This is my 76th legal education article of 2026. Today I am sharing a question that a reader raised with me by private message after readingLawyer, should I fight for custody of my child? The question she sent me by private message was:
I have two children: a 5-year-old daughter and a son who is only 1 year and 3 months old. My parents have made it clear that they will not help care for the children. I have to work, and I am on my own. My salary is just enough to support myself, and I simply cannot afford to raise two children.
The father's family home is in a rural area, and his parents have never appeared from beginning to end. The father's position is firm: he does not want the children, and he will not pay child support.
Everyone around me urged me: "Fight for them. If the children stay with their father, they will be ruined." But when I look at my bank balance, I feel uneasy.
I told her:
From the passage you described, what I see are numbers and facts. This shows that you have already moved from "emotion" to "the balance sheet." Based on the facts you gave me, I will peel this back layer by layer like an onion. Your question, "Lawyer, should I fight for them?", let me confirm whether it can be stated more precisely as:
What exactly is the father thinking with his statement that he "does not want them and will not pay"? Is there a trap? Once you understand how the other side is thinking, you can then look at whether to fight for both children, fight for one, or not fight for either.
Next, I will break this down for you layer by layer.
I. First, let us unpack the father's statement that he "does not want the children and will not pay." His rural parents have not appeared. What are they calculating?
Many women panic when they hear this sentence. They feel that the father has seized the upper hand in negotiations, that he is impervious to reason, and that they can only go along with what he says.
In fact, given the background of "the husband coming from a rural family, the parents-in-law favoring sons over daughters, and the parents never showing their faces throughout," his harsh words are driven by two calculations working at once:
The first calculation: the son is only one year old, and they know full well they cannot win custody, so they simply give up and let things fall apart
Article 1084 of the Civil Code is unequivocal: children under two years of age shall, as a matter of principle, be raised directly by the mother. The son is only one year old, so if this really went to court, there is a nine-in-ten chance the judge would award the son to you.
Families in rural areas that favor sons over daughters are shrewd; they know perfectly well that they cannot win custody of the son by fighting for it.
So their real script is:
The daughter is five years old, and they were already more indifferent toward her to begin with (in many rural families, "if a girl goes with her mother, so be it," and indeed the daughter has also grown closer to her mother; they may think the daughter is already older, her thinking is hard to change, and even if they raised her, she would not be close to them);
The son is one year old and, under the law, cannot escape being awarded to the mother; they cannot show any intention of fighting for him, for fear that you would seize the opportunity to use the son's custody as leverage to demand conditions;
The husband is still young and will easily remarry after divorce, and that is what they see as "the family line" of their own; bringing children from a previous marriage would increase the difficulty of remarriage;
Therefore, neither of the two children from this pregnancy is a key asset on their ledger; better to offload them both onto you so the husband can travel light, remarry, and have more children.
They are also letting things fall apart on child support, and the logic then becomes clear: since the son legally belongs to you and the daughter, if you fight for her, will also be raised by you, they neither act as guardians nor want to pay a single cent, wearing you down until you lack the strength to pursue accountability; in their eyes this accounts as "getting away with zero expenditure," and in their hearts they simply want to minimize the cost of divorce.
The second calculation: betting that you will ultimately, because of the difficulty and entanglement, have no choice but to accept conditions you originally could not accept
The parents-in-law do not show their faces, and there is only the husband's one sentence, "I don't want them and won't pay"—this is typical cold-treatment pressure. What they are betting on is not the courtroom, but you alone in the middle of the night (this private message was received at two in the morning):
Do the math yourself: your salary is just enough to cover childcare for two children, your parents' family will not help, the man will not pay, and even if you win custody, you cannot withstand an unexpected event.
The more you calculate, the more panicked you become, and in the end, in order to "at least secure some property to fall back on," you will very likely be forced to sign:
"The children all go to me, I waive child support, I waive the house, just get the divorce done quickly."
He uses a "double refusal" to corner you, making you lower your own bottom line. This is not a noble letting go; it is using the cost of raising the children as leverage to pry away your property and your composure.
But remember two legal bottom lines:
- Child support is a mandatory statutory obligation; Article 1085 of the Civil Code is not extinguished because "he does not want custody"; even if the agreement states "never pay," it only binds the two of you, and before the child turns 18, the child can still sue in the child's own name (the spirit of Article 16 of Interpretation II).
- The paternal grandparents not appearing does not mean the man has no responsibility; whether his parents are willing to care for the grandchildren does not affect his obligation as the father to pay.
Second, dismantle the practicality of "fighting for both"—how will the judge divide this?
When you ask "should I fight," the core question is actually "how many should I fight for (2? 1? 0?)."
Under Article 1084 of the Civil Code:
Son (1 year old): under two years of age, in principle directly raised by the mother, unless you have a statutory exception such as an infectious disease that remains uncured after prolonged treatment.
Daughter (5 years old): already over two years of age, entering the comprehensive assessment of "what is most beneficial to the minor child."
But the key issue is not the legal provisions; it is your actual capacity to handle things in reality: you have no elderly family members to help, and if your salary has to support you and two children, it is only enough to get by, and you still have to go to work.
A 1-year-old infant = clingy all day, waking at night, expensive childcare; a 5-year-old daughter = picking up from and dropping off at kindergarten, sleeping with her, and caring for her when she is sick.
If you insist on fighting for both children, the picture the judge sees is: the mother goes to work and the two children are locked at home; or the mother quits her job, and if the father defaults on child support, the whole family will have nothing to live on.
If you insist on obtaining custody of both children, and the judge actually rules, the very likely outcome is not "both go to you," but "one each"—the son goes to you (the principle for children under 2), and the daughter goes to him (although he does not want this, your difficulties may cause her to be allocated to him); or both go to you, but child support for the two children is only two to three thousand, and he finds reasons to delay payment of child support; you cannot manage, and in the future he may file a request to modify custody on the ground that "the mother is unable to raise them."
You win the fight, but your life collapses. This is not the result you want.
III. A lawyer's conscientious advice: two paths, you choose
Path A: You are determined to have both children—then do not just make empty claims; go "squeeze out" child support
If you insist on raising both children, then in addition to proving that the other party is unsuitable to raise the children, you must also solidly establish evidence of "actual expenses" and a child-rearing plan; you cannot rely on emotion alone.
- Make a "two-child survival budget": childcare fees (a 1-year-old must have someone to care for them), formula and diapers, kindergarten, outpatient visits, shared rent, commuting. In an ordinary city without help from elderly family members, the real monthly expenditure for two children is at least 8,000–10,000 yuan.
- Claim based on "actual needs": Article 49 of the judicial interpretation provides that 20%–30% for one child is a reference, and a 50% ratio for two children is the upper limit; what the judge looks at is "how much the children actually cost + his ability to bear it." If he acts shamelessly and has no fixed income, the amount is converted based on the average income in the same industry for that year, and it is not zero.
- If he refuses to pay, enforce: write the amount, payment time, and liquidated damages into the agreement; if he does not pay, file a lawsuit in the children's names and seek compulsory enforcement (deduct wages, freeze cards, place on the dishonest debtor list). His hometown is in the countryside, but he actually works in the city; it is not that he "really has no money," but that he "really does not want to pay."
But this path is extremely difficult: your salary is low, your natal family does not help, and you still have to engage in a tug-of-war with him over enforcement. Unless you can change to a higher-income job or have at least two years of financial reserves, you will be dragged down before you even get the money.
Path B: Give the younger son to him — survive first, then talk about the future (the more conscientious solution)
Given the rural context of favoring sons over daughters, this step actually has a clever angle:
- From a legal perspective: the rule that a child under 2 years old goes to the mother is a principle, not mandatory. If both parties can accept the son being raised by the father, with no adverse effects, the court may support it (the proviso to Article 1084 of the Civil Code).
- From a practical perspective: raising your 5-year-old daughter is far more physically feasible than raising "1-year-old + 5-year-old." If he really takes the 1-year-old son, his rural parents, who favor sons over daughters, may actually take over caring for him (they won't help you raise your daughter, but they may raise their grandson), and you no longer have to bear full-day childcare.
- From the fallback perspective: right now he says "I don't want him and won't give him to you." Only when the 1-year-old son is actually placed in his hands will he learn about the money drain and the sleep deprivation. When he remarries, his new wife has a child, and the son is neglected by him / falls ill with no one to care for him / wants to be with his mother after age 8 — once your finances are up, you can petition to change the son's custody under Article 56 of Interpretation I of the Marriage and Family Section, with a high success rate.
- Key legal characterization: this is not "giving the son to him"; it is placing him in safekeeping. Your salary cannot support two children. Stabilize your daughter first, preserve visitation with your son and the path to changing custody, and once you are back on your feet, bring your son back.
Maternal love is not measured only by "holding both in your hands." It is knowing that you can only stabilize one right now, so you place the other where he can survive, and walk back for him once you are able.
IV. How should the agreement be drafted so that it is "safekeeping" rather than "giving him away"?
If you choose Path B, the divorce agreement must lock in these clauses:
- Clear division of responsibilities: "The daughter shall be directly raised by the wife, and the son shall be directly raised by the husband."
- No mutual claims: "Neither party shall pay the other child support for the child directly raised by the other." (This prevents him from using "you didn't pay for your son" to withhold your daughter's child support.)
- Lock down visitation: "The wife has the right to take the son home every week, and the husband and the husband's family members shall not obstruct this; visitation shall not be restricted on the basis of child support or property division."
- Leave a fallback for modification (which also binds the husband): "If the husband or his family members fail to fulfill their child-rearing obligations toward the son, commit abuse or abandonment, or if the husband treats the son manifestly unfairly after remarrying, or if the wife's financial situation improves significantly, the wife shall have the right to petition for modification of the son's custody."
- Property consideration: "In allocating property, both parties have fully taken into account the respective costs of raising the children, and shall no longer seek child support from each other (except for any single major and reasonable expenditure exceeding 10 thousand yuan)."
In this way, you let go of the son without surrendering maternal rights, and his passive resignation of "not wanting him and not providing for him" is locked into a cage of "he raises him first, and if he fails to raise him well, he returns him to you."
V. Back to your opening question, "Should I still fight?"
The answer has two levels:
- Fighting for "both children to go to you": not advisable. It is not that you do not love them; it is that your tray is not big enough. Fighting forcefully = judgment in your favor + life collapsing + him striking back later.
- Fighting for "the daughter goes to you + the son temporarily goes to him + visitation/modification fallback written in stone": strongly advisable.
His rural parents not stepping forward and his shouting "not wanting him and not providing for him" are not him winning; they are him betting that you will panic. You simply do not panic: take good care of your daughter, place your son there temporarily while retaining the right to take him back, and establish your career. In three to five years, when your monthly salary has doubled, you have a home, and your son is constantly neglected at his place—you walk into court and say, "I want to take my son back," and the judge will listen.
Only then will you have the confidence to say to him: "Before, I could not afford to raise two; now, I will raise them."
Lawyer's summary (layer-by-layer recap):
- The husband's "not wanting him and not providing for him" = a rural son-preferring family's calculation of "we cannot win custody of the son + remarry and have another child + be passive about child support + pressure you into a cheap compromise";
- The principle is that a son under two years old goes to the mother, but they know they cannot win, so they are passive;
- Fighting hard for both children without any fallback means winning the judgment but losing in life;
- If you truly intend to raise both, prepare an actual-expenses schedule and pursue child support to the fullest under Article 1085;
- If his financial means are limited, give him the son first, retain visitation plus a fallback for modification, and take the child back once his finances improve;
- Set the agreement in writing: mutual non-recourse, independent visitation, and a fallback for modification.
— Notes from a family lawyer · Only for those who can do the math —
The above content has been anonymized and is merely a legal-education case sharing; it does not constitute advice on any individual case. If you have questions about your own case, please consult Lawyer Qu in detail (WeChat and mobile number are the same: 18721502447).

