This is my 80th public legal education article of 2026. Today I am sharing a private message consultation I received late last night from a mother, whose tone was filled with a sense of helplessness:
"The divorce agreement says 'the child may be visited at any time,' but the child's father has been away from the city long-term, and the child is actually being raised by the grandmother. Now the grandmother often takes the child to stay at her new partner's place, and I do not even know where the child is. When I want to see the child, WeChat messages go unanswered and phone calls are not picked up. What should I do?"
This is probably the most typical and most frustratingThe most typical and also the most frustratingtype of visitation rights dispute:
the agreement is written "very loosely," but enforcement is "desperate."
Today I will not talk in generalities; I will address only one core point:"Visitation at any time" is not waste paper, but you need to turn it into a specific plan that "a court can enforce," and bring "the hiding grandmother" before the law.
I. First, to be clear: why "visitation at any time" is not enough, yet still valid
Your agreement states "visitation at any time." Under Article 1086 of the Civil Code, visitation rights arestatutory rightsand will not disappear merely because they were not spelled out in detail.
However, the two words "at any time" have two fatal weaknesses in practice:
- The other party has unlimited excuses The child's father can say: "You didn't make an appointment in advance." "Grandma took the child out and isn't home." Grandma can say: "I don't know you're looking for the child." "We're at my later husband's home, and it's not convenient." The ball is kicked to a third person, and you are left with no recourse.
- The court cannot enforce "at any time" If you file a lawsuit, the judge will not uphold an unworkable formulation such as "at any time"; instead, the judge willrefine the visitation right into specific times, places, and handover methods ex officio.
Therefore, your goal is not to stubbornly insist on the two words "at any time," but ratherto use "at any time" as your leverage to obtain from the court a judgment or mediation agreement that is "specific and enforceable".
II. How does the law characterize Grandma taking the child to "hide" at her later husband's home?
Many mothers ask: "It's not as if I'm divorcing Grandma; if she won't cooperate, what can I do to her?"
The law's answer is clear:Grandma is not an outsider.
- The child's father is the primary person responsible for the duty to assist Regardless of whether he is "away from home for long periods," as long as he is the parent with direct custody, the grandmother's caregiving is the arrangement he has made for the child's care.The grandmother's non-cooperation = the child's father has failed to fulfill the duty to assist.
- As the person responsible for assisting with visitation, the child's father may be held accountable Article 68 of the Interpretation (I) on Marriage and Family expressly provides that, with respect to "relevant individuals or organizations" that refuse to assist with visitation, the court mayimpose fines or detentionIn judicial practice, where the child's father fails to stop the grandmother from hiding the child for long periods, going incommunicado, or refusing to hand the child over, the court may fully issue a Notice to Assist with Visitation to the child's father personally, and if fines prove ineffective, may even impose judicial detention.
- "Taking the child to the home of a later spouse" = disguised concealment If the residence is changed frequently, you are not told where the child is, or there is deliberate loss of contact, then, by reference to the regulatory spirit of Articles 12 and 14 of Interpretation (II) concerning the abduction and concealment of minor children, this constitutesusing the pretext of caregiving to achieve exclusion in substanceWhen the judge refines the visitation arrangement, the judge will make anegative assessment of this.
- “Failure to Pay Child Support” Is No Defense If the other party uses “you haven't paid child support” as a pretext to stonewall you, the law expressly prohibits offsetting child support against visitation rights. Keeping your transfer records can, on the contrary, expose the other party's excuse.
III. Your Three-Step Plan Now (Don't Stop at “Sending WeChat Messages”)
Step One: Preserve the Evidence of “Being Blocked” (Do It This Week)
Stop merely sending WeChat messages and waiting for replies; first secure the evidence, as this is the foundation for your subsequent lawsuit.
Focus on collecting the following categories:
- Divorce agreementMark the page stating “visitation at any time” separately to prove the source of your rights.
- Communication recordsScreenshots of the WeChat messages or text messages in which you arrange visitation (e.g., “I'll pick up the child this Saturday morning”) and the other party or the grandmother replies “not at home,” “don't come,” or “I don't know where they are.”
- Evidence of inability to reach themRecordings of calls to the child's father (in which he says, “I'm out of town, ask my mother”); videos taken at the original residence (door locked); screenshots of courier deliveries to the original address being returned; screenshots of the grandmother blocking you.
- Third-party recordsReport to the residents' committee or the grid officer that you "cannot see the child," and ask them to write a statement of the circumstances confirming that the child has been taken away from this community.
- Visitation logKeep a simple record: "On [date] I went to [community name] and did not see the child; on [date] my WeChat message was refused…" Repeat this several times to establish a factual chain of "long-term obstruction."
⚠️ Note: Do not force your way into the later spouse's home, and do not snatch the child; otherwise you will change from the rights holder into the party at fault.
Step two: File a "visitation rights dispute" and replace "at any time" with a "specific plan"
If the divorce agreement did not specify the details, file directlyvisitation rights disputeas the cause of action, in the court of the place where the child's father is domiciled.
Do not state the claim as "visitation at any time under the agreement"; state it in detail:
- On the first and third Saturdays of each month from 9:00 to 18:00, the plaintiff shall pick up the child for visitation from the child's actual place of residence or an agreed public location, and return the child before 17:00 on Sunday;
- During the winter and summer vacations, the child shall stay with the plaintiff for 7 consecutive days each vacation;
- a 20-minute video call every Wednesday evening, which the other party and any adults living with them must not obstruct;
- the defendant must inform the other party of the child's actual residential address 24 hours in advance, and must not take the child out of this city or change the child's place of residence without notice.
the court will, based on the spirit of the "at any time" agreement, together with the child's age and the fact that you have been obstructed over a long period,turn the vague "at any time" into specific "weekly/monthly" arrangements, and clarify the child's father's duty to inform and the grandmother's duty to assist.
Step three: if they still do not cooperate after the judgment, apply for enforcement + keep a close watch on the grandmother
after you obtain the judgment or mediation statement, if the other party continues to play the game of "the grandmother took the child out and cannot be reached":
- apply to the court of original trialfor compulsory enforcement(the subject of enforcement is to penalize those who refuse to assist, not to seize the child);
- make a written application againstthe child's father + the grandmotherissue a Notice to Perform Assistance; if the party still refuses to cooperate, apply forfines and detention;
- If the grandmother hides the child long-term such that you cannot see the child for six months, you may apply for ainjunction against infringement of personality rightsto stop the harm first;
- where the circumstances are especially egregious, leads on the crime of refusing to execute a judgment may be referred (serious circumstances of hiding a child may give rise to criminal liability).
IV. An easily overlooked fulcrum: the child's father "being away from home long-term" actually works in your favor
The fact that he is away for long periods and leaves caregiving entirely to the grandmother shows that:
- he, as the party with direct custody,is absent from actual caregiving, which lays the groundwork for any future attempt by you to adjust custody (of course, this time the focus is on visitation first);
- the grandmother is not the guardian, and her unilateral decision to "not let you see the child"There is no legal basis for this, and it is easier for the judge to find that "the parent with direct custody is using the elderly person to circumvent the duty to assist."
Putting this point into the "Facts and Reasons" section of the complaint will make your claims more persuasive.
V. A One-Sentence Recommendation from a Lawyer
"Visitation at any time" is not a worthless piece of paper, but it needs the court to translate it for you into"which weekends each month, where the child is picked up, and who is responsible if contact is lost".
Stop arguing with the grandmother on WeChat; she is not the obligated party, nor is she the decision-maker.Focus your fire on the child's father, and put the grandmother on the list of "actual obstructers" and press them together.
Lawyer's Summary
- The "visitation at any time" agreement is valid, but it needs to be refined into a specific arrangement through litigation.
- The child's father is the primary party obligated to assist; the grandmother, as an actual obstructor, may be fined or detained.
- Taking the child to the later spouse's home and losing contact constitutes disguised concealment, and the court may make a negative assessment of this.
- Child support and visitation rights cannot be set off against each other; unpaid child support is not an excuse to refuse visitation.
- Action path: solidify the evidence → file suit to refine the arrangement → pursue enforcement and accountability.
[Follower Benefit]
If you are also stuck in the predicament where "the agreement says I can see the child at any time, but in reality I cannot see the child at all"—
I will help you do three things:
- Help you translate "at any time" into a specific visitation arrangement that the court will recognize (this is the step where you are most likely to make mistakes when drafting the complaint yourself, and it is also the step the other side most fears you will get right);
- Calculate what visitation frequency and methods you can obtain (based on the child's age, the degree of obstruction by the other side, and local court precedents, give you a pragmatic arrangement that is "within reach if you stretch a little");
- Tell you how, when the other side does not cooperate, to lawfully exert pressure using the three cards of "fines + detention + refusal to enforce a judgment" (many mothers do not know that the grandmother, as the actual obstructer, can be directly fined by the court).
Last month, I just helped a mother who was likewise caught in the situation where the grandmother "took the child and hid in another city" change "visitation at any time" into an effective judgment of "pick-up on two weekends per month + 15 days during winter and summer vacations + one video call per week," and during the enforcement stage the grandmother no longer dared to go missing.
Click follow; consultations are free of charge—just consider it making a friend.
But if you truly want to see your child, do not wait for "next time"—evidence will not wait, and your child is growing up.
— Notes from a family lawyer · Written for everyone who wants to see their child but is trapped by the two words "at any time" —

