This is my 40th legal commentary article of 2026. Today I am sharing a case from the news: a case in which a photographer was injured in a fall at a scenic area and claimed compensation. When I saw this news, I was reminded of the first case I handled after I first joined the law firm 16 years ago (at that time, it was only my second day at the firm, and I had not yet obtained my trainee lawyer certificate, but I could represent a party in my capacity as a citizen). The two cases are very similar, so I record and share it as follows:
In many people's habitual thinking, as long as something happens on someone else's premises, the first reaction is often: "Find the venue and hold it responsible!"
However, reality is often more dramatic than a script. As a legal practitioner, whether in the news or in my actual work, I have deeply experienced that the law is never muddled compromise based on "whoever is weaker has a better case"; rather, it is a precise "art of balance."
Today, through two real cases, I would like to help you understand the "duty of care" in the law.
I. The "photographer injury case" in the news: professionals cannot pretend to be "novices"
A few days ago, I saw a news report: a wedding photographer in Sanya stepped on moss while shooting at a scenic area, fell, and was disabled as a result. He believed he was the victim and sued the scenic area, but the court of second instance upheld the original judgment: the photographer bore 70% of the liability, and the scenic area compensated only 32300.

Why?
The court's reasoning was very clear: status determines the level of the duty of care.
This photographer was not a tourist visiting for the first time, but a professional who had worked there for a long time. His familiarity with the terrain, the moss, and the slopes should have been far greater than that of an ordinary person. The law expected "expert-level care" from him, not the "tourist-level ignorance" of a first-time visitor. Because he focused on shooting and neglected the ground beneath his feet, he failed to exercise the basic duty of care for his own safety.
The law is telling us to "bear responsibility for oneself," not to "lie flat and shift the debt."
II. The first case I handled: a decorator's "high-altitude scare"
If the photographer in the news showed me the rationality of the law, then the first case I took on after joining the law firm allowed me to personally experience the power of the "duty of care" in practice.
That was a case involving liability for injury to a person providing labor services. My client was a property owner who, while renovating his home, engaged a renovation worker, Wang, who fell and was injured during the construction work. Wang subsequently sued the property owner (my client) in court, demanding compensation for substantial medical expenses.
At the time, the opposing party had retained the managing partner of a large law firm. Seeing that I was young, he was very aggressive and tried to shift the blame to the property owner using the traditional theories of 'employer liability' or 'fault in the selection of an independent contractor.'
When I received this ad hoc assignment, I was told that the witness could not appear in court and that the hearing would be a mere formality, which is why it was handed to me, a newcomer.
But in fact, apart from the witness being unable to appear, all the other hearing stages were completed one by one at that hearing. During the three-hour hearing, I went from being completely unprepared at the outset to pulling myself together and adapting on the spot, seizing on two fatal points to mount a counterattack:
- Professional barrier: Wang was a renovation worker with many years of experience, and he understood renovation procedures and safety standards even better than my client did. As a professional, his awareness of the risks of working at height and his ability to guard against them were far greater than the property owner's. A renovation worker bears the highest duty of care as a 'good administrator.'
- Lack of qualifications: Most critically, the work at height that Wang performed legally required 'work-at-height qualifications.' Not only did he lack such qualifications, but he also failed to take any safety protection measures during construction (such as wearing a safety harness). The property owner had already reviewed the renovation company's qualifications and fulfilled his duty of care.
What was the outcome?
The court adopted my defense arguments and found that: Wang, as a construction entity with professional knowledge, knew he was unqualified and failed to implement proper safety protection, while the property owner had exercised sufficient care in selecting the renovation company; the renovation company and the renovation worker were grossly negligent in causing the damage and should bear full liability.
My client, the property owner, did not have to pay a single cent. After the case concluded, the client gave me a thumbs-up. Not only had we resolved the immediate trouble, but because he saw the professionalism of our firm in handling complex disputes, he directly entrusted our team with his company's general legal counsel work.
At that moment, I deeply understood: the fairness of the law means protection for those who fulfill their duties and punishment for those who violate the rules.
This case was the battle that established my foothold in the legal profession and gave me tremendous confidence!
III. Boundaries of Liability: How Does the Law Dance on Both Ends of the Scales?
Whether it is the photographer in Sanya or the renovation worker I represented, the court's underlying logic is highly consistent: the allocation of liability is bounded by the "duty of care."
The law never asks the impossible of people. It will not require a scenic area to flatten nature and pave it into a rubber running track, nor will it require a property owner to become an expert in renovation supervision.
But it will require this: when you engage in professional activities, you must think like a professional, and you must bear the consequences of your own violations.
Final Thoughts
The biggest takeaway these two cases gave me is this: the world is rewarding those who "take responsibility for themselves," and it is also punishing those who "shift risk onto others."
If you are a business owner, be sure to review the qualifications of outsourced personnel;
If you are an employee, be sure to put safety ahead of performance;
If you are a property owner, be sure to keep the employment contract and communication records.
The law does not protect those who sleep on their rights, and it certainly does not protect "adult children" who ignore risk and act recklessly.
Disclaimer
: The content of this article is merely a sharing of legal knowledge and does not constitute legal advice for any specific case. If you have legal needs, you are welcome to consult a professional lawyer.

