to the financial regulatory, foreign exchange control, or tax rules of the relevant jurisdictions. These questions cannot be answered on the basis of on-chain records alone; they require a comprehensive analysis combining the client's identity, the transaction background, and the actual fund flows.
After clarifying the relevant facts and legal risks, lawyers may, within the scope of the specific engagement, assist the client in organizing bank statements, exchange records, wallet addresses, and on-chain transaction evidence, establishing a timeline of the main fund flows, identifying possible inconsistencies or gaps among the evidence, and, on the basis of objective facts, preparing a Source of Funds explanation, an index of evidence, and related attachments. Where the bank raises further inquiries, they may also, as appropriate, assist the client in clarifying the transaction background, supplementing materials, or engaging in communications.
If the client has already received an account closure notice, or plans to rearrange bank accounts and hold funds in another jurisdiction, it is also necessary to consider concurrently the legality and enforceability of the subsequent transaction arrangements, so as to avoid generating new compliance risks through cross-border transfers of funds while the original account issues remain unresolved.
It should be made clear thatSource of Funds materials can improve the explainability of the source of funds, but they cannot replace an independent assessment of the legality of the relevant transactions, foreign exchange compliance, and tax issues, nor can they guarantee that the bank will accept the materials or withdraw its account closure decision. The value of lawyers' work lies in helping clients clarify the facts, identify risks, organize evidence, and formulate more targeted response plans on the basis of applicable law and objective materials.
Concluding remarks
As digital assets gradually enter traditional banking, wealth management, and cross-border asset allocation scenarios, an increasing number of holders are beginning to face an issue to which they previously paid little attention: the fact that digital assets can be queried, held, and transferred on-chain does not mean that, once they enter the banking system, they will naturally be recognized by financial institutions.
In the past, investors focused more on wallet security, private key management, exchange withdrawals, and changes in asset prices,but when a long-held digital asset is ultimately converted into fiat currency deposited in a bank account, financial institutions focus not only on the asset's current value, but also on whether its original source, the process by which it was formed, and the final path by which it was credited can be reasonably explained.
A Hong Kong bank requiring a customer to terminate the account relationship does not automatically mean that the relevant digital asset has been found to be unlawful; likewise, the fact that funds in an account have not yet been frozen does not mean that the customer has completed all source-of-funds reviews. For holders planning to transfer digital asset proceeds into the traditional financial system, establishing the habit of managing transaction records as early as possible, retaining key vouchers for the flow of funds and assets, and assessing relevant legal and compliance risks before major fund conversions will help reduce uncertainty in explaining the source of funds later.
Digital assets can be preserved on-chain for many years, but when they ultimately enter a bank account, the past process by which the assets were formed may still need to be explained clearly again.
This is also an increasingly important capability in digital asset wealth management:it is necessary not only to manage the assets themselves, but also to manage the "provability" of the assets.
Mankun Law Firm continues to monitor issues related to digital assets, Hong Kong bank KYC, Source of Funds / Source of Wealth, and cross-border asset compliance, and can, according to the specific circumstances, assist clients in mapping the path by which digital asset wealth was formed, organizing supporting materials on the source of funds, and providing legal support on bank communications, identification of legal risks, and subsequent fund arrangements.

