This is my 132nd legal education article of 2026.

A follower asked me in the backend: Lawyer Qu, he is about to file for divorce. When I heard this, my mind immediately raced—I have paid annual premiums on an annuity insurance policy for my son for several years, and I have also bought wealth management insurance and critical illness insurance for myself. Will he take out all these insurance policies, convert them into cash, and split them half and half? Will the policy for the child also be touched?

This question is too typical. Today I will explain it clearly in one go: whether insurance under the child's name will be divided, how the various types of insurance under your own name will be handled, why "the fact that you paid 200 thousand does not mean 200 thousand can be divided," and what cash value actually is.

I. Insurance under the child's name is generally not dealt with

If the insured under the policy is the child, the beneficiary is the child, and you paid the premiums with the intention of "gifting to the child"—then the property interests in this policy are generally considered to point to the child and are not community property of the spouses.

In litigation, the other party can say, "This was paid with community property and should be divided." But a judge will not simply treat the "child's policy" as marital property and cut it in one stroke. The core depends on three things:

First, whether the purpose of the insurance was to provide protection/education funds for the child, rather than to use the child's name to hide money.

Second, whether there was a meeting of minds on the gift. During your marriage, did you say "this money is for the child," or are there transfer remarks, gift agreements, or chat records?

Third, whether the flow of funds is genuine. The premiums came from your account, but the contractual benefits belong to the child, not to you to withdraw and spend yourself at any time.

If these three points hold up, a court will generally not force the surrender of the "policy under the child's name" and divide the money. The more common handling is: maintain the validity of the policy, with the policyholder continuing to pay and the child continuing to enjoy the benefits, or the parties negotiate for the party obtaining the benefits to compensate the other—but not "take out the child's money and divide it."

In one sentence: it is already property under the child's name, and property under the child's name is generally not dealt with.

But note the premise: you must prove that it was "for the child," not "registered under the child's name while actually still controlled by me and withdrawable by me at any time."

How can it be made safer? Three safeguards:

First, leave a trace of the gift. When paying the premium by transfer, note "gift to son — education fund / annuity insurance premium," and keep a chat record from during the marriage saying "this policy is set aside for the child, and we both agree." With a mutual intent to gift, the probability of the transfer being found to be a transfer of marital property on divorce is low.

Second, do not treat your child's policy as your personal cash machine. Do not surrender the policy mid-term and take the cash value to pay off your own credit card, buy handbags, or transfer to your parents. Once it is proven that the policy is "in the child's name but actually used by you," it may be pierced on divorce: this is not for the child, but using the child to avoid division of property.

Third, for large education fund / annuity arrangements, take the opportunity to make a marital gift agreement plus notarization. State clearly: the source of the premium, the donee, that the policy benefits belong to the child, that the parents are only the policyholder / custodian, and that the policy may not be surrendered without the consent of both parties and the child (once an adult). A gift agreement must be implemented or notarized to be locked down; do not just sign a piece of paper.

II. Your own insurance in your name — whether it is divided and how it is divided depends first on "whether it is for protecting life or for saving money"

Many women, upon hearing "insurance has to be divided," panic and leaf through their contracts overnight. In fact, when a judge looks at insurance, there is a scale in mind:

Does this policy buy "protection" or "wealth management"?

Pure protection type — critical illness insurance, accident insurance, medical insurance, term life insurance — buys "someone pays if something happens," not "saving money to make money." Judges generally do not actively touch this type of policy. Because surrender losses are huge, and once surrendered the protection is gone, which is unfavorable to the insured. Courts tend to hold that "whoever is the insured gets the policy," and do not compel division.

Wealth-management type — annuity insurance, increasing whole life insurance, participating insurance, universal insurance — buys "money making money," and is essentially a financial asset. This type of policy will most likely have to be dealt with on divorce. But the way to deal with it is not as simple as "surrender and split the money"; rather, it is valued at the cash value.

So first look through the policies in your hands: are they for illness, for accidents, or for saving money? Clarify the type, then read on.

III. Critical illness insurance: money to protect life, generally belongs to the insured

The core function of critical illness insurance is just one sentence: if you suffer a serious illness specified in the contract, the insurer pays you a lump sum.

This policy insures your body and pays out for your illness. It is inherently distant from the logic of "marital community property."

How is this handled in practice?

If the premiums have already been fully paid, the policy generally belongs to you. A judge will not say "surrender the critical illness insurance and split the cash value," because the cash value of critical illness insurance in the early years is extremely low, and surrendering the policy would mean a substantial loss—after surrender, you would also no longer have coverage for your illness. That would be manifestly unfair to the insured, so courts usually do not do this.

If the premiums have not yet been fully paid and are being paid from marital community property, the other spouse may argue: "I paid the premiums, yet the future claim proceeds will go to you alone—am I not at a loss?" The judge may order the party holding the policy to compensate the other party for half of the "community portion of the premiums already paid." Note that this is the premiums already paid, not the sum insured, and not the future claim proceeds.

If the critical illness insurance carries a death benefit and has a cash value, that cash value portion is in theory divisible property. However, judges rarely force surrender of the policy on this ground alone. The more common approach is: the policy remains with the insured, who compensates the other party for half of the cash value, or the parties agree to "leave it unaddressed and each manage their own affairs going forward."

In one sentence: critical illness insurance is "money to protect life," and a judge generally will not cut off your protection just to divide money. Do not voluntarily surrender it—if you surrender, you lose the protection and also lose money.

IV. Accident insurance and medical insurance: basically untouched

Accident insurance has low premiums, is paid annually, and is consumption-type. The same applies to medical insurance. Such policies have almost no cash value, and surrendering them yields little money. A judge will not expend effort on this.

Moreover, they insure against "you having an accident, you being hospitalized," and the benefits point entirely to the insured personally. In divorce litigation, such policies basically do not appear. No one will fight over a one-year policy for a few hundred yuan in premiums. You do not need to worry about it; just renew normally.

V. Annuity insurance: the main battleground for dividing insurance in divorce

Why is annuity insurance the easiest to argue over? Because it is the most "money-like." The contract states: from a certain year, how much is received each year. The other party looks at it and thinks: isn't this just a fixed income? Why should you receive all of it?

But when it actually comes to division, the judge does not look at "how much will be received in the future" but at "how much can be recovered now if the policy is surrendered."

This is the cash value.

What is cash value? You need to ask your insurance broker one question: "If I surrender the policy now and cancel it, how much can you refund me?"

The figure he quotes is the cash value.

It is not equal to the premiums you have paid cumulatively. Because the insurance company has taken commissions, deducted protection costs, management fees and risk premiums, the "sunk costs" in the earlier years are high. If you surrender after paying for 3 or 5 years, the cash value is far lower than the premiums paid. If you have paid for 15 or 20 years, the cash value gradually climbs and may even exceed the premiums paid. The shorter the term, the lower the cash value; the longer the term, the higher the cash value. Every insurance contract has a "cash value table" printed in it; turn to that page and each year corresponds to a figure.

Dividends and survival benefits are not counted in the cash value. Survival benefits are the money paid out upon reaching a certain age; once paid, they are your income. Dividends accumulate separately. Cash value is the "residual value of the policy" that the insurance company refunds to you when the contract is terminated. Do not treat "I paid 200 thousand + there are dividends + there will be survival benefits later" as the total amount available for division now. What can be divided now is how much can be recovered upon surrender.

The division of annuity insurance hinges on three points in time:

When it was purchased. If purchased before marriage with personal property, it belongs to you personally. If premiums continue to be paid after marriage with joint property, the other party may claim the cash value corresponding to the post-marriage premium payments.

Whether payouts had begun at the time of divorce. If payouts have not yet begun, what is divided is the cash value. If payouts have already begun, the portion already received and used for joint living is generally not recalculated retroactively; as for the future unpaid portion, judicial approaches vary across localities: some courts award compensation for expected benefits, while others state that "this case will not address it."

Who the policyholder and the insured are. If you bought it for yourself and the policy is in your hands, the other party needs your cooperation to obtain a share. If you bought it for him and he holds the policy, you will need to prove the source of the premiums if you want to get it back.

The most common approach in practice: the policy remains held by the policyholder, and the holder compensates the other party with half of the cash value as of the time of the divorce division. It is not half of the premiums paid, not half of the sum insured, and not half of the future payout amounts.

VI. Increasing whole life insurance: cash value grows quickly, making it more likely to attract the other party's attention

Increasing whole life insurance has been extremely popular in recent years. Its features are: the sum insured increases year by year at a fixed interest rate, and the cash value rises accordingly. You can reduce the coverage and withdraw cash at any time, which is essentially a "flexible savings pot."

In a divorce division, the treatment logic for increasing whole life insurance and annuity insurance is basically the same: what is divided is the cash value at the time of divorce, not the sum insured, and not the premiums already paid.

But increasing whole life insurance has a special feature: many products now recover their cash value quickly, so after a few years of payment the cash value approaches or even exceeds the premiums already paid. If the policy is "valuable" at the time of divorce, the opposing lawyer will look at the cash value table and immediately have an incentive to fight over it.

Moreover, increasing whole life insurance allows partial surrender—you can withdraw part of it midway, and the remainder continues to grow. If the marriage is already unstable and you surrender part of the policy in advance to withdraw the money, the other party can apply for an investigation order to check the policy change records. The insurance company keeps all the records, and once retrieved, it becomes "unauthorized disposal of joint property during the marriage." Do not act secretly; either reach an agreement or wait for the judgment.

The common treatment of increasing whole life insurance is also: it is held by one party, who compensates the other party according to the cash value. If neither party wants it, they can also surrender the policy and split the money—surrender losses on increasing whole life insurance are smaller, so actual surrender-and-split situations are more common than with annuity insurance.

Remember: increasing whole life insurance is not "life insurance"; it is a wealth-management contract dressed in the guise of life insurance. In a divorce, it is treated as a financial asset.

VII. Lawyer Qu Tells You the Truth

In divorce litigation, what frightens people most is "insurance." The opposing lawyer does a calculation: 300 thousand paid, 1 million sum insured, 80 thousand receivable each year going forward—and shouts "there is something to be gained here," and you panic.

But in court, the judge does not look at "how much can be received in the future," but at "how much is it worth if surrendered now."

You paid 300 thousand, the cash value is 220 thousand, and the division is half of 220 thousand—110 thousand. Not 150 thousand.

Policies you bought for your children, if truly for the children, are generally not touched. Wealth-management insurance you bought for yourself is touched, but according to cash value, not according to total premiums. Critical illness insurance and accident insurance are basically yours. Dividends, survival benefits, and future returns are not the "present value" divided at the time of divorce.

The stupidest approach is: as soon as he makes a fuss, you surrender the increasing whole life insurance overnight and transfer the money to your parents' account. You think you have protected it, but in fact you leave a tail of "unauthorized transfer during the marriage," and you may receive a smaller share in the divorce division.

The most stable approach is: pull out each policy's policyholder, insured, beneficiary, premiums already paid, and cash value table. Sit down and talk: this one goes to me, and I will compensate you according to the cash value; that one has the child as the insured, so do not touch it; this critical illness insurance does not need to be dealt with.

If you cannot reach an agreement, let the judge decide. Acting openly and aboveboard is a hundred times better than secretly transferring assets.

One last point: when the agent sells you insurance, they talk about "compound interest, withdrawals, wealth succession, and shielding against marital risk." The more beautifully they describe it, the more important it is, when you divorce, to turn back to the last page of the contract—the cash value table. That table will not lie to you. If you paid 300 thousand and the table says 220 thousand, then 220 thousand is what can be put on the table in court.


Thank you to every sister who has read this far.

A quick like, follow, or tip all help the version of you who "paid 200 thousand thinking it was worth 200 thousand" understand, in advance, the cash value table on the last page of the insurance contract.

I am Lawyer Qu. I will help you put every insurance policy, every wealth-management product, and every premium you pay for your child in the right place: what should go to your child is not lost, what you should keep for yourself stays with you, and when it is time to divide, you will not be frightened out of your wits by "future returns."

If you are also facing a contested divorce and hold wealth-management insurance, annuity insurance, increasing whole life insurance, or children's education-fund policies, and you do not know which policy will be divided, how cash value is calculated, how to tell the judge "this is for the child," how to value the policy in your own name without suffering a major loss, or what the other side's investigation order can obtain—organize the policy type, premiums paid, policyholder and insured, and any evidence of gifts made during the marriage (redact sensitive information), and send me a private message. I will help you sort out which policy cannot be touched, which is divided according to cash value, how to negotiate compensation, how to protect the child's policy, and which policies you must never surrender secretly.

Follow me and read the Lawyer Qu marital-change series one by one: grading infidelity, the three pools of marital assets, nominal custody, exiting domestic violence, marital agreements that must not go wrong, why signing does not mean you can relax, how many steps remain between his promise to sign and the actual signature, how to make gifts to children securely, and what exactly is divided when insurance is divided in divorce—the more you understand, the fewer cuts your insurance policy will suffer.