In my days at the law firm handling marriage and family cases, I felt like an observer of the many facets of society, witnessing the complexity and helplessness behind far too many stories.
Recently, the much-watched Datong case has stirred up a wave of discussion, and today I will talk with you about the hidden workings behind it.
At first, I thought that once the Datong case was concluded, it would, like many ordinary cases, gradually fade from public view.
After all, at first glance it did not seem as sensational as last year's Chongqing Fat Cat case. Yet who could have imagined that four days later readers would still be no less enthusiastic about it; the heated discussion made me realize that this case is no simple matter!
One netizen pointed out incisively that the Fat Cat case stood out for its broad reach, while the Datong case stood out for the depth of its implications; both are of significance that cannot be ignored.
Digging deeper, we find that these much-discussed cases share a striking commonality in how they reflect contemporary relations between men and women and social phenomena.
Today, whenever a judgment in a marriage and family case is handed down, the antagonism between men and women online is like a powder keg that has been ignited, exploding with a bang.
Looking back at the Ma Rong case, the Zhai Xinxin case, the Fat Cat case, and now the Datong case, you will notice a strange and helpless phenomenon: whether it is the woman or the man who is punished when the case concludes, and no matter who has the stronger case, the online debate ultimately only further intensifies the antagonism between men and women. What logic lies behind this?
Entering the 2020s, the tensions between men and women within China have become increasingly pronounced, and family relationships have become increasingly fragile.
On the one hand, with the rapid development of productive forces, women's economic status has achieved a qualitative leap. In office buildings, white-collar men and women perform the same work, the income gap is growing ever smaller, and many women have even come to out-earn their male counterparts.
On the other hand, the spread of the internet has given women more opportunities to make their voices heard; they have gradually cast off their former dependence on men and begun to take the initiative in their own lives.
In the past, it seemed an established convention for women to submit to men. But now, the situation is entirely different.
Take the Datong case, for example. Many male internet users believe that once an engagement is made and bride price accepted, the man's demands should not be refused.
But in modern society, this old way of thinking simply cannot hold up. As the legal system continues to improve, women increasingly know how to use the law as a weapon and courageously push back against unreasonable demands.
The formerly taken-for-granted rules of a male-dominated society have been broken, and men therefore feel "offended."
From a legal perspective, the legal system tends to protect the weaker party, and in marriage and family cases this often manifests as protection for women. The purpose of the law is to uphold fairness and justice, and there is nothing wrong with that in itself.
But men feel aggrieved, believing that women are overprotected and that whatever they do is wrong. In fact, this is because, after productivity increased substantially, distribution mechanisms, moral constraints and organizational relationships all remain in a period of turbulent adjustment.
Society has not yet formed a rule system suited to the new productive forces, and everyone is still making rules using the old mindset of strong-versus-weak relationships, so conflict naturally arises.
Some internet users lamented that the Pangmao case shook young Chinese men's and women's views on romance, while the Datong case shook everyone's views on marriage.
Romantic relationships are mostly left to individuals to decide for themselves, and it is not appropriate for the government to intervene excessively.
But marriage involves major economic interests such as property distribution and child custody, so the government must establish rules.
Yet at present, China's productivity development is still in a "chaotic period," and the economic wave of more than 40 years has not fully subsided, so the basic conditions of society can hardly support a thorough transformation of the relations of production.
Using the logic of the old relations of production to handle marriage issues against the backdrop of current productive forces naturally makes it difficult to satisfy both sides.
Moreover, a cruel reality is that the more developed productivity becomes, the more severe the antagonism between men and women seems to become. This has almost become a "common problem" of developed countries, and so far no country has found a perfect solution.
Today's China, though nominally still a developing country, has in practice entered the ranks of the early-stage developed countries, and it likewise faces such internal contradictions, which leave people feeling deeply helpless.
Before this long "chaotic period" comes to an end, we may be able only to watch internal contradictions escalate bit by bit.
Still, do not be too discouraged! The long river of human history flows mightily onward, and all social contradictions, measured on the scale of time, will ultimately be resolved through changes in the productive forces.
We lawyers will also remain committed to our professionalism, seeking fair and reasonable solutions for every marriage and family case, and we also hope to contribute our part to promoting a shift in social attitudes.
The above are some of my reflections on the Datong case and the social phenomena behind it. I wonder what thoughts everyone has after reading? You are welcome to leave comments in the comment section for discussion~

