This is my 77th legal education article of 2026. Today I am sharing a question that a reader asked me by private message after readingCan the father obtain custody of a child raised by the grandmother?The question she asked me by private message was:
Sender: Xiaoyu, 25 years old, child is 1 year and 8 months old
Lawyer, I am 25 years old, and my child is almost two. In the first divorce lawsuit, the other side said that if I sought custody of the child, he would not agree to divorce, and the court did not grant the divorce. If I wait half a year and then sue again, the child will be over two years old. What worries me most is that when the child was 8 months old, the father forcibly took the child away, and the child has lived with his family ever since. Only recently did I learn thatthe father works 12 hours a day at a factory on two shifts, so he has no time to care for the child at all; only his mother (my mother-in-law) can care for the child. Moreover, I have learned thatmy mother-in-law has a Level 3 disability certificate for mental illnessand the father's father is still working away from home. Every month I transfer several hundred yuan to my mother-in-law for living expenses, and my request to take the child home for holidays was also refused. In the next lawsuit, if I submit my mother-in-law's disability certificate, can I win back custody?
Xiaoyu, your private message contains a great deal of information, and it isextremely importantMany mothers face similar difficulties: the child is taken away, the other side has an elderly person helping to care for the child, and their own financial conditions are ordinary. But your situation is quite different. I will break your situation down into the following core issues and explain them layer by layer.
Question 1: If a lawsuit is filed again when the child is over two years old, does that mean there is no hope under the approach of awarding custody to whichever parent the child has lived with longer?
No. Article 1084 of the Civil Code sets out the paramount principle—where the child is already two years old or older, the decision shall be made in accordance with the principle of what is in the best interests of the minor child, not on the basis of whoever seizes the child first.
More importantly,the law expressly rejects the grab-and-claim logic of first possession taking precedence.:
- Article 24 of the Law on the Protection of MinorsNo person may contest custody by seizing or concealing minor children or by other such means.
- Article 14, Item (4) of the Interpretation (II) on the Marriage and Family ChapterIn divorce proceedings, where one partyseizes or conceals minor children, and the other party does not have circumstances such as domestic violence, abuse, gambling, or drug use that seriously harm the children,priority consideration shall be given to direct custody by the other party.
Your child was forcibly taken away at 8 months old, and after the court hearing you were surrounded and blocked when attempting visitation, with the child snatched back—this squarely falls within the determination of "snatching and concealment." The other party wants to use "the child has lived with us for 1.5 years" as a trump card,the law directly turns this card into a negative factor.
Question 2: Can the grandmother's "Level 2 psychiatric disability certificate" be submitted? How can it be combined with the snatching conduct?
It can be submitted, and it must be submitted. Only by playing both cards together is the picture complete.
First layer (caregiver's illness): Under Article 46, Item (4) of the Interpretation (I) on the Marriage and Family Chapter, where the party living with the child (or the actual caregiver) suffers froma serious illness that remains uncured after prolonged treatment and is unsuitable for living together, the other party may be given priority consideration or a change of custody. The mother-in-law has a Level 3 psychiatric disability and in practice provides all-day care for a 1-year-8-month-old child, which is a typical case of "unsuitable for living together with a young child."
Second layer (father's absence): The husband works 12-hour two-shift rotations, and the father-in-law works away from home, which proves thatthe nominal custodian is physically absent, the real-world scenario = "a mentally disabled elderly person alone caring for a young child."
Third layer (snatching superimposed): Article 14 of Interpretation II lists "snatching and concealment" as a separate circumstance warranting priority placement with the other party. In your case,there is both snatching (forcibly taking the child away for 7 months + obstructing visitation) and the actual caregiver's serious illness, with these two negative factors tied to the other party; when the judge assesses "what is in the child's best interests," the other party's environment is directly downgraded from "has an elderly person helping to care" to a "high-risk isolation chamber."
For the second lawsuit, the recommended wording in the complaint is:
"Since the child was 8 months old, the child was snatched and taken away by the man and his relatives, and has long been actually cared for by the grandmother, who holds a Level 3 mental disability certificate; the man works 12-hour two-shift rotations at a factory, and the grandfather works away from home, so neither is present. This situation simultaneously meets Article 14, Item (4) 'snatching and concealment' of the Interpretation (II) of the Marriage and Family Volume and Article 46, Item (4) 'serious illness making joint living unsuitable' of Interpretation I, and under law direct custody by the woman should be given priority consideration."
Question Three: Why are the man's "12-hour shift work + father-in-law away from home" a plus factor (for you)?
Many people only see that "the other party has an elderly person caring for the child," but do not see that "the person doing the caring is unsuitable, and the person who should be doing the caring is absent."
- It is not that the man is "unwilling to care for the child"; it is that hecannot care for the child— with 12-hour two-shift rotations, he does not even get enough sleep, and feeding the young child, coaxing the child to sleep, and caring for the child when ill are all left unfulfilled.
- The grandfather works away from home, so the grandparent caregiving chain has lost a link.
- The only grandmother present isa person with a Level 3 mental disability.
In the judge's eyes, this equals:the directly raising party (the father) has no time to perform his duties + the primary caregiver (the grandmother) has lost part of her capacity for civil conductArticle 14 of Interpretation II, "most favorable to the child," is not about who has more money; it is aboutwhose environment causes the child less harm.
You work and support yourself, transfer living expenses every month, and keep visiting despite being refused visitation—however ordinary your environment is, it is more stable than "a shift-working father + a grandmother with a mental disability."
Question Four: The small, granular actions of "being refused visitation and transferring living expenses" all have legal value
- Transferring a few hundred yuan to the mother-in-law every monthproves that you have not interrupted your maternal duties and are not abandoning the child; it is also the basis for your later claim, if custody is awarded to the father, that you have already performed part of your child-rearing responsibility.
- Requests for visitation on holidays were refused with "after divorce, don't contact us"Prove that the other party treats visitation as a bargaining chip in divorce negotiations, in violation of Article 24 of the Law on the Protection of Minors, which requires that visitation matters be handled properly.
- A 20-minute visit was cut short when the child was snatched back, and the whole family surrounded and blocked the way.You may apply for an injunction against infringement of personality rights (Article 12 of Interpretation II), and this also serves as evidence of continued obstruction of the parent-child relationship after the court hearing.
- Transcript of the first court hearingPin down the timing of the refusal to pick up the child after the court hearing, and expose the other party's lie that they had been negotiating in good faith all along.
Question Five: How should the claims be framed in the next lawsuit (tiered drafting)
- Primary claim
Order that the minor daughter be raised directly by the mother.
In the reasoning section, set out in one paragraph the three-part combination of snatching and concealment (Article 14, item ④ of Interpretation II), the actual caregiver's Grade 2 mental disability (Article 46, item ④ of Interpretation I), and the father's absence due to shift work, citing the original text of the provisions.
2. Alternative claim
If the court considers that modification is not appropriate for the time being, then
3. Fallback
Reserve the right to seek a future change of custody pursuant to Article 56 of Interpretation I.
4. In addition
make an oral application at the hearing by reference to Article 12 of Interpretation II,issue a court admonition/personality-rights injunction against the father and his family members prohibiting them from obstructing visitation, and keep a record of the proceedings.
To answer your last question—can I
win back custody?
Xiaoyu, you are 25 years old, and the child is 1 year and 8 months old. If you file again in six months, when the child is over two years old,it is not that you have no chance—it is that the approach must change.:
- Do not merely assert, "I am the mother and I want the child." Instead, assert that "the other party took the child and is using an elderly person with a mental disability as a stand-in to care for the child, and the law expressly rejects such an environment."”.
- The grandmother's disability certificate, the father's attendance records, the grandfather's being out of town, your records of transferring living expenses, and recordings of visitation being obstructed—once these five items are assembled, the other party's narrative that "the child is more stable living with the father" will collapse outright.
- A hard-fought judgment would likely award you roughly 40–50%; if custody is awarded to the father, but with 'no sole caregiving by the grandmother + locked-in visitation + a fallback for modification' secured, you can contend for more than 70%; once your financial situation improves later, you can seek modification under Article 56 of Interpretation I, and your prospects of success will be higher.
The law does not reward those who snatch children; it punishes them.
You are not making a scene; you are using Article 14 of Interpretation II, Article 24 of the Law on the Protection of Minors, and Article 1084 to lawfully pull a child who was snatched away back from the hands of a 'shift-working father + grandmother with a mental disability.'
Lawyer's Summary
- Being over two years old is not a fatal weakness; the supreme principle under Article 1084 of the Civil Code is 'the best interests of the child,' not 'first to possess, first to obtain';
- Snatching and concealing = Article 14, Item (4) of Interpretation IIa statutory circumstance for prioritizing custody to the other partystatutory circumstances;
- Actual caregiving by a grandmother with a Grade II mental disability + the father's 12-hour shift work = Article 46, Item (4) of Interpretation I, 'unsuitable for living together' + the direct custodian having no time to perform duties;
- Play both cards (snatching + caregiving by a person with illness) together, and characterize the other party's environment as high-risk;
- Tier the claims: contest custody → lock in visitation and prohibit sole caregiving → preserve a fallback for modification.
If you are also experiencing:
- the child was forcibly taken away by the other party, and visitation is being obstructed;
- the other party's family has elderly members who help with childcare, but those elderly members are in poor physical or mental condition;
- the first lawsuit did not result in a divorce decree, and it is unclear how to incorporate the "child snatching" and "caregiver's illness" into the complaint for the second lawsuit;
You are welcome to leave a comment below, or send the three words "child custody" via direct message to receive the "Second Divorce Lawsuit · Child Custody Evidence Checklist + Statutory Citation Template."
— Notes from a family law attorney · Only for those willing to build up their evidence —

