Yesterday'sarticle about the hundred-billion-yuan inheritance dispute over Shanshan Corporation has temporarily come to a close, with the stepmother officially announcing her ascent.Underneath, many people liked comments such as: "The mistress's victory, the man's failure."
When facing the other party's infidelity
those who want revenge on the third party and do not want to forgive the other party think, "If I suffer, they shouldn't get off easy either"; those who forgive the other party want the other party to be punished and not do it again.
What should be done?
1. If your marriage is going badly, you must first make things difficult for the third party; at this point, an impulsive divorce would instead benefit the third party.
2. The cause of action for suing the third party is a gift contract dispute. Some clients, when signing the contract and seeing "gift contract dispute," have questions; the explanation is as follows: gift contract dispute is a legally established name for a cause of action. This case arises because the other party, without obtaining your consent as the spouse, disposed of marital community property on their own and gifted the marital community property to the third party. Such an act is legally determined to be invalid, and the legal consequence of an invalid act is, in law, the return of the gifted funds.
By filing a gift contract dispute against the third party, you can not only deter the third party and recover the money already transferred, but also give the third party a litigation record. Even if the third party is willing to mediate and return the funds, we will not agree to mediation; we must ensure she has a litigation record. More meaningfully, it can also let the man know that he cannot freely transfer money to others, otherwise our side has the right to recover it, which can make the other party wary and afraid to freely transfer money to the third party. If there is no money, which third party would still be willing to stay with the other party?
This can thus serve to deter the other party.
3. After a gift contract dispute is filed, usually the third party will make a scene with the other party; the other party, unable to bear the disturbance, will also negotiate with our side and choose whether to divorce or not. If the other party requests a divorce, we can put forward our demands, which of course should exceed a 50% division of property. If the other party breaks with the third party, our side can then choose whether to accept the other party's return to the family.
4. If our side does not accept the other party's return to the family, the gift contract dispute litigation can also prepare evidence for divorce proceedings.
5. The process of driving out the third party is a process of punishing evil and promoting good. Our side is the victim and needs to be treated fairly, and we also need this process to make the man break off with the third party, or to choose greater property compensation to make up for the harm our side has suffered. Through this process, the psychological harm can be repaired and the impact the man and the third party have brought upon our side can be resolved. Our family-law services not only help clients resolve property issues but also attend to their inner state, using legal means to help clients move past the pain brought by a marital breakdown, truly bringing the case to a complete conclusion and starting a new life.
I have compiled the questions that are frequently asked in the course of suing a third party in the past, and I will answer them all together here:
1. If there is no direct evidence of infidelity, can a lawsuit still be brought?
Generally, it is only when something makes you believe the other party has already been unfaithful that you come back to Lawyer Zhao. The evidence you already have has preliminarily formed an evidentiary chain, enabling us also to determine that the other party has been unfaithful. As for evidence that needs to be strengthened, the lawyer will guide you in collecting it; on the basis of the preliminary evidence, the lawyer will also obtain new evidence through investigation orders and other means, such as transfers in WeChat bearing figures like 520 and 1314, unusual hotel payment records, and so on, all of which can strengthen the determination of the other party's infidelity. If you do not want others to know, you had better not do it yourself; anything done will certainly leave evidence behind. Obtaining evidence is the lawyer's professional field, so you can rest assured.
2. If there are no transfer records and my husband is also unwilling to provide them, can this lawsuit still be pursued?
That is no problem. We can guide you in talking with the other party to put them at ease and see whether it is possible to obtain the other party's bank card or mobile phone and retrieve the payment records. As a fallback, audio recording can also be used to obtain evidence, getting the other party to admit the transfers. If that really does not work, then a divorce lawsuit can be filed to obtain the other party's bank statements; if you do not want a divorce, you can withdraw the suit after obtaining the statements.
3. If I do not have the third party's ID card, can a lawsuit still be brought?
Bringing a lawsuit requires the third party's ID number. If you do not have it, we can go to the man's side and see whether there is any ticket-booking information, mobile phone number, WeChat account, and so on, and then we will find a way to obtain the third party's ID number. There are always more solutions than difficulties; as long as you have decided that this matter must be done, we will certainly be able to find many ways to solve the problem.
4. I am a housewife. If I sue the third party and my husband makes a scene about divorcing me, and I have no money to raise the children and no source of living expenses, what should I do?
That is no problem. We first sue the third party. If your husband makes a scene about divorcing you because of this, we can negotiate the divorce terms with the other side. Because it is the other side who raised it on their own initiative, we will certainly not agree; as long as we do not agree to the divorce, even if your husband files for divorce, the court will not grant the divorce at the first attempt, and if he files again after one year of separation, the time that can be drawn out is at least two years.
By the time the other side's relationship with the third party has fallen apart, your husband will stop making a scene with you and will recognize reality and return to the family. If their relationship has not ended, then over those two years the third party usually will not be able to endure it either. During this period, if the man wants to divorce as soon as possible, he will have to come and negotiate the divorce terms with us, and we will certainly insist on cash, which will solve the problem of your having no source of cash.
You can do whatever you like with the cash. Enduring things as you are now cannot guarantee that the man will not raise divorce with you; instead, you are every day passively watching him indulge in a life of pleasure while you act as a free nanny at home, are given little living expenses, and receive not even the most basic respect.
5. What if we sue the third party and she has no money?
That is not a problem. Third parties are generally relatively young. A court judgment would not only order her to return the money but also state in writing that she had an improper romantic relationship with a married person. If such a judgment is made public, third parties are generally quite afraid of that, so most cases of this type that we encounter are resolved through mediation, and the third party voluntarily offers money in the hope of reaching a settlement.
If the third party does not care at all about her reputation and insists on resisting, then after winning the case we can seek enforcement, place her on the list of dishonest judgment debtors, and make it impossible for her to take high-speed rail or obtain loans. Being subject to consumption restrictions will affect every aspect of her life. If she had the ability to be a third party and take money from your husband, she should find other ways to obtain money to live a life free of consumption restrictions.
6. Can their hotel check-in records be obtained?
Hotel check-in records can generally be obtained only in criminal cases. Our case is a civil case, so hotel check-in records cannot be obtained. Although hotel check-in records cannot be obtained, we can obtain the other party's hotel booking information and WeChat Pay, Alipay or bank card payment records. If there is unusual hotel payment information in those records, combined with other evidence we have, it can serve the same function as hotel check-in records and prove that they engaged in substantive extramarital conduct.
7. What if the third party has relatively strong connections and engages in extreme behavior after we sue her?
That is not a problem. We now live in a society governed by the rule of law. If the other party engages in extreme behavior, we must contact our lawyer promptly, call the police immediately and preserve evidence. The more aggressively the third party behaves, the more she will expose her weaknesses and give us grounds to sue her. I believe that as long as we take a firm stance and resolve the matter through legal channels, we can lawfully protect our own rights and interests.
8. Can the other party's daily expenses, such as purchases of major items and records of dining, entertainment and other spending, be obtained and recovered together?
Gift contract disputes generally concern direct transfers. Whether daily expenses can be recovered depends on whether there is evidence of direct spending by the other party. Records of dining and entertainment alone cannot prove that the other party incurred the expense, so it would be difficult to pursue recovery from her. We can combine such records with other evidence to prove that the expense was incurred by the other party, and for larger amounts, we can also assert a claim.
Of course, we should still focus on direct transfers and secure the return of the bulk of the money, while striving as much as possible for the smaller amounts. The purpose of litigation in a gift contract dispute is, on the one hand, to recover money and, on the other hand, to create a litigation record showing that the other party had an improper romantic relationship, thereby applying pressure through this approach. If you care relatively more about recovering these daily expenses, mediation can be used to resolve the matter under pressure.
If you think it is enough to recover the bulk of the expenditures and that punishing the other party is more important, then insist on litigation and do not accept mediation, and the court will issue a judgment.

