There are no shortcuts in anti-money laundering compliance, and there is no room for relying on the notion that widespread non-compliance will go unpunished.

Introduction

As the end of 2025 approaches, the major players are still racing to obtain licenses: from Standard Chartered's custody arm Zodia Custody to the payments giant Stripe, and on to crypto-native companies such as Coinbase, Kraken and Circle, all of which have secured key authorizations including MiCA licenses or US bank charters.

However, "securing a license to come ashore"is only the starting point, never the finish line.A license brings not only market access, but also long-term compliance obligations. In today's increasingly stringent regulatory environment, once a licensed institution fails to continuously perform its compliance obligations, the license in its hands may instead become a "legitimate reason" for regulatory penalties.

Looking back at Binance's USD 4300 million record settlement and the penalties imposed on Binance TR in Turkey, the core allegations in both regulatory actions point to the same deficiency:failure to establish an effective suspicious transaction reporting mechanism.STR and SAR—two abbreviations that keep compliance officers on edge—are far more than a matter of filling out forms.

What regulatory logic and practical risks lie behind them? This article provides an in-depth analysis from the perspective of legal practice.

 

Clarifying the Concepts: The Difference Between STR and SAR

These two terms are often used interchangeably in the industry, but in the legal and regulatory systems of different countries they have clearly different emphases.

  • STR (Suspicious Transaction Report)Commonly seen in Hong Kong, Singapore, Dubai and other jurisdictions influenced by the common law system. It focuses primarily on whether transactions that have already occurred are suspicious.

Example:When the system identifies an account with frequent inflows and outflows of funds within a short period, and the fund path involves high-risk addresses (such as mixers or the dark web), an STR must be submitted for that specific transaction.

  • SAR (Suspicious Activity Report)Some jurisdictions (such as the FinCEN system in the United States) place greater emphasis on the suspicious nature of the conduct itself, even if no actual transaction has occurred. This concept was also involved in the earlier Binance case.

Example:If a user repeatedly tests the boundaries of identity verification (KYC), frequently changes IP addresses to circumvent regional restrictions, or makes tentative inquiries to customer service about "whether funds can be remitted to a certain restricted region," such conduct may trigger the SAR reporting obligation.

Mankun Tip: A system that adopts the STR concept does not mean that only transaction records are examined. In practice, all compliance systems emphasize substance over form. If only fund flows are monitored while user identity and behavioral patterns are ignored, reporting omissions may still result, bringing compliance risks.

 

Regulatory Barometer: Key Reporting Points Under Different Licensing Regimes

In the process of Web3 going global, whichever region's license is chosen, the local core regulatory rules must be complied with. The focus of different regions differs significantly:

North America: FinCEN's "all-dimensional monitoring"

  • Regulatory focus: Comply with the Bank Secrecy Act and fulfill suspicious activity reporting obligations, on the principle of "report everything that is reportable."
  • Key challenge: The FinCEN system processes massive volumes of reports and enables cross-agency data sharing, imposing extremely high demands on institutions' monitoring and reporting capabilities. As long as a business involves U.S. users, it must implement these requirements strictly.
  • Mankun note: As long as a business reaches U.S. persons, it must strictly implement suspicious activity monitoring and reporting as required. The lessons of the Binance case show that where an institution internally knows of risk exposure (such as sanctioned regions) but fails to report it, this will be treated as a willful violation with serious consequences.

EU region: Deep integration with the "Travel Rule"

  • Regulatory focus: STR requirements are closely linked to the Travel Rule, especially after the implementation of MiCA.
  • Key challenge: When a user transfers more than EUR 1,000 to a non-custodial wallet, the platform must verify wallet ownership. If verification is impossible or risk is identified, the transaction must be blocked and a suspicious report submitted.
  • Mankun note: While implementing the Travel Rule and taking user experience into account, how to connect with suspicious transaction reporting requirements is key to balancing compliance and business.

Dubai region: The 48-hour deadline and "localization" responsibility

  • Regulatory focus: Emphasis on extremely rapid response (such as reporting within 48 hours) and the genuine local performance of duties by the anti-money laundering reporting officer.
  • Key challenge: If the MLRO is a "nominee" and an overseas team operates in substance, the individual will face revocation of qualifications, and the licensed institution will be affected.
  • Mankun note: Compliance work may be outsourced, but the local MLRO must provide final sign-off, and responsibility cannot be shifted by citing "system issues."

Türkiye region: Focus on combating funds tied to fraud and gambling

  • Regulatory focus: crypto asset service providers are treated as financial institutions and subject to strict supervision.
  • Key challenge: regulation will dynamically impose additional requirements in line with each country's enforcement priorities (such as fraud and gambling); for example, transactions involving such activities must be reported regardless of amount.
  • Mankun note: within the established framework, firms should proactively monitor regulatory developments, maintain communication, and strengthen monitoring and reporting for the relevant risks in a targeted manner.

 

Industry pain point: beware of "defensive reporting"

In handling specific cases, lawyers have found that many industry participants, in order to avoid liability, have developed"reporting more is always better than reporting less"as a habit—reporting everything whenever the system triggers an alert. This practice is known as "defensive reporting" and carries significant risks.

Financial intelligence units and regulators are likewise staffed by professionals who need to process information efficiently. If an institution submits a large volume of low-quality reports but cannot provide valuable investigative leads, this may instead prompt regulators to review its internal systems. Regulators will reasonably suspect: is it that your risk-control parameters are improperly set, or that your compliance personnel lack basic judgment?

Therefore, the core of compliance reporting lies in quality, not quantity. Blind reporting not only fails to help risk prevention and control, but may also expose deficiencies in one's own capabilities and invite stricter regulatory scrutiny.

 

Mankun practical recommendations: how to establish an effective reporting system?

To strike a balance between compliance costs and regulatory safety, compliance teams in the crypto industry should focus on the following four key points:

1. Integrate "on-chain + off-chain" monitoring

Avoid, for cost reasons, monitoring on-chain activity and in-platform transactions of the same user in isolation. Such separation prevents models and personnel from obtaining a complete picture of the user and directly affects the quality of STR/SAR reports. Data must be integrated to achieve a panoramic risk view.

2. Dynamically adjust monitoring thresholds

Rigid rules generate large numbers of ineffective alerts, leading to "alert fatigue" and, conversely, causing genuinely high-risk matters to be missed. It is recommended that an internal sandbox mechanism be established to periodically review and optimize system parameters and rules in light of regulatory developments and case feedback, so as to ensure that alerts are precise and effective.

3. Cultivate "narrative" reporting capability

A high-quality report is not a pile of data; it must tell a complete story. It should answer the 5W1H: who, what, when, where, why it is suspicious, and how it was carried out. Among these, "why it is suspicious" is the core; it must be logically coherent and consistent with regulatory bottom lines and the institution's risk appetite, thereby demonstrating that the "reasonable diligence" obligation has been fulfilled.

4. Establish a record-keeping mechanism for "non-reporting"

"Not reporting" sometimes requires more documentation than "reporting." When, after manual review, a decision is made not to report an alert, the reasons for exclusion must be recorded in detail in the system and the relevant evidence preserved. This is a key record for responding to future regulatory retrospective reviews and for protecting the institution and its compliance personnel.

Through the above four points, institutions can build a solid, effective and self-evident compliance reporting system while controlling costs.

 

Conclusion

There are no shortcuts in anti-money laundering compliance, and there is no room for relying on the notion that widespread non-compliance will go unpunished.

Judging from global regulatory practice, examinations in the crypto asset field have deepened to the point of requiring institutions to provide full transaction data and conducting penetrating analysis through regulators' own models. Regulatory attention to STRs/SARs no longer stops at the number and timeliness of reports, but extends precisely to whether each specific transaction "should be reported" and "why it was not reported."

Understanding the difference between an STR and an SAR is only the starting point. What is truly key is establishing a monitoring and reporting system that both satisfies regulators' intelligence needs and supports the smooth operation of the business—this has become a mandatory course for every institution.

If you are building an anti-money-laundering internal control system, or facing practical STR/SAR challenges in a particular jurisdiction, you are welcome to engage in further discussion with Mankun Law Firm.