This is my 29th legal commentary article of 2026. Today I am sharing a recent marriage case I handled concerning child custody.
In a call in the early hours of the morning, Ms. F, her voice choked with tears, asked: "Lawyer Qu, his attitude is extremely hardline. He says I won't get to take a single child. I tremble at the sound of his voice. Is there really no hope for me?"
On the battlefield of divorce, the fight over custody is often the most heartbreaking. When the other side issues threats, many mothers—especially women who have been subjected to domestic violence—react first with fear and helplessness.
Today, through this real case I recently handled, I want to thoroughly break down for you: when the father says "not a single one," what legal cards does the mother actually hold?
I. The Story: A Mother's Realistic Predicament
Ms. F, 36 years old, has two children: a 12-year-old daughter, C, and a 3-year-old son, S. Her married life was full of suppression: long-term cold violence, endless verbal abuse from her mother-in-law, and domestic violence in which her husband, Mr. M, resorted to physical force multiple times during the marriage—one of which was witnessed by their daughter.
Mr. M is a construction site worker with a stubborn personality. Ms. F is a company employee with a stable but not particularly high income, and she currently lives with her parents. She filed for divorce and wanted custody of one child (the reason being that she wanted both children, but she knew the husband would never agree, and she was afraid of contact with him; obtaining custody of one child would allow one child to visit her, and she even said humbly that even if she were not granted custody, being able to teach the children to study would be enough). But Mr. M's response was unequivocal: "Divorce is fine, but you won't take a single child with you."
Ms. F's world nearly collapsed. Her core question—also the question of countless mothers in similar situations—was: "Am I really not even going to get one child?"
II. How Does the Law Assess This? There Is Only One Core Principle
The sole and paramount principle for a court deciding which parent a child will live with is: what is most beneficial to the child's growth?
This is not an empty phrase; it is expressly set out in the Civil Code, and the judge will carefully weigh the conditions of both parents as if on a balance scale.
In Ms. F's case, how did the balance tip? Let us look at a clear comparison:
| Aspect of comparison | Mother (Ms. F) | Father (Mr. M) | How would the law view this? |
|---|---|---|---|
| The children's ages and habits | The son, S, is only 3 years old and has been raised by his mother since birth; his daily habits depend entirely on his mother. | The son primarily lives with his mother, and the father has not proven that he can provide equivalent day-to-day care. | Clearly favors the mother. A court will never lightly change the long-term stable living environment of a young child. |
| The children's own wishes | The 12-year-old daughter, C, repeatedly told her mother in secret that she "wanted to be with you," and there is evidence of this. Although she later changed her statement, this may be because she is afraid of her father. | The daughter now says she "does not want to," but the court will focus on examining the reason for the change of statement (whether she was under pressure). | Favors the mother. A judge must hear and attach great importance to the genuine wishes of a child over 12 years old. |
| Who can raise the children well? | \1. Has stable employment and income.\2. Has the maternal grandparents' help, providing a solid support system.\3. Has long been responsible for the children's studies and daily life, and is a mother who is "devoted." | \1. Works hard, and income may be unstable.\2. The family atmosphere is extremely poor (the paternal grandmother has long verbally abused the mother), which is detrimental to the children's psychological health. | Leans toward the mother. A stable environment and devoted companionship outweigh mere financial conditions. A terrible family atmosphere is a major negative factor. |
| Whose character is better? | No adverse record. Is a victim of domestic violence. | Key hard defect: there is a police report record of domestic violence. Has a violent temper. | Strongly leans toward the mother. Domestic violence is a "trump card" of negative evidence in seeking custody; the party who has committed domestic violence is generally considered unsuitable to directly raise the children. |
| To whom are the children closer? | The son is very attached to the mother; the daughter always goes to the mother first when something happens. The emotional bond is deep. | The children themselves say they are "afraid of Dad," and there is an emotional estrangement. | Leans toward the mother. Intimate emotional dependence is the best proof of what is "in the best interests of the children." |
The conclusion is clear: in this comparison, Ms. F has the advantage on most key points, particularly because the other party has committed domestic violence, a serious and irrefutable fault. Therefore, legally, her prospects of obtaining custody of at least one child (especially the younger son) are very strong. The other party's intransigent attitude cannot withstand legal scrutiny.
III. Practical Strategy: How to Turn Legal Advantages into Victory?
Now that she knows the law is in her favor, the next step is action. My advice to Ms. F is as follows:
Adjust the claims and seize the initiative in negotiations
Strategy: Do not seek custody of only the daughter; instead, seek "custody of both children."
Purpose: This is not greed but a negotiation technique. It demonstrates your determination and confidence and creates room for subsequent mediation. The ultimate goal is very likely to secure, through negotiation, firm custody of one child (especially the son).
Systematically collect evidence—this is your strongest weapon
- Domestic violence evidence is a "nuclear bomb": Safeguard the police receipts, and recall and record in detail the time, place, witnesses, and circumstances of each incident of domestic violence.
- The child's wishes must be preserved: The recording of the daughter previously saying she "wants to live with mom" is key evidence.
- Prove that you are the "primary caregiver": Organize all records, photos, and chat logs showing that you took the children to and from school, tutored them with homework, attended parent-teacher meetings, and bought things for them.
- Expose the other party's "adverse environment": The recording of the mother-in-law insulting you is direct evidence of a hostile family atmosphere.
- Investigate the other party's true income: You may apply to the court to investigate Mr. M's bank statements, which serve both as a basis for dividing property and as the foundation for calculating how much child support he should pay.
In court, always speak around one central point.
Whether you are facing a judge or a mediator, everything you say must be anchored to one core question: "What is best for the child?"
You must repeatedly emphasize: how much psychological trauma domestic violence will inflict on the child; how cruel it is to forcibly take a four-year-old son away from his mother; and that what you can provide is a growth environment free of fear and full of care.
IV. A Few Heartfelt Words for Mothers in Similar Situations
- First, build your confidence: his "giving you nothing" is emotion and a threat, whereas a legal judgment is based on facts and evidence. The law can see what you have done for your child.
- Start cultivating an awareness of evidence now: do not wait until the hearing to regret not preserving evidence. From the moment you decide to divorce, you must consciously preserve WeChat chat records, audio recordings, photographs, receipts and invoices—everything that can prove your contribution to raising the child and the other party's fault.
- Leave professional matters to professionals: family litigation is entangled with too much emotional conflict, and it is easy to get caught up in it yourself. A good family lawyer can help you analyze calmly, formulate strategy and present forceful arguments in court, and is the comrade-in-arms you can trust most. My approach was to review the case and the existing documents that very evening, and by the next morning to prepare a draft application to amend the claims, a list of evidence and draft argument submissions and send them to Ms. F; then, on the basis of the draft and after multiple rounds of supplementation and revision, within one week to produce legal views and documents satisfactory to Ms. F, after which the documents were submitted and communication was opened with the mediator and the judge. Forming preliminary views as quickly as possible and continuously iterating on the basis of those preliminary views is a very important step forward; it enables efficient and in-depth agreement with the client and effectively advances the case.
- Property and child issues can be resolved together: do not be afraid to discuss money for fear of provoking the other party; the other party will be all the more likely to use a show of anger to pressure you. Clarifying his concealed income and the property jointly owned by the two of you can sometimes make the other party more rational on economic grounds. I once handled a case in which economic pressure led the other party to make a choice about divorce on the spot during mediation. Most human behavior and psychology can be viewed from an economic perspective; whether it is pure calculation of interests or an expression of emotion, it is a contest under conflicting interests, and only with more bargaining chips can you make the other party concede on the issue of custody. Stubbornness means the other party still believes they hold more bargaining chips in the relationship; negotiation is currently at a stage of contest with no chips. What you should do at this point is not to keep compromising, but to find your own chips and make the other party realize that venting emotions will not solve the problem and that continuing to act irrationally will expose them to loss of interests!
Finally, back to the original question: in the face of the threat of "not giving you even one," can a mother win custody?
The answer is: yes. Especially where you have devoted yourself to raising the child while the other party has committed fault such as domestic violence, the scales of the law will tilt in your favor. A mother's strength comes from love, and it should also be protected by the law.

